Let me begin with a question. How do you proceed when there are no workable solutions, only a host of unworkable ideas?
Over the past month I’ve had discussions that were simultaneously mind-expanding and frustrating. Such is the nature of a real conversation. If you look up the etymology of the word, you’ll find it comes from the Latin conversari: con, “together,” and vertere, “to turn.” To converse is to turn together. To have a real conversation, each party must be turned, changed in some way by what was said. This disqualifies much of what passes for conversation these days: one side making its points while barricading its ears as the other person talks.
I’d been invited to a soiree of sorts featuring three men with extensive Israeli military backgrounds: a special forces operator, a former Sayeret Matkal commander, and an IDF general. Each spoke at length about various weapons systems, offensive and defensive, that Israel is either using now or plans to use in the future. Soon after the Q&A began, I noticed that the questions were circling the same ideas: when will the weapons be used, what are the specifics of their tactical usage, what are the costs involved, and so on. All this is of interest to me, but at some point I felt that the questions had become redundant. I raised my hand and asked what I felt was a conversation shifter. A little change-up for an audience that had been hearing what it came to hear, an audience I was admittedly part of.
“My question may not lead anywhere pertinent to a specific issue at the moment,” I said. “Think of it as looking out at a distant horizon. What do any of you gentlemen think about JD Vance’s very direct statement to Israeli officials: ‘You can’t just kill your way out of solving every single national security problem that you have’?” I could hear a murmur go up from the 20 or so audience members, mostly Americans and a few Israelis. For context, Vance was shooting back at Ben-Gvir and Smotrich over the Iran deal. He opened his comments with “What is your exact proposal?” He was speaking about Iran, but the idea is broader than that.
There was a pause as the three men looked at each other, wondering who might field my question first. I was both surprised and not surprised at their answers. “I don’t disagree with the Vice President,” one of the men began. “There has been too little attention paid to a long horizon, as you put it. There has been insufficient time for imagining what lies beyond acts of self-defense.” Another offered, “This is an important issue. I agree that because of the war, we haven’t really put it back on the table.” The last person put it this way: “We have been incredibly creative in other areas, but this one is a challenge for which there don’t appear to be any answers.” He then added, “At least not in the near term.”
What surprised me was how willing they were to address the issue. How freely and transparently they spoke about it. What didn’t surprise me was their telling me what I already believe: there are currently no good answers for anyone, on either side of the issue. Their views felt very close to the way I see the situation. I would characterize it as intractable.
Perhaps “intractable” is a hard word to hear. We are human beings. We are solution seekers. We are by nature creative, and to say that a situation is intractable leaves a taste not unlike a crushed tablet of Tylenol. And yet we are all familiar with the nature of intractability. It is an unfortunate part of life, from dread diseases to failed marriages. There’s also a misunderstanding around the term: it has little to do with giving up. We work to keep extremely ill people alive. We endeavor to save marriages on the rocks. We maintain hope even when hope feels impossible.
Saying there is no remedy must always arrive with a caveat: there is no remedy — at this time.
To be fair, an intractable conflict may still allow for improvements: reducing suffering, creating incentives for cooperation, limiting violence, or simply making sure a terrible situation doesn’t get worse. While none of these things solves the underlying problem, they’re not nothing.
I’ve had discussions with a number of self-described anti-Zionist Jews. My understanding from those conversations is that they don’t want to destroy Israel. They simply want to turn Israel into a unitary state that’s no longer Jewish. A rebranded place where all its inhabitants can live in peace and prosperity. I’ve read a few of the actual suggested name changes: Israelstine. Or Palisrael. There’s also a well-documented one: Muammar Gaddafi proposed a single state called “Isratin” in his 2003 White Book.
This comes, I think, from a frustration with the status quo and a need to right the wrongs of Zionism. In their view, Israel was from the start an illegal, colonialist ethno-state, which left the original inhabitants homeless and stateless.
OK, let’s grant, for the sake of argument, that this is all true.
