Well, that really didn’t take long.
Amidst the greatest crisis Israel and the Jewish people have known in more than two generations, Jeffrey Herbst’s piece, URJ’s Call for a “Humanitarian Pause”, is more interested in sowing division than offering an “argument for the sake of heaven”. As the leader of the Reform movement in North America, recognizing our community is deep pain, I know that his efforts will accomplish nothing more than to further exacerbate divisions and tensions within the Los Angeles and broader Jewish communities.
At this terrible moment, the American Jewish community is overwhelmingly coming together to support Israel and one another in the face of war abroad and record levels of antisemitism at home. Los Angeles has seen too many of those horrific antisemitic attacks in recent weeks. Our responsibility is to stop this dangerous trend, even as we refute those within and beyond our communities who falsely accuse Israel of committing genocide (and are astonishingly silent about Hamas’ decades-old public call for genocide), rebut those who erroneously consider Israel a settler colonialist enterprise, and reject those who think murdered Israeli babies deserved their fate. As we do this, we must firmly denounce American Jews who, though united in supporting Israel’s just war, choose to launch spineless attacks on one another.
The author’s attempts to twist meaning and paint a false picture of the Reform movement’s unyielding commitment to Israel and the security of all her people is reprehensible. He also grossly mischaracterizes the profound difference between a humanitarian pause and a ceasefire. The pause called for by our organization will allow food, water, medicine, and other humanitarian aid to flow into Gaza – and as our statement noted, should only occur if Hamas does not divert these vital humanitarian resources. This is precisely what President Biden and Secretary of State Blinken, firm in their support of Israel, have advocated. Likewise, the Reform movement joins them in a belief that a ceasefire at this moment would be a tragic mistake and a strategic advantage to Hamas in its quest to eliminate the Jewish state.
I would also question those who, like the author, maintain there is no difference between a humanitarian pause and a ceasefire. Can they explain why Israel’s adversaries in this war opposed the U.S.-drafted UN resolution calling for a humanitarian pause? And why those same countries drafted a UN resolution calling for a ceasefire that both the U.S. and the U.K. vetoed? Apparently, these folks know something that every major government in the world is unaware of. It is unfortunate that Prof. Herbst has fueled his position by misrepresenting the Reform movement on this critical issue.
While we maintain the view that a humanitarian pause by Israel is morally and tactically warranted, we respect that others may hold their own views. But can we at least agree that all Jews who stand with Israel in its right to safety, security, and self-determination, alongside a Palestinian people who must be afforded those same rights via a negotiated solution, should refrain from publicly attacking each other and weakening the Jewish community when its heart is already breaking? Public smears do not serve our shared goal of helping Israel secure itself and return the hostages to their loved ones.
It is also wrong that Prof. Herbst chooses to proffer his argument by ludicrously suggesting that the URJ’s commitment to securing release of the 240 hostages is somehow evidence of lack of care for the plight of every Israeli who has been touched and terrorized by Hamas. Will the Israeli people ever be whole while these beloved members of our global Jewish family are held in the tunnels deep below Gaza? No one should attempt to downplay the suffering of the hostages or their families.
We face daily assaults across North America on college campuses, in the corridors of power and in the media, against which we must stay united and focused. As this war continues, the climate of opinion will shift further and further from Israel. Our shared challenge is to lovingly engage one another as we continue to make the case for Israel’s existential war not against the Palestinian people, but Hamas.
Rabbi Rick Jacobs is the President of the Union for Reform Judaism
Response to Jeffrey Herbst Piece on URJ: This is Not the Time for Jew Vs. Jew
Rabbi Rick Jacobs
Well, that really didn’t take long.
Amidst the greatest crisis Israel and the Jewish people have known in more than two generations, Jeffrey Herbst’s piece, URJ’s Call for a “Humanitarian Pause”, is more interested in sowing division than offering an “argument for the sake of heaven”. As the leader of the Reform movement in North America, recognizing our community is deep pain, I know that his efforts will accomplish nothing more than to further exacerbate divisions and tensions within the Los Angeles and broader Jewish communities.
