Like much else in life these days, the medical science surrounding the coronavirus pandemic has been controversial and disputed.
COVID-19 is caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS-CoV-2), a highly contagious virus that has infected almost 110 million people worldwide in some 220 countries.
The good news is that while the infection rate is high, the death rate is relatively low compared to other past untreated epidemics like smallpox, plague, malaria, tuberculosis, cholera and Ebola.
However, several factors from the start have led to an unusual amount of polarization surrounding this disease, including China’s lack of transparency regarding the origin and nature of the virus, which was first detected in Wuhan. We still don’t know if the zoonotic virus jumped from animals to humans or was a biodisease that escaped the Wuhan Institute of Virology, as claimed by scientist Dr. Li-Meng Yan and disputed by the World Health Organization.
It’s true that we wish to follow “good” science. But when it comes to COVID-19, we don’t seem to have a shared understanding of what “good” science is. Here are a few areas of controversy and disagreement.
Uneven Advice
Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of the World Health Organization and public health expert, got the fight against COVID-19 off to a poor start. In the critical early weeks of the virus’s spread, Tedros promoted Chinese propaganda, advising a complacent world that there was not human transmission outside of China. He also opposed travel bans.
Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, an oncologist who advocated for the Obama administration’s Affordable Care Act and has advised President Joe Biden, suggested in 2014 that he would reject curative medical care as a 75-year-old, a statement that may disturb the elderly today who are the most vulnerable to COVID-19.
And Dr. Anthony Fauci, longtime director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, initially provided admittedly conflicting advice on the use of masks, quarantining and the methods of viral transmission.
Although these doctors have received much media attention, they have generally avoided severe critique. This was not the case for Dr. Scott Atlas, a Stanford neuroradiologist, analyst of government health policy and former special coronavirus adviser to President Trump, who was critiqued for arguing that those under the age of 65 rarely die from COVID-19 and that children rarely exhibit serious illness and should return to school. He also suggested that Americans re-enter the workforce to avoid the quarantine-related development of rising mental illness, substance abuse and child abuse from lost jobs.
Many of these policies were crafted before officials fully understood the virus and its transmission. But the fact remains that pandemics are nothing new, and the consequences for learning on the fly are significant. History and hindsight will be better judges of our performance.
Pandemics are nothing new, and the consequences for learning on the fly are significant.
Disputed cause of death
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, along with the COVID Tracking Project and Johns Hopkins University, gathers data on deaths from state-generated reports. Most rely on death certificates, which list the cause of death and, often, other contributing factors.
The key question is which mortalities are actually a result of COVID-19: who died with COVID-19 and who died due to COVID-19. Pre-and-post mortem classification of cases varies among local hospitals and coroners.
Dr. Susan Bailey, the president of the American Medical Association, addressed the debate on under-counting vs. over-counting pandemic deaths, asserting, “The suggestion that doctors — in the midst of a public health crisis — are overcounting COVID-19 patients or lying to line their pockets is a malicious, outrageous and completely misguided charge.”
It is true that hospitals are paid the same for COVID-19 treatment as for any other care, although the more serious the problem, the more hospitals are paid. So, treating a ventilator patient does result in a higher payment to a hospital. However, Medicare, the government health program for the elderly and disabled, pays 20% on top of its ordinary reimbursement for COVID-19 patients — a result of the CARES Act, the federal stimulus bill that passed in spring 2020.
Social distancing
The World Health Organization has called for the separation of people by at least one meter (just over three feet). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has recommended six feet.
When you cough or sneeze, or even sing or speak, droplets are released and quickly fall within a few feet due to gravity. But smaller aerosols may float in the air for fairly long distances and remain there for longer periods of time. Some scientists have warned that aerosols can travel up to some 27 feet. Definitive studies of living patients for viral transmission have encountered ethical challenges due to the lethality of the virus.
Social distancing, people keep distance in public to protect from COVID-19 Coronavirus outbreak spreading concept, couple man and woman keep distance away on tandem bicycle with Coronavirus pathogens.
This lack of clarity on appropriate social distancing has resulted in confusion about school and business closures and the safety of shopping, religious services, athletic events and even walking around the neighborhood. It is sobering to note the studies that indicate that many COVID-19 infections result from in-home exposure to infected friends and family.
Mask wearing
Surgeons wear properly fitted and specialized medical masks to protect patients. And health experts claim that masks are a key factor, along with social distancing and hand washing, in reducing viral community spread. In fact, the CDC recently announced that wearing two masks or a tightly-fitted mask can reduce transmission of COVID-19 by 96.4%. As recommended and often mandated at work and in public, mask-wearing by the American public has generally been highly observed.
But how much a thin or poorly fitting mask alters its efficacy is still being researched. Pathogenic microbes are very small and can enter through or around the side of masks. Furthermore, mask-wearing may provide a false sense of security and even have its own potential health risks, such as touching the face with contaminated hands.
