Thursday, April 9, 2020

A Tikkun for Tikkun Olam? How ‘To Heal the World?’ Corrupts Debate & Endangers Judaism

Enjoying this article?

You'll love our roundtable.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Jonathan Neumann issued a fierce battle cry against liberal Judaism last summer, inspiring no fewer than three articles in the Jewish Journal and a forum Feb. 5 at Sinai Temple. Reviewers disagreed strongly about Neumann’s book, “To Heal the World? How the Left Corrupts Judaism and Endangers Israel,” with conservatives praising it and liberals dismissing it. Everyone, however, seemed to accept the book’s premise, that tikkun olam, “repairing the world,” isn’t only overextended in liberal Judaism, but that its meaning of social justice is recent and thoroughly American. 

But it’s this premise of Neumann’s book that is fundamentally wrong — and it is not only damning of his work but damaging to the goals Neumann believes in. 

- Advertisement -

In fact, tikkun olam, or tikkun ha-olam to use the classical term, held meanings of economic justice and progress, long before it became the darling of American Jewish liberals. These meanings, going back centuries, reached their fullest flower in mid-19th century Zionism in Eastern Europe.

The two lions of tikkun ha-olam in pre-state Palestine were Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook (1865-1935) and Rabbi Yehudah Ashlag (1885-1954). Both were deeply rooted in kabbalah and committed to translating it into everyday values. Rav Kook was the first Ashkenazi chief rabbi, who sought reconciliation between secular Zionism and the religious world, and who taught deep love for the land and all creatures. Rav Ashlag was the great translator of the “Zohar,” whose Sulam commentary is seen as indispensable by many traditional Jews.

Both are clear that tikkun ha-olam is a political goal and not just a spiritual one. Ashlag wrote, “It is not possible to fix the world (l’takein et ha-olam) in religious matters before securing for the world a tikkun of the economic system.” (“Building the Future Society”) Ashlag also wrote, “Every individual will understand that his good and the good of the community are one, and through this union the world will come into its full tikkun.” (“Peace in the World”) And Rav Kook wrote, “Any idea that is cut off from tikkun ha-olam and the ordering of society, and that floats in the spiritual air alone … is founded upon a lie that has no legs.” (“Orot Hakodesh”) 

Ashlag was a devout promoter of religious socialism. What he meant by tikkun ha-olam is more radical than any liberal Jewish program. And Rav Kook’s soaring vision of the Jewish people’s mission is as universalist as any articulated: “The national mission of (the people) Israel, unique in the world … is not for the sake of itself, but for the sake of the general good … which cannot be built except through tikkun olam b’malkhut Shaddai (“repairing the world under the rule of God,” using words from Aleinu) … which brings in its wake every good humanitarian act, to light up the world with truth and peace.” (Eyn Ayah al Brakhot) Kook also rooted tikkun ha-olam in what we call ecology, writing that “the holiness of Nature herself … is the foundation of tikkun for the entire world.” (“Orot Hatechiyah”)

“Any fair-minded reader of the Jewish tradition would agree that social justice is a deep value in Judaism, even though the rubric of tikkun ha-olam may not embrace all of its possibilities. But how social justice or tikkun ha-olam should translate into state policy or national policy is an open question.”

The progressive Zionist culture Kook and Ashlag participated in was likely the major influence on Alexander Dushkin and Shlomo Bardin, two educators who brought socially engaged tikkun ha-olam from Israel to America. (Neumann mentions them both but seems unaware of their connections to Eretz Yisrael.)

- Advertisement -

Going back further, ancient and medieval sources where tikkun ha-olam also means social progress, invention, or the renewal of Nature or society, run the gamut from “Ecclesiastes Rabbah” (fifth century) to Bachya ibn Pakuda (11th century) and Maimonides (12th century) to the “Zohar.” Many connect tikkun ha-olam with the command to “love your neighbor as yourself,” providing a foundation for tikkun ha-olam’s modern meaning. 

More recent examples, like the Malbim (a well-known Bible commentator) and Chaim Yudah Leib (a disciple of the Tzemach Tzedek), sound like the liberal version of tikkun ha-olam, long before it made its way to America. These authors, many of whom spent time in the center of humanistic culture that was Warsaw, could have impacted Kook and Ashlag. 

One particularly resonant medieval text is found in “Sefer Hachinukh,” which explains that “not putting a stumbling block before the blind” is an expression of tikkun ha-olam, and that this means Jews may not sell weapons to non-Jews or to Jews who might resell them to criminals (section 232). In other words, tikkun ha-olam provides a basis for gun control!

