Wednesday, April 8, 2020

Pompeo’s Settlement Statement: Facts on the Ground

Enjoying this article?

You'll love our roundtable.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

The Bluff

Note the double negative in the statement by Secretary of State Mile Pompeo: “the establishment of Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank is not, per se, inconsistent with international law”. Pompeo did not say that establishing settlement is consistent with international law. He said it is not inconsistent. And more importantly he said it does not matter. That is, international law does not matter. In. fact, I’d argue that his most important observation was the following sentence: “The hard truth is that there will never be a judicial resolution to the conflict, and arguments about who is right and who is wrong as a matter of international law will not bring peace.”

- Advertisement -

Are settlements illegal? Thoughtful people can have a sincere debate about that.

Can there be a judicial resolution to the conflict? There can be no serious debate about that.

This means that Pompeo’s most important observation is plainly true. International law has no practical meaning in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict (and one could legitimately wonder if it has any meaning anywhere). Inserting it into the conversation is a disruption. Inserting it into the conversation is a manipulation. It is a tactic aimed at presenting Israel as a pariah state, a state guilty of criminality.

We should thank Secretary Pompeo and the Trump administration for calling this bluff.


- Advertisement -

The Settlements

When Pompeo said that settlements were not illegal, he did not say that they were not damaging to the cause of peace. He did not say they were not stupid. Again, this is less a statement on the settlements, and more a statement on the role and the limitations of international law.

The settlements are a separate issue. As Pompeo said, they create new realities on the ground. They create realities that some people see as disastrous. True, international law is irrelevant to talking about the settlements. And yet, we need to talk about the settlements, the strategy behind them, their advantages and disadvantages. We still need to talk about an area in which millions live under Israel’s control without having full political rights. We still need to consider the options for Israel as it moves forward, mixing settlers and Palestinians in ways that could make separation complicated, if not impossible.


The Timing

- Advertisement -

A few days ago, the European Union’s top court ruled that European countries must label products made in Israeli settlements. Pompeo’s declaration is a clear and immediate rebuff of this unwise decision by the court. Again, it is calling a bluff: this is not a judicial decision based on law, it is a political decision expressing Europe’s opposition to settlement activity.

So, the timing is important, but Israel will still have to deal with a European Union – its largest business partner – whose policy is to use international law as an excuse for labeling products made by Jews who live in a certain, disputed area.

Timing is also important because Israel is in the midst of a nutty political process. And Pompeo’s statement – on the heels of last week’s Gaza eruption – make a coalition supported by the Arab Party seem less viable. The leader of Blue and White, Benny Gantz, responded favorably to the U.S. change of policy. The leaders of the Arab bloc are furious. In other words, Pompeo added another wedge to the many wedges that separate Gantz and the Arabs, and made a coalition headed by him and supported by them, seem unrealistic (if not impossible).


The Response

Europe disagrees with the Trump administration. This was to be expected.

The Palestinians are unhappy. That’s natural.

Most Jewish organizations meekly support the statement (AIPAC), or strongly oppose it (Reform rabbis). Unfortunate, and yet predictable.

Democratic presidential candidates disagree with the Trump administration. “The Trump administration’s statement on West Bank settlements is not only a significant step backward in our efforts to achieve a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, it is the latest in a pattern of destructive decisions that harm our national interests,” said Presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg. That’s important because of simple truth: The Trump administration altered a position that can be altered back. In other words, should Sanders, Biden, Warren or Buttigieg enter the Oval Office, they can conceivably restore the “settlements illegal” policy.

And yet, unlike statements, some facts on the ground are not easy to undo. When the US embassy was moved to Jerusalem, Democratic candidates were unhappy, but it’s unlikely that any of them would attempt to move the embassy back to Tel Aviv. With settlement activity they will have a similar problem: What Israel decides to build under a Trump umbrella will add “facts on the ground” to the statement. Reversing the statement will be possible, evacuating these settlements much more difficult.


Syria Situation: To understand the situation on the Israel-Syria border (rockets, Iron Dome activated, reports on recent attacks), listed to Rosner’s Podcast with Prof. Eyal Zisser, a leading expert on Israel-Syria relations. It is here.


- Advertisement -

Enjoyed this article?

You'll love our email updates.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
- Advertisement -

Popular Articles

The Timetable for Ending the Quarantine

A Harvard white paper from the Safra Center for Ethics reminds us that the Italian word quarantine refers to 40 days. The social distancing stay-at-home orders, the...

What I Learned After Unlocking My Papa’s History

On Friday nights, I’d watch Papa Cohen stand at the head of the table in his finest suit, reciting the Kiddush in his Polish-accented...

In The Sea of Uncertainty

This Pesach, we tremble at the preciousness of life so we don't want to cause harm. This quaking in our bodies is an outgrowth of love. The Israelites felt...

Let’s Take a Virtual Field Trip Together #SafeAtHome

Thanks to Global CommUnity for this list of Virtual Field Trips! While we are #SafeAtHome, we can explore the world from our...

Obituaries: April 9, 2020

Marilyn L. Bachner died March 23 at 86. Survived by sons Evan (Lisa), Robert; 5 grandchildren. Mount Sinai Jewel Brager died March 23 at 93....

