What started with light had become dark.
Whatever God had dreamed when He dreamed of creation, had gotten away from Him. Adam and Chava had sinned, tarnishing the perfection of the Garden of Eden. In slaying his brother Abel, Cain had ushered violence and murder into the world. These aberrations, like God’s own creations, came about from nothing: ex nihilo. God had not willed them, and yet they were here.
Moreover, they now threatened to consume everything else.
The people became very wicked. They filled the earth with violence, tearing at one another like beasts. Through their sin, they corrupted the earth.
And so, God decided to begin again.
First, He had to undo what had already been done.
Stitch by stitch, the work of creation was unknit.
Dark clouds concealed the light.
The waters above and the waters below were rejoined—brought back to their primordial unity by the deluge that poured from the heavens down to the earth.
The seas, once discrete, gathered together and covered the land.
The soil loosened and the earth’s vegetation, unmoored, drifted into the stormy sea.
The animals drowned.
The people died.
Not all life, however, was extinguished. Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed. Out there, on the surface of this endless ocean, is a sealed cask.
Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed.
It is battered by rain above and tossed by waves below.
It is an ark, coated in pitch, in which a family dwells in darkness.
Subdivided into many rooms, the ark is cramped and fetid. It has a window, yes, but that will not be opened to the brilliance of light until many days and nights have passed, until the rain has abated and the dove is sent out to search for land.
For now, it is lightless, and the reek of animals fills the cabins. The family grows insensate to the deafening sound of the animals’ bellowing out for relief or the clatter of hooves on the wooden boards.
Crickets, cockroaches, ants and spiders coat the floors, the walls. Noah and his family huddle close to one another and wait.
Is this Eden in a time capsule? Indeed, inside that dark cell, snakes slither to and fro, winding themselves around one’s legs, constricting and hissing, terrifying and tempting.
But perhaps it is not Eden.
Perhaps, rather, it should be likened to a seed, in which the genetic material of all creation lies coiled, dormant, unrealized.
When the waters abate, Noah expresses his gratitude to the lord with a sacrifice.
He slaughters an animal. The smell is pleasing to God, who vows to never destroy the earth by flood again.
God then permits humans to consume meat.
“Every creature that lives shall be yours to eat; as with the green grasses, I give you all these. You must not, however, eat flesh with its life-blood in it” (Genesis 9:3-4).
We are no longer in Eden. We are no longer in our first draft. This is a revised edition, worked over with a red pen so much that the original text is no longer visible. It is a world of moral compromise, in which violence is to be mitigated but not eliminated, in which God realizes that creation is an act of letting go, of accepting that what you create can never be fully yours to control, in which you learn the hard way, over and over again, that what you create, creates you.
“Whoever sheds the blood of man,
By man shall his blood be shed;
For in His image
Did God make man” (Ibid 9:6).
Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.
Unscrolled Noach: In the Beginning, Again
Matthew Schultz
What started with light had become dark.
Whatever God had dreamed when He dreamed of creation, had gotten away from Him. Adam and Chava had sinned, tarnishing the perfection of the Garden of Eden. In slaying his brother Abel, Cain had ushered violence and murder into the world. These aberrations, like God’s own creations, came about from nothing: ex nihilo. God had not willed them, and yet they were here.
Moreover, they now threatened to consume everything else.
The people became very wicked. They filled the earth with violence, tearing at one another like beasts. Through their sin, they corrupted the earth.
And so, God decided to begin again.
First, He had to undo what had already been done.
Stitch by stitch, the work of creation was unknit.
Dark clouds concealed the light.
The waters above and the waters below were rejoined—brought back to their primordial unity by the deluge that poured from the heavens down to the earth.
The seas, once discrete, gathered together and covered the land.
The soil loosened and the earth’s vegetation, unmoored, drifted into the stormy sea.
The animals drowned.
The people died.
Not all life, however, was extinguished. Just when it seems as though we had returned to un-being, to the darkness that came before light, we spot a candle flickering in the distance, though it is very dim indeed. Out there, on the surface of this endless ocean, is a sealed cask.
It is battered by rain above and tossed by waves below.
It is an ark, coated in pitch, in which a family dwells in darkness.
Subdivided into many rooms, the ark is cramped and fetid. It has a window, yes, but that will not be opened to the brilliance of light until many days and nights have passed, until the rain has abated and the dove is sent out to search for land.
For now, it is lightless, and the reek of animals fills the cabins. The family grows insensate to the deafening sound of the animals’ bellowing out for relief or the clatter of hooves on the wooden boards.
Crickets, cockroaches, ants and spiders coat the floors, the walls. Noah and his family huddle close to one another and wait.
