What started with light had become dark.
Whatever God had dreamed when He dreamed of creation, had gotten away from Him. Adam and Chava had sinned, tarnishing the perfection of the Garden of Eden. In slaying his brother Abel, Cain had ushered violence and murder into the world. These aberrations, like God’s own creations, came about from nothing: ex nihilo. God had not willed them, and yet they were here.
Moreover, they now threatened to consume everything else.
The people became very wicked. They filled the earth with violence, tearing at one another like beasts. Through their sin, they corrupted the earth.
And so, God decided to begin again.
First, He had to undo what had already been done.
Stitch by stitch, the work of creation was unknit.
Dark clouds concealed the light.
The waters above and the waters below were rejoined—brought back to their primordial unity by the deluge that poured from the heavens down to the earth.
The seas, once discrete, gathered together and covered the land.
The soil loosened and the earth’s vegetation, unmoored, drifted into the stormy sea.
The animals drowned.
The people died.
Not all life, however, was extinguished. Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed. Out there, on the surface of this endless ocean, is a sealed cask.
Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed.
It is battered by rain above and tossed by waves below.
It is an ark, coated in pitch, in which a family dwells in darkness.
Subdivided into many rooms, the ark is cramped and fetid. It has a window, yes, but that will not be opened to the brilliance of light until many days and nights have passed, until the rain has abated and the dove is sent out to search for land.
For now, it is lightless, and the reek of animals fills the cabins. The family grows insensate to the deafening sound of the animals’ bellowing out for relief or the clatter of hooves on the wooden boards.
Crickets, cockroaches, ants and spiders coat the floors, the walls. Noah and his family huddle close to one another and wait.
Is this Eden in a time capsule? Indeed, inside that dark cell, snakes slither to and fro, winding themselves around one’s legs, constricting and hissing, terrifying and tempting.
But perhaps it is not Eden.
Perhaps, rather, it should be likened to a seed, in which the genetic material of all creation lies coiled, dormant, unrealized.
When the waters abate, Noah expresses his gratitude to the lord with a sacrifice.
He slaughters an animal. The smell is pleasing to God, who vows to never destroy the earth by flood again.
God then permits humans to consume meat.
“Every creature that lives shall be yours to eat; as with the green grasses, I give you all these. You must not, however, eat flesh with its life-blood in it” (Genesis 9:3-4).
We are no longer in Eden. We are no longer in our first draft. This is a revised edition, worked over with a red pen so much that the original text is no longer visible. It is a world of moral compromise, in which violence is to be mitigated but not eliminated, in which God realizes that creation is an act of letting go, of accepting that what you create can never be fully yours to control, in which you learn the hard way, over and over again, that what you create, creates you.
“Whoever sheds the blood of man,
By man shall his blood be shed;
For in His image
Did God make man” (Ibid 9:6).
Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.
Unscrolled Noach: In the Beginning, Again
Matthew Schultz
What started with light had become dark.
Whatever God had dreamed when He dreamed of creation, had gotten away from Him. Adam and Chava had sinned, tarnishing the perfection of the Garden of Eden. In slaying his brother Abel, Cain had ushered violence and murder into the world. These aberrations, like God’s own creations, came about from nothing: ex nihilo. God had not willed them, and yet they were here.
Moreover, they now threatened to consume everything else.
The people became very wicked. They filled the earth with violence, tearing at one another like beasts. Through their sin, they corrupted the earth.
And so, God decided to begin again.
First, He had to undo what had already been done.
Stitch by stitch, the work of creation was unknit.
Dark clouds concealed the light.
The waters above and the waters below were rejoined—brought back to their primordial unity by the deluge that poured from the heavens down to the earth.
The seas, once discrete, gathered together and covered the land.
The soil loosened and the earth’s vegetation, unmoored, drifted into the stormy sea.
The animals drowned.
The people died.
Not all life, however, was extinguished. Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed. Out there, on the surface of this endless ocean, is a sealed cask.
It is battered by rain above and tossed by waves below.
It is an ark, coated in pitch, in which a family dwells in darkness.
Subdivided into many rooms, the ark is cramped and fetid. It has a window, yes, but that will not be opened to the brilliance of light until many days and nights have passed, until the rain has abated and the dove is sent out to search for land.
For now, it is lightless, and the reek of animals fills the cabins. The family grows insensate to the deafening sound of the animals’ bellowing out for relief or the clatter of hooves on the wooden boards.
Crickets, cockroaches, ants and spiders coat the floors, the walls. Noah and his family huddle close to one another and wait.
Is this Eden in a time capsule? Indeed, inside that dark cell, snakes slither to and fro, winding themselves around one’s legs, constricting and hissing, terrifying and tempting.
But perhaps it is not Eden.
Perhaps, rather, it should be likened to a seed, in which the genetic material of all creation lies coiled, dormant, unrealized.
When the waters abate, Noah expresses his gratitude to the lord with a sacrifice.
