Movie audiences everywhere await the premier of Christopher Nolan’s star-studded summer blockbuster, “The Odyssey,” featuring Matt Damon. Meanwhile, another movie, “Citizen Vigilante,” helmed by a largely unknown German director and starring Armie Hammer, who suffered the cancellation consequences of #MeToo, failed to get a commercial release.
Nonetheless, “Citizen Vigilante” tops Amazon’s VOD streaming list at number one, and has received a 94% Rotten Tomatoes audience score. Other platforms are streaming the film with similar audience enthusiasm.
A tale of two movies depicting Europe: one centered in Ancient Greece; the other delving into the dark side of today’s continent. In “The Odyssey,” a victorious general tries to make his way home after 10 years at war and another decade in a brutal journey back. “Citizen Vigilante” is about how an entire homeland can be surrendered to foreigners who violently take over the mores of a civilization, are placated by cowardly governments, and assured that their crimes will go unpunished.
“The Odyssey” is about the aftermath of war; “Citizen Vigilante” is about a war to come where citizens must decide whether they are prepared to reclaim their nations and ensure the safety of their families.
For this reason, “Citizen Vigilante” is the true thriller and truth-teller of the summer. If you can see only one movie, skip the lines at the multiplex, forgo the IMAX technology, and contemplate a “Mad Max” morality. Expose yourself to a fictional tale that is looking all too real each day—and will soon be playing at a theater near you.
Not a movie theater, but a theater of war on city streets!
“Citizen Vigilante” is no cinematic achievement. It’s low-budget, self-financed fare. Grimly lit. Poorly plotted. And no score or soundtrack to speak of. Hammer, always compelling, is no longer a matinee “star.” No matter how many times the movie gets streamed, a career comeback is not likely from this performance.
And, yet, he should be congratulated for taking on both the project and the risk. Germany banned the movie outright. The rest of Western Europe is withholding popcorn. What reviews exist are uniformly critical. The establishment—governments, mainstream media, academia—view “Citizen Vigilante” as xenophobic, racist propaganda.
Europeans who have watched the movie, however, are seeing something else: an ominous reflection through a mirror that isn’t resorting to movie magic to dispel a dire situation. They know it’s an awful movie, but so is the condition of the continent it depicts—the one they must navigate cautiously with their lives.
Europe is suffering from moral decay and cultural rot. “Citizen Vigilante,” a feature film, projects the shadows of a documentary: raw, intimate and all too familiar.
A young mother is killed—nearly beheaded—by a migrant in front of her son. A young girl is gangraped by five Muslim boys. Young migrants bully and rob a younger boy soon after refusing to pay their fares on a bus. Thousands refuse to pay their rent despite receiving government subsidies. A Muslim father excuses his teenage son’s participation in a sexual assault because it is permitted in the Koran. The sister of the rapist blames the victim for the way she is dressed.
The movie showcases the disgraceful and hapless European legal system that either ignores or shifts the blame for criminal behavior. The failure of immigrants to assimilate is, dumbfoundingly, the fault of Europeans: “Our politics failed to integrate or get them help to function and obey our rules,” the judge explains. “Traumatic integration” is framed as an exonerating legal argument. Cultural differences are the real culprits. Rapists are victims, too.
The movie showcases the disgraceful and hapless European legal system that either ignores or shifts the blame for criminal behavior.
Meanwhile, the news media reports on the exploits of Hammer’s righteous vigilante as he takes down criminals, and the judges who coddle them. He accepts no excuses, bluntly telling one of the Muslims who explains why asylum was necessary: “I think it’s not the good ones who got out of your country; it was the bad ones.”
He becomes a folk hero for taking justice into his own hands. Aided by face-blurring and voice-distorting technology, he tells Europeans that he will continue to serve as their avenger until ordinary citizens are willing to defend themselves.
“Citizen Vigilante” taps into Europe’s hushed buyer’s remorse over accepting far too many refugees from Syria’s civil war and other war-torn Muslim nations. The movie dares Europeans to deal harshly with those who are making their lives miserable.
