During this year’s Rosh Hashanah service, just as I read about Abraham leading an unsuspecting Isaac up Mount Moriah, intent on sacrificing him, the Lev Shalem machzor downloaded onto my phone cut out. I was momentarily spared the trigger of a father taking his own son’s life, a reminder of a painful relationship with my own father. Restarting my phone didn’t help. My ancient tablet took forever to load. I had no choice but to go analog and reached for the Adler High Holiday prayer book my parents used.
It was bittersweet holding what they davened from, there in the flicker of their yahrzeit candles. The book’s cloth covers were as black as my bar mitzvah suit and the boxy Hebrew typography on its glossy pages as prim as the sitcoms of that period. Paging through this relic was at least as uncomfortable as confronting one’s bad hair in a high school yearbook. Worse, it beamed me right back to the suffocating Old Boy Judaism of my Conservative synagogue in the Bronx in the mid-1960s.
Adler’s consistently masculine pronouns gave God a distinctly male voice that the men of our shul — rabbi, cantor, sexton and their counterparts in the junior congregation — no doubt felt addressed them personally. This masculine language also reinforced my impression of Judaism as a men’s club, right down to the suits checking High Holiday tickets at the door or the boys reciting Torah blessings in their unsure, post-bar mitzvah voices. The women of our shul worked in the office and sang in the Sisterhood musicals; none shared the bimah with me during my bar mitzvah. The minyan, drawn exclusively from this men’s club, was trusted to open the ark and carry its Torah. Along similar lines, the locker room wisecracks made by my father and uncles at the first bris I attended gave Judaism the feel of a fraternity that would hardly welcome a faygele like me.
The Adler’s literary translations, worthy of a Norton Critical Edition, reproduced the meter and structure of the original Hebrew as faithfully as period instruments recreate early music. Its archaic King James Version vibe, complete with walkeths and goeths (this in 1959) betrayed its eighteenth-century English origins, appropriate for a sovereign claiming divine right. It stripped any Thou from the I and Thou and rendered God an unapproachable divine monarch, which more or less sums up the approach of my shul’s cheder classes. No wonder I learned to picture God as the proverbial old man with a white, flowing beard — not unlike that Al Hirschfeld drawing of Bernard Shaw on the cover of my mother’s recording of My Fair Lady — and a New York Yankees baseball cap. (We lived near the stadium.)
My ten year-old mind saw such hypermasculine Judaism spilling over into the equally gendered realm of sports. Both worlds emphasized feats of skill, tribal loyalty and shaming. Both made me anxious; I feared mixing up the meat and dairy silverware or flubbing a left-field catch in equal measure. God and softball tested and demanded; shirkers were exposed and lackluster performance punished. Still, if one could go home after nine innings of softball, God-as-umpire, scorekeeper and team-chooser never quit the diamond of the Jews. My pitifully unathletic self saw God’s stern hand in all those who made sure guys would “man up”: my gym teacher, father, grandfather and camp counselor. If God was nigh, as we sang around Boy Scout campfires, he was ready to call balls and strikes and banish those who couldn’t hit a softball if their lives depended on it.
Judaism’s male focus is particularly apparent in Adler’s rendering of High Holiday Torah texts. Abraham not only attempts to kill one son but is ready to off a second by banishing him and his mother. Slacker Jonah’s self-absorbed misanthropy endangers the lives of others. Yet I was taught to admire Abraham’s steadfastness and show no compassion for Jonah’s spiritual crisis. I was supposed to take Abraham’s potential violence in stride, even when it reminded me of bullying classmates, and I was to condemn Jonah’s fecklessness and his flight, even if the closeted person I was at the time recognized the need to keep secrets by keeping one’s distance. Abraham forgoes parental love, while God’s tone-deaf reaction to Jonah’s spiritual impasse compares with police arresting a disturbed person instead of helping them. These stories identify blind obedience and a very masculine abhorrence of weakness as essential Jewish values demanded by an alpha-male God.
I was taught to admire Abraham’s steadfastness and show no compassion for Jonah’s spiritual crisis.
