“We are a nation of immigrants.”
We hear that a lot nowadays. It’s become the go-to phrase for those who believe that border controls are cruel and deporting violent illegal immigrants is downright un-American.
It is undeniably true that for much of American history, immigrants from all over the world staked their claim in this land of opportunity. The United States benefited monumentally from the infusion of highly motivated, finely skilled, and eternally grateful foreigners eager to immerse themselves into the American melting pot.
Ellis Island proved better than a lottery ticket. It was the starting line in the sprint for the pursuit of happiness.
Nowadays we are discovering that America’s longstanding immigration story has taken a different, less industrious and patriotic turn. Where earlier generations of immigrants came to our shores with grit, more recent arrivals specialize in grift—siphoning off America’s entitlements and diverting vast sums of taxpayer and charitable money to terrorist groups elsewhere.
The dream of making it in America may soon become a nightmare of Islamic terrorism paid for by Uncle Sam. Say what you want about the 9/11 conspirators, but aside from the hijacked planes, they paid their own ride.
The dream of making it in America may soon become a nightmare of Islamic terrorism paid for by Uncle Sam. Say what you want about the 9/11 conspirators, but aside from the hijacked planes, they paid their own ride.
This week the House Oversight Committee will hear testimony from those who have uncovered an astonishing amount of fraud in Minnesota—all involving federal monies earmarked for housing, daycare, and autism centers and mostly perpetrated by the state’s sizable Somali community. Apparently, 90 percent of those charged are from Somalia.
Many are recent arrivals who quickly adopted the Democratic Party as their ticket to American inclusion. Their political engagement is curious since it appears that many are not quite sold on America itself. Nonetheless, they have become reliable voters and donors to Democratic candidates. Minnesota congresswoman and chief Squad gadfly, Ilhan Omar, is Somali in origin.
Minnesota is returning the favor in manifold ways. The state’s newly minted state flag bears a strong resemblance to the national flag of Somalia. But looking the other way when it comes to Somali criminality is the most significant sign that this tight-knit community is appreciated in the North Star State—even though some are umbilically connected to Islamic extremism back home in Africa.
These crimes are recent—occurring since the pandemic—and were in plain view. It involves roughly $9 billion in pilfered taxpayer funds. The U.S. Department of Justice is presently prosecuting more than 90 Minnesotans—90 percent of whom are from Somalia—for gaming welfare programs that provide food, housing, childcare and treatment for children with autism.
Apparently, the Somalis were playing a game of hide the salami.
Except they left behind a mountainous paper trail of fraudulent undertakings. In 2021 alone, bogus meals that never went to feed children accounted for nearly $200 million in graft. Child daycare centers were empty of children. These newcomers to American culture seemed to know a lot about doctored attendance records and fabricated invoices.
Their most brazen act of racketeering involved a program for autistic children. One Somali woman alone bilked the federal government of $14 million. She recruited fellow Somalis to enroll their children, virtually none of whom had an autism diagnosis. Nearly 10 percent of all four-year-old Somali Minnesotans were reported to be autistic—300 percent higher than other groups!
Signing up for benefits came with privileges. Somali families received monthly cash kickbacks of approximately $300 to $1,500 per month, per child. So cocky and dependent had they become on the boondoggle, many threatened to jump to competing sham facilities unless their kickbacks were increased.
The scope of this Medicaid fraud skyrocketed from $3 million in 2018 to $399 million in 2023.
Yet, the moment any regulator, politician or journalist became suspicious, these co-conspirators knew to invoke the ironclad get-out-of-jail-free card that has defined our multicultural age: racial discrimination. Black Lives Matter served as their shield—lives mattered; moral failings did not. Politicians feared losing votes; the media rebuffed any story that cast persons of color in a negative light. Minnesota was George Floyd’s state, after all.
More distressingly, a large portion of the ill-gotten gains flowed back to Somalia. As much as 40 percent of households in the impoverished country received foreign money transfers. In 2023, for instance, American taxpayers inadvertently gifted $1.7 billion to Somalia, which dwarfed its annual governmental budget.
And some Republicans are decrying the $3 billion in aid Israel lawfully received the same year that the October 7 massacre took place!
Worse still, some of this stolen money ended up in the hands of Somalia’s homegrown al Qaeda-linked terrorist group al-Shabab.
