The Hamas-led surprise attack on Israel, Hamas’s barbarism, its inhumanity, its savagery, its obvious delight in torture and killing, its emphasis on degrading women, has been shocking in the extreme.
One can argue about who is at fault for the conditions in Gaza, whether Israelis have contributed to the sense of hostility, whether conditions there are the result of necessary or unnecessary Israeli precautions, whether Arabs in Gaza are their own worst enemies in how they have chosen to rule themselves and their stance toward Israel, or whether their situation is somehow beyond their control. One can argue about the causes of the war they have now started. But war, having been chosen, has its own boundaries which Hamas and its followers have simply chosen to ignore. Many of us have begun to wonder whether the cruelty with which this war has been fought is inherent in Muslim culture.
I have been troubled by this same speculation.
My friend Raheel Raza, the Pakistani-Canadian founder of Council for Muslims Facing Tomorrow and the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism, seems to have read my mind, sending me a number of statements by prominent Muslim leaders, in her words, “debunking the Islamist ideology and recognizing the truth.”
Mohammed Rizwan, a journalist, writes: “The unprovoked aggression unleashed by the Hamas-Hezbollah terrorist-infiltrators inside Israel stunned the world. The well-planned and well-coordinated attack by Iranian backed Hezbollah and Hamas combined is a daredevil attempt to derail the impending Israeli-Saudi peace deal and a desperate bid to thwart the peace process in the Middle East underlined by the Abraham Accords. Thoughts and prayers for the victims of this abhorrent act of aggression.”
Noor Dahri, executive director, Islamic Theology of Counter Terrorism (UK), writes “I strongly condemn these heinous crimes by Hamas against Israel. It is time for the international community to stand with Israel and stop Hamas aggression for good.”
“This attack,” writes Haras Rafiq, senior research fellow at the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy, “is a deliberate tactic employed by Hamas and its backers to delegitimize peace and derail ongoing negotiations. We must not let the terrorists win!”
Dalia al-Aqidi, an Iraqi-American journalist, notes that “Iran-backed Palestinian terrorists launched an invasion against our ally Israel committing ghastly war crimes. They are celebrating their slaughter in Gaza and the West Bank. We must fully support Israel’s right to defend itself and stand strong on the front lines against terrorism. I stand unequivocally with Israel.”
“Today,” writes Dr. Zuhdi Jasser, Founder and President of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy, “we are all Israelis.”
“Today,” writes Dr. Zuhdi Jasser, founder and president of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy, “we are all Israelis.”
These quotations from Muslim leaders remind us that our enemy is neither Islam nor its adherents. We must be careful not to generalize from the viciousness of particular individuals and groups. While there are amongst our enemies those who call for the killing and degrading of Jews and the obliteration of Israel, we — myself included — must understand that this is not a war of Islam against Jewry. As these quotations show, our Muslim friends stand firmly with us. As Dr. Jasser writes, “we are all Israelis.”
Gregory R. Smith is an attorney in Los Angeles and president of Westwood Kehilla.
Hamas Does Not Speak for Islam
Gregory Smith
The Hamas-led surprise attack on Israel, Hamas’s barbarism, its inhumanity, its savagery, its obvious delight in torture and killing, its emphasis on degrading women, has been shocking in the extreme.
One can argue about who is at fault for the conditions in Gaza, whether Israelis have contributed to the sense of hostility, whether conditions there are the result of necessary or unnecessary Israeli precautions, whether Arabs in Gaza are their own worst enemies in how they have chosen to rule themselves and their stance toward Israel, or whether their situation is somehow beyond their control. One can argue about the causes of the war they have now started. But war, having been chosen, has its own boundaries which Hamas and its followers have simply chosen to ignore. Many of us have begun to wonder whether the cruelty with which this war has been fought is inherent in Muslim culture.
I have been troubled by this same speculation.