The Lev Shalem machzor, by contrast, realizes there’s a problem with this depiction. A marginal note suggests that Abraham should have protested God’s orders. A later gloss reads Jonah’s story as a searing inner conflict rather than mere weakness in Jonah’s disobedience. Both interpretations favor understanding over judgement; they make allowances for human complexity. Adler, however, delivers these texts straight out of the box with nary a comment. Its flowery Jacobean renderings tacitly advocate submission over reflection. They ignore the cost of what these men do to themselves as well as others, condoning zero-sum, toxic masculinity.
I was glad when Lev Shalem’s gender-diverse service lit up on my phone again. The tally of three patriarchs heralding the Amidah is rounded out with the four matriarchs. Blessings appear in variant forms, not only pronoun-wise but offering gender- and theologically-neutral renderings of God’s name. Such Judaism feels less feminized than normalized, reflecting a world I want to live in. Yet traces of musty black-and-white Adler lurked in the “traditional” translations paired with contemporary versions, which prompted me to wonder when tradition becomes oppressive. When is it time, for example, to take down Confederate statues? The stories recounted during the High Holidays are part of who we are, yes, but that needn’t preclude some retooling.
And then there’s Avinu Malkeinu, the magisterial prayer for forgiveness that rarely leaves me dry-eyed. Still, the repetitions of father and king marching down the pages of both the Adler and Lev Shalem can be daunting. Lev, however, leaves these words untranslated, somehow diluting their masculine authority just enough — for English readers, at least — for them to become figures of comfort rather than power. This year, each iteration of these words clapped against my heart, releasing a tear of forgiveness for my own father.
Adler’s issues center less around text or translation but around God, an idea both fluid and amorphous, an expression of universal good and human striving that is ultimately too infinite to be contained between the covers of any book. Yet the idea has been commandeered by those who might be politely termed spiritual administrators, usually male, who, for example, prevented women from becoming Conservative rabbis until 1985. And in 2009, after Avi Weiss, my parents’ rabbi, ordained Sara Hurwitz, the Orthodox Rabbinical Council of America forbade its members from ordaining women. Ten years later, the Open Orthodox yeshiva founded by Weiss himself refused to ordain a gay rabbinical student. The best translations won’t easily loosen the chokehold of such male-centered Judaism; only a change of heart and mind can. In 2016, for example, my husband and I were married by a gay male rabbi.
The rabbi leading the services I streamed began this year’s Kol Nidre service as always: by announcing that she believes in a God who doesn’t care whether someone believes in God. It is easy for nonbelieving Jews such as myself to feel comfortable with a genderless, non-judgmental divine presence, unconcerned if I choose not to play softball that evening or ever again.
Eric Gabriel Lehman’s work has appeared in the New York Times, Brooklyn Rail, Raritan and elsewhere. He lives with his husband and two turtles in New York and teaches at Queens College.
God and Man in 5781
Eric Gabriel Lehman
During this year’s Rosh Hashanah service, just as I read about Abraham leading an unsuspecting Isaac up Mount Moriah, intent on sacrificing him, the Lev Shalem machzor downloaded onto my phone cut out. I was momentarily spared the trigger of a father taking his own son’s life, a reminder of a painful relationship with my own father. Restarting my phone didn’t help. My ancient tablet took forever to load. I had no choice but to go analog and reached for the Adler High Holiday prayer book my parents used.
It was bittersweet holding what they davened from, there in the flicker of their yahrzeit candles. The book’s cloth covers were as black as my bar mitzvah suit and the boxy Hebrew typography on its glossy pages as prim as the sitcoms of that period. Paging through this relic was at least as uncomfortable as confronting one’s bad hair in a high school yearbook. Worse, it beamed me right back to the suffocating Old Boy Judaism of my Conservative synagogue in the Bronx in the mid-1960s.