Israel Declares Full Curfew Starting on Passover Eve

Jerusalem will be divided into eight districts, with residents unable to travel between them.

UK Prime Minister Moved to ICU As Coronavirus Symptoms Worsen

United Kingdom Prime Minister Boris Johnson was moved to the intensive care unit (ICU) on April 6 after being hospitalized the previous day for...

Is Coronavirus Really “Dismantling the Ultra-Orthodox Model?” Questions and Comments

This is a crisis in Charedi society — a crisis that is shaking the foundations of the entire Charedi society.

Israel Cordons Off Heavily Infected Orthodox Suburb

Israeli security forces cordoned off the city of Bnei Brak, near Tel Aviv, and are enforcing a total lockdown there.

My Religion Pivoted To Zoom. Will My Faith, Too?

Three times a day, six times a week, my shul convenes on Zoom for minyan-less minyan.

BDS Founder Says It’s OK to Use Israeli Coronavirus Vaccine

Omar Barghouti, the founder of the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement, said in an April 5 Facebook livestream that it’s perfectly fine for...

This Year, Let’s Sing the Sephardic Bibhilu at Every Seder Table

In these pandemic times, as we prepare for Passover seders that will be unlike any other, we can all use a special blessing. Well, I...

Winner of $1 Million Genesis Prize Donates Award To COVID-19 Aid

Human-rights activist Natan Sharansky, the winner of this year’s $1 million Genesis Prize award, has asked the Genesis Prize Foundation to donate the money...

Table for Five: Special Shabbat of Passover

One verse, five voices. Edited by Salvador Litvak, the Accidental Talmudist And Moses hastened, bowed his head to the ground and prostrated himself, and said: “If...

Prof. Yair Zakovitch and Prof. Avigdor Shinan: The Song of Songs Scroll

Shmuel Rosner, Professor Yair Zakovitch and Professor Avigdor Shinan discuss their new book - The Song of Songs Scroll, a New Israeli Commentary. Prof. Yair...


Idina Menzel, Ben Platt, Rabbis David Wolpe, Sharon Brous and More Invite You to a Virtual Seder

It would have been enough to vicariously see our favorite Broadway and Hollywood stars celebrating Passover on social media, but now fans will get...

Recipes for Mimouna, The Moroccan Celebration of Spring

The mimouna table overflows with sweet treats like orange jam, eggplant jam, marzipan, meringues and, of course, the famous moufleta, crepes served with butter and honey.

Rabbi Donin’s Trilogy Speaks Volumes About Jewish Life

Donin himself conceived of his work as “a practical handbook on how to live a Jewish life,” but he also acknowledges that the overarching goal of the three books in the series is “to answer the constant query, ‘Why?’

Gloves, Masks, Curbsides: Passover Shopping During a Pandemic

Passover shopping is hectic enough in normal times.

Jews Are Celebrating Passover – Hospitalized with COVID-19, Or Not

Even with abnormal hospital restrictions, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center is ensuring Jews can still have a seder.


Adam Sandler Salutes Doctors and Nurses in ‘Quarantine Song’

“Doctors and nurses will save us from this mess if we get them the supplies that they need. And I hope they save us soon ‘cause I’m really, really sick of my family.”

It’s In Israelis’ DNA to Battle the Coronavirus

Many years ago, some Israelis were among a group of backpackers abducted by terrorists in Asia. I forgot what country this occurred in, but...

7 No-Cost Decorating Tricks For Your Quarantined Home

Now that we’re all spending so much time inside during shelter in place orders, we might as well spruce up our homes a little...

Adam Schlesinger, Songwriter for ‘Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,’ Fountains of Wayne, Dies Due to COVID-19 Complications

Adam Schlesinger, one of the lead songwriters of Fountains of Wayne and the musical series “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” died April 1 due to complications from...

This Pandemic is the Time to Preserve Your Family’s Stories

Everyone has a story. It is not only those who have experienced terrible suffering or accomplished something extraordinary. Wouldn’t we all love to have...


Larry David Says Bernie Sanders Should Drop Out of Presidential Race

Larry David, the Bernie Sanders doppelganger who often portrays the presidential candidate in skits on “Saturday Night Live,” says the senator from Vermont should...

‘On the Map’ Free Online Screening and Q&A This Sunday

The documentary “On the Map” tells the story of the underdog Israeli basketball team’s triumphant victory at the European championship in 1977. Set against...

‘Frozen’ at the Pantages: It Doesn’t Have to Be Jewish

Let’s face it, there’s nothing particularly Jewish about the Disney musical “Frozen.” Unless you count Idina Menzel and Josh Gad, both of whom appeared...
- Advertisement -


Pandemic Times Episode 18: Can family stories nourish us during pandemic times?

New David Suissa Podcast Every Morning at 11am. As we prepare to tell the Passover story, a refection on the value of our own family...

Let My Bagels Go

The only bagel-related thing you should be consuming this Passover is...new and classic episodes of The Bagel Report! Erin and Esther reflect on the meaning of...

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact