Last week, from June 25 to 27, marked the 150th anniversary of General George Custer’s disastrous defeat in a defining battle of American history in 1876. The silence around this commemoration resounded loudly. These days, it feels like every word about that moment is fraught. Too many think that history is about breast-beating or finger-pointing, while others reduce it to mindless cheerleading. Both are wrong – and we all missed an important opportunity to learn more about the chaos of that moment, about America’s strengths and flaws and about history’s multi-dimensionality.
Today, for Americans and Jews, the Battle of Little Big Horn has relevance and resonance. Living in a society still shaped by Christian sensibilities, Americans tend to read history through the Early Christian doctrine of Original Sin. Many instinctively see America as defined by its two original sins – the enslavement of Africans and the brutalization of the natives. That wiring makes it easy to view the world through that oh-so-popular – and tedious – oppressed/oppressor lens. Such oversimplifications reduce the complex dynamics of the 1930s and 1940s, whereby the Arab world tried to annihilate the Jews, into saying, “Of course, Israel has an ‘original sin’ too … displacing the Palestinians.”
Especially as we approach America’s 250th – and we easily generate lists of “250 Reasons to Thank America” — Little Big Horn’s 150th should stretch us to approach history more maturely. Better to wield magnifying glasses, to peer closely and understand the event, instead of always, mindlessly, bringing down the hammer, without acknowledging that sensibilities develop, perspectives shift, and most human beings are neither angels nor devils but simply individuals, living history, trying to get by.
I grew up in simpler – and admittedly more callous – times. We learned that “the Indians” “massacred” General Custer and his troops. Custer to us was a hero, romantic, impulsive, brave – with flowing golden hair, a Civil War demi-god. I even had a General Custer action figure.
A Brigadier General by 23, George Armstrong Custer led the Michigan Brigade’s charge at Gettysburg, urging, “Come on you Wolverines!” He was the kind of guy who didn’t wait for the ever-cautious General George McClellan’s engineers to measure how deep the Chickahominy River was. Defying enemy fire, Custer charged into the water on horseback, hit midpoint, turned and yelled, “McClellan, that’s how deep it is, General!”
Today, honoring Custer’s contributions to freeing slaves and reuniting the Union in the 1860s doesn’t preclude struggling about how he and the American government hunted down Native Americans in the 1870s. There’s value in understanding what happened, and in assessing Custer as a leader.
Contrary to the legend his widow Elizabeth Bacon “Libby” Custer tended for 57 years until her death in 1933, most historians now view Custer’s catastrophe as self-inflicted. With his bigoted dismissal of his foes, and his egotistical quest for glory, he failed to take basic precautions.
For decades, such thoughts were heresy. Americans believed that Custer’s soldiers had fought courageously, rigorously, never breaking ranks.
By 1970, the myth was shattering. With America mired in Vietnam and rebels questioning America’s traditional, self-justifying, historical spin, Dee Brown published “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee.” While detailing the broken treaties and brutal military campaigns Native Americans endured, Brown shifted perspectives, writing about “Sitting Bull and the War for Black Hills.” Brown exposed Custer’s nickname, “Squaw Killer,” following his 1868 massacre killing women and children at Washita, a Cheyenne village. While resetting the moral dynamics, Brown framed Custer’s losing battle as a Native fight for self-defense, mounted courageously.
Thirteen years later, an August, 1983 wildfire consumed much of the thick brush that had grown in Little Bighorn National Monument, in southeastern Montana. Archaeologists led by Dr. Douglas Scott and Dr. Richard Fox started digging.
As Scott wrote in 2025 in the American Society of Arms Collectors Bulletin, the evidence confirmed much of the “Native American oral tradition” summarized in “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee.” Using metal detectors, forensic technology and GPS mapping of each spent shell-casing found, researchers discovered “that Lakota and Cheyenne warriors used 47 different firearm types to completely outgun the U.S. 7th Cavalry.” The battle debris strewn far and wide suggests what Fox calls “tactical panic,” not a disciplined “Last Stand.” “Custer’s command,” Scott concluded, “was outnumbered, outgunned and simply outfought by the Lakota and Cheyenne warriors who were defending their way of life.”
Custer boasted: “There are not enough Indians in the world to defeat the 7th Cavalry.” Unaware of at least 1,800 Native warriors waiting in ambush, Custer weakened his own forces by dividing them into thirds.
Letters collected by the Shapell Manuscript Foundation also show that Custer’s soldiers – distanced from their command, overwhelmingly poor – justifiably feared their enemy, as did many officers. On April 20, 1876, William Losee of Company F, 7th Cavalry, ended his letter to “Father and Mother,” admitting “my Eyes are dim with tears[.] So good Bye all and a Kiss for all…”
On June 21st, Second Lieutenant William Van Wyck Reily, a 23-year-old officer, wrote to “My own darling Ma,” from the Yellowstone River in Montana, after two weeks of scouting the area. “We start tomorrow, and expect to have a fight inside of four days …” he wrote. “Much love to all. We have pretty hard times, but I will assure you that I am satisfied, and am not complaining. I may be able to go to the Centennial without asking, if so expect me in September some time, if I live through this campaign.”
Within days, Losee, Reily, and Custer were among the 268 soldiers, officers and civilians killed. Casualties included two of Custer’s younger brothers, his brother-in-law and his 18-year-old nephew. Most were stripped naked, scalped, with hands, fingers and legs slashed or dismembered. War clubs shattered heads and faces; arrows riddled most bodies. The warriors’ ritualized killings infuriated Americans. That anger turned the Natives’ victory into an ultimate defeat, as America’s military flooded tribal areas and retaliated severely.
Historians are neither prosecutors nor defense attorneys. We’re analysts not priests, dedicated to explaining not moralizing. Custer’s battle today is a still-relevant warning to all armies against underestimating enemies. It highlights the tragic clash between Natives defending their homeland and soldiers equally convinced that their side was on the right side of history. And it shows how thorough research rather than partisan posturing can often bring us closer to the truth, in all its complexity and moral messiness.
For the author’s podcast on the Battle of the Little Bighorn, click here.
Gil Troy, an American presidential historian and Senior Fellow at the JPPI, the Global Thinktank of the Jewish People, is the host of The Human Side of History Podcast sponsored by the Shapell Manuscript Foundation. He is the author of 18 books, including his two latest: “250 Reasons to Thank America” with David Suissa – and, with the JJPI, “The Essential Guide to the U.S-Israel Partnership, the 250th Anniversary Edition.”
Remembering Little Big Horn 150 Years Later as Historians, not Prosecutors or Priests
Gil Troy
Last week, from June 25 to 27, marked the 150th anniversary of General George Custer’s disastrous defeat in a defining battle of American history in 1876. The silence around this commemoration resounded loudly. These days, it feels like every word about that moment is fraught. Too many think that history is about breast-beating or finger-pointing, while others reduce it to mindless cheerleading. Both are wrong – and we all missed an important opportunity to learn more about the chaos of that moment, about America’s strengths and flaws and about history’s multi-dimensionality.
Today, for Americans and Jews, the Battle of Little Big Horn has relevance and resonance. Living in a society still shaped by Christian sensibilities, Americans tend to read history through the Early Christian doctrine of Original Sin. Many instinctively see America as defined by its two original sins – the enslavement of Africans and the brutalization of the natives. That wiring makes it easy to view the world through that oh-so-popular – and tedious – oppressed/oppressor lens. Such oversimplifications reduce the complex dynamics of the 1930s and 1940s, whereby the Arab world tried to annihilate the Jews, into saying, “Of course, Israel has an ‘original sin’ too … displacing the Palestinians.”
Especially as we approach America’s 250th – and we easily generate lists of “250 Reasons to Thank America” — Little Big Horn’s 150th should stretch us to approach history more maturely. Better to wield magnifying glasses, to peer closely and understand the event, instead of always, mindlessly, bringing down the hammer, without acknowledging that sensibilities develop, perspectives shift, and most human beings are neither angels nor devils but simply individuals, living history, trying to get by.
I grew up in simpler – and admittedly more callous – times. We learned that “the Indians” “massacred” General Custer and his troops. Custer to us was a hero, romantic, impulsive, brave – with flowing golden hair, a Civil War demi-god. I even had a General Custer action figure.
