fbpx

A Moment in Time: Charlottesville – When There is no Other Hand

[additional-authors]
August 15, 2017
Dear all,
In Fiddler on the Roof, Tevya’s daughters pressed his boundaries as their marriages called Jewish protocol into question.  He would weigh the options, looking to the sky saying, “On the one hand, XXX.  On the other hand, YYY.  But on the first hand, ZZZ.”
But there came a time when he was pushed too far, and he finally shouted, “There is no other hand!”
As we look to the incident in Charlottesville, VA, the racists, Neo-nazis and fascists have been compared to those who oppose them.  Let’s be clear: granting the two groups moral equivalency reveals a complete moral bankruptcy.  And while we often strive to find credence in multiple points of view, there are times when there is no other hand.  This is one of those times, and it should take no explaining.  If you march with neo-nazis, you are not a “fine person.”
There will be those who criticize this message.  But I neither ask for permission nor do I apologize.  If we can’t stand up against racism, then we relinquish our role as a Light to the Nations.
And if we can’t oppose anti-Semitism, then what are we at all?
This weekend, alt-right rallies are being planned in cities throughout the country, including in Los Angeles.  These participants feel emboldened.  We can’t expect the moral tone of our nation to come from above.  So we need to start here on the ground.
How?
1) I encourage you to go to the website of the Souther Poverty Law Center, an organization that identifies and tracks hate groups in the United States.  Consider making a donation.  Encourage others to do the same.
2) Get involved politically on a local level, so that good voices can surface and make a difference.
3) Don’t be alone.  Important relationships are vital, be it a friend, a family member,  a pet, a  religious community ….  We all need each other right now.
Friends, I have hope.  I believe that the foundation of our country is stronger than what we are enduring right now.  I believe that the voice of goodness is mightier than the voice of evil.  I believe that justice will survive.
But none of it will happen unless we take this moment in time to do something about it.  Right here.  Right now.  Today
With all my love,
Rabbi Zach Shapiro
Rabbi Zach Shapiro
A change in perspective can shift the focus of our day – and even our lives.  We have an opportunity to harness “a moment in time,” allowing our souls to be both grounded and lifted.  This blog shows how the simplest of daily experiences can become the most meaningful of life’s blessings.  All it takes is a moment in time.
 
Rabbi Zach Shapiro is the Spiritual Leader of Temple Akiba, a Reform Jewish Congregation in Culver City, CA.  He earned his B.A. in Spanish from Colby College in 1992, and his M.A.H.L. from HUC-JIR in 1996.  He was ordained from HUC-JIR – Cincinnati, in 1997.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Hanging Out at the Jewish American Summit

Among the speakers, Adam Milstein, a real estate investor, philanthropist and co-founder of the fast-growing Impact Forum, urged attendees to frame antisemitism as an American issue and not just a Jewish issue.

A Festive French Roast

One of my favorite things to cook for the Jewish holidays is a beautiful French roast. It’s so very festive and is perfect to feed a hungry crowd.

The Genius of the Marx Brothers

Like the greatest satirists, such as Jonathan Swift and Mark Twain, they chose comedy over accusation to mock the folly of society and add levity to dark times. But their aim was not levity alone.

AKLA Rises

From a Local Experiment to a National Program: AKLA Expands Its Vision for Jewish Teens

Better Kisser Than a Cook

Sometimes love arrives ahead of you, in spite of you. Cooking slowly became a way of being there for the people I love. A wordless language that says: I see you. I hear you. You’re worth the onion-chopping.

Israel’s Brain-Drain Debate Is Asking the Wrong Question

If an experienced professional with rare expertise leaves Israel, the impact cannot be understood simply by adding another person to a brain-drain statistic. The more relevant question is how many people with comparable experience remain, how essential that expertise is and how easily it can be rebuilt.

A New Borscht Belt?

If renewed exclusion teaches us only to become more protective of Jewish work, we will have learned the wrong lesson from the original Borscht Belt.

Judaism as a Covenant for the Ages

Given the realities of our current time, we are more in need than ever of the depth, wisdom, and joy that Jewish tradition offers.

A Summit to Remember

Our shared stories of hatred, humiliation, oppression and slavery obligate us to show up for one another.

Old-Guard Dems Pushing Back

While it’s indisputable that younger and progressive voters are driving the party away from its historic support for Israel, the old-guard Zionist Democrats have made it clear that they will not surrender without a fight.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.