European governments, for this reason, hate this movie. Elected officials have refused to admit their mistakes in welcoming so many who do not appreciate welfare handouts and want nothing to do with infidels who worship Jesus Christ.
And thanks for making it easier to kill Jews living in Europe. It’s nearly impossible to pick off bad-ass Israelis back home in the Middle East.
“Citizen Vigilante” comes from the same cinematic universe that spawned some of Hollywood’s classic revenge movies, like “Dirty Harry,” “Taxi Driver,” and “Death Wish,” a movie that literally forced New Yorkers of the 1970s to decide whether it was time to reclaim their city and subways from muggers, murderers, rapists, gangs and looters.
I know a little something about revenge movies. I wrote a book years ago, “Payback: The Case for Revenge,” in which, among other things, I argue that filmmakers do a much better job than judges in making justice real and victims feel whole.
In every good film about vengeance, the legal system is given the first opportunity to mete out justice—fairly and thoroughly. Once the legal system fails, however, or is complicit in the crime, an avenger, often ambivalently, enters the picture and takes justice into his or her hands because no one else was willing to do it and the moral universe demands it.
“An eye for an eye” is not a call for bloodlust, but a demand for precision: measure for measure. Taking more than an eye leads to the recycling of violence. But payback requires getting even—to receive less as repayment when more is owed is not justice, either.
“An eye for an eye” is not a call for bloodlust, but a demand for precision: measure for measure. Taking more than an eye leads to the recycling of violence. But payback requires getting even.
Due to moral relativism, identity politics and the self-debasement of white Westerners, we live in societies where sensitivities toward the accused count more than the grief of victims—whose losses are trivialized, their agony dismissed, and where wrongdoers go under-punished.
It is the consequence of living in a culture where merely offending people is deemed a capital offense (unless those people are Jewish). Where calling attention to the moral failings of brown people is a war crime. Where spin doctors become tongue-tied in excusing the indefensible violence from those who don’t know how to behave as guests.
“Citizen Vigilante” serves as a warning to governments that if they don’t secure their borders, enforce laws, and protect their most vulnerable, ordinary people will resort to self-help.
It’s an honest movie, which is exactly why leftist European governments and “progressives” who dominate the film industry don’t want citizens to see it.
And that’s precisely why it must be seen.
The Movie Europe Doesn’t Want You to See
Thane Rosenbaum
Movie audiences everywhere await the premier of Christopher Nolan’s star-studded summer blockbuster, “The Odyssey,” featuring Matt Damon. Meanwhile, another movie, “Citizen Vigilante,” helmed by a largely unknown German director and starring Armie Hammer, who suffered the cancellation consequences of #MeToo, failed to get a commercial release.
Nonetheless, “Citizen Vigilante” tops Amazon’s VOD streaming list at number one, and has received a 94% Rotten Tomatoes audience score. Other platforms are streaming the film with similar audience enthusiasm.
A tale of two movies depicting Europe: one centered in Ancient Greece; the other delving into the dark side of today’s continent. In “The Odyssey,” a victorious general tries to make his way home after 10 years at war and another decade in a brutal journey back. “Citizen Vigilante” is about how an entire homeland can be surrendered to foreigners who violently take over the mores of a civilization, are placated by cowardly governments, and assured that their crimes will go unpunished.
“The Odyssey” is about the aftermath of war; “Citizen Vigilante” is about a war to come where citizens must decide whether they are prepared to reclaim their nations and ensure the safety of their families.
For this reason, “Citizen Vigilante” is the true thriller and truth-teller of the summer. If you can see only one movie, skip the lines at the multiplex, forgo the IMAX technology, and contemplate a “Mad Max” morality. Expose yourself to a fictional tale that is looking all too real each day—and will soon be playing at a theater near you.
Not a movie theater, but a theater of war on city streets!
“Citizen Vigilante” is no cinematic achievement. It’s low-budget, self-financed fare. Grimly lit. Poorly plotted. And no score or soundtrack to speak of. Hammer, always compelling, is no longer a matinee “star.” No matter how many times the movie gets streamed, a career comeback is not likely from this performance.
