fbpx

Gun Control or Antidepressant Control? | Are We Prescribing Too Much?

[additional-authors]
January 15, 2013

Are antidepressants being prescribed too often and too much? Has the definition of clinical depression become too broad? And why are mass shootings now being linked to antidepressant use? The risk that antidepressants will ignite violent or self-destructive behavior has been the subject of renewed controversy.

After evidence that several gunmen involved in mass shootings were taking antidepressants during the time of their outburst, a number of threads have been appearing on the Web regarding this issue, but the media refuses to bring it up.

After all, companies like Pfizer and GlaxoSmithKline might stop advertising with news outlets if this notion is ever addressed, or even worse, researched in depth.

Under the influence of three powerful constituencies—the pharmaceutical industry, the social work industry,  and the psychotherapy industry—along with their handmaidens—the government, the media, and advertising—it has become exceedingly difficult for people to believe that unhappiness might just be an ordinary reaction to unpleasant circumstances.

Because of false advertisements, millions of people per year are tricked into renaming their unhappiness “depression.”  Even a television advertisement could lead you to believe that you are clinically depressed. 

Leading questions like “feeling tired and hopeless?” are geared toward subconsciously convincing people that any given pill can cure all of their symptoms.

But try reading about the symptoms and reactions caused by these pills. Suicidal–and perhaps homicidal—thoughts are almost always prevalent in the long lists of side effects written in small print on a flimsy sheet of paper folded several times over.

Many psychiatrists have admitted that antidepressants may also cause manic or aggressive behavior, especially for those who are prone to bipolar disorder. So why are tens of millions Americans taking antidepressants?

Instead of solving their problems and building resilience, people are choosing to medicalize their situations in hopes of finding a simpler solution through a happy pill that will miraculously banish symptoms of what is probably just conditional unhappiness. While some people may need them, it shouldn’t be so easy for everyone to obtain these drugs.

Of course, depression is a serious illness, and those who are truly afflicted with the disorder should seek help. But it is important to consider that perhaps advertising has allowed the mental health and pharmaceutical industries to turn human unhappiness into a cash cow through these medications—and at a cost we cannot accurately measure.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

The Blessings of a Broken World

Without the longing and passion that come with failures and mistakes, without the introspection required by repentance, one cannot become the best possible version of themselves.

Chicken With a Lemony Twist

The huge plus is that a super, simple sheet pan recipe results in a dish that looks so impressive and sophisticated.

Troubled Marriage

As Netanyahu visits Trump, Israelis look to Washington with wearier eyes. What does the future hold for the relationship?

Tu b’Av and Redemption

On Tu b’Av, the full moon rises. The same people who mourned begin to dance. The same nation who splintered begins to seek one another out again in the vineyards, in the fields, in the moments of vulnerability and return.

Mission to the Jewish Community of Ethiopia

I didn’t even know that there were still Jews left in Ethiopia, but what I encountered there firsthand was a thriving Jewish community, with some very significant struggles.

The Myth of the Marxist Mishpacha

The Jewish immigrant who organized for a 40-hour work week did not do so to give his grandchildren a politics that asks them to feel guilty for their education, their professional success or their attachment to a Jewish state.

Framing the Faith of Maimonides

In this enriching new edition of the classic code of Jewish law, readers can delve deeply into the mind of Maimonides, from his analysis of the commandments to the controversies that have accompanied his writings, offering a window into the wisdom of one of our tradition’s preeminent thinkers.

Finding Communal Comfort

In the book of Isaiah, God calls the prophet to comfort the Jewish people. But we know this is really something we must do for one another.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.