But how does a unitary state work in 2026? At its root, it’s what people around the world are aiming for when they shout “From the River to the Sea.” How would Israel go about sharing, for example, the kinds of military equipment spoken about at the meeting I attended? What about Israel’s financial system, its infrastructure, its government? How would its citizens and the vast majority of Jews around the world who support its Jewish character feel about such a radical change? The frustrating part is that no one, not the keffiyeh-draped students at Columbia nor the military men who came to speak, has a workable answer. Detailed proposals do exist, such as binational and confederation models like “A Land for All.” But again, each is subject to the same issues I just raised. None strikes me as realistic.
I’m aware that in some circles there is the thought that world pressure will come to bear on Israel so heavily that the Jewish State will simply give in. This is a stated goal of the BDS movement, of antizionist groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, and of a growing faction within the DSA. I understand that there are those who passionately support this “solution.” But it is a complete fantasy.
Were this to be attempted — by that I mean a true, unilateral forcing of Israel into a corner, politically or through arms — I believe there would be an internecine conflict that would backfire for the Palestinians and their supporters in a most spectacular fashion.
Now, the more difficult issue, the one the military men spoke so candidly about. As the third officer put it, this is a challenge “for which there don’t appear to be any answers. At least not in the near term.” And what about Palestinian leaders? Do they not also have agency here? Do they not also need to think creatively, to imagine as deeply as Israelis? Or has the world infantilized them to the point of exemption?
However one defines the current status quo, it is not sustainable. I strongly believe that. Perhaps for some, it was not sustainable from the start, and only now has enough time passed for the issues buried under the rug to come to light. But what happens when we are on a course that we determine is not sustainable? And at the same time, when no solutions are readily available?
Still, one has to consider the best way to proceed.
What are the limits of the human imagination? Better put: does imagination itself fail us, or do we retreat from the endeavor simply because, somehow, hopelessness feels safer, easier? Is it unreasonable to ask what harm there is in merely discussing something, even as it lies on the most distant of horizons? In any sort of innovation, be it in music, science, war or peacemaking, there is an iterative process. Everything goes on the table, because everything can still be taken off it.
Maybe it’s more and bigger bombs. Maybe it’s more painful concessions. Maybe it’s continuing to sustain the status quo. Maybe it’s digging in our heels, or becoming more flexible. And what might the details of each entail?
Maybe it’s …
For me at least, the Q&A and the shift that occurred in the discussion had been a real conversation. A real turning. It made me think more deeply. It made me accept that intractable does not equate to failure. After the session, I had a chance to speak with each of the men. I can’t know for sure, but I suspect they had been changed to some degree as well.
Dear reader, I apologize for not ending with an answer to the question I began with. Maybe you’ve got an idea?
I’m all ears.
Peter Himmelman is a Grammy and Emmy nominated performer, songwriter, film composer, visual artist and award-winning author. This piece was published in his Substack.
To Turn Together: Israel, Intractability and Distant Horizons
Peter Himmelman
Let me begin with a question. How do you proceed when there are no workable solutions, only a host of unworkable ideas?
Over the past month I’ve had discussions that were simultaneously mind-expanding and frustrating. Such is the nature of a real conversation. If you look up the etymology of the word, you’ll find it comes from the Latin conversari: con, “together,” and vertere, “to turn.” To converse is to turn together. To have a real conversation, each party must be turned, changed in some way by what was said. This disqualifies much of what passes for conversation these days: one side making its points while barricading its ears as the other person talks.
I’d been invited to a soiree of sorts featuring three men with extensive Israeli military backgrounds: a special forces operator, a former Sayeret Matkal commander, and an IDF general. Each spoke at length about various weapons systems, offensive and defensive, that Israel is either using now or plans to use in the future. Soon after the Q&A began, I noticed that the questions were circling the same ideas: when will the weapons be used, what are the specifics of their tactical usage, what are the costs involved, and so on. All this is of interest to me, but at some point I felt that the questions had become redundant. I raised my hand and asked what I felt was a conversation shifter. A little change-up for an audience that had been hearing what it came to hear, an audience I was admittedly part of.
“My question may not lead anywhere pertinent to a specific issue at the moment,” I said. “Think of it as looking out at a distant horizon. What do any of you gentlemen think about JD Vance’s very direct statement to Israeli officials: ‘You can’t just kill your way out of solving every single national security problem that you have’?” I could hear a murmur go up from the 20 or so audience members, mostly Americans and a few Israelis. For context, Vance was shooting back at Ben-Gvir and Smotrich over the Iran deal. He opened his comments with “What is your exact proposal?” He was speaking about Iran, but the idea is broader than that.
