When I tell people I’m a nonobservant Orthodox Jew, there is usually a small pause, followed by a look that says: Pick one. I understand it. The phrase sounds like a hedge, or like someone claiming a title he hasn’t earned. But I don’t think it’s a contradiction.
It helps to start with where this came from, because it didn’t come from childhood. Until a few years ago, I wasn’t curious about any of it. I was secular and, on some subjects, actively hostile to religion. What changed was Oct. 7, 2023, and then a semester when I was honored to be associated with Yeshiva University. I came away wanting to know more than I did, and I’ve been picking at that ever since.
I should be clear about the scale of it: I am not a learned man in the Jewish sense of that word. If you quoted a passage at me, there’s a good chance I wouldn’t recognize it. What I do is modest and improvised. I listen to podcasts — “Take One” is one I come back to. I keep books like Rabbi Joseph Telushkin’s “Jewish Wisdom” within reach. When something comes up in my life and I want to know whether the tradition has anything to say about it, I ask — sometimes a person, more often now AI, which is either a sign of the times or a small miracle depending on your mood. It’s not a formal program of study; it’s a habit of turning toward something.
So why call it Orthodox at all?
Partly, it’s an acknowledgment. I didn’t come to this on my own. It took an event and a place — and more than the place, the people in it. I came to admire the Modern Orthodox community I found at Yeshiva University: serious about the texts and serious about the world at the same time. The description is the most honest way I have of pointing at where this came from.
Partly, it’s because the word describes where I look, not what I do. It’s about what I take seriously — what I treat as having standing over how I understand my own life. When something happens to me, I’ve learned to ask a second question: not what I think about it, but what “they” would have said about it. What did the rabbis notice in a situation like this that I haven’t noticed yet?
As for the other half of the phrase: I am not observant. But I don’t experience that as failure, and I’m not walking around with a ledger of everything I’ve missed. Nor am I claiming the obligations don’t apply to me, as if I had examined them and placed myself above all that. They apply. I came to them late, with a life already built around other habits, and I have not rebuilt my week around them. That isn’t a principle I hold; it’s simply a fact about me.
What I get out of any of this is harder to describe. Sometimes it is direct. There is a command that a worker’s wages must not stay with you overnight, that you pay him the same day, before the sun sets. I used to let bills sit, not out of any bad intention but in the ordinary way a person puts things off, and I don’t anymore. Now I pay when the invoice arrives, especially when it comes from an individual rather than a company.
More often it is about how to carry myself, and Leviticus is full of it: not to spread gossip, not to hate your brother in your heart, not to take revenge or bear a grudge — the grudge being the harder of the two, because you can hold one for years while telling yourself you have let it go. Those sit in consecutive verses, leading directly to loving your neighbor as yourself. None of it is hard to understand. It is very hard to do, and I don’t always manage it. But going to look for what the rabbis said slows me down, and whatever is in front of me, I am not the first to face it. Having that in view makes me steadier than I would otherwise be — more centered, more at ease, less at the mercy of whatever happened to me that day.
That grounding in tradition takes on an even deeper weight when viewed alongside those who had everything stripped away. Look at the hostages in Gaza, who put all of this in true proportion. Eli Sharabi, who had never been religious a day in his life, began saying Shema Yisrael every morning in captivity, making Friday night Kiddush with water because there was no wine. Agam Berger kept kosher underground, refusing meat when she was hungry, and sewed a cover for a prayer book out of the leg of a ruined pair of trousers.
I was deeply moved by what they reached for in the dark, and by the strength it gave them. Some part of my own reading today is in their honor, and through it my bond with my people has become stronger than it ever was. Keeping less than others keep is not a complaint or a critique. We do Shabbat dinners at home, though not religiously, and when I see friends and family for whom Shabbat is a day genuinely set apart — work put down, the week shaped by the stopping — I look at that with respect, and some weeks I envy the discipline, and the community that comes with it.
The tradition has always been bigger than any one person’s grip on it. What draws me is simple: I think these texts are a good part of why we are still here as a people. I want to know them and, in my own way, embrace them. Orthodox is where I turn. Nonobservant is what I do. It’s where I’ve been standing these last couple of years, and I don’t assume I’m on my way somewhere else. I never thought this was something I needed, or that anything was missing. I didn’t expect any of it, and I wouldn’t give it back.
Mauricio Karchmer was a computer science lecturer at MIT until December of 2023, when he quit in protest over how the institute treated its Jewish community after the Oct. 7 terror attacks.
Can One Be a Non-Observant Orthodox Jew?
Mauricio Karchmer
When I tell people I’m a nonobservant Orthodox Jew, there is usually a small pause, followed by a look that says: Pick one. I understand it. The phrase sounds like a hedge, or like someone claiming a title he hasn’t earned. But I don’t think it’s a contradiction.
It helps to start with where this came from, because it didn’t come from childhood. Until a few years ago, I wasn’t curious about any of it. I was secular and, on some subjects, actively hostile to religion. What changed was Oct. 7, 2023, and then a semester when I was honored to be associated with Yeshiva University. I came away wanting to know more than I did, and I’ve been picking at that ever since.
I should be clear about the scale of it: I am not a learned man in the Jewish sense of that word. If you quoted a passage at me, there’s a good chance I wouldn’t recognize it. What I do is modest and improvised. I listen to podcasts — “Take One” is one I come back to. I keep books like Rabbi Joseph Telushkin’s “Jewish Wisdom” within reach. When something comes up in my life and I want to know whether the tradition has anything to say about it, I ask — sometimes a person, more often now AI, which is either a sign of the times or a small miracle depending on your mood. It’s not a formal program of study; it’s a habit of turning toward something.
So why call it Orthodox at all?
Partly, it’s an acknowledgment. I didn’t come to this on my own. It took an event and a place — and more than the place, the people in it. I came to admire the Modern Orthodox community I found at Yeshiva University: serious about the texts and serious about the world at the same time. The description is the most honest way I have of pointing at where this came from.
Partly, it’s because the word describes where I look, not what I do. It’s about what I take seriously — what I treat as having standing over how I understand my own life. When something happens to me, I’ve learned to ask a second question: not what I think about it, but what “they” would have said about it. What did the rabbis notice in a situation like this that I haven’t noticed yet?
As for the other half of the phrase: I am not observant. But I don’t experience that as failure, and I’m not walking around with a ledger of everything I’ve missed. Nor am I claiming the obligations don’t apply to me, as if I had examined them and placed myself above all that. They apply. I came to them late, with a life already built around other habits, and I have not rebuilt my week around them. That isn’t a principle I hold; it’s simply a fact about me.
What I get out of any of this is harder to describe. Sometimes it is direct. There is a command that a worker’s wages must not stay with you overnight, that you pay him the same day, before the sun sets. I used to let bills sit, not out of any bad intention but in the ordinary way a person puts things off, and I don’t anymore. Now I pay when the invoice arrives, especially when it comes from an individual rather than a company.
More often it is about how to carry myself, and Leviticus is full of it: not to spread gossip, not to hate your brother in your heart, not to take revenge or bear a grudge — the grudge being the harder of the two, because you can hold one for years while telling yourself you have let it go. Those sit in consecutive verses, leading directly to loving your neighbor as yourself. None of it is hard to understand. It is very hard to do, and I don’t always manage it. But going to look for what the rabbis said slows me down, and whatever is in front of me, I am not the first to face it. Having that in view makes me steadier than I would otherwise be — more centered, more at ease, less at the mercy of whatever happened to me that day.
That grounding in tradition takes on an even deeper weight when viewed alongside those who had everything stripped away. Look at the hostages in Gaza, who put all of this in true proportion. Eli Sharabi, who had never been religious a day in his life, began saying Shema Yisrael every morning in captivity, making Friday night Kiddush with water because there was no wine. Agam Berger kept kosher underground, refusing meat when she was hungry, and sewed a cover for a prayer book out of the leg of a ruined pair of trousers.
I was deeply moved by what they reached for in the dark, and by the strength it gave them. Some part of my own reading today is in their honor, and through it my bond with my people has become stronger than it ever was. Keeping less than others keep is not a complaint or a critique. We do Shabbat dinners at home, though not religiously, and when I see friends and family for whom Shabbat is a day genuinely set apart — work put down, the week shaped by the stopping — I look at that with respect, and some weeks I envy the discipline, and the community that comes with it.
