If Ukrainians come out in the millions shouting “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death," maybe they could still save their own freedom and possibly that of Russia as well.
Remember Patrick Henry on the eve of the American Revolution? History teaches us that nations unwilling to fight for their freedom generally lose it, unless a third party is willing to fight on their behalf. America and Europe have abandoned Ukraine to its fate. The Ukrainian people is being put to the ultimate test: Will they cower in their homes or dash for the closest border, or will they go out and confront the Russian Army?
Unfortunately, there are only two ways that the Ukrainians can save their country. The first is the Stalingrad option- to turn every apartment building in every city into a death trap for the Russians. The cost would be indescribable, but if anyone knows what such a struggle would mean it is the Russians, whose own heroism in the battle against the Nazis brought about one of the greatest victories in history. The result of turning Kyiv into Stalingrad would be tragic, but the Russian people are likely to draw the same conclusion they did after their experience in Afghanistan, overturning Putin and his fellow oligarchs and once again attempting to build a truly democratic country.
The result of turning Kyiv into Stalingrad would be tragic, but the Russian people are likely to draw the same conclusion they did after their experience in Afghanistan.
The other alternative for Ukraine is to adopt a strategy based on a second, non-violent but no less dangerous example of Russian heroism. On August 19, 1991, the KGB carried out a putsch against Mikhail Gorbachev, author of the liberal policies of glasnost and perestroika. Boris Yeltsin, the mayor of Moscow, gathered thousands of courageous Russians around his official residence, known as the “White House”. In response, the KGB and the leadership of the plot ordered Soviet tanks to confront the demonstrators. One brave tank commander, Sergey Yevdokimov, ordered his men to surround the White House and to turn their tanks around in order to protect it. Demonstrators surged forward to confront the Soviet troops with flowers in their hands; the Russian soldiers refused to shoot them and the coup was defeated.
There are 40 million people in the Ukraine. If enough of them come out to confront the Russian Army with flowers many are likely to pay the ultimate price. But Putin is not Stalin, the Russian Army is not the S.S. and Russia itself is not Nazi Germany. If Ukrainians come out in the millions shouting “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death,” maybe they could still save their own freedom and possibly that of Russia as well.
Americans must understand that, sometimes, especially when facing maniacal Jihadi dictators, a little bit of short-term war is the best way to get a whole lot of long-term peace.
It is not a change in their belief that Iran must be stopped from acquiring a nuclear weapon. It is a change in their belief about Israel’s ability to achieve that goal. That belief is the genuine shift.
While it may feel noble to push for gun reforms and other so-called peaceful measures to strengthen our society, there will inevitably be moments where this society cannot keep us safe.
Two Ways Ukraine Can Fight Back
Yitzhak Sokoloff
Remember Patrick Henry on the eve of the American Revolution? History teaches us that nations unwilling to fight for their freedom generally lose it, unless a third party is willing to fight on their behalf. America and Europe have abandoned Ukraine to its fate. The Ukrainian people is being put to the ultimate test: Will they cower in their homes or dash for the closest border, or will they go out and confront the Russian Army?
Unfortunately, there are only two ways that the Ukrainians can save their country. The first is the Stalingrad option- to turn every apartment building in every city into a death trap for the Russians. The cost would be indescribable, but if anyone knows what such a struggle would mean it is the Russians, whose own heroism in the battle against the Nazis brought about one of the greatest victories in history. The result of turning Kyiv into Stalingrad would be tragic, but the Russian people are likely to draw the same conclusion they did after their experience in Afghanistan, overturning Putin and his fellow oligarchs and once again attempting to build a truly democratic country.
The other alternative for Ukraine is to adopt a strategy based on a second, non-violent but no less dangerous example of Russian heroism. On August 19, 1991, the KGB carried out a putsch against Mikhail Gorbachev, author of the liberal policies of glasnost and perestroika. Boris Yeltsin, the mayor of Moscow, gathered thousands of courageous Russians around his official residence, known as the “White House”. In response, the KGB and the leadership of the plot ordered Soviet tanks to confront the demonstrators. One brave tank commander, Sergey Yevdokimov, ordered his men to surround the White House and to turn their tanks around in order to protect it. Demonstrators surged forward to confront the Soviet troops with flowers in their hands; the Russian soldiers refused to shoot them and the coup was defeated.
There are 40 million people in the Ukraine. If enough of them come out to confront the Russian Army with flowers many are likely to pay the ultimate price. But Putin is not Stalin, the Russian Army is not the S.S. and Russia itself is not Nazi Germany. If Ukrainians come out in the millions shouting “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death,” maybe they could still save their own freedom and possibly that of Russia as well.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Israelis Stranded in LA
Iranian Payback, Long Overdue
TV, Podcasts & Passion Projects: I’m a 5-Time Finalist!
3 Israelis Killed in Iranian Missile Strikes; Iran, Israel Vow Further Escalation
Maybe Israelis Simply Got Tired of Walking on Eggshells
The Satan Series: Chaos Erupts in Hell After Sudden Iranian Influx
Culture
“Chutzpah”: The Story of a Haredi, Queer Role Model
Hollywood Film Producer and Philanthropist Peter Samuelson on ‘Finding Happy’
A Memoir for Fathers, Sons, and Anyone Trying to Break the Cycle
A Memoir in Ritual Moments
On the Broken Path
The broken Book of Bamidbar is the teacher for when we walk on the broken path of life.
Calling All Jews: This is Your Moment
Americans must understand that, sometimes, especially when facing maniacal Jihadi dictators, a little bit of short-term war is the best way to get a whole lot of long-term peace.
Why Did Israel Suddenly Attack?
It is not a change in their belief that Iran must be stopped from acquiring a nuclear weapon. It is a change in their belief about Israel’s ability to achieve that goal. That belief is the genuine shift.
Jews Must Arm Themselves
While it may feel noble to push for gun reforms and other so-called peaceful measures to strengthen our society, there will inevitably be moments where this society cannot keep us safe.
Extreme Alert at 3 am
We, the entire country, were awakened by air raid sirens and a few minutes later by an ear-splitting continuous shriek on our phones. EXTREME ALERT!
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Sam E. Goldberg: Respect the Chain, Restaurants and Ratatouille
Happy Hoffman: Music, Emotion and Gluten-Free Cinnamon Challah
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.