The central question of the relationship between Donald Trump and the virulent strain of populism that has raged in our country has been frequently raised and never conclusively answered: is Trump a symptom of these passions or the cause of them?
Was the soon-to-be-former president an instigator of the anti-establishment anger that has characterized our recent history or the product of it? Did he just happen across the landscape at the right time to benefit from the same resentments that led to Brexit in the United Kingdom, the Golden Dawn uprising in Greece and similar movements sweeping across the European continent in Poland, Hungary, Germany, Italy and other counties? Or did he astutely recognize the political potential in these emotions and purposefully capitalize on them?
Could Trump-ism have existed without Trump? And will it survive without him?
We’re about to find out.
When Trump leaves office on January 20, after a flagrantly atypical and unprecedentedly raucous transition period, the populist resentments and rages that now characterize American public debate will not disappear. We are a more confrontational country, a sharper-edged and shriller nation, a less tolerant society than we used to be. Loyal partisans from both parties will leap to condemn their opponents for this deterioration, but the truth is that there is more than enough blame and shame to go around.
Joe Biden has spent the weeks since his election became official arguing that the American people are still capable of unifying to confront a horrific series of common threats. There are sizable numbers of voters in both parties who are hopeful that he’s right and no shortage of others who dismiss him as hopelessly naive.
Can Biden’s collaborative instincts, his memories of a less-divided country and a time-weathered affability provide him with the skills to stitch us back together? Or will he end up with tread marks on his back when hardened ideologues in both parties stampede past his calls for unity back to their more familiar hyper-polarized turf?
We’re about to find out.
Will the Republicans standing with Trump as he fights to the very bitter end stay loyal to him even once he is out of office? Will his most committed supporters maintain their fervor and demand that GOP elected officials continue the scorched-earth politics they have practiced since Trump’s election? Will progressive activists allow Biden to attempt to govern from the center, or will they insist that congressional Democrats withhold votes from compromise legislation and hold out for more ideologically pure alternatives?
Will Senator Mitch McConnell find issues on which he can work with Biden? Will Speaker Nancy Pelosi be able to navigate the challenges of a painfully-thin House majority? Will Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Kevin McCarthy incite their party’s ideological bases toward further political brutality, or will they leverage their hard-earned grassroots credibility to convince skeptics that an occasional truce can be tolerated? How many members on both sides will spend the next two years looking nervously over their shoulders for possible primary challenges, and how many will decide that winning a primary is of little use if it marginalizes you in a general election?
The truth is that we have no idea what’s coming next. We have no way of guessing whether the country’s political divisions will further deepen or whether past historical cycles of balkanization followed by reconciliation can be repeated today — an era in which every one of us is empowered with technological tools that allow us to ignore, mock or threaten those who dare to disagree with us.
The truth is that we have no idea what’s coming next.
American history is filled with examples of hate-filled combatants realizing that the only way to move forward is to set aside their mutual contempt and animosity — even grudgingly and temporarily — to meet a moment that requires something better. Do the rest of us, who have worked so hard to isolate ourselves from the other half of the country that votes for the wrong people, have it in ourselves to take those same steps forward, at least for a short time until we’re back on track?
Or will we continue to convince ourselves that because we’re right and the other side is wrong, because we are smart and good and they are stupid and evil, that no such ceasefire is possible?
We’re about to find out.
Dan Schnur teaches political communications at UC Berkeley, USC and Pepperdine. He hosts the weekly webinar “Politics in the Time of Coronavirus” for the Los Angeles World Affairs Council & Town Hall.
Will Politics Get Better… or Worse? We’re About to Find Out.
Dan Schnur
The central question of the relationship between Donald Trump and the virulent strain of populism that has raged in our country has been frequently raised and never conclusively answered: is Trump a symptom of these passions or the cause of them?
Was the soon-to-be-former president an instigator of the anti-establishment anger that has characterized our recent history or the product of it? Did he just happen across the landscape at the right time to benefit from the same resentments that led to Brexit in the United Kingdom, the Golden Dawn uprising in Greece and similar movements sweeping across the European continent in Poland, Hungary, Germany, Italy and other counties? Or did he astutely recognize the political potential in these emotions and purposefully capitalize on them?
Could Trump-ism have existed without Trump? And will it survive without him?
We’re about to find out.
When Trump leaves office on January 20, after a flagrantly atypical and unprecedentedly raucous transition period, the populist resentments and rages that now characterize American public debate will not disappear. We are a more confrontational country, a sharper-edged and shriller nation, a less tolerant society than we used to be. Loyal partisans from both parties will leap to condemn their opponents for this deterioration, but the truth is that there is more than enough blame and shame to go around.
Joe Biden has spent the weeks since his election became official arguing that the American people are still capable of unifying to confront a horrific series of common threats. There are sizable numbers of voters in both parties who are hopeful that he’s right and no shortage of others who dismiss him as hopelessly naive.
Can Biden’s collaborative instincts, his memories of a less-divided country and a time-weathered affability provide him with the skills to stitch us back together? Or will he end up with tread marks on his back when hardened ideologues in both parties stampede past his calls for unity back to their more familiar hyper-polarized turf?
We’re about to find out.
Will the Republicans standing with Trump as he fights to the very bitter end stay loyal to him even once he is out of office? Will his most committed supporters maintain their fervor and demand that GOP elected officials continue the scorched-earth politics they have practiced since Trump’s election? Will progressive activists allow Biden to attempt to govern from the center, or will they insist that congressional Democrats withhold votes from compromise legislation and hold out for more ideologically pure alternatives?