The tradition has always been bigger than any one person’s grip on it. What draws me is simple: I think these texts are a good part of why we are still here as a people. I want to know them and, in my own way, embrace them. Orthodox is where I turn. Nonobservant is what I do. It’s where I’ve been standing these last couple of years, and I don’t assume I’m on my way somewhere else. I never thought this was something I needed, or that anything was missing. I didn’t expect any of it, and I wouldn’t give it back.
Mauricio Karchmer was a computer science lecturer at MIT until December of 2023, when he quit in protest over how the institute treated its Jewish community after the Oct. 7 terror attacks.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Noahides Sign Historic Declaration in Jerusalem at Global Congress
Lessons in Gratitude
‘Notes of Deception’: The Klezmer Was a Spy
‘Tell Me Everything’: The Family Secrets and Personal Struggles Behind Israel’s Oscar Submission
‘Topol: On Top of the World’ – The Story Behind Israel’s Most Celebrated Actor
Building the Jewish Homeland’s Future With So Much More Than Little Blue Boxes
At 88 Years Old, Bob Waldorf Is One Happy Camper
In an age when so much of children’s lives revolves around screens, the camp gives them an opportunity to unplug, explore and discover new strengths.
Held Hostage to Gratitude
The idea is to say thank you for everything you are experiencing because it is all from God.
A Thanksgiving to Remember
The first holiday my family celebrated in Los Angeles was Thanksgiving. Although it was many decades ago, I can picture that day like it was yesterday and my heart bursts with gratitude for how meaningful and special that day was.
Table for Five: Vayetzei
Jacob’s Holy Pillow
The Thanksgiving Parade and a Jewish Pennsylvanian
The Gimbel family had benefitted greatly from America, and for that they were grateful. A Jewish family, thankful for the freedom to pursue the American Dream, gifted the country, among its many contributions, its quintessential Thanksgiving public celebration.
Gratitude and Mindfulness
To live Jewishly is to discover that life is not somewhere else. It is here, in this moment.
From a Global People to a People of Israel
Today, 46% of world Jewry lives in Israel. In 2070, according to the forecast, 62% will live there. The U.S. share of world Jewry will drop from 39% to 26%, which numerically means 1.2 million fewer people.
We All Need the Zionist Trifecta of Patriotism, Gratitude and Decency
Patriotic gratitude generates the grace and graciousness we should bestow on our neighbors, even if they dare disagree with us politically.
To Turn Together: Israel, Intractability and Distant Horizons
How do you proceed when there are no workable solutions, only a host of unworkable ideas?
Giving Thanks
Below are some of the things for which I am grateful.
The Magic Words
At every turn Judaism is a religion that is held up by gratitude. Our identity is linked with this most remarkable value, to be grateful.
An Attitude of Gratitude
I raise my glass of Martinelli’s and wish you all a happy, healthy, grateful Thanksgiving.
Torah Portion: Vayetzei
Laban is shrewd. Jacob is shrewder.
Jewish Groups and Students to Protest CUNY Hunter’s Cancelation of Cultural Affairs Night After Hillel Inclusion
“Antisemitism has no place at Hunter College.” – Statement from CUNY Hunter Hillel
Where Dating Meets DNA ft. Canavan Foundation
What Israel Taught Me About the Two Sides of Resilience
Last week, I stood at the edge of Kibbutz Nir Oz and looked across a few fields to Gaza.
In Praise of Showing Up
I still believe America is an extraordinary place to be Jewish, that most Americans are decent and that we have more allies than enemies. But those relationships won’t build themselves.
Good Sabbath, South Africa
South Africans know, in their bones, what it means to be oppressed because of who you are. They learned that lesson at a terrible cost, and they are not about to repeat it.
Launching a Rabbinical School in Germany and Pausing for Some Gratitude
Our best days are yet to be. Inspired by our successes from the past, and by our considerable legacy of wisdom, resilience, and strength, we will forge a Jewish tomorrow worthy of our past.
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Bestowing a name on a newborn in memory of a person elevates their values in our lives, but what happens when your child feels the need to change that name?
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.