It is a tragedy that Palestinian civilians lost their lives in the course of the IDF’s mission to rescue four hostages from the Nuseirat refugee camp in Gaza.
But let’s not be confused about how this tragedy came about. When Hamas decided to turn a crowded refugee camp into a military stronghold and a dungeon for Israeli captives, they were guaranteeing that Nuseirat would eventually become a battlefield, and that when it did, innocent people would be hurt.
This is what they wanted to happen. Hamas knows that mass casualty events put pressure on Israel, and so they engineer them wherever they can. This strategy depends on having reliable partners in the media and the international community. Luckily for Hamas, they have no shortage of those.
EU High Representative Joseph Borrell called Israel’s operation a “massacre.”
A BBC anchor demanded to know why the IDF didn’t warn civilians in the area ahead of time about the top-secret undercover rescue operation.
An “expert” interviewed by CNN called it one of the “bloodiest Israeli assaults” to date.
But Israel taking a PR hit is not the worst result of this confusion. More troubling is the fact that the world is actively incentivizing Hamas’ use of human shields. Terrorists everywhere are watching and taking notes. The result will be, in this conflict and in future conflicts, more civilian deaths.
Hamas has reported that over 200 people were killed in the operation. At this point, we do not know if that number is correct. We do not know what percentage was killed by Hamas fire. We do not know how many of them were combatants.
All we know is that 200 is a bigger number than 4, and this seems to be the source of some of the outrage over Israel’s mission. But comparing these two numbers, those killed versus those saved, tells us nothing about the morality of the operation.
This is not how morality works. Nor is it how international law works. Germany suffered greater losses than the Allies in WWII. That doesn’t make them the good guy. Similarly, the fact that (according to the notorious Gaza Health Ministry) over 200 people died in an operation to rescue four individuals does not mean that Israel is the bad guy.
Blaming Israel at this point has become second nature. Palestinian death tolls are reported without scrutiny and without distinguishing combatants from civilians and are then instantly interpreted as a barometer of Israel’s guilt.
We are well-accustomed to these dynamics, but this latest incident clarifies something, which is that for Israel’s haters, nothing Israel does will ever be legitimate.
After all, there can be no more justified operation than the mission to rescue Noa Argamani, Almog Meir Jan, Andrey Kozlov and Shlomi Ziv. Israel not only had a right to rescue them, but an obligation. The IDF also had every right to return fire when Hamas militants attempted to stop them from fleeing with the rescued hostages.
The moral takeaway of this operation should be clear. One side of this war is willing to risk everything, including the life of the heroic commander Arnon Zamora, to save the lives of its people. The other side of this war intentionally endangers its people by hiding hostages in their midst and operating military strongholds in civilian areas.
If Hamas wants the fighting to stop, there is an Israeli deal on the table to get the rest of the hostages home and stop the war. I hope, for the sake of the hostages and for the sake of Palestinian civilians in Gaza, that they take this deal.
In the meantime, however, they should know that Israel, unlike the media and the international community, is not confused, and we will continue to do whatever it takes to rescue those who have been stolen from us.
Matthew Schultz is a Jewish Journal columnist and rabbinical student at Hebrew College. He is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (Tupelo, 2020) and lives in Boston and Jerusalem.
The World’s Response to the Hostage Rescue Proves That Israel Can Do No Right
Matthew Schultz
It is a tragedy that Palestinian civilians lost their lives in the course of the IDF’s mission to rescue four hostages from the Nuseirat refugee camp in Gaza.
But let’s not be confused about how this tragedy came about. When Hamas decided to turn a crowded refugee camp into a military stronghold and a dungeon for Israeli captives, they were guaranteeing that Nuseirat would eventually become a battlefield, and that when it did, innocent people would be hurt.
This is what they wanted to happen. Hamas knows that mass casualty events put pressure on Israel, and so they engineer them wherever they can. This strategy depends on having reliable partners in the media and the international community. Luckily for Hamas, they have no shortage of those.
EU High Representative Joseph Borrell called Israel’s operation a “massacre.”
A BBC anchor demanded to know why the IDF didn’t warn civilians in the area ahead of time about the top-secret undercover rescue operation.
An “expert” interviewed by CNN called it one of the “bloodiest Israeli assaults” to date.
But Israel taking a PR hit is not the worst result of this confusion. More troubling is the fact that the world is actively incentivizing Hamas’ use of human shields. Terrorists everywhere are watching and taking notes. The result will be, in this conflict and in future conflicts, more civilian deaths.
Hamas has reported that over 200 people were killed in the operation. At this point, we do not know if that number is correct. We do not know what percentage was killed by Hamas fire. We do not know how many of them were combatants.
All we know is that 200 is a bigger number than 4, and this seems to be the source of some of the outrage over Israel’s mission. But comparing these two numbers, those killed versus those saved, tells us nothing about the morality of the operation.
This is not how morality works. Nor is it how international law works. Germany suffered greater losses than the Allies in WWII. That doesn’t make them the good guy. Similarly, the fact that (according to the notorious Gaza Health Ministry) over 200 people died in an operation to rescue four individuals does not mean that Israel is the bad guy.
Blaming Israel at this point has become second nature. Palestinian death tolls are reported without scrutiny and without distinguishing combatants from civilians and are then instantly interpreted as a barometer of Israel’s guilt.
We are well-accustomed to these dynamics, but this latest incident clarifies something, which is that for Israel’s haters, nothing Israel does will ever be legitimate.
After all, there can be no more justified operation than the mission to rescue Noa Argamani, Almog Meir Jan, Andrey Kozlov and Shlomi Ziv. Israel not only had a right to rescue them, but an obligation. The IDF also had every right to return fire when Hamas militants attempted to stop them from fleeing with the rescued hostages.
The moral takeaway of this operation should be clear. One side of this war is willing to risk everything, including the life of the heroic commander Arnon Zamora, to save the lives of its people. The other side of this war intentionally endangers its people by hiding hostages in their midst and operating military strongholds in civilian areas.
If Hamas wants the fighting to stop, there is an Israeli deal on the table to get the rest of the hostages home and stop the war. I hope, for the sake of the hostages and for the sake of Palestinian civilians in Gaza, that they take this deal.
In the meantime, however, they should know that Israel, unlike the media and the international community, is not confused, and we will continue to do whatever it takes to rescue those who have been stolen from us.
Matthew Schultz is a Jewish Journal columnist and rabbinical student at Hebrew College. He is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (Tupelo, 2020) and lives in Boston and Jerusalem.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
At the Mountain – A poem for Parsha Behar-Buchukotai
Immortality Lives On … as It Should
A Bisl Torah — Carving Out and Making Space
A Moment in Time: “Tikkun Olam – Fixing the World”
Vain Pronouncements
Print Issue: Fearless | May 8, 2026
Behind the Scenes at the Israel Prize Ceremony
Synchronistic meetings prove, once again, that Israel is a small country
‘Immigrant Songs’: The Rise, Fall and Revival of Yiddish Theater
The film blends archival footage, original music and scholarly insight to bring to life a cultural legacy that continues to resonate today.
Dr. Edith Eger, Psychologist and Holocaust Survivor, Dies at 98
Calling Auschwitz her “best classroom,” Edith used the inner resources she developed in hell to help others.
Larry David on Fire at Book Festival
Larry’s voluntary sit-down with Lorraine Ali was in support of the official “Curb Your Enthusiasm” book, “No Lessons Learned,” published last September.
Braid Celebrates America’s 250th Birthday with ‘L’Chaim America’
The Braid Jewish theater company’s latest show highlights the diversity of contemporary Jewish-American life.
‘We Met at Grossinger’s’ Brings the Borscht Belt to Los Angeles Jewish Film Festival
Director Paula Eiselt’s documentary acknowledges the early careers of Mel Brooks, Buddy Hackett, Carl Reiner, Joan Rivers and Jerry Lewis. It also goes deeper into why Grossinger’s Resort and Hotel had to exist in the first place.
Exodus from Los Angeles: Outmigration, AI, and the Fate of Jewish Angelenos
For those who remain, the struggle is real.
Mt. Sinai and Forest Lawn Warn LA Bike Lane Plan Could Disrupt Funeral Access on Forest Lawn Drive
Mount Sinai estimates the road carries about 20,000 vehicles per day and provides the only route to both memorial parks, including large funeral processions.
LAUSD Makes History with Jewish American Heritage Month Recognition
While she believes the program can play an important role in addressing antisemitism, Tishby emphasized that no single initiative can solve the problem on its own. “It will be a tool, but let’s not kid ourselves that one thing is going to be the answer.”
Recipes and Food Memories for Mother’s Day
Mother’s Day is a time to celebrate Mom while savoring those foods and food memories.
Blessings and Best Scone Recipe
I learned to bake scones as a young girl in Australia. I’m still amazed that simple ingredients like a bit of flour, butter and whole milk can be transformed into such delicious bites.
Mother’s Day: The Full Circle of Love
The first time I tasted this peach upside-down cardamom loaf cake was at high tea in London.
Table for Five: Behar-Bechukotai
The Rainmaker
The ‘Gadfather’ Makes an Offer He Hopes You Can’t Refuse
Controversial professor Gad Saad talks about “Suicidal Empathy” and why the world considers it cool to hate Jews.
Rosner’s Domain | The Broad Coalition: Sentiment vs. Reality
Gantz’s ideological message is based on a noble dream: a grand bargain that could seat everyone from Bezalel Smotrich to Yair Lapid at the same table.
For Our Religious Fractures, Science May Be a Healing Salve
On specific points of belief, Christians and Jews are not mutually understandable to each other. But the cosmic foundation of scientific evidence is equally accessible to us all, on the very same terms.
The Weight of Words: Hearing Rachel Goldberg-Polin Speak
Having heard Rachel’s words, I have become once again astonished at their power, reawakened to their strangeness and to their potentially infinite value.
John Quincy Adams and Aaron, the High Priest of Harvard
No doubt Adams kept Aaron’s model in mind as his own political career advanced. He would seek to emulate Aaron’s elocution upon being elected president, bringing the High Priest’s legacy with him to the White House.
Man Pleads Guilty in Paul Kessler Death, Faces Up to One Year
Alnaji, 54, of Moorpark, accepted the deal and pleaded guilty, avoiding a jury trial that had been scheduled for May 12.
Georgetown Commencement Speaker Mort Schapiro Withdraws After Firestorm Caused by his Jewish Journal Columns
In his column, Schapiro has written about a range of subjects, including the need for hope and optimism and improving the public discourse. But he has also expressed supportive views of Israel, and that was a bridge too far for a group of law students.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.