No real surprise. Homeland Security has revealed that Minnesota leads the nation in Americans joining, or attempting to join, ISIS—of the 58 so far, nearly half are Minnesotans.
This is how we are fighting the War on Terror — by redeploying federal taxpayer money to fund enemies that seek to replace our liberal democracy with an Islamic theocracy? All for the ostensible benefit of diversity and inclusion, and to avoid accusations of racism.
Europe has been dealing with this problem far longer. In November, Sweden reported that over $100 million in public funds intended for schoolchildren were diverted to Islamists abroad. The country has become a fertile recruiting ground of radicalized Islamists. Since 2013, more than 300 Swedes have joined jihadi groups, second only to Belgium. In 2023, it was discovered that 24 former ISIS terrorists were serving as public employees in Sweden.
The German Interior Ministry recently reported that 450 Hamas members are living in Germany and actively engaged in propaganda under the cover of Palestinian activism.
George Washington University released a study detailing how Hamas has created an elaborate network of fundraising and recruitment entities through charities, NGOs, and phony businesses. All are operating openly in Western countries.
In 2024, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies reported that 30 Hamas-linked aid organizations are based in the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, Belgium and the Netherlands. Inexplicably, the European Union—and those very same countries—have long designated Hamas to be an unlawful terror outfit.
Given these Minnesota revelations, can we be very far behind?
Note: Obviously I am not accusing every single Minnesotan of Somali origin with criminal behavior. But it’s not racist to point out a strong correlation between serious crimes and a significant percentage of those sharing the same ethnicity or race as the perpetrators.
Ben Affleck came across as a buffoon in a 2014 debate with Bill Maher and Sam Harris when he failed to comprehend that when a solid majority of the world’s 2 billion Muslims believe in killing infidels and apostates—along with stoning and beheading allegedly unfaithful wives—there is little comfort in knowing that several hundred million other Muslims believe otherwise.
It’s time to stop condescendingly proclaiming that we are a nation of immigrants. We already know that. Very few Americans are native to this land. Even the Pilgrims needed a boat to get here.
When “huddled masses” become sleeper cells, when “yearning to breathe free” becomes secondary to setting off bombs or financing an oncoming caliphate, there is little consolation in the reminder that immigrants can be patriots, too.
We’ve all seen the Statue of Liberty. We know about the “huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” But when “huddled masses” become sleeper cells, when “yearning to breathe free” becomes secondary to setting off bombs or financing an oncoming caliphate, there is little consolation in the reminder that immigrants can be patriots, too.
Minnesota’s ‘Melting Pot’
Thane Rosenbaum
“We are a nation of immigrants.”
We hear that a lot nowadays. It’s become the go-to phrase for those who believe that border controls are cruel and deporting violent illegal immigrants is downright un-American.
It is undeniably true that for much of American history, immigrants from all over the world staked their claim in this land of opportunity. The United States benefited monumentally from the infusion of highly motivated, finely skilled, and eternally grateful foreigners eager to immerse themselves into the American melting pot.
Ellis Island proved better than a lottery ticket. It was the starting line in the sprint for the pursuit of happiness.
Nowadays we are discovering that America’s longstanding immigration story has taken a different, less industrious and patriotic turn. Where earlier generations of immigrants came to our shores with grit, more recent arrivals specialize in grift—siphoning off America’s entitlements and diverting vast sums of taxpayer and charitable money to terrorist groups elsewhere.
The dream of making it in America may soon become a nightmare of Islamic terrorism paid for by Uncle Sam. Say what you want about the 9/11 conspirators, but aside from the hijacked planes, they paid their own ride.
This week the House Oversight Committee will hear testimony from those who have uncovered an astonishing amount of fraud in Minnesota—all involving federal monies earmarked for housing, daycare, and autism centers and mostly perpetrated by the state’s sizable Somali community. Apparently, 90 percent of those charged are from Somalia.
Many are recent arrivals who quickly adopted the Democratic Party as their ticket to American inclusion. Their political engagement is curious since it appears that many are not quite sold on America itself. Nonetheless, they have become reliable voters and donors to Democratic candidates. Minnesota congresswoman and chief Squad gadfly, Ilhan Omar, is Somali in origin.