He slaughters an animal. The smell is pleasing to God, who vows to never destroy the earth by flood again.
God then permits humans to consume meat.
“Every creature that lives shall be yours to eat; as with the green grasses, I give you all these. You must not, however, eat flesh with its life-blood in it” (Genesis 9:3-4).
We are no longer in Eden. We are no longer in our first draft. This is a revised edition, worked over with a red pen so much that the original text is no longer visible. It is a world of moral compromise, in which violence is to be mitigated but not eliminated, in which God realizes that creation is an act of letting go, of accepting that what you create can never be fully yours to control, in which you learn the hard way, over and over again, that what you create, creates you.
“Whoever sheds the blood of man,
By man shall his blood be shed;
For in His image
Did God make man” (Ibid 9:6).
Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Sailing Tahiti on The Jet Set TV: Why Windstar Cruises Delivers Small Ships, Big Experiences
Print Issue: Reflections | April 3, 2026
The Fourth Son in the Haggadah Echoes Kafka’s Investigative Dog
A Bisl Torah — Dayeinu: Enough or More than Enough
Order, Please – A poem for Passover
Why the Seder Is the Oldest Classroom in Human History
Rabbis of LA | Rabbi Shapiro Wants Music in All Aspects of Temple Life
Second of two parts
Antisemitism, Deicide, and Revolution
The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops did a remarkable thing: It issued a memorandum to all American Catholic bishops urging them to prepare their teachings carefully during this Easter period and ensure that they accurately present the Church’s positive teachings about Jews.
Ruth Wisse Challenges Americans to Live American, Jewish and Zionist Values
On March 25, Professor Ruth Wisse, the legendary Yiddish literature and Jewish culture scholar, used an all-American platform to inspire Americans with Jewish, Zionist and quintessentially American, lessons.
Shuk-style Mazal Market Returns with Pre-Passover ‘Renewal’
“Mazal Market will exist as long as there is a need for it. It’s a place where everyone feels like they’re Jewish enough together.”
Israeli Entrepreneurs Fuel California’s Economy with High-Paying Jobs
California has long been home to Israeli entrepreneurs and companies spanning tech, cybersecurity, custom software, financial services and full-service restaurants. These businesses generate jobs and strengthen the state economy.
Israel Bachar on Antisemitism, Hollywood and Mobilizing Global Support for Israel
While some voices on the far left and far right attempt to portray Israel as dragging the U.S. into war, Bachar stressed that this is not the reality, noting that the United States is acting based on its own strategic interests.
Chametz Is More than Crumbs in the Corners of our Homes
Chametz is also something that gathers in the corners of our being, the spiritual chametz that, like the physical particles we gather the night before Passover, can infect, wither, influence and sabotage us as we engage with others.
Kugel Kugel Everywhere
At Passover time, all kugels are welcome.
Joan Nathan’s Passover Favorites
Nathan’s family holidays go back 46 years with rotating guests and a community that forms around her ever-changing table.
Magic of Mimouna and a Walnut Cookie Recipe
They are perfect for a Mimouna table because they are flourless and can be baked during Passover, before Mimouna.
Alpine Flavors—a Crunchy Granola Recipe
Every Passover, I prepare a truly delicious gluten-free granola. I use lots of nuts and seeds (pistachios, walnuts, almonds and pumpkin seeds) and dried fruits (apricots, dates and cranberries).
Table for Five: Passover
The Our Ongoing Exodus
From Late-Night Vacuuming to Transcendence: A Passover Meditation
Passover itself denotes transcendence. Leaving one’s limitations. Leaping beyond the ordinary.
Pesach Reflections
How does the Exodus story, Judaism’s foundational narrative of freedom, speak to the present? We asked local leaders, including rabbis, educators and podcasters, to weigh in.
Rosner’s Domain | Be Skeptical of Skeptics, Too
Whoever risks a decisive or semi-decisive prediction of the campaign’s end (and there is a long list of such figures on the Israeli side as well as the American side) is not demonstrating wisdom but rather a lack of seriousness.
When We Can No Longer Agree on Who Is Pharaoh
The Seder asks us to remain present to the tension between competing fears and obligations. It does not require choosing one lesson over the other, but rather, it creates space for us to articulate our concerns and listen to the fears and hopes that shape others’ views.
The Battle for Zionism Will Be Won — or Lost — at the Seder Table
The Haggadah’s original purpose is not to soothe. It is to mobilize.
Pesach at War. Leaving Fast, Leaving Slow.
Freedom, it would seem, is erratic; it happens in fits and starts, three steps forward and two steps back. Freedom is a leap into the unknown, driven by a dream. We will figure it out in time.
A Moment in Time: “Passover – Bedikat Chametz”
The Bias of KPBS, San Diego’s National Public Radio Affiliate
NPR executives may deny accusations of political bias, but the reporting by KPBS on the IHRA definition and the presence of an outspoken anti-Zionist as a producer exemplifies of what makes NPR so vulnerable.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.