fbpx

Close to Home

Abby Kirban and Georg Hartmann initially kept quiet about falling in love after she auditioned for a play he directed in Los Angeles in 1997.
[additional-authors]
November 22, 2001

Abby Kirban and Georg Hartmann initially kept quiet about falling in love after she auditioned for a play he directed in Los Angeles in 1997.

Why? Because she’s Jewish and he’s German — a touchy liaison even half a century after the Holocaust.

"I felt a bit uncomfortable about breaking the news to my parents," Kirban, 28, admits. Hartmann, 35, was even more nervous because his father had been a leader in the Hitler Youth Movement. Even after their parents OK’d the union, the couple’s friends continued to bombard them with questions, prompting the Echo Park filmmakers to explore their relationship in a poignant documentary, "Close to Home," to air Nov. 29 on the Sundance Channel.

Kirban, the producer, and Hartmann, the writer-director, began shooting the movie after noting that Kirban’s grandfather had helped manufacture the American bombs that had killed most of Hartmann’s family in the war. The director’s father, Karl-Dieter, was so devastated by the loss that he never took Georg to visit their graves, a couple of miles from their home in Witten, Germany. Nor did he discuss details of his Nazi experience, though he was quick to deplore the Final Solution. "I was burning with curiosity to learn what involvement, if any, my family had in the Holocaust, though I was wondering if Abby would still love me after that," Hartmann says of the documentary.

He was so anxious before interviewing a Holocaust survivor — a friend of the Kirbans’ — that he became physically ill en route to her home. Even more difficult was grilling the reticent Karl-Dieter, who eventually opened up on camera.

But the most memorable moment for the filmmakers, who will wed next June, was walking hand-in-hand at Auschwitz. "We felt so lucky to be living at a time when you can fall in love with whomever you want," Hartmann says.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Doubling Down on Who We Are

There is something in this people, covenanted to justice, to memory, to one another, that is impossible to extinguish.

We Are Upset Because We Can Read

Americans – and Israelis in particular – are not reacting to spin, or to partisan framing, or to media distortions. They are reacting to the text of the agreement itself, and to what has followed it.

Print Issue: A Time-Out for Gratitude | June 26, 2026

America’s 250th birthday arrives at a time when things have been especially lousy for Jews. But gratitude is a great Jewish value, so we’ve created a very special birthday present: an e-book with 250 reasons to be grateful for America.

Bye-Bye Bluebird: A Greek Summer with an Israeli Twist

Wandering through narrow streets filled with cafés, restaurants and small boutique shops, it was easy to understand why so many Israeli visitors fall in love with Greece and keep coming back or simply stay permanently.

Did Hamas Accomplish Its Oct. 7 Goal?

The Hamas supporters have managed, at least for now, to turn American elected officials and a large portion of the American population against one of its foremost allies.

The Politics of War

Trump’s biggest headache will be Netanyahu, his erstwhile ally who now recognizes that continued loyalty to the American leader would cost him his own reelection this fall.

There Would Be No America Without Jerusalem

America is not modern Israel’s creator, and Israel is not America’s dependent. The two nations have influenced one another and benefited from one another, but the deepest roots of that relationship predate them both.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.