fbpx

Questions for the critics

A poem by Erika Dreifus
[additional-authors]
May 11, 2016

Would you be satisfied, then,
if more Israelis died?
If children and their parents didn’t heed the sirens?
If they didn’t burrow beneath the ground?
If the rockets were “better” in design and aim?
If they landed on Ben Yehuda and Dizengoff?
In your calculus, would the Israelis be “justified,” then?
Would it all be more “proportionate” (oh, that word!)
if only those hundreds of rockets flying toward them
left fewer able to run, to hide — and to fight back?


Originally published on RJ.org.

Erika Dreifus is the author of “Quiet Americans: Stories,” which was named an American Library Association/Sophie Brody Medal Honor Title for outstanding achievement in Jewish literature. Visit her online at ErikaDreifus.com and follow her on Twitter @ErikaDreifus

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Living in an Upside-Down World

Terrorists and budding terrorists are referred to as “survivors,” who, we’re told with no caveats, “blame Israel for their wounds.”

Iran’s Political Instability: Capital and Brain Drain

The Tehran Chamber of Commerce has reported a persistent decline in new investments over the past decade. At the same time, large-scale capital flight has been reported—signaling deep economic instability and widespread impoverishment.

Ozymandias Then and Now

Percy Shelly’s 1818 poem “Ozymandias” conveys a timeless message, as important today as it was the day it was published.

Print Issue: Our Last Free Issue | August 8, 2025

As you know, it’s costly to produce and print your favorite paper every week. So we need thousands of readers like you to contribute by ordering home delivery. You win, we win, the community wins. Go to Jewishjournal.com/subscribe for details.

Why Would Anyone Ever Hire Me?

The Journal gave a kid who, at one time, the world had washed their hands of a chance. For a writer to have the open forum I’ve had is a blessing.

Israel, the Jew Among the Nations

By consistently outperforming expectations and not only surviving but also thriving in spite of hostile forces, Israel has become the Jew among the nations.

How My Gaza Column Got Interrupted

In our frenzy to keep up with the news, we’re missing a whole other Israel that has little to do with the war and everything to do with what keeps a country thriving.

More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.