fbpx

Psychiatrist Says Monsey Stabbing Suspect Is Mentally Unfit for Trial

[additional-authors]
January 29, 2020
MONSEY, NY – DECEMBER 29: Ramapo police guard the house of Rabbi Chaim Rottenberg on December 29, 2019 in Monsey, New York. Five people were injured in a knife attack during a Hanukkah party and a suspect, identified as Grafton E. Thomas, as was later arrested in Harlem. (Photo by Stephanie Keith/Getty Images)

A psychiatrist concluded that Grafton Thomas, who is accused of stabbing five people at a Hanukkah party on Dec. 28 in Monsey, N.Y., is mentally ill and therefore not able to stand trial.

Michael Sussman, Thomas’ attorney, made the announcement on Jan. 27. Federal prosecutors have two weeks to respond.

Sussman has asserted since Thomas’ arrest the day after the stabbings, that his client has a history of mental illness. As an example, Sussman pointed to Thomas being arrested in September when his mother — with whom he lived at the time — called 911 in response to Thomas slicing a chicken with a knife. Thomas was arrested when an officer ordered him to put down the knife but he refused to do so. He was subsequently diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. He was subsequently released, according to Patch.com.

Additionally, Sussman also has stated that Thomas told him that he has heard voices in his head.

Thomas’ family has similarly claimed in a statement to CNN that he is mentally ill and never has expressed any anti-Semitic beliefs.

“We believe the actions of which he is accused, if committed by him, tragically reflect profound mental illness for which … [for] Grafton has received episodic treatment before being released,” they said.

Federal prosecutors said on Dec. 30 that they discovered journals written by Thomas containing a swastika and references to Adolf Hitler and he searched for “Zionist temples” near him on his phone. Sussman has said that he found evidence supporting his client’s case in a vacant cabin that Thomas once inhabited. Prosecutors are demanding that Sussman hand over the evidence.

Thomas faces federal hate crime charges as well as charges of attempted murder. He pled not guilty to all charges.

One of the victims, 72-year-old Josef Neumann, currently is in a coma.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

A Deafening Silence

A Jewish woman burned to death on American soil. The violence wasn’t random. It was ideological, premeditated, and still, almost no one says her name.

Refreshing Summer Salads

Bright, earthy and deeply refreshing, this salad brings together the forest-like aroma of fresh herbs with a sweet and nutty crunch.

Print Issue: Reclaiming American Values | July 4, 2025

“American values” was once shorthand for the animating ideals of liberal democracy. Now it’s become politicized. As we celebrate July 4th, Jews must lead the way in reclaiming an idea that is meant to unite us, not divide us.

Why Jews Must Reclaim American Values

“American values” was once shorthand for the animating ideals of liberal democracy. Now it’s become politicized. As we celebrate July 4, Jews must lead the way in reclaiming an idea that is meant to unite us, not divide us.

Dawn of a New Era in the Middle East

The ceasefire that President Trump brokered is the second crucial step in that process, not the end of the story but the start of a new chapter.

The Fall of Pride. And the March Into Mayhem

To those raising fists in solidarity with the “Free Palestine” movement in the Western world and chanting “resistance by any means necessary,” we ask: Does your “resistance support” include the execution of queer people?

More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.