I realize Neumann doesn’t know any of this. He drew his sources from the articles he cites without, it seems, doing more research. But the authors of those articles were not trying to undermine liberal Judaism, so they didn’t need to unearth every root of tikkun ha-olam. Instead, they were answering a simpler question: How did tikkun ha-olam reach the stature it has for contemporary Jewry? 

However, if one is not just writing history but also trying to condemn and “demolish” one’s enemy, as Neumann is, you need a deeper level of introspection, and a high standard of proof. If not, it’s better to let “silence be a fence for wisdom.” (Pirkei Avot 3:13) It’s not possible to maintain the curiosity and openness you need for real research if you have such a big ax to grind. 

- Advertisement -

I could go on and on with specific errors and examples of nastiness, but I don’t want to lose the forest for the trees. The reader has enough information about Rav Kook to judge Neumann’s discussion and extrapolate from there. But it seems wrong to blame Neumann, who is being egged on by a conservative Jewish establishment whose goal seems to have shifted from debating the left to destroying it. The blame properly lies with Neumann’s political and spiritual rebbes, who have encouraged him to see Jews he disagrees with as corrupt enemies. 

People on the left and right, especially those learned in the tradition, already long intuited the problem with treating tikkun ha-olam as the root of all Judaism. No one needed Neumann to tell us this. It’s as if contemporary Jews are pulling on a single thread that holds together so much of Judaism’s fabric. When they pull so hard that the thread comes free of the weave, both thread and fabric are damaged. 

At the same time, any fair-minded reader of tradition would agree that social justice is a deep Jewish value, even though the rubric of tikkun ha-olam may not embrace all its possibilities. But how social justice or tikkun ha-olam translates into state or national policy is an open question. It’s not all progressive roses, after all. “Sefer Habrit” (18th century) sees patent and copyright law as essential elements of tikkun ha-olam (77b-78a). “Sefer Hachinukh” also includes under tikkun ha-olam the rule that one may kill the “moser,” the government informant against Jews (section 243).

It should be no surprise that social justice and tikkun ha-olam as the Jewish tradition sees them do not always align with liberalism. That leaves enough room for open-minded conservatives and liberals to find common ground. As Rav Kook wrote, fixing the world is not just the community’s task but the mission of the Jewish people. How we achieve that mission, in our communal institutions and in the role we play in national policy, is a vital question that we must not lose sight of.

The solution — the tikkun — to this problem is not to tear out the thread of tikkun ha-olam but to reweave the loose thread back into the garment. By ripping out this thread, turning a real question into a screed, Neumann deprives his readers of one of the best hopes for reconnecting liberal Judaism to the State of Israel at a time when this becomes more and more difficult. Perhaps some folks on the right don’t want to make this connection. After all, the light shed by the humanistic, prophetic vision of society in early Zionism makes the Israel of today look very unwell. But we need that light, not just to connect Jews to Israel, but to connect Israel to its truest purpose. Doing anything less really does endanger Israel.

Rabbi David Seidenberg is the creator of neohasid.org and author of “Kabbalah and Ecology: God’s Image in the More-Than-Human World.” A former Los Angeles resident, he lives in Northampton, Mass., and teaches throughout the world. 

- Advertisement -

Enjoyed this article?

You'll love our email updates.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
- Advertisement -

Popular Articles

Too Many Gloves, Not Enough Love

This week, I was driving down Pico, and it was one of those annoying short trips where I hit every red light along the...

Israel Cordons Off Heavily Infected Orthodox Suburb

Israeli security forces cordoned off the city of Bnei Brak, near Tel Aviv, and are enforcing a total lockdown there.

Bowing of Daffodils Around the Bridal Path

The daffodils are bowing their heads on this gray afternoon In unison. Perhaps they are ashamed To be witness to a plague. Corona may not be a direct...

Wiesenthal Center Demands Social-Media Giants Delete Viral Anti-Semitic Posts

"The coronavirus pandemic may be new, but Jews have a long and tragic history of being accused of spreading deadly viruses.”

Ultra-Orthodox Jews Are Not The Enemy

While there is room for criticism of how Haredi leaders have handled the coronavirus epidemic, the discourse reeks of prejudice.

Debra Messing, Chrissy Metz and Emmy Rossum Hold Social Justice Seder

Jewish celebrities are teaming up to hold an online "social justice Seder" this Thursday night. The Passover celebration, called "This Year Together – A Digital...

Israeli Missile-Production Line Starts Churning Out Much-Needed Ventilators

“We are operating in a challenging time, and in a global ‘war’ to acquire the necessary components and fulfill our mission,” said Udi Kantor, CEDO of Inovytec.