There was a pause as the three men looked at each other, wondering who might field my question first. I was both surprised and not surprised at their answers. “I don’t disagree with the Vice President,” one of the men began. “There has been too little attention paid to a long horizon, as you put it. There has been insufficient time for imagining what lies beyond acts of self-defense.” Another offered, “This is an important issue. I agree that because of the war, we haven’t really put it back on the table.” The last person put it this way: “We have been incredibly creative in other areas, but this one is a challenge for which there don’t appear to be any answers.” He then added, “At least not in the near term.”
What surprised me was how willing they were to address the issue. How freely and transparently they spoke about it. What didn’t surprise me was their telling me what I already believe: there are currently no good answers for anyone, on either side of the issue. Their views felt very close to the way I see the situation. I would characterize it as intractable.
Perhaps “intractable” is a hard word to hear. We are human beings. We are solution seekers. We are by nature creative, and to say that a situation is intractable leaves a taste not unlike a crushed tablet of Tylenol. And yet we are all familiar with the nature of intractability. It is an unfortunate part of life, from dread diseases to failed marriages. There’s also a misunderstanding around the term: it has little to do with giving up. We work to keep extremely ill people alive. We endeavor to save marriages on the rocks. We maintain hope even when hope feels impossible.
Saying there is no remedy must always arrive with a caveat: there is no remedy — at this time.
To be fair, an intractable conflict may still allow for improvements: reducing suffering, creating incentives for cooperation, limiting violence, or simply making sure a terrible situation doesn’t get worse. While none of these things solves the underlying problem, they’re not nothing.
I’ve had discussions with a number of self-described anti-Zionist Jews. My understanding from those conversations is that they don’t want to destroy Israel. They simply want to turn Israel into a unitary state that’s no longer Jewish. A rebranded place where all its inhabitants can live in peace and prosperity. I’ve read a few of the actual suggested name changes: Israelstine. Or Palisrael. There’s also a well-documented one: Muammar Gaddafi proposed a single state called “Isratin” in his 2003 White Book.
This comes, I think, from a frustration with the status quo and a need to right the wrongs of Zionism. In their view, Israel was from the start an illegal, colonialist ethno-state, which left the original inhabitants homeless and stateless.
OK, let’s grant, for the sake of argument, that this is all true.
But how does a unitary state work in 2026? At its root, it’s what people around the world are aiming for when they shout “From the River to the Sea.” How would Israel go about sharing, for example, the kinds of military equipment spoken about at the meeting I attended? What about Israel’s financial system, its infrastructure, its government? How would its citizens and the vast majority of Jews around the world who support its Jewish character feel about such a radical change? The frustrating part is that no one, not the keffiyeh-draped students at Columbia nor the military men who came to speak, has a workable answer. Detailed proposals do exist, such as binational and confederation models like “A Land for All.” But again, each is subject to the same issues I just raised. None strikes me as realistic.
I’m aware that in some circles there is the thought that world pressure will come to bear on Israel so heavily that the Jewish State will simply give in. This is a stated goal of the BDS movement, of antizionist groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, and of a growing faction within the DSA. I understand that there are those who passionately support this “solution.” But it is a complete fantasy.
Were this to be attempted — by that I mean a true, unilateral forcing of Israel into a corner, politically or through arms — I believe there would be an internecine conflict that would backfire for the Palestinians and their supporters in a most spectacular fashion.
Now, the more difficult issue, the one the military men spoke so candidly about. As the third officer put it, this is a challenge “for which there don’t appear to be any answers. At least not in the near term.” And what about Palestinian leaders? Do they not also have agency here? Do they not also need to think creatively, to imagine as deeply as Israelis? Or has the world infantilized them to the point of exemption?
However one defines the current status quo, it is not sustainable. I strongly believe that. Perhaps for some, it was not sustainable from the start, and only now has enough time passed for the issues buried under the rug to come to light. But what happens when we are on a course that we determine is not sustainable? And at the same time, when no solutions are readily available?