Adler’s consistently masculine pronouns gave God a distinctly male voice that the men of our shul — rabbi, cantor, sexton and their counterparts in the junior congregation — no doubt felt addressed them personally. This masculine language also reinforced my impression of Judaism as a men’s club, right down to the suits checking High Holiday tickets at the door or the boys reciting Torah blessings in their unsure, post-bar mitzvah voices. The women of our shul worked in the office and sang in the Sisterhood musicals; none shared the bimah with me during my bar mitzvah. The minyan, drawn exclusively from this men’s club, was trusted to open the ark and carry its Torah. Along similar lines, the locker room wisecracks made by my father and uncles at the first bris I attended gave Judaism the feel of a fraternity that would hardly welcome a faygele like me.
The Adler’s literary translations, worthy of a Norton Critical Edition, reproduced the meter and structure of the original Hebrew as faithfully as period instruments recreate early music. Its archaic King James Version vibe, complete with walkeths and goeths (this in 1959) betrayed its eighteenth-century English origins, appropriate for a sovereign claiming divine right. It stripped any Thou from the I and Thou and rendered God an unapproachable divine monarch, which more or less sums up the approach of my shul’s cheder classes. No wonder I learned to picture God as the proverbial old man with a white, flowing beard — not unlike that Al Hirschfeld drawing of Bernard Shaw on the cover of my mother’s recording of My Fair Lady — and a New York Yankees baseball cap. (We lived near the stadium.)
My ten year-old mind saw such hypermasculine Judaism spilling over into the equally gendered realm of sports. Both worlds emphasized feats of skill, tribal loyalty and shaming. Both made me anxious; I feared mixing up the meat and dairy silverware or flubbing a left-field catch in equal measure. God and softball tested and demanded; shirkers were exposed and lackluster performance punished. Still, if one could go home after nine innings of softball, God-as-umpire, scorekeeper and team-chooser never quit the diamond of the Jews. My pitifully unathletic self saw God’s stern hand in all those who made sure guys would “man up”: my gym teacher, father, grandfather and camp counselor. If God was nigh, as we sang around Boy Scout campfires, he was ready to call balls and strikes and banish those who couldn’t hit a softball if their lives depended on it.
Judaism’s male focus is particularly apparent in Adler’s rendering of High Holiday Torah texts. Abraham not only attempts to kill one son but is ready to off a second by banishing him and his mother. Slacker Jonah’s self-absorbed misanthropy endangers the lives of others. Yet I was taught to admire Abraham’s steadfastness and show no compassion for Jonah’s spiritual crisis. I was supposed to take Abraham’s potential violence in stride, even when it reminded me of bullying classmates, and I was to condemn Jonah’s fecklessness and his flight, even if the closeted person I was at the time recognized the need to keep secrets by keeping one’s distance. Abraham forgoes parental love, while God’s tone-deaf reaction to Jonah’s spiritual impasse compares with police arresting a disturbed person instead of helping them. These stories identify blind obedience and a very masculine abhorrence of weakness as essential Jewish values demanded by an alpha-male God.
The Lev Shalem machzor, by contrast, realizes there’s a problem with this depiction. A marginal note suggests that Abraham should have protested God’s orders. A later gloss reads Jonah’s story as a searing inner conflict rather than mere weakness in Jonah’s disobedience. Both interpretations favor understanding over judgement; they make allowances for human complexity. Adler, however, delivers these texts straight out of the box with nary a comment. Its flowery Jacobean renderings tacitly advocate submission over reflection. They ignore the cost of what these men do to themselves as well as others, condoning zero-sum, toxic masculinity.
I was glad when Lev Shalem’s gender-diverse service lit up on my phone again. The tally of three patriarchs heralding the Amidah is rounded out with the four matriarchs. Blessings appear in variant forms, not only pronoun-wise but offering gender- and theologically-neutral renderings of God’s name. Such Judaism feels less feminized than normalized, reflecting a world I want to live in. Yet traces of musty black-and-white Adler lurked in the “traditional” translations paired with contemporary versions, which prompted me to wonder when tradition becomes oppressive. When is it time, for example, to take down Confederate statues? The stories recounted during the High Holidays are part of who we are, yes, but that needn’t preclude some retooling.