Minnesota is returning the favor in manifold ways. The state’s newly minted state flag bears a strong resemblance to the national flag of Somalia. But looking the other way when it comes to Somali criminality is the most significant sign that this tight-knit community is appreciated in the North Star State—even though some are umbilically connected to Islamic extremism back home in Africa.
These crimes are recent—occurring since the pandemic—and were in plain view. It involves roughly $9 billion in pilfered taxpayer funds. The U.S. Department of Justice is presently prosecuting more than 90 Minnesotans—90 percent of whom are from Somalia—for gaming welfare programs that provide food, housing, childcare and treatment for children with autism.
Apparently, the Somalis were playing a game of hide the salami.
Except they left behind a mountainous paper trail of fraudulent undertakings. In 2021 alone, bogus meals that never went to feed children accounted for nearly $200 million in graft. Child daycare centers were empty of children. These newcomers to American culture seemed to know a lot about doctored attendance records and fabricated invoices.
Their most brazen act of racketeering involved a program for autistic children. One Somali woman alone bilked the federal government of $14 million. She recruited fellow Somalis to enroll their children, virtually none of whom had an autism diagnosis. Nearly 10 percent of all four-year-old Somali Minnesotans were reported to be autistic—300 percent higher than other groups!
Signing up for benefits came with privileges. Somali families received monthly cash kickbacks of approximately $300 to $1,500 per month, per child. So cocky and dependent had they become on the boondoggle, many threatened to jump to competing sham facilities unless their kickbacks were increased.
The scope of this Medicaid fraud skyrocketed from $3 million in 2018 to $399 million in 2023.
Yet, the moment any regulator, politician or journalist became suspicious, these co-conspirators knew to invoke the ironclad get-out-of-jail-free card that has defined our multicultural age: racial discrimination. Black Lives Matter served as their shield—lives mattered; moral failings did not. Politicians feared losing votes; the media rebuffed any story that cast persons of color in a negative light. Minnesota was George Floyd’s state, after all.
More distressingly, a large portion of the ill-gotten gains flowed back to Somalia. As much as 40 percent of households in the impoverished country received foreign money transfers. In 2023, for instance, American taxpayers inadvertently gifted $1.7 billion to Somalia, which dwarfed its annual governmental budget.
And some Republicans are decrying the $3 billion in aid Israel lawfully received the same year that the October 7 massacre took place!
Worse still, some of this stolen money ended up in the hands of Somalia’s homegrown al Qaeda-linked terrorist group al-Shabab.
No real surprise. Homeland Security has revealed that Minnesota leads the nation in Americans joining, or attempting to join, ISIS—of the 58 so far, nearly half are Minnesotans.
This is how we are fighting the War on Terror — by redeploying federal taxpayer money to fund enemies that seek to replace our liberal democracy with an Islamic theocracy? All for the ostensible benefit of diversity and inclusion, and to avoid accusations of racism.
Europe has been dealing with this problem far longer. In November, Sweden reported that over $100 million in public funds intended for schoolchildren were diverted to Islamists abroad. The country has become a fertile recruiting ground of radicalized Islamists. Since 2013, more than 300 Swedes have joined jihadi groups, second only to Belgium. In 2023, it was discovered that 24 former ISIS terrorists were serving as public employees in Sweden.
The German Interior Ministry recently reported that 450 Hamas members are living in Germany and actively engaged in propaganda under the cover of Palestinian activism.
George Washington University released a study detailing how Hamas has created an elaborate network of fundraising and recruitment entities through charities, NGOs, and phony businesses. All are operating openly in Western countries.
In 2024, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies reported that 30 Hamas-linked aid organizations are based in the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, Belgium and the Netherlands. Inexplicably, the European Union—and those very same countries—have long designated Hamas to be an unlawful terror outfit.
Given these Minnesota revelations, can we be very far behind?
Note: Obviously I am not accusing every single Minnesotan of Somali origin with criminal behavior. But it’s not racist to point out a strong correlation between serious crimes and a significant percentage of those sharing the same ethnicity or race as the perpetrators.
Ben Affleck came across as a buffoon in a 2014 debate with Bill Maher and Sam Harris when he failed to comprehend that when a solid majority of the world’s 2 billion Muslims believe in killing infidels and apostates—along with stoning and beheading allegedly unfaithful wives—there is little comfort in knowing that several hundred million other Muslims believe otherwise.
It’s time to stop condescendingly proclaiming that we are a nation of immigrants. We already know that. Very few Americans are native to this land. Even the Pilgrims needed a boat to get here.