A Brigadier General by 23, George Armstrong Custer led the Michigan Brigade’s charge at Gettysburg, urging, “Come on you Wolverines!” He was the kind of guy who didn’t wait for the ever-cautious General George McClellan’s engineers to measure how deep the Chickahominy River was. Defying enemy fire, Custer charged into the water on horseback, hit midpoint, turned and yelled, “McClellan, that’s how deep it is, General!”
Today, honoring Custer’s contributions to freeing slaves and reuniting the Union in the 1860s doesn’t preclude struggling about how he and the American government hunted down Native Americans in the 1870s. There’s value in understanding what happened, and in assessing Custer as a leader.
Contrary to the legend his widow Elizabeth Bacon “Libby” Custer tended for 57 years until her death in 1933, most historians now view Custer’s catastrophe as self-inflicted. With his bigoted dismissal of his foes, and his egotistical quest for glory, he failed to take basic precautions.
For decades, such thoughts were heresy. Americans believed that Custer’s soldiers had fought courageously, rigorously, never breaking ranks.
By 1970, the myth was shattering. With America mired in Vietnam and rebels questioning America’s traditional, self-justifying, historical spin, Dee Brown published “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee.” While detailing the broken treaties and brutal military campaigns Native Americans endured, Brown shifted perspectives, writing about “Sitting Bull and the War for Black Hills.” Brown exposed Custer’s nickname, “Squaw Killer,” following his 1868 massacre killing women and children at Washita, a Cheyenne village. While resetting the moral dynamics, Brown framed Custer’s losing battle as a Native fight for self-defense, mounted courageously.
Thirteen years later, an August, 1983 wildfire consumed much of the thick brush that had grown in Little Bighorn National Monument, in southeastern Montana. Archaeologists led by Dr. Douglas Scott and Dr. Richard Fox started digging.
As Scott wrote in 2025 in the American Society of Arms Collectors Bulletin, the evidence confirmed much of the “Native American oral tradition” summarized in “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee.” Using metal detectors, forensic technology and GPS mapping of each spent shell-casing found, researchers discovered “that Lakota and Cheyenne warriors used 47 different firearm types to completely outgun the U.S. 7th Cavalry.” The battle debris strewn far and wide suggests what Fox calls “tactical panic,” not a disciplined “Last Stand.” “Custer’s command,” Scott concluded, “was outnumbered, outgunned and simply outfought by the Lakota and Cheyenne warriors who were defending their way of life.”
Custer boasted: “There are not enough Indians in the world to defeat the 7th Cavalry.” Unaware of at least 1,800 Native warriors waiting in ambush, Custer weakened his own forces by dividing them into thirds.
Letters collected by the Shapell Manuscript Foundation also show that Custer’s soldiers – distanced from their command, overwhelmingly poor – justifiably feared their enemy, as did many officers. On April 20, 1876, William Losee of Company F, 7th Cavalry, ended his letter to “Father and Mother,” admitting “my Eyes are dim with tears[.] So good Bye all and a Kiss for all…”
On June 21st, Second Lieutenant William Van Wyck Reily, a 23-year-old officer, wrote to “My own darling Ma,” from the Yellowstone River in Montana, after two weeks of scouting the area. “We start tomorrow, and expect to have a fight inside of four days …” he wrote. “Much love to all. We have pretty hard times, but I will assure you that I am satisfied, and am not complaining. I may be able to go to the Centennial without asking, if so expect me in September some time, if I live through this campaign.”
Within days, Losee, Reily, and Custer were among the 268 soldiers, officers and civilians killed. Casualties included two of Custer’s younger brothers, his brother-in-law and his 18-year-old nephew. Most were stripped naked, scalped, with hands, fingers and legs slashed or dismembered. War clubs shattered heads and faces; arrows riddled most bodies. The warriors’ ritualized killings infuriated Americans. That anger turned the Natives’ victory into an ultimate defeat, as America’s military flooded tribal areas and retaliated severely.