Still, one has to consider the best way to proceed.
What are the limits of the human imagination? Better put: does imagination itself fail us, or do we retreat from the endeavor simply because, somehow, hopelessness feels safer, easier? Is it unreasonable to ask what harm there is in merely discussing something, even as it lies on the most distant of horizons? In any sort of innovation, be it in music, science, war or peacemaking, there is an iterative process. Everything goes on the table, because everything can still be taken off it.
Maybe it’s more and bigger bombs. Maybe it’s more painful concessions. Maybe it’s continuing to sustain the status quo. Maybe it’s digging in our heels, or becoming more flexible. And what might the details of each entail?
Maybe it’s …
For me at least, the Q&A and the shift that occurred in the discussion had been a real conversation. A real turning. It made me think more deeply. It made me accept that intractable does not equate to failure. After the session, I had a chance to speak with each of the men. I can’t know for sure, but I suspect they had been changed to some degree as well.
Dear reader, I apologize for not ending with an answer to the question I began with. Maybe you’ve got an idea?
I’m all ears.
Peter Himmelman is a Grammy and Emmy nominated performer, songwriter, film composer, visual artist and award-winning author. This piece was published in his Substack.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
From a Global People to a People of Israel
We All Need the Zionist Trifecta of Patriotism, Gratitude and Decency
To Turn Together: Israel, Intractability and Distant Horizons
Giving Thanks
The Magic Words
An Attitude of Gratitude
Torah Portion: Vayetzei
Laban is shrewd. Jacob is shrewder.
Jewish Groups and Students to Protest CUNY Hunter’s Cancelation of Cultural Affairs Night After Hillel Inclusion
“Antisemitism has no place at Hunter College.” – Statement from CUNY Hunter Hillel
Where Dating Meets DNA ft. Canavan Foundation
What Israel Taught Me About the Two Sides of Resilience
Last week, I stood at the edge of Kibbutz Nir Oz and looked across a few fields to Gaza.
In Praise of Showing Up
I still believe America is an extraordinary place to be Jewish, that most Americans are decent and that we have more allies than enemies. But those relationships won’t build themselves.
Good Sabbath, South Africa
South Africans know, in their bones, what it means to be oppressed because of who you are. They learned that lesson at a terrible cost, and they are not about to repeat it.
Launching a Rabbinical School in Germany and Pausing for Some Gratitude
Our best days are yet to be. Inspired by our successes from the past, and by our considerable legacy of wisdom, resilience, and strength, we will forge a Jewish tomorrow worthy of our past.
A Samuel Is a Sam Is a Sierra: What’s in a (Jewish) Name? Both More and Less Than We Think
Bestowing a name on a newborn in memory of a person elevates their values in our lives, but what happens when your child feels the need to change that name?
Setting Our Own Rules
As independent voters, we will no longer be forced to pretend that the zealots in our party must be tolerated in the name of “party unity.”
Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’
No matter how stressful or anxious life gets, gratitude is the saving grace, the one virtue that can give us the strength to keep going.
Jewish National Fund-USA’s Global Conference for Israel: Four Days of Zionist Pride in San Diego
It marked 125 years since the inception of the organization and its commitment to building up the land of Israel.
AJU’s Ziegler School to Launch Dual-Degree Model for Future Rabbis
The curriculum will also address contemporary challenges facing Jewish communities, including antisemitism and the responsible use of artificial intelligence and digital media.
Sharon Osbourne: ‘It’s Very Fashionable to Hate Jews and Israel’
Osbourne spoke candidly about antisemitism, her own Jewish roots and what she sees as an increasingly hostile world for Jews
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
What if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages?
What Isaac the Blind Sees
Isaac is not merely a blind man with insight; he is a blind man who has seen beyond this world.
Rabbis of LA | IDF Veteran, Guest of Rabbi Kahn, Remembers Oct. 7, 2023
Second of two parts
L.A. Federation’s Tour de Summer Camps, International Chabad Conference in NYC
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
Call Sheet – A poem for Parsha Toldot
See who’s in the cast.
A Bisl Torah ~ Dangerous Comparisons
Let us not compare child to child. God will remind us; there are ample parental blessings for each child to receive.
A Moment in Time: Holding On
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.