And, yet, he should be congratulated for taking on both the project and the risk. Germany banned the movie outright. The rest of Western Europe is withholding popcorn. What reviews exist are uniformly critical. The establishment—governments, mainstream media, academia—view “Citizen Vigilante” as xenophobic, racist propaganda.
Europeans who have watched the movie, however, are seeing something else: an ominous reflection through a mirror that isn’t resorting to movie magic to dispel a dire situation. They know it’s an awful movie, but so is the condition of the continent it depicts—the one they must navigate cautiously with their lives.
Europe is suffering from moral decay and cultural rot. “Citizen Vigilante,” a feature film, projects the shadows of a documentary: raw, intimate and all too familiar.
A young mother is killed—nearly beheaded—by a migrant in front of her son. A young girl is gangraped by five Muslim boys. Young migrants bully and rob a younger boy soon after refusing to pay their fares on a bus. Thousands refuse to pay their rent despite receiving government subsidies. A Muslim father excuses his teenage son’s participation in a sexual assault because it is permitted in the Koran. The sister of the rapist blames the victim for the way she is dressed.
The movie showcases the disgraceful and hapless European legal system that either ignores or shifts the blame for criminal behavior. The failure of immigrants to assimilate is, dumbfoundingly, the fault of Europeans: “Our politics failed to integrate or get them help to function and obey our rules,” the judge explains. “Traumatic integration” is framed as an exonerating legal argument. Cultural differences are the real culprits. Rapists are victims, too.
Meanwhile, the news media reports on the exploits of Hammer’s righteous vigilante as he takes down criminals, and the judges who coddle them. He accepts no excuses, bluntly telling one of the Muslims who explains why asylum was necessary: “I think it’s not the good ones who got out of your country; it was the bad ones.”
He becomes a folk hero for taking justice into his own hands. Aided by face-blurring and voice-distorting technology, he tells Europeans that he will continue to serve as their avenger until ordinary citizens are willing to defend themselves.
“Citizen Vigilante” taps into Europe’s hushed buyer’s remorse over accepting far too many refugees from Syria’s civil war and other war-torn Muslim nations. The movie dares Europeans to deal harshly with those who are making their lives miserable.
European governments, for this reason, hate this movie. Elected officials have refused to admit their mistakes in welcoming so many who do not appreciate welfare handouts and want nothing to do with infidels who worship Jesus Christ.
And thanks for making it easier to kill Jews living in Europe. It’s nearly impossible to pick off bad-ass Israelis back home in the Middle East.
“Citizen Vigilante” comes from the same cinematic universe that spawned some of Hollywood’s classic revenge movies, like “Dirty Harry,” “Taxi Driver,” and “Death Wish,” a movie that literally forced New Yorkers of the 1970s to decide whether it was time to reclaim their city and subways from muggers, murderers, rapists, gangs and looters.
I know a little something about revenge movies. I wrote a book years ago, “Payback: The Case for Revenge,” in which, among other things, I argue that filmmakers do a much better job than judges in making justice real and victims feel whole.
In every good film about vengeance, the legal system is given the first opportunity to mete out justice—fairly and thoroughly. Once the legal system fails, however, or is complicit in the crime, an avenger, often ambivalently, enters the picture and takes justice into his or her hands because no one else was willing to do it and the moral universe demands it.
“An eye for an eye” is not a call for bloodlust, but a demand for precision: measure for measure. Taking more than an eye leads to the recycling of violence. But payback requires getting even—to receive less as repayment when more is owed is not justice, either.
Due to moral relativism, identity politics and the self-debasement of white Westerners, we live in societies where sensitivities toward the accused count more than the grief of victims—whose losses are trivialized, their agony dismissed, and where wrongdoers go under-punished.
It is the consequence of living in a culture where merely offending people is deemed a capital offense (unless those people are Jewish). Where calling attention to the moral failings of brown people is a war crime. Where spin doctors become tongue-tied in excusing the indefensible violence from those who don’t know how to behave as guests.
“Citizen Vigilante” serves as a warning to governments that if they don’t secure their borders, enforce laws, and protect their most vulnerable, ordinary people will resort to self-help.
