Here’s one college move-in story I can guarantee you haven’t heard before.
This fall, my son began his freshman year at a college too far from our home in New York for us to load the car with all his stuff and drive him, which we had done for his older sister each year. Instead, he decided to fly, and because New York’s COVID-19 regulations would have required us to quarantine for 14 days upon our return, we sent him by himself. His luggage would be picked up at our house, placed in a gigantic U-Haul, and driven 16 hours to the Midwest, where it would sit in a warehouse in the summer heat for nearly a week until he arrived to claim it. I lamented that I wouldn’t be able to make up his bed in his dorm room. He said I shouldn’t worry; he’s not planning to make his bed — ever. Cringe.
His impending independence notwithstanding, my son was grateful when I offered to pack the duffle bag with linens, blankets, towels and various other sundries for his room. I explained the usage of the new white mattress pad and pillow protectors, and he looked at me blankly. He politely declined the washcloths, wondering aloud what they’re for. I added a surge protector and a small fan, and congratulated myself on providing some items that will be useful but wouldn’t have occurred to him. I tossed in a collapsible lawn chair in the hopes he’ll socially distance outdoors while the weather holds.
I left him to pack his clothes — he was way too grown up for me to choose his pants or count his underwear. I smiled when I noticed he’d packed a suit for yom tov and teared up when I saw he’d left at least a few of his beloved Mets shirts behind. On Sunday night, he managed to stuff all of his clothes and shoes into his old, soft-sided camp trunk. I don’t know whether he had to sit on the top to close the zipper; I was afraid to ask.
On Monday morning, two friendly and efficient young men arrived to pick up the bags. We watched as they loaded the luggage onto the truck, then we went inside the house, lost in thought, wondering what to do with ourselves until his departure the following Sunday.
On Wednesday night, after dinner, my son opened the freezer and, after looking around for a minute, asked, “Where’s my ice cream?”
“I don’t know. Did you buy ice cream?” I asked.
“Yes. I bought a pint of Häagen-Dazs when I went to the CVS for my shampoo and stuff.”
A look of confusion passed over his face, then understanding, then horror. He had packed the ice cream in his clothes trunk.
“What flavor?” I asked, in an attempt to mask my distress.
“Vanilla chocolate chip.”
My son, an honors physics student in high school, calculated the volume of frozen versus melted ice cream and contemplated how the container would expand in the heat. I retreated to my bedroom to run a Google search: Does melted ice cream in a closed space explode? I found nothing, but was not reassured.
All week, I imagined every permutation of what that ice cream was doing in my son’s luggage. I envisioned a terrible sour odor emanating from the bag, clinging to his clothing and destroying any chance of him making new friends. I saw the chocolate staining his good suit. In the middle of the night, I woke up in a sweat, picturing ants, literally, in his pants.
By Thursday, my son announced he was “over it.” It will be what it will be.
He left on the plane Sunday morning, and I sat on my hands so I wouldn’t flood him with texts upon his arrival. In the mid-afternoon, he finally posted a video in our family group chat. I watched as he approached the bag, nose-first, announcing that from the outside, there was no smell. He methodically opened the trunk, removing layers and pausing to sniff, until he uncovered the paper CVS bag. He reached in and pulled out the pint of ice cream. It was entirely intact, dry and odorless. He raised a fist in triumph and declared with a confident smile, “We’re all good.”
And we are. We’re all good.
Reyna Marder Gentin is a graduate of Yale Law School. Her forthcoming novel for young readers, My Name is Layla, will be published in January 2021.
Averting a Meltdown
Reyna Gentin
Here’s one college move-in story I can guarantee you haven’t heard before.
This fall, my son began his freshman year at a college too far from our home in New York for us to load the car with all his stuff and drive him, which we had done for his older sister each year. Instead, he decided to fly, and because New York’s COVID-19 regulations would have required us to quarantine for 14 days upon our return, we sent him by himself. His luggage would be picked up at our house, placed in a gigantic U-Haul, and driven 16 hours to the Midwest, where it would sit in a warehouse in the summer heat for nearly a week until he arrived to claim it. I lamented that I wouldn’t be able to make up his bed in his dorm room. He said I shouldn’t worry; he’s not planning to make his bed — ever. Cringe.
His impending independence notwithstanding, my son was grateful when I offered to pack the duffle bag with linens, blankets, towels and various other sundries for his room. I explained the usage of the new white mattress pad and pillow protectors, and he looked at me blankly. He politely declined the washcloths, wondering aloud what they’re for. I added a surge protector and a small fan, and congratulated myself on providing some items that will be useful but wouldn’t have occurred to him. I tossed in a collapsible lawn chair in the hopes he’ll socially distance outdoors while the weather holds.
I left him to pack his clothes — he was way too grown up for me to choose his pants or count his underwear. I smiled when I noticed he’d packed a suit for yom tov and teared up when I saw he’d left at least a few of his beloved Mets shirts behind. On Sunday night, he managed to stuff all of his clothes and shoes into his old, soft-sided camp trunk. I don’t know whether he had to sit on the top to close the zipper; I was afraid to ask.
On Monday morning, two friendly and efficient young men arrived to pick up the bags. We watched as they loaded the luggage onto the truck, then we went inside the house, lost in thought, wondering what to do with ourselves until his departure the following Sunday.
On Wednesday night, after dinner, my son opened the freezer and, after looking around for a minute, asked, “Where’s my ice cream?”
“I don’t know. Did you buy ice cream?” I asked.
