fbpx

After Losing 1400 Family Members, It’s OK if I Suffer a Little

It’s as if all the victims of the October 7 massacres have lodged themselves in my brain.
[additional-authors]
October 20, 2023
Israeli singer Avraham Tal sings at the funeral for Yitzhak Seitan, 76, his wife, Hannah Seitan, 73, their son, Tal Seitan, 49, and his aunt Pesi Cohen, 68, at the Hod Ha’sharon cemetery, on October 18, 2023 in Hod HaSharon, Israel. (Photo by Alexi J. Rosenfeld/Getty Images)

Like many others, I haven’t slept much since October 7. I don’t just mean because of my work; that’s only one reason.

I mean the nightmares.

I can’t unsee the images. Not that I haven’t tried.

They’re too stark. They’re too shocking.

The babies. The dancers in the desert. The families in safe rooms. The toys in the bedrooms. The child crying for his mother. That elderly woman in a wheelchair. Of course, the hostages.

It’s as if all the victims of the October 7 massacres have lodged themselves in my brain, even those I haven’t seen on social media.

And it hurts, not in a physical way, more in a psychic way.

At times, my brain will just freeze and it’s hard to function or think straight.

It’s the images. I can’t unsee them. Even when I sleep.

I read articles about “how to cope” but I really don’t feel like coping. It’s true that keeping busy “in the fight” helps us cope to a certain extent. Gathering articles, covering the story hour to hour, writing and editing– all that activity helps me forget the darkness.

But I can’t forget the images. I can’t unsee them. Even when I sleep.

I know that if I do stuff like practice mindfulness, intentional breathing, go on long walks, etc., I will be stronger for the fight. Stronger for my work. It’s a good argument: Take care of yourself, and you’ll better help Israel.

And yet, part of me prefers the pain. The insomnia. The brain freezes. The debilitating moments of darkness.

The truth is, even if that part of me didn’t prefer the pain, I’m not sure I have a choice. It doesn’t seem to matter what I do.

It’s the images. I can’t unsee them. Even when I sleep.

Maybe grieving over these images is the only way I have of connecting to my “Jewish family” in Israel.

Maybe I just need to suffer a little.

Am Yisrael Chai.

Shabbat shalom.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

The Fall of Pride. And the March Into Mayhem

To those raising fists in solidarity with the “Free Palestine” movement in the Western world and chanting “resistance by any means necessary,” we ask: Does your “resistance support” include the execution of queer people?

Why Jews Must Start Standing Up for America

If America is “irredeemably racist,” then so are the Jews. If America is in trouble, then so are the Jews. If more and more people are becoming anti-American, you can be sure they’re also becoming anti-Jewish.

The Fourth of July and ‘Four Score’

This July Fourth, members of the Jewish faith can take particular pride in one of their rabbis likely inspiring America’s most beloved president’s famous phrase.

‘As a Jew,’ I Love America

America is our home. Our flawed, beautiful, battered, and still-standing home. We don’t need to agree with everything in it to love it. 

Life Lessons at the DMV

A few weeks ago I traveled to the building made of cement and despair that is called the DMV, to take my Behind-the-Wheel Driving Test.

Tikkun Olam and Iran

Why haven’t Tikkun Olam advocates, particularly, if not exclusively, within the Jewish community, spoken out against the Iranian regime as part of their social action agenda?

Schumer Flips on Antisemitism

To prove his loyalty to his party, and no doubt to fend off challenges from Mamdani supporters (such as Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez), Sen. Schumer has chosen to join them rather than fight them.

NYC Muslim Mayor Blues

If the Democratic Party retains its time-honored hold on the city electorate, the next Hizzoner will be an avowed Jew-hater.

An Imaginary Journey to the Wedding of the Century

Given my insecurities about the invitation, I decided that instead of my usual schmoozing, I would do lots of observing, like an anthropologist studying a species of human beings I rarely encounter– filthy rich people who are not Jewish.

More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.