Historians are neither prosecutors nor defense attorneys. We’re analysts not priests, dedicated to explaining not moralizing. Custer’s battle today is a still-relevant warning to all armies against underestimating enemies. It highlights the tragic clash between Natives defending their homeland and soldiers equally convinced that their side was on the right side of history. And it shows how thorough research rather than partisan posturing can often bring us closer to the truth, in all its complexity and moral messiness.
For the author’s podcast on the Battle of the Little Bighorn, click here.
Gil Troy, an American presidential historian and Senior Fellow at the JPPI, the Global Thinktank of the Jewish People, is the host of The Human Side of History Podcast sponsored by the Shapell Manuscript Foundation. He is the author of 18 books, including his two latest: “250 Reasons to Thank America” with David Suissa – and, with the JJPI, “The Essential Guide to the U.S-Israel Partnership, the 250th Anniversary Edition.”
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Noahides Sign Historic Declaration in Jerusalem at Global Congress
Lessons in Gratitude
‘Notes of Deception’: The Klezmer Was a Spy
‘Tell Me Everything’: The Family Secrets and Personal Struggles Behind Israel’s Oscar Submission
‘Topol: On Top of the World’ – The Story Behind Israel’s Most Celebrated Actor
Building the Jewish Homeland’s Future With So Much More Than Little Blue Boxes
At 88 Years Old, Bob Waldorf Is One Happy Camper
In an age when so much of children’s lives revolves around screens, the camp gives them an opportunity to unplug, explore and discover new strengths.
Held Hostage to Gratitude
The idea is to say thank you for everything you are experiencing because it is all from God.
A Thanksgiving to Remember
The first holiday my family celebrated in Los Angeles was Thanksgiving. Although it was many decades ago, I can picture that day like it was yesterday and my heart bursts with gratitude for how meaningful and special that day was.
Table for Five: Vayetzei
Jacob’s Holy Pillow
The Thanksgiving Parade and a Jewish Pennsylvanian
The Gimbel family had benefitted greatly from America, and for that they were grateful. A Jewish family, thankful for the freedom to pursue the American Dream, gifted the country, among its many contributions, its quintessential Thanksgiving public celebration.
Gratitude and Mindfulness
To live Jewishly is to discover that life is not somewhere else. It is here, in this moment.
From a Global People to a People of Israel
Today, 46% of world Jewry lives in Israel. In 2070, according to the forecast, 62% will live there. The U.S. share of world Jewry will drop from 39% to 26%, which numerically means 1.2 million fewer people.
We All Need the Zionist Trifecta of Patriotism, Gratitude and Decency
Patriotic gratitude generates the grace and graciousness we should bestow on our neighbors, even if they dare disagree with us politically.
To Turn Together: Israel, Intractability and Distant Horizons
How do you proceed when there are no workable solutions, only a host of unworkable ideas?
Giving Thanks
Below are some of the things for which I am grateful.
The Magic Words
At every turn Judaism is a religion that is held up by gratitude. Our identity is linked with this most remarkable value, to be grateful.
An Attitude of Gratitude
I raise my glass of Martinelli’s and wish you all a happy, healthy, grateful Thanksgiving.
Torah Portion: Vayetzei
Laban is shrewd. Jacob is shrewder.
Jewish Groups and Students to Protest CUNY Hunter’s Cancelation of Cultural Affairs Night After Hillel Inclusion
“Antisemitism has no place at Hunter College.” – Statement from CUNY Hunter Hillel
Where Dating Meets DNA ft. Canavan Foundation
What Israel Taught Me About the Two Sides of Resilience
Last week, I stood at the edge of Kibbutz Nir Oz and looked across a few fields to Gaza.
In Praise of Showing Up
I still believe America is an extraordinary place to be Jewish, that most Americans are decent and that we have more allies than enemies. But those relationships won’t build themselves.
Good Sabbath, South Africa
South Africans know, in their bones, what it means to be oppressed because of who you are. They learned that lesson at a terrible cost, and they are not about to repeat it.
Launching a Rabbinical School in Germany and Pausing for Some Gratitude
Our best days are yet to be. Inspired by our successes from the past, and by our considerable legacy of wisdom, resilience, and strength, we will forge a Jewish tomorrow worthy of our past.
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Bestowing a name on a newborn in memory of a person elevates their values in our lives, but what happens when your child feels the need to change that name?
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.