fbpx

Thoughts about death and living life -by Rabbi Hyim Shafner

[additional-authors]
February 23, 2012

One of my favorite stories is one told of a great rabbi and mystic who lived several centuries ago, Rabbi Menachem Mendal of Kotzk.  He asked his students, “What would you do if you knew you had only one more week to live?”  The first answered, “I would spend it with my family,” another said, “I would spend it doing mitzvoth, good acts of kindness,”  a third said” I would spend it studying Torah, meditating and praying.”  Then they turned to Rabbi Menachem Mendal and asked him, rabbi, “and what would you do?”  Answered the rabbi, “I would do what I do every day.” 

I have often wondered what it would be like to know I was dying.  We all are, you know.  Religion runs the risk of missing this.  Often it either focuses on a different world after death, and so misses the impact of living here and now in a way informed by the reality of our death, or fixated on how to perform the details of this life, its proscriptions, beliefs and rituals, shrinking the space humans have in which to sit back and really feel the great reality of death; that we are dying and on some level, for even the most profound believer, death brings with it annihilation, nonbeing as we know it. 

Some will instinctively dismiss this notion with, “yes, but for a better life with God.”  Perhaps, but even if that is so, if we do not give ourselves the opportunity to know we are dying, to feel the dread of oblivion first, then we have ignored an important gift.  Being human, truly being present in the here and now, means knowing we will cease to be.  Many deny death, ignore death in these and other much more superficial ways, but to live in a state of avoidance is perhaps to not really live. 

How would you live if you knew we are dying?  (Which again I remind you, we are.)  What regrets do you have?  What changes can be made?  What letters written?  What experiences had?  What really is meaningful and what is not?  Why are we here?  What is my unique place and mission in this mysterious, but I believe meaningful, world?

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Searching for the Red Heifer

While there’s nothing wrong with keeping your eyes on the horizon for that magical heifer to appear, be sure to appreciate what you already have.

Broadening the Fight

If we agree that antisemitism is only one example of a widespread and pernicious instinct toward division and “other-ization,” then it becomes clear that we can only eradicate these animosities as part of a far broader effort.

Evil Does Not Negotiate

Evil is repeatedly misunderstood because civilized societies instinctively judge others through the lens of their own moral framework.

How the World Cup Makes Boredom Look Good

Can you imagine telling someone about a sport where after 90 minutes, a team only manages three shots on goal? It’d be like going to a Bruce Springsteen concert and only hearing three songs.

No Wars for Jews

It was of paramount importance, particularly to the Americans, that their fight in World War II not be seen as a war on behalf of the Jews.

Shabbat Shalom, America

In the midst of our parties and barbeques, Shabbat is God’s birthday present to America to remind us that we still live in the greatest country on earth.

The More We Analyze, the Worse It Gets

Here we are with brilliant commentators producing brilliant commentary on, say, the roots of antisemitism and antizionism – complete with books, summits and white papers – and it barely makes a dent.

A Bisl Torah — Go Out Before Them

No matter if we assign ourselves the title of leader, we each lead in some respect, whether it’s leading as a parent, a supervisor, a friend, or a member of our neighborhoods.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.