Will Senator Mitch McConnell find issues on which he can work with Biden? Will Speaker Nancy Pelosi be able to navigate the challenges of a painfully-thin House majority? Will Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Kevin McCarthy incite their party’s ideological bases toward further political brutality, or will they leverage their hard-earned grassroots credibility to convince skeptics that an occasional truce can be tolerated? How many members on both sides will spend the next two years looking nervously over their shoulders for possible primary challenges, and how many will decide that winning a primary is of little use if it marginalizes you in a general election?
The truth is that we have no idea what’s coming next. We have no way of guessing whether the country’s political divisions will further deepen or whether past historical cycles of balkanization followed by reconciliation can be repeated today — an era in which every one of us is empowered with technological tools that allow us to ignore, mock or threaten those who dare to disagree with us.
American history is filled with examples of hate-filled combatants realizing that the only way to move forward is to set aside their mutual contempt and animosity — even grudgingly and temporarily — to meet a moment that requires something better. Do the rest of us, who have worked so hard to isolate ourselves from the other half of the country that votes for the wrong people, have it in ourselves to take those same steps forward, at least for a short time until we’re back on track?
Or will we continue to convince ourselves that because we’re right and the other side is wrong, because we are smart and good and they are stupid and evil, that no such ceasefire is possible?
We’re about to find out.
Dan Schnur teaches political communications at UC Berkeley, USC and Pepperdine. He hosts the weekly webinar “Politics in the Time of Coronavirus” for the Los Angeles World Affairs Council & Town Hall.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
All the Words — A poem for Parsha Devarim
Leftist Jews Will Criticize their People, But Never Their Party
A Bisl Torah — Low to High, High to Low
Moses the Thoughtful Judge
Print Issue: City of Lost Angels? | July 17, 2026
Unbreakable Bond: From Einstein’s $500 Bond to $57 Billion in Israel Bonds
Kitchri—Comfort and Culture in a Bowl
For me, and probably every other Iraqi Jew, kitchri is the quintessential meal of the Nine Days.
Everyone Screams for Ice Cream in July: Culturally and Creamy Rich Recipes from Pati Jinich
Jewish Mexican chef Pati Jinich brings her multicultural perspective to every recipe she creates, blending the traditions, ingredients and stories that have shaped her cooking.
Great Grilled Grub for National Grilling Month
Whether you’re planning a backyard barbecue, a casual weeknight dinner or a Shabbat meal on the patio, the possibilities are endless.
A Moment in Time: On Sabbatical
Table for Five: Devarim
Justice For All
Letter from Los Angeles
A Jewish Angeleno looks back several decades and wonders whether the golden age of LA Jewry is behind us.
Dear England: Don’t Cry for Thee Argentina
When England took a 1-0 lead early in the second half, I felt a sense of cosmic justice. Sixty years is a long time. Argentina won it the last time. Maybe it was England’s turn.
The Admirable Epstein: ‘Mr. Moonlight: Brian Epstein and the Making of the Beatles‘
The Beatles’ manager’s life makes “a wonderfully inspiring and terribly sad story.”
Summer in Israel: Still Waiting for Tourists to Return
Restaurants, gift shops, hotels and car rental companies have all been hit hard by the ongoing war. The blow to the economy is evident almost everywhere you go.
Rosner’s Domain | Can You Be a Zionist Without Zionism?
Do you want to convince Jews, and the world, that Zionism is a cause worth supporting? Explain what “Zionism” is, and perhaps it will turn out that the world is actually on our side.
The Story This Moment Needs
In this moment of rising antisemitism, I’ve noticed that the way I remember, and retell, my own childhood has changed too.
The Jewish Tree of Life and American Tree of Liberty
The Kristallnacht Monument and the Question of Whether to Stop
Miniature, polite gestures of memorialization serve neither as insurance against future catastrophes nor as tributes to the victims. So should we stop to acknowledge them?
Jewish Donors: Don’t Walk Away
Do not give up on institutions — but do not disengage from the responsibility to hold them accountable.
Capping the Fire Hydrant
For close to 30 years, we forked up whatever we could afford and were happy to do it. It was now time for them to experience the exhilaration of staring at a pile of bills, not knowing where the money would come from.
Lindsey Graham’s Last Dream
It is difficult to see another member of Congress or administration official capable of moving a possible Israel-Saudi deal to fruition.
L.A. Jewish Leaders Split Over Rahm Emanuel’s Israel Speech
During his roughly 30-minute speech, he warned that Israel had become a “prisoner of its own tools” and that the American-Israel relationship, although historically strong, was “at a crossroads.”
When Confronting Israel Becomes a Career Strategy, Who Speaks for California?
At a moment when California faces soaring costs, housing shortages, energy challenges, water insecurity and mounting technological competition from China, Ro Khanna chose to travel halfway around the world in pursuit of yet another public confrontation with America’s closest and best ally in the Middle East.
Bar-Ilan University and Sheba Medical Center Joining Forces for Biotech Innovation Institute With $120 Million Investment
This $120 million investment is modeled after the American NIH, and it will accelerate the timeline from lab discovery to clinical treatment.
Jew Hatred is an Emotion. Discrimination is the Evidence.
Just like any emotion or any label, hate can be denied. What is much harder to deny is one set of rules for the world and another for the Jews. That’s not an emotion. It’s an action.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.