fbpx

A Moment in Time: “I am a Jew”

[additional-authors]
January 22, 2026

Dear all,

(The attached photo is from my bris)

I was thinking about where we are in our Torah cycle – as Moses goes head to head with Pharaoh. At no point, did Pharaoh ask Moses, “What kind of a Hebrew (Jew) are you?”

It didn’t matter to Pharaoh.

It didn’t matter to Hitler.

It didn’t matter to those who murdered Daniel Pearl.

And it doesn’t matter in this moment in time to those who oppose Judaism today.

And so it got me thinking. How should I define myself Jewishly? Here is what I discovered?

I am a Jew, and I shouldn’t need a further “distinction.”

I’m not a “religious” Jew.

I’m not a “cultural” Jew.

I’m not an “ethnic” Jew.

I am a Jew.

I’m not a “Reform” Jew.

I’m not an “Orthodox” Jew.

I’m not “secular” Jew.

I’m not a “Bu-Jew.”

I’m not “post-denomination” Jew.

I am a “Jew.”

I’m not a “Jewish-American.”

I’m not an “American Jew.”

I am a Jew.

I’m not a “Mizrachi” Jew.

I’m not “Sephardic” Jew

(nor am I a “Sephardic on Passover” Jew!)

I’m not an “Ashkenazi” Jew.

I am a Jew.

I’m not a “Social Justice” Jew.

I’m not a “practicing” Jew.

I’m not a “twice-a-year” Jew.

I am a Jew.

I’m not a “half” Jew.

I’m not a “patrilineal” Jew.

I’m not a “matrilineal” Jew.

I am a Jew.

My belonging does not depend on labels.

My covenant does not require categories.

My name does not change with context.

Wherever I go,

in any country,

in any language,

under any flag,

I am a Jew.

Sent with love and Shalom,

Rabbi Zachary R. Shapiro

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

What Does Faith Have to Do with Ethics?

One by one, the Ten Commandments teach us how we bring God into our daily lives. Each additional commandment encourages us to climb further up the ladder of faith.

Craving Kitsch

Everywhere I turned was another kiosk selling either sticky sweet things or tourist trinkets. I was in tacky heaven and, somehow, it felt great.

Print Issue: Here He Is | February 6, 2026

Former Columbia Professor Shai Davidai became an unlikely Israel activist after Oct. 7, 2023. Now he has started “Here I Am” for Zionist activists who “choose action over outrage and substance over performance.”

The Charm of Shabbat Chamin

Ever since I was a small child, Dafina has been a favorite food. This Moroccan hamim (Shabbat stew) is the ultimate comfort food.

National Bagel and Lox Day

Of course, you don’t need a special holiday to enjoy this classic breakfast, brunch or post-fast holiday dish.

Shai Davidai: Here He Is

Former Columbia Professor Shai Davidai became an unlikely Israel activist after Oct. 7, 2023. Now he has started “Here I Am” for Zionist activists who “choose action over outrage and substance over performance.”

The Jewish Community Lags Behind on Disability Inclusion

As we honor Jewish Disability Awareness, Acceptance and Inclusion Month, the Jewish community must step up to support its members by making proactive, genuine commitments to inclusion – not because external pressure demands it, but because our values do.

Rosner’s Domain | The West, from Israel

Debates about the West’s collapse will remain muddled until we admit what we are really debating: not the fate of a civilization, but the meaning of its name.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.