fbpx

Remembering October 6

Next Tuesday on Simchat Torah, may our 2023 tears of grief be replaced by our 2025 tears of joy.
[additional-authors]
October 8, 2025
Fabrice Peresse/Getty Images

It’s hard to remember a more massive effort to resolve an impossible mess.

Ever since Hamas terrorists savagely massacred 1200 Israelis on Oct. 7, 2023, which triggered Israel’s longest war, ending the devastation and getting the hostages released became the deadlock nobody could crack.

Now, with a determined President Trump knocking heads and using every ounce of his leverage with the countries of the region, it looks like the first phase of deal has been reached and the hostages captured on Oct. 7 will finally come home.

As I look back on the lingering nightmare of Oct. 7, my mind today is also on Oct. 6.

Oct. 6 was before Gaza turned into rubble, before tens of thousands of civilians perished while hundreds of thousands lived in fear and misery, before hundreds of Israeli soldiers gave their lives, before the primal screams to get the hostages out, before the world turned on Israel, before antisemitism mushroomed everywhere.

But here’s the thing about Oct. 6, 2023 that the world must never forget.

There was a ceasefire.

There were no Palestinian casualties.

There were no Israeli hostages.

There were no Gaza neighborhoods turned into rubble.

The ceasefire that Trump and a mini-army of allies have been trying to get for months was already there on Oct. 6.

It’s true that the current plan is aiming higher than a return to Oct. 6, with ideas for long-term solutions for Gaza, an eventual resolution of the Palestinian conflict and an expansion of the Abraham Accords. We can only hope that at least some of these aspirations will come to fruition.

In the meantime, as we await eagerly for the deal to be signed and the hostages to be released, let’s put analyses on hold for a minute and remember that glorious day of October 6, 2023, the day before a nightmare greeted Israel and the Jewish people on the most joyful day of the Jewish calendar—Simchat Torah.

What will greet us next Tuesday on Simchat Torah? As we anticipate images of liberated hostages, may our 2023 tears of grief be replaced by our 2025 tears of joy.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Fire Up the Grill for Memorial Day Weekend

There’s nothing like gathering outdoors, firing up the grill and trying some new, delicious dishes. While traditional cookout fare always has its place, there are plenty of ways to mix things up.

Fighting Smart

A new book by Melanie Phillips challenges the conventional wisdom and offers innovative ideas and practical tools to fight the global surge of antisemitism.

A Ray of Zionist Hope on a College Campus

In a world where encampments, boycotts and student government protests of released hostages make headlines, we must focus on students who want to learn, engage and become bridge builders.

The Ultimate Act of Antisemitism

There are currently two pieces of legislation (in addition to joint resolutions) that are aimed toward stripping Israel of American military arms. Every military action Israel takes is under interpretation for legality. That is despite them battling a multi-front attack.

Shavuot, the Source of American Gratitude

Abraham Lincoln established the yearly American practice of finding – amidst our personal and national battles – sources of brightness within them, and being thankful for them.

Can Harvard Confront the Campus Climate It Helped Create?

The administration has acknowledged rising tensions and concerns about antisemitism, yet it has largely avoided addressing how parts of the university’s own intellectual and institutional culture may have contributed to those conditions.

Between Munich and Vietnam

The fear of acting on uncertain threats can itself become distorting when it evolves into a demand for near-perfect certainty before any meaningful response is considered. History rarely grants that luxury.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.