We’ve all seen the Statue of Liberty. We know about the “huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” But when “huddled masses” become sleeper cells, when “yearning to breathe free” becomes secondary to setting off bombs or financing an oncoming caliphate, there is little consolation in the reminder that immigrants can be patriots, too.
Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is the legal analyst for CBS News Radio. His most recent book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.”
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
The Unusual Urge to Meet a Stranger
Rabbis of LA | Rabbi Engel’s ‘Shabbos in a Gas Station’
Sinai Akiba Masquerade Ball, Builders of Jewish Education’s 2026 Annual Benefit
The Architecture of Will: Decision and the Structure of Transformation
We Need More Jewish Babies
Congregation Beth Israel: Fond Memories of My Childhood Synagogue in LA’s Fairfax District
A Moment in Time: “When Losing an Hour Inspires Holiness”
A Bisl Torah — The Story You Need to Tell
May the story you share be a reminder that through our fears and uncertainty, alongside the bitterness we experience, redemption awaits.
Is Religious Knowledge Receding or Revealed via Tephilllin, Phylacteries?
Dutch Mistreat: Anti-Zionists in the Netherlands Tried Disrupting My Zoom Lecture
Denouncing my invitation, anti-Zionists smashed over 25 plate-glass windows in two nights of vandalism. Their graffiti proclaimed: “Stop your Zionist war propaganda” and “stop zios.”
Dancing While The War Raged On – A poem for Parsha Vayakhel-Pekudei
I just returned from B’nei Mitzvah in Chicago … War broke out in the middle of the festivities
Suspect Dead after Car Crash, Shooting at Detroit-area Reform Temple, Largest in North America
The director of security at Temple Israel was injured in the attack, the Reform congregation said.
Print Issue: The Year Everything Changed | March 13, 2026
Crazy as it might sound, it all started with the Dodgers, and how they won back-to- back World Series in 2024 and 2025. That year, with those two championships on either end, is the exact same year l became a practicing Jew. And I don’t think that’s a coincidence.
Rabbi Jerry Cutler, 91
In 1973, he founded Synagogue for the Performing Arts, drawing the likes of Walter Matthau, Ed Asner and Joan Rivers.
Racing Back to War: Israelis Stranded Abroad Desperate to Return Home
From Los Angeles to Thailand, Israelis are sitting anxiously, waiting for a notice from El Al or other airlines, hoping for a chance to board a flight back to Israel.
Healing Through Play: Mobile STEAM Unit Delivers Trauma Relief to War-Affected Communities
We are delivering hands-on learning and building resilience for a generation growing up under conflict in a region that lacks a dedicated children’s museum.
Friday Night Star – Spicy, Saucy Salmon
We made this recipe Passover-friendly because who doesn’t need an easy one-skillet dish that is healthy and delicious!?!
Pies for Pi Day
March 14, or 3/14 is Pi Day in celebration of the mathematical constant, 3.14159 etc. Any excuse to enjoy a classic or creative pie.
Table for Five: Vayakhel
Funding The Mishkan
The Light of Wonderment: A Letter to My Sons
Crazy as it might sound, it all started with the Dodgers, and how they won back-to-back World Series in 2024 and 2025.
Rosner’s Domain | Why Israelis See the War Differently
American malaise involves gloomy thoughts about spiking gas prices, or depressing flashbacks to previous wars where days stretched into decades. Israeli malaise is accompanied by gloomy thoughts about the Americans.
God: An Invitation
No single philosophical system can contain God.
For the Dogs? The Delightful Surprises of Jewish Medieval Art
Canines’ renowned loyalty was a natural representation of the “loyal transmission of the divine mandate from generation to generation.”
Honoring Palestinian Women Terrorists on International Women’s Day
Even those self-described human rights groups that are strongly biased in favor of the Palestinian Arab cause acknowledge the PA’s systemic mistreatment of women.
It Didn’t Start with Auschwitz
Jews today do have a voice. For the moment. But we have not used it where it counts – in the mainstream media, the halls of power, on campuses, on school boards, in the public square.
Regime Humiliation: No, You Won’t Destroy Israel
After years of terrorizing Israelis with existential threats, the Islamic regime is now worried about its own existence. In a region where the projection of power is everything, that is humiliation.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.