War is Hell on earth. People die during war. Many of those deaths are innocent civilians, including young children. Many more people are permanently injured, unable to walk, speak, see, hear or smile. Others suffer mental traumas ranging from nightmares to paralyzing hallucinations and delusions.
At least the deceased see their pain end. For the surviving family members and other loved ones, there is eternal agony. The pain never heals. Parents who bury their children die every day they live. War is truly hell.
For these and many other reasons, singing “Kumbaya” or “Give Peace a Chance” has a powerful allure. Unfortunately, this approach often leads to more war and more deaths. Evil actors see this kindness for weakness, inviting more aggression.
So as Israel prepares for a lengthy, painful war with Hamas and Hezbollah, it is imperative to dismiss calls for an immediate ceasefire. Sometimes war is the answer. In the case of Israel and her enemies, war is the only answer. That comes straight from the Torah.
The Torah does not say “Thou shalt not kill.” It says “Thou shalt not murder.” The Torah also says that a Jew can take any steps necessary to save a life with the three exceptions: Adultery, idolatry and murder.
Judaism is not a religion of surrender. The Jewish holiday of Hanukkah is a celebration of a military victory. The Greeks tried to wipe out the Jews, and the Jews led by the Maccabees forcefully and successfully fought back.
Judaism is not a religion of surrender. The Jewish holiday of Hanukkah is a celebration of a military victory. The Greeks tried to wipe out the Jews, and the Jews led by the Maccabees forcefully and successfully fought back. During the Holocaust, members of the Warsaw Ghetto fought back. Many Jews died, but some of them were saved. They eliminated many more Nazis than expected.
War freed the slaves. War saved the world from Nazism and fascism. War preserved freedom in South Korea.
Sometimes there is no peaceful solution. When Pearl Harbor was bombed, FDR was willing to do anything to preserve the American way of life. His successor President Truman’s use of nuclear weapons was so shocking that it ended Japanese involvement in World War II. JFK was willing to wage war and risk Armageddon during the Cuban Missile crisis. The Russians backed down. After the September 11th attacks, George W. Bush led a Global War on Terror that routed the Taliban and removed Saddam Hussein from earth. Donald Trump kept his word and smashed ISIS to pieces.
Self-defense and defense of others is more than justified to save innocent lives. Saving lives is not just mandatory according to Torah law. Saving lives is Torah law.
Self-defense and defense of others is more than justified to save innocent lives. Saving lives is not just mandatory according to Torah law. Saving lives is Torah law. That is why if a loved one — God forbid — has a heart attack on Shabbos, the only course of action is to immediately telephone 911 or drive them to the hospital.
Saving lives sometimes involves ending other lives. Such is the case with terrorists. For humans to survive, civilization must be preserved. Barbarism is contra to civilization. Raping, torturing and decapitating innocent civilians is not compatible with civilization. Israel’s enemies have repeatedly used such brutal barbaric tactics against innocent Jews. The terrorists even thrust barbarism upon their own people. Any society that utilizes suicide bombers is a society that is incompatible with civilization.
Suicide bombers render diplomacy useless. Wars end or are avoided in one of two circumstances. Either one side realizes victory is hopeless … checkmate … or both sides come to that conclusion that neither can gain a complete victory… stalemate. Death is usually a deterrent. America avoided a “hot war” with Russia, China and even North Korea because none of the people running those governments wanted to die. The Russians wanted blue jeans and Beatles tapes. The Chinese leaders are like J.R. Ewing from “Dallas.” They want to buy everything.
A culture that encourages suicide bombers is impossible to reason with. People willing to kill themselves while killing others need to be physically stopped before they self-detonate.
All diplomatic options in Israel have been exhausted because both sides still have hope of victory. Hamas and Hezbollah are unwilling to stop murdering innocent Jews. They can only be stopped by superior firepower.
This means collateral damage. This means more parents will weep openly as they bury their beloved children. This is awful. This is also necessary. The alternative of endless war and death is far worse.
So to those demanding a ceasefire, only one retort is necessary. If you truly want the closest thing to permanent peace, ignore John Lennon’s advice. Unleash the Israeli Defense Forces. Give war a chance.
Eric Golub is a retired stockbrokerage and oil professional living in Los Angeles.
All We Are Saying is Give War a Chance
Eric Golub
War is Hell on earth. People die during war. Many of those deaths are innocent civilians, including young children. Many more people are permanently injured, unable to walk, speak, see, hear or smile. Others suffer mental traumas ranging from nightmares to paralyzing hallucinations and delusions.
At least the deceased see their pain end. For the surviving family members and other loved ones, there is eternal agony. The pain never heals. Parents who bury their children die every day they live. War is truly hell.
For these and many other reasons, singing “Kumbaya” or “Give Peace a Chance” has a powerful allure. Unfortunately, this approach often leads to more war and more deaths. Evil actors see this kindness for weakness, inviting more aggression.
So as Israel prepares for a lengthy, painful war with Hamas and Hezbollah, it is imperative to dismiss calls for an immediate ceasefire. Sometimes war is the answer. In the case of Israel and her enemies, war is the only answer. That comes straight from the Torah.