“Yes. I bought a pint of Häagen-Dazs when I went to the CVS for my shampoo and stuff.”
A look of confusion passed over his face, then understanding, then horror. He had packed the ice cream in his clothes trunk.
“What flavor?” I asked, in an attempt to mask my distress.
“Vanilla chocolate chip.”
My son, an honors physics student in high school, calculated the volume of frozen versus melted ice cream and contemplated how the container would expand in the heat. I retreated to my bedroom to run a Google search: Does melted ice cream in a closed space explode? I found nothing, but was not reassured.
All week, I imagined every permutation of what that ice cream was doing in my son’s luggage. I envisioned a terrible sour odor emanating from the bag, clinging to his clothing and destroying any chance of him making new friends. I saw the chocolate staining his good suit. In the middle of the night, I woke up in a sweat, picturing ants, literally, in his pants.
By Thursday, my son announced he was “over it.” It will be what it will be.
He left on the plane Sunday morning, and I sat on my hands so I wouldn’t flood him with texts upon his arrival. In the mid-afternoon, he finally posted a video in our family group chat. I watched as he approached the bag, nose-first, announcing that from the outside, there was no smell. He methodically opened the trunk, removing layers and pausing to sniff, until he uncovered the paper CVS bag. He reached in and pulled out the pint of ice cream. It was entirely intact, dry and odorless. He raised a fist in triumph and declared with a confident smile, “We’re all good.”
And we are. We’re all good.
Reyna Marder Gentin is a graduate of Yale Law School. Her forthcoming novel for young readers, My Name is Layla, will be published in January 2021.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
The Sweet Song of Survival
A Big Bear Getaway: Nature, Luxury, and Restoration.
A Moment in Time: God’s Birthday
A Bisl Torah — Spiritual Enslavement
On That Day – A poem for Parsha Ki Tisa
Purim and the Ten Commandments
Gavin Newsom Is No Jack Kennedy
Ambition over principle. Political gain over integrity. That is his legacy — a legacy stained in shame.
Print Issue: Iran | March 5, 2026
Success in the war against Iran – which every American and Israeli should hope for – will only strengthen the tendency of both leaders to highlight their dominant personalities as the state axis, at the expense of the boring institutions that serve them.
Diving, Luxury and Wild Discoveries in Central Florida on The Jet Set TV
In a Pickle– A Turshi Recipe
Tangy, bright and filled with irresistible umami flavor, turshi is the perfect complement to burgers, kebabs and chicken, as well as the perfect foil for eggs and salads.
Sweet Kugel Recipes for National Noodle Month
Nothing says Jewish comfort food like sweet noodle kugel.
Table for Five: Ki Tisa
Understanding The Divine
Re-Reading Persia: Thoughts on an Ancient Text in a Modern Moment
On Purim, re-reading Persia, we stand at the intersection of the past and this very moment. May we merit not merely a temporary cessation of war, but true peace — the ultimate end of all conflict.
The War in Iran: Revolution, Assassination, Reconstruction
As Israel is learning in Gaza, achieving regime change from the outside, without a commitment to deep and continuous involvement, is a difficult task.
Who Knows?
When future generations tell your story and mine, which parts will look obvious in hindsight? What opportunities will we have leveraged — and decisions made — that define our legacy?
Nostalgia for the ‘80s and ‘90s and the Lost World of Third Spaces
The nostalgia attached to the ’80s and ’90s often comes from a world where public hanging-out was built into daily life.
You Heard It Here First, Folks!
For over half a decade, I had seen how the slow drip of antisemitism, carefully enveloped in the language of social justice and human rights, had steadily poisoned people whom I had previously considered perfectly reasonable.
Bringing the Best of Diaspora Jewry to Israel
Today, amid rising global antisemitism and uncertainty in the Diaspora, many Anglos considering aliyah are searching not only for housing but for belonging.
Trump’s Critics Have a Lot Riding on the Iran Conflict
Their assumptions about the attack on Iran are based on a belief in the resilience of an evil terrorist regime, coupled with a conviction that Trump’s belief in the importance of the U.S.-Israel alliance is inherently wrong.
The Snake, the Shepherd’s Crook, and the Eye of the Sun: Uncovering the Haggadah’s Hidden Meaning
As Bar Ilan University professor Joshua Berman engagingly and convincingly demonstrates in his “Echoes of Egypt” Haggadah, the process by which the Passover story took shape was as a polemic against the belief system and symbols of authority of Pharaoh and his people.
The Night Watch: How Hundreds of U.S. Volunteers Support Israel Through the Night
We may never know each other’s names. We may never meet. Yet for those minutes, across oceans, time zones, and screens, we share something deeply human.
Me Llamo Miguel
With Purim having just passed, I’ve been thinking about how Jews have been disguising ourselves over the years.
The Hope of Return
This moment calls for moral imagination. For solidarity with the Iranian people demanding dignity. For sustained support of those who seek a freer future.
Stranded by War
We are struggling on two fronts: we worry about friends and family, and we are preoccupied with our own “survival” on a trip extended beyond our control.
Tuning Up Trouble: Daniel Roher Turns a Piano Tuner into a Master Safe-Cracker
In the film, Leo Woodall plays Niki White, a gifted young piano tuner in New York whose heightened auditory abilities allow him to detect even the faintest mechanical sounds.
Love Letters to Israel
Looking around at the tears, laughter, and joy after two years of hell, the show was able to not just touch but nourish our souls.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.