Contact tracing
The emergent epidemic of COVID-19 inspired a new generation of digital systems to identify, track and monitor the movement of individuals by government authorities. There are almost four billion smartphones around the globe, and apps that track our movements risk expanded surveillance, lockdowns and a potential violation of individual rights.
There are reports that in Syria, the government has disguised malware as a contact-tracing app. Several countries in Africa have been accused of brutal lockdowns. In Israel, citizens have complained about the involvement of the Shin Bet security service in case tracing. In Australia, authorities have promised that health data collected after the pandemic won’t be retained.
After the initial lockdowns, Chile was considering — and rejected — a “release certificate” identifying those who have been infected and recovered. South Korea tested electronic trackers on individuals violating quarantine, and Germany promoted a smartphone-based tracker.
Closures and economic costs
In the spring of 2020, the Trump administration desired that public schools re-open by the fall. It is now a year later, and the Biden administration has disappointed many by announcing it hopes to have more than 50% of American schools open for teaching “at least one day a week” by April 30, 2021.
The costs to children from school closures are incalculable, ranging from learning loss and socialization effects to mental illness. Families have been impacted, and parents have struggled.
Sinai Akiba Academy classrooms have been reconfigured for when the state and county say in-person learning can resume. Photo courtesy of Sinai Akiba Academy.
Schools are not the only institutions to have suffered from closures. While the stock market has soared as large public companies have reaped the benefits of reduced competition, soaring numbers of small businesses and individuals face bankruptcy from COVID-19 related closures.
Federal relief spending during the crisis has pushed the already-rising national debt toward $30 trillion. Our debt-to-GDP ratio has now risen well past 100%, which some economists assert risks severe future economic slowdown and inflation.
Debates Over Treatments
One debate over treatment focused on the virological cure effects of hydroxychloroquine (with Zinc), especially in combination with the antibiotic azithromycin. In June 2020, The FDA withdrew authorized emergency use of hydroxychloroquine as unlikely to be effective and a heart risk. When physicians representing a group called “America’s Frontline Doctors” touted HCQ on the front steps of the U.S. Capitol in July 2020, they were met with fierce denunciation from public health officials arguing that personal observations have not been matched by scientific studies.
The FDA has approved the antiviral drug Remdesivir, and some doctors are also using anti-inflammatory corticosteroids like dexamethasone to treat COVID-19 pneumonia. The FDA has issued and updated emergency use authorization of an immune-based therapy called convalescent plasma for hospitalized COVID-19 patients.
Fortunately, the rapid development of several vaccines, with more to come, offers hope for an ailing world. Monitoring of any adverse events is advised by former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson, author of “Unreported Truths About COVID-19 and Lockdown,” who has clarified that the mRNA vaccine differs from the vaccines we have used in the past. Other public health experts claim that mRNA vaccines have been used in studies for decades and have been tweaked for COVID-19.
Clinical trials have strongly indicated vaccines may reduce the risk of infection. We await studies on the efficacy of the vaccine for the most vulnerable populations, who were not a statistically significant part of the vaccine development testing protocols. It also remains to be seen for how long one may be immune once vaccinated and how well vaccines will protect against the spread of recent variants of the coronavirus from the United Kingdom, South Africa, and Brazil.
A year into this pandemic, it is startling how much confusion remains about the elusive virus. The science, it seems, is not at all yet settled.
Larry Greenfield is a Fellow of The Claremont Institute for the Study of Statesmanship & Political Philosophy.
What if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages?
A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.
When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.
We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.
JSU is a network of Jewish culture clubs in public and secular private high schools in North America, and it’s a program of NCSY, the international youth movement of the Orthodox Union.
Over the last month, Americans and Israelis voted in elections that were consequential to the characters of both countries. For many, these elections represented inflection points, signaling the directions their respective societies will take moving forward.
The future of the U.S.-Israel relationship will not be secured by winning one more primary. It will depend on whether Americans understand why Israel matters, why Jewish self-determination is legitimate, and why the alliance benefits both nations.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
The Scientific Controversies Around COVID-19
Larry Greenfield
Like much else in life these days, the medical science surrounding the coronavirus pandemic has been controversial and disputed.
COVID-19 is caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS-CoV-2), a highly contagious virus that has infected almost 110 million people worldwide in some 220 countries.
The good news is that while the infection rate is high, the death rate is relatively low compared to other past untreated epidemics like smallpox, plague, malaria, tuberculosis, cholera and Ebola.
However, several factors from the start have led to an unusual amount of polarization surrounding this disease, including China’s lack of transparency regarding the origin and nature of the virus, which was first detected in Wuhan. We still don’t know if the zoonotic virus jumped from animals to humans or was a biodisease that escaped the Wuhan Institute of Virology, as claimed by scientist Dr. Li-Meng Yan and disputed by the World Health Organization.
