fbpx
[additional-authors]
September 14, 2010

Once in a while my son will stump me with a question that I don’t have answers to or don’t quite know how to answer.  It usually can be resolved by a quick Google search, trip to the library or strategic distraction (which is usually not that difficult when you are dealing with a four year old), but this time it was different.

I was getting my son ready for bed.  Pajamas?  Check.  Teeth brushed?  Check.  I had just promised him that he could watch the last few minutes of one his favorite shows before he went to sleep. Just as I was brushing his hair, he stumped me.  Out of the blue.

He asked, “What happened to my Saba (Grandpa)?  What happened to your daddy?” (Who had died long before my son was born.)  I decided to answer with just the facts and nothing more.  My voice trembled, I was taken aback.  We had never spoken about what had happened or even the concept of death.  Just the fact that he was “gone.”

“My dad is gone,” I answered with tears in my eyes.

“Did he die?”  Again, I was shocked.  We never talked about death.  I always avoided the discussion, until now.  But I answered.

“Yes, he did,” I said.

“So, he is dead?” my son asked.

“Yes, he is dead.  And he is watching over us.”

“How did he die, Mommy?  Was he sick?”

“Yes, he was very sick.”

“And no doctors could help him?” he asked.

“No, no doctors could help him.”  Then he continued.

“I would love him, Mommy.  I would want to play with him.”

“He would love you too.  He loved you before you were born.  I am sorry he can’t play with you.”

“Can we watch Netflix now?”

I stepped into the other room as my son watched the end of another episode of Diego and cried.  My father had always wanted a grandson.  He was like the father from My Big Fat Greek Wedding – “Get married, make babies,” he’d say, just without the “you look so old” part.  He talked about all the places he would take my son; it is as if he knew I would have a son.  He spoke of soccer days and park days, but never got the chance to meet his grandson.  How do I explain this to a four year old?  How do I explain losing the ones that we loved the most?  How do I explain that his grandfather loved him even before he was born?  How do I explain that he would have been an incredible grandfather that now he will never know?  Long after my son fell asleep, I was still up.  I was up thinking about our conversation and my son’s curiosity.  I couldn’t get it out of my mind.

I should have turned on Netflix.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Bringing Israeli Doctors Back

ScienceAbroad works with two groups in medicine: physicians who leave Israel for fellowships and Israeli students who attend medical school in Europe.

The Antizionist’s Dilemma

It’s not easy being an antizionist these days. Especially if you’re determined to live in accordance with your most important moral imperative: the denigration of the world’s only Jewish state.

How the Supreme Court Adapted Parshat Shoftim

The Torah offers a better model than avenging and avoiding. It offers a safe opportunity for parties to meet and peacefully explain their perspectives, which might have been misunderstood. They can offer apologies and, where necessary, make amends for harms caused.

Can One Be a Non-Observant Orthodox Jew?

The tradition has always been bigger than any one person’s grip on it. What draws me is simple: I think these texts are a good part of why we are still here as a people. I want to know them and, in my own way, embrace them. Orthodox is where I turn.

Lies, Damned Lies and the Right Side of History

One question alone matters these days: Does this fact strengthen my tribe, or is it bad for it? If bad, it must be suppressed, denied, explained away. The higher truth is the narrative that serves the cause, the quest of the righteous and true.

Life Lessons in Old Age

Hardship and joy are present at every step. There is no time when it will be all good, so focus on the good and carry on. There are always moments to savor and appreciate.

Is Mamdani Helping Bibi?

By explicitly linking Mamdani’s efforts to rising levels of antisemitism, Netanyahu was able to frame himself as a defender of Israel against growing international hostility.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.