My friend Raheel Raza, the Pakistani-Canadian founder of Council for Muslims Facing Tomorrow and the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism, seems to have read my mind, sending me a number of statements by prominent Muslim leaders, in her words, “debunking the Islamist ideology and recognizing the truth.”
Mohammed Rizwan, a journalist, writes: “The unprovoked aggression unleashed by the Hamas-Hezbollah terrorist-infiltrators inside Israel stunned the world. The well-planned and well-coordinated attack by Iranian backed Hezbollah and Hamas combined is a daredevil attempt to derail the impending Israeli-Saudi peace deal and a desperate bid to thwart the peace process in the Middle East underlined by the Abraham Accords. Thoughts and prayers for the victims of this abhorrent act of aggression.”
Noor Dahri, executive director, Islamic Theology of Counter Terrorism (UK), writes “I strongly condemn these heinous crimes by Hamas against Israel. It is time for the international community to stand with Israel and stop Hamas aggression for good.”
“This attack,” writes Haras Rafiq, senior research fellow at the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy, “is a deliberate tactic employed by Hamas and its backers to delegitimize peace and derail ongoing negotiations. We must not let the terrorists win!”
Dalia al-Aqidi, an Iraqi-American journalist, notes that “Iran-backed Palestinian terrorists launched an invasion against our ally Israel committing ghastly war crimes. They are celebrating their slaughter in Gaza and the West Bank. We must fully support Israel’s right to defend itself and stand strong on the front lines against terrorism. I stand unequivocally with Israel.”
“Today,” writes Dr. Zuhdi Jasser, founder and president of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy, “we are all Israelis.”
These quotations from Muslim leaders remind us that our enemy is neither Islam nor its adherents. We must be careful not to generalize from the viciousness of particular individuals and groups. While there are amongst our enemies those who call for the killing and degrading of Jews and the obliteration of Israel, we — myself included — must understand that this is not a war of Islam against Jewry. As these quotations show, our Muslim friends stand firmly with us. As Dr. Jasser writes, “we are all Israelis.”
Gregory R. Smith is an attorney in Los Angeles and president of Westwood Kehilla.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
More Than 500 UC Faculty Members Call on Board of Regents to Address Anti-Israel Activism by Faculty, Departments
Race to Erase MS Gala 2024: Where Glamour Meets Giving Back!
Talmudic Grappling is Alive and Well at Milken Conference
Artist Chari Pere Creates Cartoonmentary on Miscarriage
100th Anniversary: The U.S. Immigration Law That Doomed Europe’s Jews
Chef Katie Chin: Heritage, Chinese Cooking and Chocolate-Raspberry Wontons
Culture
Chef Katie Chin: Heritage, Chinese Cooking and Chocolate-Raspberry Wontons
Taste Buds with Deb Celebrates One Year, A Triple Chai of Eps
Chico Menashe: Asif: Culinary Institute of Israel, Cooking with Chutzpah and The Open Kitchen Project
Welcome Back, Carbs!
Yom HaShoah Ceremony Draws 600 Attendees to Pan Pacific Park
The Oct. 7 attack and the subsequent sharp rise in antisemitism nationwide hung like a shadow over an already-somber event.
Jews Are Becoming More, Not Less, Zionist
Zionists understand that Jews are a people not just a religion, with millennia-old ties to one particular homeland, and the right to build a state on that homeland.
Why 2024 Is Not 1968
While both crises feature a centrist president being targeted by an aggressive anti-war movement, the differences between Gaza and Vietnam are immense.
An Ode to Hillel
To Hillel International: I stand unequivocally with you, your resilient students and your devoted staff.
The Enemy is the Status Quo
The Jewish community must learn several important lessons from the civil rights movement if they want to end the occupation of US campuses by anti-Israel and antisemitic groups.
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Chef Katie Chin: Heritage, Chinese Cooking and Chocolate-Raspberry Wontons
Chico Menashe: Asif: Culinary Institute of Israel, Cooking with Chutzpah and The Open Kitchen Project
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.