fbpx

A Moment in Time: “Finding, Making, Becoming”

[additional-authors]
October 30, 2025

Dear all,

Rabbi Judah ben Perachya taught in the Mishnah, “Asei l’cha Rav.”

It’s not the easiest phrase to translate. Here are three possibilities:

  1. “Make yourself into a rabbi.”
  2. “Make (or find) for yourself a rabbi.”
  3. “Create rabbis—inspire others to become rabbis.”

I found myself reflecting on this teaching earlier this week over coffee with my dear friend, Rabbi Eric Rosenstein. Eric was just a young boy when I first became a rabbi, growing up in the congregation I served. I was elated when he chose to become a rabbi himself.

For years, I believed I had lived out two of these interpretations. I had helped inspire someone else to become a rabbi (number three), and Eric had made himself into a rabbi (number one).

But during our recent conversation, as Eric shared his wisdom and insights, I realized something new: I had also fulfilled the second teaching. In Eric, I had found for myself a rabbi.

When our students become our teachers, the world opens to new possibilities. And in that moment in time, the present becomes a bridge to tomorrow.

With love and shalom,

Rabbi Zachary R. Shapiro

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Perfect Pumpkin Soup Recipes

These recipes, which came from plant-based chefs Marisa Baggett and Micah Siva, are as nutritious as they are delicious.

Righteous Among the Rockers

As antisemitism continues to rise, a group of musicians has stood up against the forces of hate and built bridges through their music.

The Power of a Billion Prayers

The release of the last living hostages has created a clean end point for the special prayers. Yet it is important to recognize the value of these billion prayers, even as they come to an end.

Baseball, the Bible and William Brewster

Whether or not Whitecaps alum Will Smith and the Dodgers emerge victorious once more, all Americans have reason to cheer for William Brewster – a fascinating figure whose biblically-infused impact on America continues to inspire.

More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.