Is this Eden in a time capsule? Indeed, inside that dark cell, snakes slither to and fro, winding themselves around one’s legs, constricting and hissing, terrifying and tempting.
But perhaps it is not Eden.
Perhaps, rather, it should be likened to a seed, in which the genetic material of all creation lies coiled, dormant, unrealized.
When the waters abate, Noah expresses his gratitude to the lord with a sacrifice.
He slaughters an animal. The smell is pleasing to God, who vows to never destroy the earth by flood again.
God then permits humans to consume meat.
“Every creature that lives shall be yours to eat; as with the green grasses, I give you all these. You must not, however, eat flesh with its life-blood in it” (Genesis 9:3-4).
We are no longer in Eden. We are no longer in our first draft. This is a revised edition, worked over with a red pen so much that the original text is no longer visible. It is a world of moral compromise, in which violence is to be mitigated but not eliminated, in which God realizes that creation is an act of letting go, of accepting that what you create can never be fully yours to control, in which you learn the hard way, over and over again, that what you create, creates you.
“Whoever sheds the blood of man,
By man shall his blood be shed;
For in His image
Did God make man” (Ibid 9:6).
Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Power Addict Trump Getting High on New Lows
When Social Media Rewrites Jewish Identity
“United for Sydney” Event, Galperin Named AJC Interim Director, Jewish Future Fellowship
UC Irvine Student Government Removes Language Mentioning Modern Antisemitism and Holocaust Denial in IHRD Resolution
State Senator Scott Wiener to Step Down as Jewish Caucus Co-Chair
I Went – A poem for Parsha Bo
Rain in the Flood, Sodom and Gomorrah and Egypt
A Bisl Torah – Complete Darkness
What does it mean to live in total and complete darkness?
A Moment in Time: “I am a Jew”
American Jewish University Rabbi Brad Artson Begins New Chapter
AJU has announced that Rabbi Artson will be named the Mordecai Kaplan Distinguished Scholar, effective July 1, a position that places him at the heart of the university’s intellectual, spiritual and public-facing life.
Where Service Becomes Story: Sailing the Norwegian Escape
Print Issue: Three Days of Israeliness | January 23, 2026
More than 3,500 participants gathered for the Israeli-American Council’s 10th annual summit, a gathering that happily blurred the line between serious content and Israeli vibes.
Hilary Sheinbaum: Going Dry, Sober Curiosity and Non-Alcoholic Margaritas
Taste Buds with Deb – Episode 139
Reflecting on a Giant of Tzedakah, Marvin Schotland, z”l
Marvin Schotland—who passed away Jan. 7 at the age of 78—led the Jewish Community Foundation of Los Angeles for 33 years.
Runner-Up on ‘Survivor,’ Now a Debut Author: Stephen Fishbach’s ‘Escape!‘
The novel centers on Kent Duvall, a faded reality TV star, and a disgraced producer who are offered one last chance at redemption in a competition filmed on a remote island.
Catching Up with Meryl Ain, Author of the Humorous Book of Essays, ‘Remember to Eat’
“I hope that readers laugh, cry, ponder and discuss. I hope they see themselves and people they know in some of the situations and stories.“
This International Holocaust Remembrance Day, Let’s Start with the Survivors Among Us
International Holocaust Remembrance Day is not only a time to look back, it is a call to care for those still here.
Israel on Campus Coalition Takes Fellows on a Meaningful Trip to Israel and UAE
Every year, Israel on Campus Coalition, a nonprofit that empowers pro-Israel students to stand up for Israel on campus, takes their fellows on a 10-day trip to the United Arab Emirates and Israel.
Sephardic and Mizrahi Groups Condemn Wiener’s Genocide Claim
LA-based Iranian-American-Jewish advocacy group, 30 Years After, withdraws support from JPAC until further notice
Life in Black and White
These nostalgic pinwheel cookies are simply delicious. Perhaps you’ll bake them and create special memories for a child in your life.
Pies for Pie Day
These produce-based pies are the perfect addition to any milchig or parve meal.
Table for Five: Bo
Pharaoh’s Refusal
Heroes, Celebrities and Community: Inside the 10th Annual IAC Summit
More than 3,500 participants gathered for the Israeli-American Council’s 10th annual summit, a gathering that happily blurred the line between serious content and Israeli vibes.
Judea Pearl’s New Book and Other Lively Words
A passionate Zionist and renowned scientist shows us that “fighting words” don’t have to look like fighting words.
When Hate Crosses the Threshold: Antisemitism and the Targeting of Jewish Greek Life
We cannot allow Jewish students to live in fear of constant attacks because it’s easier than finding ways to have hard conversations and explore resolutions.
Rosner’s Domain | Turkey or Apocalypse
There are four things to consider as we ponder the U.S.-declared transition to a “second phase” in Gaza.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.