fbpx

The Real Manya

Manya Hartmayer Breuer, a docent at The Jewish Federation\'s Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust, usually doesn\'t watch Holocaust films. They stir up too many painful memories.
[additional-authors]
February 8, 2001

Manya Hartmayer Breuer, a docent at The Jewish Federation’s Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust, usually doesn’t watch Holocaust films. They stir up too many painful memories. But last week, the Culver City resident watched — and cried through — all four hours of the upcoming CBS miniseries “Haven,” the story of 982 Holocaust survivors whisked from war-torn Europe to America.

Manya’s reasons were personal. She was one of the survivors escorted to safety by the Jewish American journalist Ruth Gruber, and she was the first bride to marry in the U.S. Army camp where the refugees were interned in 1944. In the miniseries, we first encounter Manya as a tall, thin teenager with haunted, sunken blue-green eyes, as played by actress Tamara Gorski.

During a Journal interview, the real Manya, who is also tall and slender, described how she survived five concentration camps; in one, she endured a beating so severe that she huddled in a corner for weeks, unable to move. After fleeing over the Alps to Rome, wearing only summer clothing, she hid in a convent where she subsisted for months on moldy chestnuts. One day, while walking through the city with false papers, she stood before a little synagogue in the shadow of the Coliseum and felt as hunted as the early Christians who were martyred in the Roman amphitheater. “When I was liberated, my first step was to go back to that little synagogue to thank HaShem,” she says. It was while she was in the shul that she met the U.S. officials who helped her secure a coveted spot on Gruber’s mission.

When a fellow refugee named Ernst Breuer fell in love with Manya and proposed marriage, the survivor was reluctant, as depicted in the miniseries. She was too worried about her parents to contemplate the future: She had last seen her mother in the Gurs concentration camp, and her father had been arrested by the Nazis. At one point, Manya’s father had given her his cotton shirt to protect her from the cold; she refused to take it off long after she arrived at the Army camp in Oswego, N.Y. In one of the most poignant scenes in “Haven,” Manya explains that the shirt is the sole memento she has left of her Papa.

In another powerful scene, Manya finally meets Breuer under the chuppah; for the real Manya, the sequence stirred memories of her wedding day. The balmy August morning began as the survivor and her friends raced around the camp, picking wildflowers for her bridal bouquet. Later, in a barracks room, Gruber and her mother helped Manya slip into a borrowed gray gown and a white silk veil Ruth’s mother had crocheted for the occasion. A little after 10 a.m., Mama Gruber helped escort Manya down the aisle, in lieu of her own mother. “I will always love you for this,” the survivor told her.

While Hartmayer Breuer believes no film can ever capture the Holocaust experience, she is pleased that the refugees’ story will air on national television this week. “From the Shoah, we learn that the important thing is to love and respect one another,” says the survivor, who participated in a recent panel discussion after a “Haven” screening sponsored by The Jewish Federation’s L.A. Museum of the Holocaust in association with the MorningStar Commission. “It doesn’t matter who you are, where you come from or how you believe in HaShem.”

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

The Oprahs of Gaza

Emmanuel Macron, Keir Starmer and Mark Carney are now de facto benefactors of rogue states, the Oprahs of Gaza: “You get a state! And you get a state, too!”

In Praise of Jewish Labels

Jews are living in an era of our grand family reunion. After 1900 years of wandering the world, now we can all meet up at Pico Glatt.

The Shema: A Love Story

The Shema is the Jewish mission statement, and even more; it has become over the years a symbol of Jewish identity.

Living in an Upside-Down World

Terrorists and budding terrorists are referred to as “survivors,” who, we’re told with no caveats, “blame Israel for their wounds.”

Iran’s Political Instability: Capital and Brain Drain

The Tehran Chamber of Commerce has reported a persistent decline in new investments over the past decade. At the same time, large-scale capital flight has been reported—signaling deep economic instability and widespread impoverishment.

Ozymandias Then and Now

Percy Shelly’s 1818 poem “Ozymandias” conveys a timeless message, as important today as it was the day it was published.

Print Issue: Our Last Free Issue | August 8, 2025

As you know, it’s costly to produce and print your favorite paper every week. So we need thousands of readers like you to contribute by ordering home delivery. You win, we win, the community wins. Go to Jewishjournal.com/subscribe for details.

Why Would Anyone Ever Hire Me?

The Journal gave a kid who, at one time, the world had washed their hands of a chance. For a writer to have the open forum I’ve had is a blessing.

More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.