It’s true that we wish to follow “good” science. But when it comes to COVID-19, we don’t seem to have a shared understanding of what “good” science is. Here are a few areas of controversy and disagreement.
Uneven Advice
Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of the World Health Organization and public health expert, got the fight against COVID-19 off to a poor start. In the critical early weeks of the virus’s spread, Tedros promoted Chinese propaganda, advising a complacent world that there was not human transmission outside of China. He also opposed travel bans.
Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, an oncologist who advocated for the Obama administration’s Affordable Care Act and has advised President Joe Biden, suggested in 2014 that he would reject curative medical care as a 75-year-old, a statement that may disturb the elderly today who are the most vulnerable to COVID-19.
And Dr. Anthony Fauci, longtime director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, initially provided admittedly conflicting advice on the use of masks, quarantining and the methods of viral transmission.
Although these doctors have received much media attention, they have generally avoided severe critique. This was not the case for Dr. Scott Atlas, a Stanford neuroradiologist, analyst of government health policy and former special coronavirus adviser to President Trump, who was critiqued for arguing that those under the age of 65 rarely die from COVID-19 and that children rarely exhibit serious illness and should return to school. He also suggested that Americans re-enter the workforce to avoid the quarantine-related development of rising mental illness, substance abuse and child abuse from lost jobs.
Many of these policies were crafted before officials fully understood the virus and its transmission. But the fact remains that pandemics are nothing new, and the consequences for learning on the fly are significant. History and hindsight will be better judges of our performance.
Disputed cause of death
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, along with the COVID Tracking Project and Johns Hopkins University, gathers data on deaths from state-generated reports. Most rely on death certificates, which list the cause of death and, often, other contributing factors.
The key question is which mortalities are actually a result of COVID-19: who died with COVID-19 and who died due to COVID-19. Pre-and-post mortem classification of cases varies among local hospitals and coroners.
Dr. Susan Bailey, the president of the American Medical Association, addressed the debate on under-counting vs. over-counting pandemic deaths, asserting, “The suggestion that doctors — in the midst of a public health crisis — are overcounting COVID-19 patients or lying to line their pockets is a malicious, outrageous and completely misguided charge.”
It is true that hospitals are paid the same for COVID-19 treatment as for any other care, although the more serious the problem, the more hospitals are paid. So, treating a ventilator patient does result in a higher payment to a hospital. However, Medicare, the government health program for the elderly and disabled, pays 20% on top of its ordinary reimbursement for COVID-19 patients — a result of the CARES Act, the federal stimulus bill that passed in spring 2020.
Social distancing
The World Health Organization has called for the separation of people by at least one meter (just over three feet). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has recommended six feet.
When you cough or sneeze, or even sing or speak, droplets are released and quickly fall within a few feet due to gravity. But smaller aerosols may float in the air for fairly long distances and remain there for longer periods of time. Some scientists have warned that aerosols can travel up to some 27 feet. Definitive studies of living patients for viral transmission have encountered ethical challenges due to the lethality of the virus.
This lack of clarity on appropriate social distancing has resulted in confusion about school and business closures and the safety of shopping, religious services, athletic events and even walking around the neighborhood. It is sobering to note the studies that indicate that many COVID-19 infections result from in-home exposure to infected friends and family.
Mask wearing
Surgeons wear properly fitted and specialized medical masks to protect patients. And health experts claim that masks are a key factor, along with social distancing and hand washing, in reducing viral community spread. In fact, the CDC recently announced that wearing two masks or a tightly-fitted mask can reduce transmission of COVID-19 by 96.4%. As recommended and often mandated at work and in public, mask-wearing by the American public has generally been highly observed.
But how much a thin or poorly fitting mask alters its efficacy is still being researched. Pathogenic microbes are very small and can enter through or around the side of masks. Furthermore, mask-wearing may provide a false sense of security and even have its own potential health risks, such as touching the face with contaminated hands.
Contact tracing
The emergent epidemic of COVID-19 inspired a new generation of digital systems to identify, track and monitor the movement of individuals by government authorities. There are almost four billion smartphones around the globe, and apps that track our movements risk expanded surveillance, lockdowns and a potential violation of individual rights.
There are reports that in Syria, the government has disguised malware as a contact-tracing app. Several countries in Africa have been accused of brutal lockdowns. In Israel, citizens have complained about the involvement of the Shin Bet security service in case tracing. In Australia, authorities have promised that health data collected after the pandemic won’t be retained.
After the initial lockdowns, Chile was considering — and rejected — a “release certificate” identifying those who have been infected and recovered. South Korea tested electronic trackers on individuals violating quarantine, and Germany promoted a smartphone-based tracker.
