fbpx

The Value of 9/11: A Short Pause for National Unity

Of course, we can never recapture that singular moment of unity from 19 years ago, nor should we need another moment of tragedy to be what brings us together. But because we are so incredibly divided today, perhaps the memory of 9/11 can help us temper our divisions so they don’t turn into irreversible animosity.
[additional-authors]
September 11, 2020
NEW YORK, NY – JULY 04: Small American flags are placed in all 2,983 names on the 9/11 Memorial on July 4, 2017 in the Manhattan borough of New York City. (Photo by Alex Wroblewski/Getty Images)

Our country has become so viciously divided it’s hard to remember a time when we were not at each other’s throats.

But there was such a time. It was 19 years ago today. We all remember where we were when terrorists hijacked commercial airplanes and flew them right into the Twin Towers. Thousands died. The images stunned the nation. A poor soul threw himself out of a window rather than perish in the fires of hell. Hundreds of firefighters lost their lives trying to save others.

To paraphrase President Franklin Roosevelt, it was a day that will surely live in American infamy. And that’s not a bad thing, because here’s what I remember most about that day and its aftermath: Americans were utterly united.

It’s not as if we haven’t suffered national disasters before or since that have brought us together. We have, from devastating hurricanes and earthquakes to horrible mass shootings.

But 9/11 felt different.

It happened at a time when New York City had recaptured the heart of the nation, with Times Square feeling like a safe Disneyland after its crime-ridden past. The Twin Towers were the ultimate symbol of the ultimate American city. If you wanted to rip the heart out of a nation, take those towers down for everyone to see– which we did, over and over again.

The images of those giant towers crumbling were overwhelming. It left us numb, shocked, furious. But it also left us united. A feeling of compassion for the victims spread throughout the country. It didn’t matter if the victims were Democrats or Republicans. Ethnicity, gender, age, class, race— none of it mattered. What mattered was that they were all part of the human race.

It didn’t matter if the victims were Democrats or Republicans. Ethnicity, gender, age, class, race— none of it mattered. What mattered was that they were all part of the human race.

That extraordinary feeling of unity didn’t last, of course. It can’t. But for a moment at least, we all felt it. We felt united by a common pain, a common shock, a common purpose.

As dark as those days were, it was still breathtaking to see a whole nation rally around an unspeakable tragedy.

Is there value to remembering that show of unity? I think so. However fleeting it was, it gave us a taste of something bigger than ourselves; it showed us what can happen when the common good overtakes our individual interests.

Because we are so incredibly divided today, perhaps the memory of 9/11 can help us temper our divisions so they don’t turn into irreversible animosity.

Of course, we can never recapture that singular unifying moment, nor should we need another tragedy to bring us together. But because we are so incredibly divided today, perhaps the memory of 9/11 can help us temper our divisions so they don’t turn into irreversible animosity.

We are blessed in America to have a tradition of commemorating big events in our history– whether they are great or devastating. As we remember today the victims of that devastation from 19 years ago, let’s pause to remember the unity they inspired– and show them they didn’t die in vain.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

A Ka’ak By Any Other Name

A symbol of hospitality, families bake batches for holidays, family celebrations and visits with friends and relatives.

The Story That Never Goes Away

Rachel Goldberg-Polin, mother of slain hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin, can’t stop speaking about her pain and the public love her body cannot always receive. She talks to the Journal about her son’s legacy and her new book.

Rosner’s Domain | A Dime-Store Abe: The Karhi Crisis

This week’s “Constitutional Crisis” is typical of the way the government operates. It issues a statement, or a tweet and then walks it back. Oops, we did not mean it. Or rather, we did, but we also meant to deny that we did.

Why Can’t We Be Friends?

If we want to see a less polarized society, both internally and beyond, we must emphatically reject the idea that political alignment is the predominant commonality for friendship.

Ruth-less, the Enigma of a Name

Jews spoke in two voices about Ruth, a kind of national schizophrenia, one with joyous chanting on Shavuos as the Book of Ruth was read; the other, removing her name from the chain-link of repeated names throughout the generations.

Honoring My Father: Saying Kaddish with Men

Saying kaddish every day tested my faith and commitment. It made me realize that there is no room for excuses. It taught me how to show up. It taught me that my voice can be heard, even when not expected.

The Yiddish Letter of American Liberty

Phillips’ letter – with its faith in Congress’ Declaration – now sits in display not far from the Liberty Bell and its inscription from the biblical book of Leviticus.

Searching for the Red Heifer

While there’s nothing wrong with keeping your eyes on the horizon for that magical heifer to appear, be sure to appreciate what you already have.

Broadening the Fight

If we agree that antisemitism is only one example of a widespread and pernicious instinct toward division and “other-ization,” then it becomes clear that we can only eradicate these animosities as part of a far broader effort.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.