It’s an honest movie, which is exactly why leftist European governments and “progressives” who dominate the film industry don’t want citizens to see it.
And that’s precisely why it must be seen.
Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is a contributing writer for White Rose magazine. His most recent book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.”
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
“No Matter What” The Realities of Healthcare Crisis
The Best-Tasting Food in the World
Jews Are Winning Because Hatred Is Exhausting
Shahid Hussain Sentenced to Seven Years in Prison for Defacing Northwestern University with Antisemitic Symbols
JNF-USA Holds 9/11 Ceremonies, UCLA Nazarian Center Names Deputy Director
What a Mask Fight at a Lesbian Bar Has to Do with Antizionism
The Joy Within
Sukkot asks us to receive the harvest that has actually come in—not the one we imagined or wished for.
Our Celebrated Guests – Ushpizot – A Sukkot Poem
These are the seven guests, ushpizot, invited to our Sukkah –
Choose Your Heroes Wisely
Who a society calls a hero is not a minor detail; it’s close to the whole diagnosis.
Does Cal State’s Faculty Union Have a Jewish Problem? Newsom Should Look at the Record
Jewish members are describing antisemitism within CFA itself as the union presses to weaken protections born of the post-Oct. 7 campus antisemitism crisis.
A Bisl Sukkot ~ Don’t Be Afraid, Go Outside
The sukkah reminds us to go out into the world, especially when the comforts of insularity beckon us closer—to explore paths we have yet to take and seek journeys ready for wandering.
A Moment in Time: Sukkot
Kol Nidrei, Broken Eggs and a Beethoven Quartet in C Sharp Minor
Print Issue: Can We Rescue Our Youth From Social Media? | September 25, 2026
A Jewish high school in Los Angeles has developed a program that encourages students to reclaim their lives from social media. It is changing the conversation.
Before Oct. 7 and After: Arab Audiences Keep Watching ‘Fauda’
Season 5 is the first season of “Fauda” built around the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023 terror attacks on Israel.
For These Israelis, Voting Is Worth a $10,000 Trip Home
The Journal spoke with a dozen Israelis from California who are planning to travel to Israel for the election.
A Harira Hug in the Sukkah
I love making soup for this holiday because even if the days are still warm, the cooler evenings make you start craving something warm and comforting.
Table for Five: Sukkot
A Divine Hug
Can We Rescue Our Youth from Social Media?
A Jewish high school in Los Angeles has developed a program that encourages students to reclaim their lives from social media. It is changing the conversation.
‘Let No Person Judge Himself’ — On the Apostate, Self-Hatred, and the Wrong Questions
There is a difference between criticism that comes from responsibility and love, and an almost psychological need to prove to the world: I am not one of them.
Israeli Ambassador Yechiel Leiter’s Son Undergoes Brain Surgery After West Bank Terror Attack
Shaare Zedek Medical Center in Jerusalem said Wednesday night that after undergoing lifesaving procedures in its trauma unit, Leiter underwent complex brain surgery lasting several hours along with additional treatments.
More Than a Toolkit: Helping Jewish Students Navigate Campus
First launched in 2024 and updated again this year, the guide offers practical resources and advice for navigating the current campus climate.
The Beat Goes On
While so much of the world seems obsessed with and consumed by its hatred of Israel and Jews, Israelis continue to build, create, work, celebrate, argue, raise families, and plan for the future.
Viral AI Video Targets Jewish Comedian
“The biggest concern is that people now have a pathway to shut down Jewish voices through complete falsities that people will believe. … For the future of Jewish entertainment, it’s very scary.”
Yiddish Historians: Writing in Their Own Language for Their Own People
Mark Smith has compiled an important anthology of Jewish history using 49 works by Yiddish historians to recreate or at least open the door to a world of Jewish thought that was once almost mainstream, but which no longer exists, except in the minds of too few specialists.
The Everlasting Melody
Most Jews who have sung “Eitz Chaim” over the past half-century probably never knew Portnoy. They did not know when he wrote the melody or how young he was when he composed it. They simply knew the song.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.