At this terrible moment, the American Jewish community is overwhelmingly coming together to support Israel and one another in the face of war abroad and record levels of antisemitism at home. Los Angeles has seen too many of those horrific antisemitic attacks in recent weeks. Our responsibility is to stop this dangerous trend, even as we refute those within and beyond our communities who falsely accuse Israel of committing genocide (and are astonishingly silent about Hamas’ decades-old public call for genocide), rebut those who erroneously consider Israel a settler colonialist enterprise, and reject those who think murdered Israeli babies deserved their fate. As we do this, we must firmly denounce American Jews who, though united in supporting Israel’s just war, choose to launch spineless attacks on one another.
The author’s attempts to twist meaning and paint a false picture of the Reform movement’s unyielding commitment to Israel and the security of all her people is reprehensible. He also grossly mischaracterizes the profound difference between a humanitarian pause and a ceasefire. The pause called for by our organization will allow food, water, medicine, and other humanitarian aid to flow into Gaza – and as our statement noted, should only occur if Hamas does not divert these vital humanitarian resources. This is precisely what President Biden and Secretary of State Blinken, firm in their support of Israel, have advocated. Likewise, the Reform movement joins them in a belief that a ceasefire at this moment would be a tragic mistake and a strategic advantage to Hamas in its quest to eliminate the Jewish state.
I would also question those who, like the author, maintain there is no difference between a humanitarian pause and a ceasefire. Can they explain why Israel’s adversaries in this war opposed the U.S.-drafted UN resolution calling for a humanitarian pause? And why those same countries drafted a UN resolution calling for a ceasefire that both the U.S. and the U.K. vetoed? Apparently, these folks know something that every major government in the world is unaware of. It is unfortunate that Prof. Herbst has fueled his position by misrepresenting the Reform movement on this critical issue.
While we maintain the view that a humanitarian pause by Israel is morally and tactically warranted, we respect that others may hold their own views. But can we at least agree that all Jews who stand with Israel in its right to safety, security, and self-determination, alongside a Palestinian people who must be afforded those same rights via a negotiated solution, should refrain from publicly attacking each other and weakening the Jewish community when its heart is already breaking? Public smears do not serve our shared goal of helping Israel secure itself and return the hostages to their loved ones.
It is also wrong that Prof. Herbst chooses to proffer his argument by ludicrously suggesting that the URJ’s commitment to securing release of the 240 hostages is somehow evidence of lack of care for the plight of every Israeli who has been touched and terrorized by Hamas. Will the Israeli people ever be whole while these beloved members of our global Jewish family are held in the tunnels deep below Gaza? No one should attempt to downplay the suffering of the hostages or their families.
We face daily assaults across North America on college campuses, in the corridors of power and in the media, against which we must stay united and focused. As this war continues, the climate of opinion will shift further and further from Israel. Our shared challenge is to lovingly engage one another as we continue to make the case for Israel’s existential war not against the Palestinian people, but Hamas.
Rabbi Rick Jacobs is the President of the Union for Reform Judaism
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Israeli Singer Eden Golan Advances to Grand Final of Eurovision
Brave-ish wins Literary Titan Gold Book Award
Proud Jews, Despite Everything
ADL, Brandeis Center File Complaints Against Occidental, Pomona College Over Antisemitism
Beit Issie Shapiro’s Global Impact: Transforming Lives and Communities
Remembering Joe Lieberman
Culture
From Unexpected Offer to Cannes Triumph: The Jewish Succession
Food Memories – and Recipes – for Mother’s Day
A G-d Squad and a Perfect Herby Salmon
Constituting the American Experiment
Let There Be Love – A poem for Parsha Kedoshim
Let love be love …
A Moment in Time: “Because That’s What Jews Do”
A Bisl Torah – We Will Find a Way
With our commitment to never forget, even through these pummeling times, we will find a way and rise again.
Print Issue: Who’s Funding It? | May 10, 2024
As anti-Israel demonstrators take over college campuses, an exclusive investigation into who’s behind it and where the money is coming from.
Magen Am Expands: Strengthening Jewish Community Security in Orange County
The recent surge in antisemitism has driven a sharp rise in demand for Magen Am services.
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Chef Katie Chin: Heritage, Chinese Cooking and Chocolate-Raspberry Wontons
Chico Menashe: Asif: Culinary Institute of Israel, Cooking with Chutzpah and The Open Kitchen Project
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.