fbpx

The Tramp Vs. The Dictator

In April 1889, two baby boys were born within four days of each other. One was Charles Chaplin, a Londoner. The other was a native of Braunau am Inn in Austria and was named Adolf Hitler.
[additional-authors]
September 26, 2002

In April 1889, two baby boys were born within four days of each other. One was Charles Chaplin, a Londoner. The other was a native of Braunau am Inn in Austria and was named Adolf Hitler.

Grown to manhood, both men were to sport funny little mustaches, Chaplin as the screen’s greatest comic actor, Hitler as the führer of Nazi Germany.

The lives of the ardent pacifist and the bloodthirsty tyrant were to intersect only once. In 1940, Chaplin directed and starred in the dual role (and his first speaking one) of a little Jewish barber and as Adenoid Hynkel, leader of the feared Double Cross party, in "The Great Dictator."

It may be hard to believe now, but at the time, with the war already raging in Europe, to lampoon the Nazi regime was considered foolhardy by Hollywood’s predominantly Jewish establishment, whose first rule was not to make waves.

The political and artistic pressures that surrounded the making of the film are probed in a one-hour documentary, "The Tramp and the Dictator," which will have its premiere on Turner Classic Movies (TCM) on Oct. 1. The screening will be followed by a festival of 28 wartime films and nine cartoons celebrating the years when, finally, "Hollywood Takes on the Nazis."

The documentary by Kevin Brownlee, narrated by British actor Kenneth Branagh, includes recently discovered color footage taken on the set of "The Great Dictator" by Chaplin’s brother, Sydney.

With startling and frightening effect, the documentary intercuts scenes of the Jewish barber being bullied in "The Great Dictator" with newsreel shots of the actual pogroms in the streets of Berlin.

Also rejoined is the apparently endless debate whether Chaplin was Jewish.

One of the great moments in "The Great Dictator" is the triumphal dance with an inflated global balloon by Hynkel, the world conqueror. In an eerie footnote, the documentary shows newsreel footage of Hitler’s bunker in Berlin, smashed into complete rubble, except for an untouched globe.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Chametz Is More than Crumbs in the Corners of our Homes

Chametz is also something that gathers in the corners of our being, the spiritual chametz that, like the physical particles we gather the night before Passover, can infect, wither, influence and sabotage us as we engage with others.

Alpine Flavors—a Crunchy Granola Recipe

Every Passover, I prepare a truly delicious gluten-free granola. I use lots of nuts and seeds (pistachios, walnuts, almonds and pumpkin seeds) and dried fruits (apricots, dates and cranberries).

Pesach Reflections

How does the Exodus story, Judaism’s foundational narrative of freedom, speak to the present? We asked local leaders, including rabbis, educators and podcasters, to weigh in.

Rosner’s Domain | Be Skeptical of Skeptics, Too

Whoever risks a decisive or semi-decisive prediction of the campaign’s end (and there is a long list of such figures on the Israeli side as well as the American side) is not demonstrating wisdom but rather a lack of seriousness.

When We Can No Longer Agree on Who Is Pharaoh

The Seder asks us to remain present to the tension between competing fears and obligations. It does not require choosing one lesson over the other, but rather, it creates space for us to articulate our concerns and listen to the fears and hopes that shape others’ views.

Pesach at War. Leaving Fast, Leaving Slow.

Freedom, it would seem, is erratic; it happens in fits and starts, three steps forward and two steps back. Freedom is a leap into the unknown, driven by a dream. We will figure it out in time.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.