The Torah does not say “Thou shalt not kill.” It says “Thou shalt not murder.” The Torah also says that a Jew can take any steps necessary to save a life with the three exceptions: Adultery, idolatry and murder.
Judaism is not a religion of surrender. The Jewish holiday of Hanukkah is a celebration of a military victory. The Greeks tried to wipe out the Jews, and the Jews led by the Maccabees forcefully and successfully fought back. During the Holocaust, members of the Warsaw Ghetto fought back. Many Jews died, but some of them were saved. They eliminated many more Nazis than expected.
War freed the slaves. War saved the world from Nazism and fascism. War preserved freedom in South Korea.
Sometimes there is no peaceful solution. When Pearl Harbor was bombed, FDR was willing to do anything to preserve the American way of life. His successor President Truman’s use of nuclear weapons was so shocking that it ended Japanese involvement in World War II. JFK was willing to wage war and risk Armageddon during the Cuban Missile crisis. The Russians backed down. After the September 11th attacks, George W. Bush led a Global War on Terror that routed the Taliban and removed Saddam Hussein from earth. Donald Trump kept his word and smashed ISIS to pieces.
Self-defense and defense of others is more than justified to save innocent lives. Saving lives is not just mandatory according to Torah law. Saving lives is Torah law. That is why if a loved one — God forbid — has a heart attack on Shabbos, the only course of action is to immediately telephone 911 or drive them to the hospital.
Saving lives sometimes involves ending other lives. Such is the case with terrorists. For humans to survive, civilization must be preserved. Barbarism is contra to civilization. Raping, torturing and decapitating innocent civilians is not compatible with civilization. Israel’s enemies have repeatedly used such brutal barbaric tactics against innocent Jews. The terrorists even thrust barbarism upon their own people. Any society that utilizes suicide bombers is a society that is incompatible with civilization.
Suicide bombers render diplomacy useless. Wars end or are avoided in one of two circumstances. Either one side realizes victory is hopeless … checkmate … or both sides come to that conclusion that neither can gain a complete victory… stalemate. Death is usually a deterrent. America avoided a “hot war” with Russia, China and even North Korea because none of the people running those governments wanted to die. The Russians wanted blue jeans and Beatles tapes. The Chinese leaders are like J.R. Ewing from “Dallas.” They want to buy everything.
A culture that encourages suicide bombers is impossible to reason with. People willing to kill themselves while killing others need to be physically stopped before they self-detonate.
All diplomatic options in Israel have been exhausted because both sides still have hope of victory. Hamas and Hezbollah are unwilling to stop murdering innocent Jews. They can only be stopped by superior firepower.
This means collateral damage. This means more parents will weep openly as they bury their beloved children. This is awful. This is also necessary. The alternative of endless war and death is far worse.
So to those demanding a ceasefire, only one retort is necessary. If you truly want the closest thing to permanent peace, ignore John Lennon’s advice. Unleash the Israeli Defense Forces. Give war a chance.
Eric Golub is a retired stockbrokerage and oil professional living in Los Angeles.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Chayei Sarah – a poem for Chayei Sarah
Joan Nathan’s “A Sweet Year” is Full of Meaning and Delicious Family-Friendly Recipes
“Saving Abigail” Recaps a Year of Advocating for Hostages
A Bisl Torah~Challah Prayers
Three Abrahamic Faiths But Still We Survive
A Moment in Time: “An Eye that Sees”
Culture
“Saving Abigail” Recaps a Year of Advocating for Hostages
Jessie-Sierra Ross: Straight to the Hips Baby, Seasons Around the Table and Apple and Pear Crumble
Comedy Fantasy Camp, with Teacher Jay Leno, Returns This January
Stand Up! Records Releases Tom Lehrer Vinyl Just in Time for Hanukkah
Print Issue: “They Hate Us Because We’re Good” | Nov 22, 2024
A new film, “Tragic Awakening,” reframes the world’s oldest hatred in a way that makes it uniquely relevant to our times.
Sephardic Torah from the Holy Land | Music Soothes the Soul
I learn so much from Rabbi Uziel about halakha and philosophy – and now – how to “chill and relax” in these stressful times.
‘Survivors’ Brings Holocaust Stories to Life for Students
“Survivors” is a powerful one-hour play that recounts the experiences of 10 Holocaust survivors before, during and after World War II.
Hearty Veggie Thanksgiving Sides
Here are some recipes that pair well with the main attraction, yet are filling enough for any vegetarians’ main course.
Rabbis of L.A. | Rabbi Broner and the Challenges of Being a Ninth Grade Dean
Rabbi Eli Broner, the confident, imaginative, broadly educated and experienced ninth grade dean at Shalhevet High School, puts himself into his work.
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Jessie-Sierra Ross: Straight to the Hips Baby, Seasons Around the Table and Apple and Pear Crumble
Or Amsalam: Lodge Bread, Baking Bread and Shakshuka Recipe
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.