Jonathan Pollard leaves a New York court house following his release from prison on November 20, 2015 in New York, New York. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
1.
At 3am Wednesday morning, Jonathan and Esther Pollard landed in Israel. Their arrival was a surprise. Not surprise in the metaphysical sense – we all knew they intended to come. It was a surprise in the operational sense – we did not know it was coming today. Very few Israelis had prior knowledge that they were coming today.
Thus, Israel did not prepare for the event. And of course, this is by design. No preparation means no festival of media attention and public gatherings, no live coverage, no flags on roadsides, no bombastic speeches. A surprise enabled Israel to keep Pollard’s aliya a low-key event. As it wanted it to be. As it needed it to be.
2.
Why did it happen now? Because Esther Pollard, whose health is not well, was able to travel. Because Israel wanted to wrap up this drama before the change of administration in Washington. It is good for the Trump administration to be seen as the one who gave Pollard and Israel this last gift before its departure. It is good for the Biden administration not to have this hot potato complicating its relations with Israel. It is good for Israel to get this issue off the main road of US-Israel relations when a new chapter is about to begin.
It is good for Israel to get this issue off the main road of US-Israel relations when a new chapter is about to begin.
Netanyahu was still there, at the airport, to say hello, to recite a blessing, to issue a press release. One might ask: If Israel wanted this to be low key why wake the PM up so early in the morning and have him travel to the airport? The answer is twofold. One – because low key is one thing and a complete silence is quite another. Israel is walking a fine line here. It does want to communicate its appreciation for Pollard and its remorse for all that he had to suffer and its responsibility in cooking this sorrow event of many years ago. Two – there is an election coming, and the release of Pollard is still an asset for the PM. So, as he balanced all the reasons for keeping this a low-key event and all the benefit he could gain from still taking credit for Pollard’s coming – he chose a middle road.
4.
This is an old and tired and sad story. There is no point rehashing it. We should all let the Pollards be. We should let them enjoy the time they still have under Israel’s sun. We – Americans and Israelis – should forget, and, if possible, also forgive. It is time.
“These women were pivotal to both the process and the outcome of the trial. Yet they were marginalized on many occasions, literally reduced to footnotes.“
It’s worth paying attention to what is – or isn’t – happening to our “large” parties. They are quite small, or at least that’s how they appear in the polls even as Election Day draws near.
We need not know where every decision will lead before taking the first step. Sometimes acting upon our deepest convictions is itself the beginning of wisdom.
New opportunities and challenges have always come and gone. But pulpit clergy with their years of training, education and perspective on life, generated from atop the pulpit, are especially well suited for whatever lies ahead.
Pollard in Israel: Four Comments
Shmuel Rosner
1.
At 3am Wednesday morning, Jonathan and Esther Pollard landed in Israel. Their arrival was a surprise. Not surprise in the metaphysical sense – we all knew they intended to come. It was a surprise in the operational sense – we did not know it was coming today. Very few Israelis had prior knowledge that they were coming today.
Thus, Israel did not prepare for the event. And of course, this is by design. No preparation means no festival of media attention and public gatherings, no live coverage, no flags on roadsides, no bombastic speeches. A surprise enabled Israel to keep Pollard’s aliya a low-key event. As it wanted it to be. As it needed it to be.
2.
Why did it happen now? Because Esther Pollard, whose health is not well, was able to travel. Because Israel wanted to wrap up this drama before the change of administration in Washington. It is good for the Trump administration to be seen as the one who gave Pollard and Israel this last gift before its departure. It is good for the Biden administration not to have this hot potato complicating its relations with Israel. It is good for Israel to get this issue off the main road of US-Israel relations when a new chapter is about to begin.
Netanyahu was still there, at the airport, to say hello, to recite a blessing, to issue a press release. One might ask: If Israel wanted this to be low key why wake the PM up so early in the morning and have him travel to the airport? The answer is twofold. One – because low key is one thing and a complete silence is quite another. Israel is walking a fine line here. It does want to communicate its appreciation for Pollard and its remorse for all that he had to suffer and its responsibility in cooking this sorrow event of many years ago. Two – there is an election coming, and the release of Pollard is still an asset for the PM. So, as he balanced all the reasons for keeping this a low-key event and all the benefit he could gain from still taking credit for Pollard’s coming – he chose a middle road.
4.
This is an old and tired and sad story. There is no point rehashing it. We should all let the Pollards be. We should let them enjoy the time they still have under Israel’s sun. We – Americans and Israelis – should forget, and, if possible, also forgive. It is time.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
To Begin Again
Abraham’s God in the Age of Atheism
AJU Reopens Ziegler School Admissions, Seeks to Reimagine Rabbinic Education
Show Us How It’s Done – A poem for Parsha Lech Lecha
Weinberg: The Secret German Life of a Jewish Last Name
The Anti-Zionist Agenda at the Heart of UC Ethnic Studies
The Beauty of the Slow and Steady
What could our lives look like if we embraced the infinitesimal as infinite?
Ziegler School Welcomes Prominent Rabbi, O.C. Federation Names CEO, Pico-Robertson Cleanup
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
A Moment in Time: Beyond the Chuppah
A Bisl Torah ~ The Company You Keep
Does the company we keep enable our name to be a blessing? Are we doing enough to make our name as great as God intends?
Because We Can
Print Issue: The View From Israel | October 23, 2026
Three years after Oct. 7, a country trying to heal is still waiting for a full accounting of what went wrong.
Rabbis of LA | Rabbi Taff’s Daughter Follows Her Father’s Footsteps
Second of two parts
‘The Nuremberg Women’: The Untold Stories of Eight Women Who Witnessed History
“These women were pivotal to both the process and the outcome of the trial. Yet they were marginalized on many occasions, literally reduced to footnotes.“
A Very Jewish Stew: Toscano Hamin
This Hamin Toscano recipe reminded us of a Tuscan wedding soup.
Table for Five: Lech Lecha
Shield Of Abraham
The View from Israel
Three years after Oct. 7, Israel is still waiting for a full accounting of what went wrong.
Albie Selznick’s Unlikely Connection to David Bowie Inspires New Solo Show
Selznick saw his idol David Bowie perform live when he was 15 and made up his mind that he wanted to create a show of his own and work with Bowie.
Is the New Facebook Film Equal to the Original?
“The Social Reckoning” isn’t about a power struggle, but shows that powerful companies are reluctant to change unless there is pain.
Larry David Is Spot-on in His Satire of the DSA
In his article about his proposals for the Democratic Socialists of America, he jokes that “The DSA has great respect for religious traditions.”
Remember and Be Grateful
Memory is the mother of gratitude. If we do not remember our past, it is difficult to improve our present or build a better future.
Michael Broukhim’s Journey to a Deeper Judaism
What began as a personal exploration of Judaism eventually became intertwined with Broukhim’s professional life.
Rosner’s Domain | No Surprise Is Also an Election Surprise
It’s worth paying attention to what is – or isn’t – happening to our “large” parties. They are quite small, or at least that’s how they appear in the polls even as Election Day draws near.
Lech Lecha: The Journey of Growth and the Process of Becoming
We need not know where every decision will lead before taking the first step. Sometimes acting upon our deepest convictions is itself the beginning of wisdom.
From Atop the Pulpit
New opportunities and challenges have always come and gone. But pulpit clergy with their years of training, education and perspective on life, generated from atop the pulpit, are especially well suited for whatever lies ahead.
Abraham’s Lessons in Leadership on the Eve of Israel’s Elections
Anyone who votes, or leads, would be wise to study the story of Abraham and David.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.