Closures and economic costs
In the spring of 2020, the Trump administration desired that public schools re-open by the fall. It is now a year later, and the Biden administration has disappointed many by announcing it hopes to have more than 50% of American schools open for teaching “at least one day a week” by April 30, 2021.
The costs to children from school closures are incalculable, ranging from learning loss and socialization effects to mental illness. Families have been impacted, and parents have struggled.
Schools are not the only institutions to have suffered from closures. While the stock market has soared as large public companies have reaped the benefits of reduced competition, soaring numbers of small businesses and individuals face bankruptcy from COVID-19 related closures.
Federal relief spending during the crisis has pushed the already-rising national debt toward $30 trillion. Our debt-to-GDP ratio has now risen well past 100%, which some economists assert risks severe future economic slowdown and inflation.
Debates Over Treatments
One debate over treatment focused on the virological cure effects of hydroxychloroquine (with Zinc), especially in combination with the antibiotic azithromycin. In June 2020, The FDA withdrew authorized emergency use of hydroxychloroquine as unlikely to be effective and a heart risk. When physicians representing a group called “America’s Frontline Doctors” touted HCQ on the front steps of the U.S. Capitol in July 2020, they were met with fierce denunciation from public health officials arguing that personal observations have not been matched by scientific studies.
The FDA has approved the antiviral drug Remdesivir, and some doctors are also using anti-inflammatory corticosteroids like dexamethasone to treat COVID-19 pneumonia. The FDA has issued and updated emergency use authorization of an immune-based therapy called convalescent plasma for hospitalized COVID-19 patients.
Fortunately, the rapid development of several vaccines, with more to come, offers hope for an ailing world. Monitoring of any adverse events is advised by former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson, author of “Unreported Truths About COVID-19 and Lockdown,” who has clarified that the mRNA vaccine differs from the vaccines we have used in the past. Other public health experts claim that mRNA vaccines have been used in studies for decades and have been tweaked for COVID-19.
Clinical trials have strongly indicated vaccines may reduce the risk of infection. We await studies on the efficacy of the vaccine for the most vulnerable populations, who were not a statistically significant part of the vaccine development testing protocols. It also remains to be seen for how long one may be immune once vaccinated and how well vaccines will protect against the spread of recent variants of the coronavirus from the United Kingdom, South Africa, and Brazil.
A year into this pandemic, it is startling how much confusion remains about the elusive virus. The science, it seems, is not at all yet settled.
Larry Greenfield is a Fellow of The Claremont Institute for the Study of Statesmanship & Political Philosophy.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Setting Our Own Rules
Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’
Jewish National Fund-USA’s Global Conference for Israel: Four Days of Zionist Pride in San Diego
AJU’s Ziegler School to Launch Dual-Degree Model for Future Rabbis
Sharon Osbourne: ‘It’s Very Fashionable to Hate Jews and Israel’
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
What if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages?
What Isaac the Blind Sees
Isaac is not merely a blind man with insight; he is a blind man who has seen beyond this world.
Rabbis of LA | IDF Veteran, Guest of Rabbi Kahn, Remembers Oct. 7, 2023
Second of two parts
L.A. Federation’s Tour de Summer Camps, International Chabad Conference in NYC
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
Call Sheet – A poem for Parsha Toldot
See who’s in the cast.
A Bisl Torah ~ Dangerous Comparisons
Let us not compare child to child. God will remind us; there are ample parental blessings for each child to receive.
A Moment in Time: Holding On
Abraham Plants a Tamarisk Tree
Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026
A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.
Why Are We Even Here?
When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.
Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises
Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.
Boulou: A Cookie That Traveled From Djerba to Los Angeles
Boulou has deep roots in Djerba, but is treasured in all Tunisian Jewish kitchens, where it is baked for the holidays and special occasions.
What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?
We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.
“What Did the Doctor Say?” and Other Things that Keep Us from Laughing
Who’s got time to crack up in these crazy times? Well, I do.
NCSY Welcomes 400 Proudly Jewish Student Leaders to the JSU President’s Conference
JSU is a network of Jewish culture clubs in public and secular private high schools in North America, and it’s a program of NCSY, the international youth movement of the Orthodox Union.
Table for Five: Toldot
Sibling Rivalry
Genocide and International Relations
The book casts its net far and wide, from debates within the field of research itself to the analysis of genocidal events across the past century.
Heading Toward Bipartisan Opposition?
For an Israeli observer of the American elections, there is a double cause for concern.
A Concrete Case for Hope
Over the last month, Americans and Israelis voted in elections that were consequential to the characters of both countries. For many, these elections represented inflection points, signaling the directions their respective societies will take moving forward.
AIPAC Isn’t the Problem. It’s Part of the Solution.
The future of the U.S.-Israel relationship will not be secured by winning one more primary. It will depend on whether Americans understand why Israel matters, why Jewish self-determination is legitimate, and why the alliance benefits both nations.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.