If you wanted to write a script about a volatile situation, you could start with this logline: two enemies navigate under great uncertainty. They both have new leaders who must prove to their people and the world that they have what it takes to lead a country in a time of crisis. One of them sees an opportunity because of global developments that make it easy for him to be more aggressive. The other one is afraid that the enemy is taking advantage of the situation, and becomes nervous. Then, one of them initiates an attack. The result is somewhat more dire than expected. The other turns to the international community for help. They tell him “do what you have to do.”
Episode one. The end.
Do you see why this is a most dangerous time for these countries? We are talking about Iran, with a newly-elected president, and Israel, with a newly-elected Prime Minister. And it is the Biden administration that wants to keep its cool in order to avoid ruining delicate negotiations to renew the so-called nuclear deal with Iran. Following an Iranian attack on a ship off the coast of Oman, the U.S. State Secretary acknowledged that the attack “follows a pattern of attacks and other belligerent behavior.” To this pattern, the current U.S. response is business as usual. Iran attacks—as usual. The U.S. seeks a diplomatic agreement—as usual. Israel grumbles and threatens—as usual. “We are working to rally the world, but at the same time we also know to act alone,” Israel’s PM Naftali Bennett said.
It is often the newly-elected who make the most aggressive moves against an enemy, as not to be seen as weak. A Financial Times story captured the mood in Tehran with a vivid headline: “Iran’s new hardline president defiant in face of sanctions and security concerns.” And if Iran’s president is defiant, Bennett must reciprocate by also being defiant. A decade and a half ago, when Ehud Olmert became the Prime Minister, he felt that he must respond decisively to a Hezbollah attack in the north. The result was the second Lebanon war. Would he have acted similarly had he not been new on the job? That’s hard to tell. And yet, we can’t discount the suspicion that a new leader, needing to prove his worth, might be more aggressive than an experienced old lion.
It is often the newly-elected who make the most aggressive moves against an enemy, as not to be seen as weak.
On Monday, the Brits, who weren’t pleased with Iran’s behavior, summoned the Iranian ambassador for a brief talk about what the British government called the “unlawful attack” on a ship. On Tuesday afternoon, reports about more missing ships began circulating. A “potential hijack” was unfolding off the coast of the United Arab Emirates, Britain’s maritime trade agency reported. The details were murky, but some observers were quick to assume that this is Iran’s deed. Would Tehran go as far as provoking a hard-nosed government? Only time will tell. But it’s not impossible that Iran senses an opportunity to send a “back off” message to the west by upping the ante.
Surely, Boris Johnson has better things to do than open a front against Iran.
And as for Joe Biden, he already proved that his heart is somewhere else.
Does Bennett feel the great burden of having to stand alone in a dangerous and consequential battlefield? Being Israel’s Prime Minister is a difficult job. It is difficult not because of Covid, or the nonsense of coalition politics, or having to plan a budget. It is difficult because Israel has dangerous enemies out there, who constantly search for an opportunity to attack us.
Shmuel Rosner is an Israeli columnist, editor, and researcher. He is the editor of the research and data-journalism website themadad.com, and is the political editor of the Jewish Journal.
Jewish Journal
The High Risk of Newly Appointed Warriors
Shmuel Rosner
If you wanted to write a script about a volatile situation, you could start with this logline: two enemies navigate under great uncertainty. They both have new leaders who must prove to their people and the world that they have what it takes to lead a country in a time of crisis. One of them sees an opportunity because of global developments that make it easy for him to be more aggressive. The other one is afraid that the enemy is taking advantage of the situation, and becomes nervous. Then, one of them initiates an attack. The result is somewhat more dire than expected. The other turns to the international community for help. They tell him “do what you have to do.”
Episode one. The end.
Do you see why this is a most dangerous time for these countries? We are talking about Iran, with a newly-elected president, and Israel, with a newly-elected Prime Minister. And it is the Biden administration that wants to keep its cool in order to avoid ruining delicate negotiations to renew the so-called nuclear deal with Iran. Following an Iranian attack on a ship off the coast of Oman, the U.S. State Secretary acknowledged that the attack “follows a pattern of attacks and other belligerent behavior.” To this pattern, the current U.S. response is business as usual. Iran attacks—as usual. The U.S. seeks a diplomatic agreement—as usual. Israel grumbles and threatens—as usual. “We are working to rally the world, but at the same time we also know to act alone,” Israel’s PM Naftali Bennett said.
It is often the newly-elected who make the most aggressive moves against an enemy, as not to be seen as weak. A Financial Times story captured the mood in Tehran with a vivid headline: “Iran’s new hardline president defiant in face of sanctions and security concerns.” And if Iran’s president is defiant, Bennett must reciprocate by also being defiant. A decade and a half ago, when Ehud Olmert became the Prime Minister, he felt that he must respond decisively to a Hezbollah attack in the north. The result was the second Lebanon war. Would he have acted similarly had he not been new on the job? That’s hard to tell. And yet, we can’t discount the suspicion that a new leader, needing to prove his worth, might be more aggressive than an experienced old lion.
On Monday, the Brits, who weren’t pleased with Iran’s behavior, summoned the Iranian ambassador for a brief talk about what the British government called the “unlawful attack” on a ship. On Tuesday afternoon, reports about more missing ships began circulating. A “potential hijack” was unfolding off the coast of the United Arab Emirates, Britain’s maritime trade agency reported. The details were murky, but some observers were quick to assume that this is Iran’s deed. Would Tehran go as far as provoking a hard-nosed government? Only time will tell. But it’s not impossible that Iran senses an opportunity to send a “back off” message to the west by upping the ante.
Surely, Boris Johnson has better things to do than open a front against Iran.
And as for Joe Biden, he already proved that his heart is somewhere else.
Does Bennett feel the great burden of having to stand alone in a dangerous and consequential battlefield? Being Israel’s Prime Minister is a difficult job. It is difficult not because of Covid, or the nonsense of coalition politics, or having to plan a budget. It is difficult because Israel has dangerous enemies out there, who constantly search for an opportunity to attack us.
Shmuel Rosner is an Israeli columnist, editor, and researcher. He is the editor of the research and data-journalism website themadad.com, and is the political editor of the Jewish Journal.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Print Issue: Got College? | Mar 29, 2024
Rabbis of LA | Grief Helped Pave a Career Highway for Rabbi Anne Brener
Make a Star of David Pendant with Drinking Straws
New York Jewish Couple Redefines Kosher Wine Market
Campus Watch March 28, 2024
War and Tech Meet, Creating Need for Israel Tech Missions Venture
Culture
A Love Letter to ‘The Jewish Holiday Table’
Moroccan Fish: A Taste of Casablanca for Passover
Katie Workman: The Mom 100, Comfort Food and Ground Turkey Tacos
National Hillel Basketball Tournament in Maryland Led by Two Shalhevet Alumni
Table for Five: Tzav
Bloodless
Difficult Choices
Jews have always believed in the importance of higher education. Today, with the rise in antisemitism across many college campuses, Jewish high school seniors are facing difficult choices.
All Aboard the Lifeboat
These are excruciating times for Israel, and for the Jewish people. It is so tempting to succumb to despair. That is why we must keep our eyes open and revel in any blessing we can find.
Texas Gov. Abbott Signs Executive Order Addressing Campus Antisemitism
Order mandates that all college campuses in Texas use the IHRA definition of antisemitism.
Joseph Lieberman, Centrist Senator and First Jew on a Major Presidential Ticket, Dies at 82
Lieberman was known for his attempts to build bridges in an increasingly polarized Washington.
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Katie Workman: The Mom 100, Comfort Food and Ground Turkey Tacos
Jamie Pachino: “So Help Me Todd,” Food on TV and Chocolate Chip Cake
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.