fbpx

In Hebrew, Netanyahu retracts comments on unilateral withdrawal

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is used to admonishing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas for saying one thing in English, but another thing in Arabic.
[additional-authors]
November 11, 2015

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is used to admonishing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas for saying one thing in English, but another thing in Arabic.

But it seems that for Pennsylvania-raised Netanyahu, a statement in English is non-binding in Hebrew and vice versa on diplomatic affairs.

On Tuesday, during an appearance at the Center for American Progress, Netanyahu, for the first time, raised the possibility of unilateral action in securing Israel’s borders with the Palestinian territories.

“Unilateralism, I suppose that is possible, but it would have to meet Israeli security criteria,” the Prime Minister said. “It would require a broader international understanding than exists now.”

David Makovsky, the Ziegler distinguished fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, who asked the question, told the Forward afterward: “He opened the door to some sort of unilateral movement. It’s the first time he’s opened that door. Now I just hope it stays open.”

The comments caught the Israeli right and his coalition partners by surprise. Education Minister Naftali Bennett said raising the possibility sends a dangerous message to the Palestinians that terror pays off. “If terrorism pays, terrorism will increase,” Bennett said on Wednesday. “Unilaterally giving land to Arabs is always a grave mistake. Talking about it at the height of a wave of terrorism sends the opposite message of what we need to send. The enemy needs to be punished for terrorism and not be given a prize for murdering Jews.”

Later in the day, The Likud Party spokesman sent out a statement – in Hebrew – that “Netanyahu was not talking about unilateral withdrawal, rather, he was talking about the possibility of unilateral steps that could specifically strengthen Israel’s national and security interests in facing terrorism. The interpretation of what the prime minister said yesterday in the US is wrong: Prime Minister Netanyahu will not evacuate and will not uproot settlements. We will not repeat that mistake.” (Translation via The Jerusalem Post)

The clarification was also posted on Netanyahu’s Facebook page and personal Twitter handle. But unlike previous statements, usually sent out at the same time, the retraction was not translated into English.

This post originally appeared at Jewish Insider.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Ladino Shabbat at Sinai

On a recent Shabbat, Sinai celebrated the Ladino tradition and invited me to tell my story.

A Short Fuse

At 73, I know I am on a slippery slope that’s getting slipperier.

Newsom’s Machinations

Newsom’s machinations are a warning that the current difficulties for American politicians facing rising voter unhappiness with Israel will only become harder.

How Antisemites Can Save the Jews

American Jews have always understood a key lesson of life: even if your victimhood is justified, if you wear it it will kill you.

Trump in ‘The Twilight Zone’

With moral clarity not clouded by anti-Trump, anti-Israel hysteria, everyone should be able to get behind this just war against Iran—not unlike Israel’s just war in Gaza.

Hating Trump More Than Terrorists

While one of the world’s most evil regimes is taking a beating, much of the mainstream media, Hollywood and our cultural elite would rather focus on who’s doing the beating.

The ‘Scream’ Franchise Is Back—Sans Antisemites.

It seems that Melissa Barrera – and those who followed her off set – may have inadvertently saved the franchise from itself. In getting back to basics, the film found a way to connect with audiences from both the past and the present.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.