For approximately a decade, throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, I was a member of the Israel section of Amnesty International. During this period, I was also a member of the board of directors, and in 1998-1999, I was its chair. There, I met good people who devoted their energy, money and time to helping people they did not know, and all of this on a purely voluntary basis.
Currently, I am not a member of the organization, and I do not know most of the members at the Israeli section. Most of the officials of the international movement who were active at the beginning of the millennium have been replaced by others. It goes without saying that I do not pretend to represent the organization or speak for it.
Amnesty was founded in 1961 following an article published in The Observer titled, “The Forgotten Prisoners.” In its infancy, one of the organization’s major focuses was “prisoners of conscience”: people who were imprisoned for exercising their basic human rights in a non-violent way, and without calling for the use of violence. At that time, it was relatively easy to find prisoners of conscience: It was just a matter of locating a person in the Communist Bloc or in a European or Latin American dictatorship who was imprisoned or who had vanished as a result of such activity.
In the late 1980s and 1990s, as these regimes were gradually disappearing, distinct prisoners of conscience became rarer. More human rights organizations, which fought for the same pool of activists and donors as Amnesty International, entered the arena. In addition, the spotlight turned to ethnic conflicts like the one that erupted in Yugoslavia, following CNN and similar parties that broadcasted live from all over the world. These conflicts involved widespread and severe human rights violations, but investigating them required staff members with different skill sets than the ones used to aid prisoners of conscience.
These developments made the organization’s investigations of events that took place months and sometimes years before publication, irrelevant, and pressure mounted to publish current reports. However, producing quick and accurate research requires many qualified experts, access to warzones and to classified materials, as well as the ability to interview combatants in real time, and more. The organization did not possess the manpower and financial resources that enable such investigations, and to the best of my knowledge it does not have them today, rendering its reports far less professional. These phenomena were further exacerbated during the second decade of the 21st century, when social networks became an influential factor in the organization’s agenda and modus operandi.
The organization did not possess the manpower and financial resources that enable such investigations, and to the best of my knowledge it does not have them today, rendering its reports far less professional.
A recently published Amnesty International report declared that Israel practices a policy of apartheid against the Palestinians, both in Israel and the Palestinian Authority. In my view, this is a ridiculous claim, but since this is a case of a detailed report by a prestigious organization, cries of antisemitism will clearly not be helpful here. Readers around the world would rather believe an organization that is considered reliable and neutral and not the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
I wish to address the report itself, particularly at the methodological level.
Amnesty International’s reports are written anonymously. There is no way to know who authored the report, how many researchers were involved in its preparation, what their professional experience is and so on. In addition, when examining the sources on which the current report is based, a disturbing picture emerges. The report contains about 1,600 footnotes, the majority of which refer to past reports and policy papers by Amnesty International, B’Tselem, Adalah, HaMoked, Ir Amim, Bimkom, Al-Haq, and additional far-Left Israeli organizations, as well as reports by the UN Human Rights Council and similar international bodies. When these are the sources for “research” that purports to examine the State of Israel’s attitude toward its Arab population from 1948 to the present, it is clear that the result will be biased and one-sided. While I am not familiar with all the legal experts quoted in the report, if one relies on people like John Dugard, who is known for his critical attitude toward Israel, it is clear that the views of people like him will lead any reasonable person to similar conclusions. Furthermore, despite the fact that the report claims to confirm the theory that Israel, since its inception, has aspired to discriminate against Arabs on racial grounds, the number of sources concerning Israel’s first fifty years is negligible compared to those concerning recent decades.
Amnesty International prides itself on the organization’s high level of research and its neutrality. This report is an extreme example of how baseless that claim is.
Amnesty International prides itself on the organization’s high level of research and its neutrality. This report is an extreme example of how baseless that claim is. If one writes a report based almost entirely on all one-sided sources, does not bother to engage with civil society organizations that hold a different perspective, and does not turn to mainstream academics and legal experts, then he is conducting biased and negligent research with the main purpose of smearing Israel and harming its international status. His aim is not to promote human rights. Anyone who seeks to have a dialogue with Israel and improve its human rights situation should not label it an apartheid state, which by definition makes it illegitimate.
Dr. Michael Ehrlich, Department of Middle Eastern Studies Bar-Ilan University, Israel
Behind the Scenes of Amnesty International’s Report on Israel
Michael Ehrlich
For approximately a decade, throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, I was a member of the Israel section of Amnesty International. During this period, I was also a member of the board of directors, and in 1998-1999, I was its chair. There, I met good people who devoted their energy, money and time to helping people they did not know, and all of this on a purely voluntary basis.
Currently, I am not a member of the organization, and I do not know most of the members at the Israeli section. Most of the officials of the international movement who were active at the beginning of the millennium have been replaced by others. It goes without saying that I do not pretend to represent the organization or speak for it.
Amnesty was founded in 1961 following an article published in The Observer titled, “The Forgotten Prisoners.” In its infancy, one of the organization’s major focuses was “prisoners of conscience”: people who were imprisoned for exercising their basic human rights in a non-violent way, and without calling for the use of violence. At that time, it was relatively easy to find prisoners of conscience: It was just a matter of locating a person in the Communist Bloc or in a European or Latin American dictatorship who was imprisoned or who had vanished as a result of such activity.
