fbpx

Four short questions about Gaza

[additional-authors]
March 12, 2012

As exchanges of fire around Gaza continue (rockets fired on Israel, targets hit in Gaza), here are four questions for which I’m not sure I have an answer:

1.

Is there a better option for Israel than the one it is using now – namely, to defend Israel’s citizens with the Iron Dome system (quite successfully), shoot suspected terrorists, and work through third parties (Egypt, Europe) to end yet another cycle of violence with yet another fragile cease-fire? While talk about a Cast Lead II operation tends to spread whenever there’s fire in Gaza, I don’t see much appetite for it right now in Israel, and no real pressure to do it as long as Israeli civilians get through this recent escalation without much damage. 

2.

Can the terrorists of Gaza find a way to circumvent the successes of Iron Dome? Clearly, if they can’t do it, their rockets become much less effective and Israel’s freedom of action becomes much more pronounced. I’m sure the Gazans and their allies (Iran included) are thinking about new ways to hurt Israel, and can only hope it will take them a very long time to come up with some good ideas.

3.

I read this morning that the Quartet of Middle East negotiators – the United States, Russia, the United Nations and European Union – “will meet on Monday to discuss the long-stalled peace process between Israel and the Palestinians”. That’s probably a joke, right?

4.

If one has to list the possible doomsday scenarios in Gaza, what we have now (occasional outbursts of violence) is hardly top of the list – this list:

  1. Chaos.
  2. Having to reoccupy and control Gaza.
  3. Constant barrages of rocket fire.

In light of this list, can Israel really strive to topple Hamas without having someone ready, willing and able to control the area? Can you imagine a candidate for such thankless job?

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Sushi Day Recipes with Marisa Baggett

Whether you’re a longtime sushi lover or a newbie to preparing this creative cuisine, Baggett’s recipes are a delicious way to mark the holiday.

What Antisemitism Requires of Us

The current Jewish debate cannot end with a choice between fighting antisemites and strengthening Jewish life. Both are necessary, but neither fully answers what this moment requires.

Is History Asking Too Much of Us?

The question for the Jewish people today is not merely whether we believe in the future but whether we are willing to become the kind of people that the future requires.

Rosner’s Domain | Can Israel’s Image Be Fixed?

Israelis view themselves as fighting for survival, just, fair, moral and brave, while the rest of the world sees something else entirely, viewing Israel as a country that has lost its brakes, destabilizing the order and running amok without justification.

Nothing to Fear but Fear

If I toss out a can of baked beans that expired one day earlier for fear of botulism, what do you think goes through my mind when it comes to bears, mountain lions, sharks and rattlesnakes?

The Many-States Solution

As we weigh the benefits and downsides of a potential two-state solution, the unguaranteed but plausible prospect of an unprecedented regional peace should be considered as part of that discussion.

What Can AI Do for Us?

The question is not whether Jewish communities will use AI; they already are. The question is whether we will adopt these tools passively, or shape them deliberately according to Jewish values, Jewish learning, and Jewish responsibility.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.