Israeli Cycling Team to Hold Virtual Indoor Cycling Ride for Mask Donations

On April 5 at 9:30 p.m. ET, an Israeli cycling team will host a virtual indoor ride as a way to donate N95 masks...

Grandson of Yitzhak Rabin Wishes Coronavirus on Benjamin Netanyahu, Then Apologizes

Ben Artzi frequently tweets criticism of Netanyahu, whose trial on corruption charges has been delayed due to the pandemic.

Life Social Distancing in Les Baux

Well, it’s a fine day here in Les Baux and yeah, yeah, yeah, ok enough of the Garrison Keiler talk because something huge has...

The Guardian: Trump Is a Nazi and Jews Are His Enablers

To compare Trump — the father of a Jewish daughter and grandfather to three Jewish grandchildren — to Lindbergh/Hitler is an affront to the memory of 1.5 million Jewish children murdered by the Nazis.

10 Scientific Miracles in The Fight Against COVD-19

We might be living through a plague, but science is offering modern-day miracles this Passover.

Israel National Security Adviser Believes Coronavirus Infection Rate May Be ‘Slowing Down,’ Report Says

Israeli National Security Adviser Meir Ben-Shabbat reportedly said on April 2 that the country’s coronavirus infection rate is starting to decline. The Times of Israel...

Leave Anne Frank Alone

While doctors scramble for protective equipment, laid-off workers pray for their next paycheck, and over 6,000 Americans have died from COVID-19, people are cracking...

Catalyst Campaigns’ Scott Goodstein on Yebiga, Working with Faith No More’s Bill Gould and Future Projects

Scott Goodstein is probably best known for his work with unique political campaigns that blend art, music, and culture. Having co-founded Punkvoter.com, Rock Against...


Jewish NFL Star Mitch Schwartz Becomes A Food Blogger During COVID-19 Quarantine

Schwartz has turned to what he loves maybe more than football: cooking.

Idina Menzel, Ben Platt, Rabbis David Wolpe, Sharon Brous and More Invite You to a Virtual Seder

It would have been enough to vicariously see our favorite Broadway and Hollywood stars celebrating Passover on social media, but now fans will get...

Recipes for Mimouna, The Moroccan Celebration of Spring

The mimouna table overflows with sweet treats like orange jam, eggplant jam, marzipan, meringues and, of course, the famous moufleta, crepes served with butter and honey.

Rabbi Donin’s Trilogy Speaks Volumes About Jewish Life

Donin himself conceived of his work as “a practical handbook on how to live a Jewish life,” but he also acknowledges that the overarching goal of the three books in the series is “to answer the constant query, ‘Why?’

Gloves, Masks, Curbsides: Passover Shopping During a Pandemic

Passover shopping is hectic enough in normal times.


Russian-Jewish Businessman Donates 3,000 Meals Daily to Senior Citizens Under Lockdown

The initiative is a response to the Russian government’s decision to lockdown citizens older than 65.

Print Issue: April 10, 2020

For Fullscreen click here.  

Obituaries: April 9, 2020

Marilyn L. Bachner died March 23 at 86. Survived by sons Evan (Lisa), Robert; 5 grandchildren. Mount Sinai Jewel Brager died March 23 at 93....

Experts Say Israel Is Ahead of Curve on Coronavirus

Israel’s battle to stop the spread of coronavirus appears to be bearing fruit and is leading many experts to express cautious optimism about these...

Israel Declares Full Curfew Starting on Passover Eve

Jerusalem will be divided into eight districts, with residents unable to travel between them.


Larry David Says Bernie Sanders Should Drop Out of Presidential Race

Larry David, the Bernie Sanders doppelganger who often portrays the presidential candidate in skits on “Saturday Night Live,” says the senator from Vermont should...

‘On the Map’ Free Online Screening and Q&A This Sunday

The documentary “On the Map” tells the story of the underdog Israeli basketball team’s triumphant victory at the European championship in 1977. Set against...

‘Frozen’ at the Pantages: It Doesn’t Have to Be Jewish

Let’s face it, there’s nothing particularly Jewish about the Disney musical “Frozen.” Unless you count Idina Menzel and Josh Gad, both of whom appeared...
- Advertisement -


Pandemic Times Episode 18: Can family stories nourish us during pandemic times?

New David Suissa Podcast Every Morning at 11am. As we prepare to tell the Passover story, a refection on the value of our own family...

Let My Bagels Go

The only bagel-related thing you should be consuming this Passover is...new and classic episodes of The Bagel Report! Erin and Esther reflect on the meaning of...

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact