fbpx

Undeniable Truth

Irving is suing Lipstadt and her British publisher, Penguin Books, over passages in her book, \"Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory.\"
[additional-authors]
January 27, 2000

A British Holocaust revisionist who is suing a U.S. Holocaust scholar in a London court has admitted that the Nazis “systematically” gassed 97,000 Jews in trucks.

David Irving, whose trial against Deborah Lipstadt, a professor of Emory University in Atlanta, is now entering its third week, said last week that he was “willing to eat humble pie” after he admitted that he had been “quite plainly wrong” for statements in which he said the Nazis used gassing trucks “on a very limited scale to experiment.”

Irving is suing Lipstadt and her British publisher, Penguin Books, over passages in her book, “Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory.”

He says that by labeling him a denier of the Holocaust and accusing him of distorting historical data to suit his own ideological goals, Lipstadt has ruined his career as a writer and historian.

Irving told the High Court that what he had said in the past about the scale and number of the gas truck deaths was based on his knowledge at the time.

But under cross-examination by Richard Rampton, Irving admitted he was mistaken after he was shown a document that specified that 97,000 Jews were gassed in three trucks in a period of just five weeks.

When the judge, Justice Charles Gray, asked Irving if he would describe that as “very limited and experimental,” Irving replied: “No, this is systematic.”

In another exchange, Rampton said Irving must be “mad or a liar” to suggest that Jews who were deported to the East during the war were not being sent to their deaths.

He was responding to a claim by Irving that messages intercepted by British wartime intelligence indicated trains transporting Jews to the camps were equipped with a “very substantial amount of food” and “tools of the trade” for their occupants.

Irving said this indicated “the system that was sending them was apprehending that they would be doing something when they got there.”

Rampton asked why he thought the Jews were being sent to “little villages in the middle of nowhere” in eastern Poland in 1942.

“The documents do not tell me,” replied Irving, adding that “there could be any number of convincing explanations.”

At an earlier hearing, Irving told the judge that his extradition was being sought by a German court for telling a meeting in Germany that the gas chambers at Auschwitz were erected as a tourist attraction by Poland’s postwar Communist regime.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Michael Douglas Memoir, ‘One Helluva Ride,’ Is a Helluva Read

At 82, Douglas has survived cancer, is married to the love of his life, Catherine Zeta-Jones, has been in iconic films including “Wall Street” and “Basic Instinct” and grew up with the pressure of having a famous father, the legendary actor Kirk Douglas.

A Burst of Inspirational Art in Hadassah

What makes them special, in addition to their ethereal beauty, is that four of the paintings are of women; two others, while abstract, appear to reference the female.

Jon Polin Wants Answers, Not Revenge, Three Years After Oct. 7

One day before the three-year anniversary of the Oct. 7th attacks, the father of slain hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin called for a national commission of inquiry, spoke about what comes next for him and Rachel, and said punishment for Israel’s failures is not what he seeks.

Making Jewish Fiction New Again

In a climate of anti-Jewish censorship, a new fiction imprint from Wicked Son will play a part in determining the future of Jewish fiction in America.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.