And then there’s Avinu Malkeinu, the magisterial prayer for forgiveness that rarely leaves me dry-eyed. Still, the repetitions of father and king marching down the pages of both the Adler and Lev Shalem can be daunting. Lev, however, leaves these words untranslated, somehow diluting their masculine authority just enough — for English readers, at least — for them to become figures of comfort rather than power. This year, each iteration of these words clapped against my heart, releasing a tear of forgiveness for my own father.
Adler’s issues center less around text or translation but around God, an idea both fluid and amorphous, an expression of universal good and human striving that is ultimately too infinite to be contained between the covers of any book. Yet the idea has been commandeered by those who might be politely termed spiritual administrators, usually male, who, for example, prevented women from becoming Conservative rabbis until 1985. And in 2009, after Avi Weiss, my parents’ rabbi, ordained Sara Hurwitz, the Orthodox Rabbinical Council of America forbade its members from ordaining women. Ten years later, the Open Orthodox yeshiva founded by Weiss himself refused to ordain a gay rabbinical student. The best translations won’t easily loosen the chokehold of such male-centered Judaism; only a change of heart and mind can. In 2016, for example, my husband and I were married by a gay male rabbi.
The rabbi leading the services I streamed began this year’s Kol Nidre service as always: by announcing that she believes in a God who doesn’t care whether someone believes in God. It is easy for nonbelieving Jews such as myself to feel comfortable with a genderless, non-judgmental divine presence, unconcerned if I choose not to play softball that evening or ever again.
Eric Gabriel Lehman’s work has appeared in the New York Times, Brooklyn Rail, Raritan and elsewhere. He lives with his husband and two turtles in New York and teaches at Queens College.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Where Dating Meets DNA ft. Canavan Foundation
What Israel Taught Me About the Two Sides of Resilience
In Praise of Showing Up
Good Sabbath, South Africa
Launching a Rabbinical School in Germany and Pausing for Some Gratitude
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Setting Our Own Rules
As independent voters, we will no longer be forced to pretend that the zealots in our party must be tolerated in the name of “party unity.”
Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’
No matter how stressful or anxious life gets, gratitude is the saving grace, the one virtue that can give us the strength to keep going.
Jewish National Fund-USA’s Global Conference for Israel: Four Days of Zionist Pride in San Diego
It marked 125 years since the inception of the organization and its commitment to building up the land of Israel.
AJU’s Ziegler School to Launch Dual-Degree Model for Future Rabbis
The curriculum will also address contemporary challenges facing Jewish communities, including antisemitism and the responsible use of artificial intelligence and digital media.
Sharon Osbourne: ‘It’s Very Fashionable to Hate Jews and Israel’
Osbourne spoke candidly about antisemitism, her own Jewish roots and what she sees as an increasingly hostile world for Jews
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
What if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages?
What Isaac the Blind Sees
Isaac is not merely a blind man with insight; he is a blind man who has seen beyond this world.
Rabbis of LA | IDF Veteran, Guest of Rabbi Kahn, Remembers Oct. 7, 2023
Second of two parts
L.A. Federation’s Tour de Summer Camps, International Chabad Conference in NYC
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
Call Sheet – A poem for Parsha Toldot
See who’s in the cast.
A Bisl Torah ~ Dangerous Comparisons
Let us not compare child to child. God will remind us; there are ample parental blessings for each child to receive.
A Moment in Time: Holding On
Abraham Plants a Tamarisk Tree
Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026
A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.
Why Are We Even Here?
When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.
Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises
Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.
Boulou: A Cookie That Traveled From Djerba to Los Angeles
Boulou has deep roots in Djerba, but is treasured in all Tunisian Jewish kitchens, where it is baked for the holidays and special occasions.
What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?
We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.
“What Did the Doctor Say?” and Other Things that Keep Us from Laughing
Who’s got time to crack up in these crazy times? Well, I do.
NCSY Welcomes 400 Proudly Jewish Student Leaders to the JSU President’s Conference
JSU is a network of Jewish culture clubs in public and secular private high schools in North America, and it’s a program of NCSY, the international youth movement of the Orthodox Union.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.