[Update, Feb. 19: In the span of two short months, life has been turned upside down for the roughly 55,000 African asylum seekers who have taken shelter in Israel over the last eight years.
Israel's whirlwind efforts to drive out the Africans began in December, when authorities
Because the new facility is “open,”
Israel offers the African prisoners only one alternative: pocket $3,500 and return to war-torn Sudan or oppressive Eritrea. (Anwar Suliman, a 33-year-old community organizer from Darfur, said he personally knows of two Sudanese men who accepted this deal and were murdered upon returning home.)
Holot's first batch of about 300 prisoners — who had already been held at Saharonim, a closed prison nearby, for nearly two years — quickly took advantage of the new prison's come-and-go policy. But instead of escaping, half of them
The prisoners trudged through a fresh Jerusalem snowfall for hours, asking parliament members to treat them as refugees, not criminals.
But as the sun set on Israel's version of Capitol Hill, the march ended in tears. One by one, immigration police strong-armed the prisoners onto buses that transported them back down to Holot.
When a second group of prisoners “>launched a protest movement. They gathered in Levinsky Park, their longtime hangout in rundown South Tel Aviv, and marched through the streets, stopping traffic and drawing stares.
Not long after the movement took off, the second phase of Israel's plan to expel its Africans was set in motion. Asylum seekers who had lived and worked in Israel for years — including
Many others, like “>Gebretsadik Mashu, an Eritrean father of five.
In response to this blanket sentencing, anti-government rallies
Later that week, they staged a highly coordinated and historic demonstration — 10,000 strong — on the lawn overlooking Israel's parliament building. It was unlike anthing lawmakers had ever seen.
Despite the roaring African outcry and pressure from “>by the beginning of February. That number has since reached 3,000.
Tour buses full of new prisoners now depart for Holot from the Nokia Arena parking lot
The community does its best to lift spirits at Holot. Each Saturday, a tight-knit group of lefties and non-jailed Africans makes a two-hour trip to the desert prison to hang with 600-plus prisoners currently living there. Visitors bring shoes, books, guitars, food that doesn't “People who two weeks ago came from Tel Aviv, now I see in their faces that they are more down,” Sudanese community leader Anwar Suliman said after last Saturday's visit. “They do not show it, but inside they are more sad.” (Suliman himself must report to Holot on March 9.)
Back in Tel Aviv, in a final show of desperation, hundreds of asylum seekers camped out in the playground area at Levinsky Park for two weeks. One week in, 29-year-old Eritrean protester Habtom Tesfay told me: “We people here are like a ship without a compass.”
Although Tesfay said “we will be here until we get our rights,” the park-sitters were eventually driven back to their crowded apartments by unrelenting rain.
Just before the rains came, another protester, 20-year-old Filmon Ghide from Eritrea (pictured below in a striped long-sleeve shirt), told me that Bedouin kidnappers had tortured him in the Sinai desert for six months before collecting $35,000 in ransom from his family and dumping him at the Israeli border fence. “They burned me all over my body. They made us walk on broken glass,” he said.
Although Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Interior Minister Gideon Sa'ar have largely ignored the protests and continued their prison campaign with an iron fist, shards of hope remain. A small group of African community leaders recently met with the government's Committee on Foreign Workers to find possible alternatives to mass imprisonment. And in April, the Israeli Supreme Court is expected to decide whether detaining Africans indefinitely at Holot is unconstitutional.
The Eritrean and Sudanese communities are meanwhile filling out individual applications for official refugee status — almost a two-hour process — en masse. When they're done, they plan to turn in the entire stack to both the Ministry of Interior and, more symbolically, to the U.N.
“The only solution I think is fair is to check all the claims,” said Moussa Abdoulaye (pictured below at a press conference, far left), one of those meeting with Israeli politicians.
On the bus back to Tel Aviv from Holot last weekend, Israeli activist Sigal Avivi said she thought the key was to help “people in Holot understand that they are soldiers in the struggle — that they're helping their community by sitting in prison.” Suliman agreed. “My plan is to make the people at Holot strong,” he said. “We have to be patient.”
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks



What Ever Happened to the LA Times?

Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?


No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles

The ‘Fauda’ Enigma

Jewish Democrats Cave to Anti-Semites


“Just a Few Sleeps Away” by Mike Nichols

Rabbi Kaplan Named JCC Camps Senior VP; Maman Events, JFSLA, Temple of the Arts



When Celebrities Endorsed a Different “Free Palestine”
When many of America’s leading celebrities called for a “Free Palestine” eighty years ago this week, they were talking about freeing Palestine from British occupation, in order to establish a Jewish state.

A Bisl Yom Kippur~ Plenty of Regrets
Yom Kippur is admitting our plentiful regrets and summoning and building our inner determination and drive to be better people, regrets, and all.



Print Issue: Renewing American Jewry | September 18, 2026
In this time of introspection and rising adversity, let us resolve as American Jews to write our new chapter by better understanding our history.

Expanding the Soul
There is a struggle within us between constriction and expansion, between despair and vitality. Good humor can be a powerful ally against the constriction that suffering creates.

Making Torah More Accessible
The 402-page book is organized around 36 life lessons related to the Book of Genesis, with thoughtful study questions and dozens of responses from respected sources in Jewish thought.

Avi Nesher Fights the Boycott with a Human Story
Making Israeli films is not easy. Budgets are generally small by American standards, and international financing has become increasingly difficult to secure amid the cultural boycott of Israeli cinema.

Combating Antisemitism Through Education in Beverly Hills
For Judith, her family’s experience as refugees from Iran is part of what drives her commitment to speaking out against antisemitism and never staying silent.

From Israel’s Farms to Los Angeles: The Etrog with a Purpose
Mickey Katzburg, founder of the World Center for Jewish Education, is trying to give Los Angeles Jews another option: an etrog grown in Israel, while at the same time helping support farmers in the country’s Gaza border region.

What’s in a Name: Peanut Butter Date Bark
Dates are a perfect way to add natural caramelized sweetness to desserts.


ACF Report Reveals the Strongest – and Most Concerning – Campuses for Jewish and Pro-Israel Students
The report, which can be found on CampusFairness.org, took into consideration five criteria: incident record, institutional response, anti-Israel organizing, Jewish life on campus, and the legal and structural environment.

Jason Arday, Donald Trump, and the Post-Truth World
For both MAGA and Arday’s defenders, truth doesn’t matter, lies are accepted as facts, and tribe matters above all.

How Yom Kippur’s Afternoon Prophet Inspires America
When Jonah makes his appearance on the holiest day of the year, he is meant to remind Jews across the globe of the remarkable grace of repentance.

Knowing Our History
In this time of introspection and rising adversity, let us resolve as American Jews to write our new chapter by better understanding our history.

Macklemore Dropped from Ed Sheeran Tour After ‘Free Palestine’ Remarks at MetLife Stadium
Among the most high-profile artists to criticize Macklemore’s MetLife Stadium rant was P!NK. Born Alecia Moore, P!NK is a Jewish Grammy-winning pop star who has been increasingly public about her Judaism and antisemitism since Oct. 7.

Noah Wyle, Rob Reiner, and the Jewish Winners at the 78th Emmys
Wyle won Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series for playing Dr. Michael “Robby” Robinavitch on HBO Max’s “The Pitt.”

Rosner’s Domain | Choosing the Next Government
Are you better off than you were four years ago?