In the late 1980s and 1990s, as these regimes were gradually disappearing, distinct prisoners of conscience became rarer. More human rights organizations, which fought for the same pool of activists and donors as Amnesty International, entered the arena. In addition, the spotlight turned to ethnic conflicts like the one that erupted in Yugoslavia, following CNN and similar parties that broadcasted live from all over the world. These conflicts involved widespread and severe human rights violations, but investigating them required staff members with different skill sets than the ones used to aid prisoners of conscience.
These developments made the organization’s investigations of events that took place months and sometimes years before publication, irrelevant, and pressure mounted to publish current reports. However, producing quick and accurate research requires many qualified experts, access to warzones and to classified materials, as well as the ability to interview combatants in real time, and more. The organization did not possess the manpower and financial resources that enable such investigations, and to the best of my knowledge it does not have them today, rendering its reports far less professional. These phenomena were further exacerbated during the second decade of the 21st century, when social networks became an influential factor in the organization’s agenda and modus operandi.
A recently published Amnesty International report declared that Israel practices a policy of apartheid against the Palestinians, both in Israel and the Palestinian Authority. In my view, this is a ridiculous claim, but since this is a case of a detailed report by a prestigious organization, cries of antisemitism will clearly not be helpful here. Readers around the world would rather believe an organization that is considered reliable and neutral and not the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
I wish to address the report itself, particularly at the methodological level.
Amnesty International’s reports are written anonymously. There is no way to know who authored the report, how many researchers were involved in its preparation, what their professional experience is and so on. In addition, when examining the sources on which the current report is based, a disturbing picture emerges. The report contains about 1,600 footnotes, the majority of which refer to past reports and policy papers by Amnesty International, B’Tselem, Adalah, HaMoked, Ir Amim, Bimkom, Al-Haq, and additional far-Left Israeli organizations, as well as reports by the UN Human Rights Council and similar international bodies. When these are the sources for “research” that purports to examine the State of Israel’s attitude toward its Arab population from 1948 to the present, it is clear that the result will be biased and one-sided. While I am not familiar with all the legal experts quoted in the report, if one relies on people like John Dugard, who is known for his critical attitude toward Israel, it is clear that the views of people like him will lead any reasonable person to similar conclusions. Furthermore, despite the fact that the report claims to confirm the theory that Israel, since its inception, has aspired to discriminate against Arabs on racial grounds, the number of sources concerning Israel’s first fifty years is negligible compared to those concerning recent decades.
Amnesty International prides itself on the organization’s high level of research and its neutrality. This report is an extreme example of how baseless that claim is. If one writes a report based almost entirely on all one-sided sources, does not bother to engage with civil society organizations that hold a different perspective, and does not turn to mainstream academics and legal experts, then he is conducting biased and negligent research with the main purpose of smearing Israel and harming its international status. His aim is not to promote human rights. Anyone who seeks to have a dialogue with Israel and improve its human rights situation should not label it an apartheid state, which by definition makes it illegitimate.
Dr. Michael Ehrlich, Department of Middle Eastern Studies Bar-Ilan University, Israel
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Where Dating Meets DNA ft. Canavan Foundation
What Israel Taught Me About the Two Sides of Resilience
In Praise of Showing Up
Good Sabbath, South Africa
Launching a Rabbinical School in Germany and Pausing for Some Gratitude
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Setting Our Own Rules
As independent voters, we will no longer be forced to pretend that the zealots in our party must be tolerated in the name of “party unity.”
Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’
No matter how stressful or anxious life gets, gratitude is the saving grace, the one virtue that can give us the strength to keep going.
Jewish National Fund-USA’s Global Conference for Israel: Four Days of Zionist Pride in San Diego
It marked 125 years since the inception of the organization and its commitment to building up the land of Israel.
AJU’s Ziegler School to Launch Dual-Degree Model for Future Rabbis
The curriculum will also address contemporary challenges facing Jewish communities, including antisemitism and the responsible use of artificial intelligence and digital media.
Sharon Osbourne: ‘It’s Very Fashionable to Hate Jews and Israel’
Osbourne spoke candidly about antisemitism, her own Jewish roots and what she sees as an increasingly hostile world for Jews
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
What if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages?
What Isaac the Blind Sees
Isaac is not merely a blind man with insight; he is a blind man who has seen beyond this world.
Rabbis of LA | IDF Veteran, Guest of Rabbi Kahn, Remembers Oct. 7, 2023
Second of two parts
L.A. Federation’s Tour de Summer Camps, International Chabad Conference in NYC
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
Call Sheet – A poem for Parsha Toldot
See who’s in the cast.
A Bisl Torah ~ Dangerous Comparisons
Let us not compare child to child. God will remind us; there are ample parental blessings for each child to receive.
A Moment in Time: Holding On
Abraham Plants a Tamarisk Tree
Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026
A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.
Why Are We Even Here?
When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.
Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises
Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.
Boulou: A Cookie That Traveled From Djerba to Los Angeles
Boulou has deep roots in Djerba, but is treasured in all Tunisian Jewish kitchens, where it is baked for the holidays and special occasions.
What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?
We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.
“What Did the Doctor Say?” and Other Things that Keep Us from Laughing
Who’s got time to crack up in these crazy times? Well, I do.
NCSY Welcomes 400 Proudly Jewish Student Leaders to the JSU President’s Conference
JSU is a network of Jewish culture clubs in public and secular private high schools in North America, and it’s a program of NCSY, the international youth movement of the Orthodox Union.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.