With Passover days away, it should be remembered that California’s governor, Gavin Newsom, unlike Ramses, the Pharoah of ancient Egypt, actually let his people go—without putting up a fight.
Not that disgruntled Californians were enslaved, of course. But like Pharoah, Newsom wanted them to stay. Jews escaped bondage in Egypt for the Promised Land; the Exodus from states like New York, Illinois and California to Texas and Florida arose from an entirely different set of plagues: high taxes, rising crime, declining municipal services, woke insanities and reckless sanctuary city policies.
Governor Newsom and the California Highway Patrol can’t very well mount chariots and chase after former residents all the way down to a parted Gulf of America.
But there are some things he might be able to do to lure his people back and keep others from leaving. As an added bonus, he could boost his presidential marquee by separating himself from progressives who have hijacked the Democratic Party and remade it in ways that are wholly unrecognizable to centrist, common-sense Americans.
Governor Newsom and the California Highway Patrol can’t very well mount chariots and chase after former residents all the way down to a parted Gulf of America. But there are some things he might be able to do to lure his people back and keep others from leaving.
It would require that we see more of what he accomplished this past week, however: a welcome display of moral courage in defiance of his party’s descent into antisemitism as improbable selling point.
Lax criminal law enforcement and a twisted misreading of the First Amendment have given American Jews ample reasons to make haste to red states.
Since the October 7, 2023 massacre and Israel’s eventual routing of its Islamist enemies in a just war that has now, finally, set its sights on Iran, Jews have become conditioned to watch their backs in synagogues and on college campuses and city streets. Identifying as a Zionist—or even sharing a sympathetic word about Israel—can be a career-ending, friendship-shattering, and family-dissolving experience.
Here’s an area where California’s governor could generate some political goodwill—by flexing his Jewish mojo. Jews are slowly coming to the realization (far too slowly, to my mind) that the Democratic Party to which they have been eternally loyal since the FDR administration, actually wants the existence of Israel to come to an end.
Democrats have renounced their fidelity to the only democratic nation in the Middle East. Solidarity now favors the incalcitrant, rejectionist and faithfully violent Palestinian people. What a poor choice that is: Clamoring to “Free Palestine”—a mythical place that never existed—by killing the Jews of Israel who built their nation 1,500 years before a Muslim ever walked anywhere on Earth.
Democrats have renounced their fidelity to the only democratic nation in the Middle East. Solidarity now favors the incalcitrant, rejectionist and faithfully violent Palestinian people. What a poor choice that is.
The Gulf nations that joined the Abraham Accords came to the obvious conclusion that Palestinians don’t want a state, never showed any interest in nation-building, and wouldn’t know what to do with a state if they had one. Honestly, how many suicide vests does a people need? The two-state solution is one-step closer to yet another terrorist state.
That’s what AOC, Omar, Tlaib and Mamdani are selling to a guileless American public.
Newsom redeemed himself for having carelessly read from the script that excites Democratic Socialists and maniacal Islamists alike. Appearing on “Pod Save America,” he spoke of Israel as becoming “sort of an apartheid state,” referencing Thomas Friedman, from the New York Times, as his source.
After speaking with leaders of California’s Jewish community and a Florida lawyer with a long history of Jewish advocacy, Newsom, in a subsequent interview on a Politico podcast, reflected more thoughtfully and recanted the apartheid charge. He then said, “I revere the state of Israel. I’m proud to support the state of Israel.”
Bernie Sanders must have had a heart attack when he read that revocation. Progressives, especially Jewish ones, live to libel Israel. But for the governor, it was a wise decision to distance himself from the antisemitic riffraff.
The governor could also benefit from an information overhaul. Who’s handling his briefing books? Because they are outdated and rife with Jew-hatred—and Jewish self-hatred.
For instance, no one outside of the New York Times cares what Tom Friedman thinks anymore. They did in 1989 when he wrote “From Beirut to Jerusalem.” Nowadays, he’s just an overpaid Israel-bashing shill. He’s been wrong on most matters related to his purported expertise: the Middle East! He supported Barack Obama’s Iran Deal and never saw the Abraham Accords coming.
Even his falafel restaurant recommendations should now be disqualified.
Here’s someone else to ignore. Mark Ruffalo roundly criticized Newsom’s backtracking on Israeli apartheid, stating, “I don’t know what billionaire got in your ear but it’s not working for you. This is not how you are going to win. It’s Apartheid and it’s a Genocide. Today!”
What a lack of humility from an empty-headed actor. Is Ruffalo, or, for that matter, Javier Bardem, John Cusack, Emma Stone, Ariana Grande and Dua Lipa, really credentialled to render opinions on Middle East history and politics, and international law? Ruffalo never attended nor graduated from college (neither have the others). He doubtlessly is poorly read, knows very little history, has not travelled to regions infested with terror, and has had no direct contact with terrorists and Islamists.
Ruffalo is in no position to advise Governor Newsom or any presidential candidate on American foreign policy or international humanitarian law.
These red-carpet virtue-signaling spotlights, and Bardem’s narcissistic commentary while presenting an Oscar, are especially galling. Palestinians—even most of the civilians—are accomplices to terrorism. They are also the source of their own suffering. Meanwhile these celebrities blithely ignore the 50,000 who have been murdered by the Islamists of Iran.
It’s time to properly acknowledge that for many of these A-listers, the “A” stands for antisemites. They repeatedly single out Israel—where artists, women and homosexuals live freely and thrive—but have nothing to say about the terrorism of Hamas or the suffering of tens of millions in nations run by Islamists.
There’s something seriously awry in having a predisposition to think the worst of Jews and always have a ready justification for any harm that comes to them, or Israel—the repository of all contemporary Jewish hatred.
One final thought for Gavin Newsom should he falter or be enticed to restate the false apartheid charge. For apartheid to be present, a state must forcibly separate and discriminate against a disfavored group within the population on racial grounds. Jews and Arabs, however, are not racial groups, and there is no “racial separation”—or any division at all—between them.
In Israel, Jews and Arabs (20 percent of the population) ride the same public transports, eat in the same restaurants and enjoy identical civil and political rights. Arabs serve on the Supreme Court, in the Knesset and governing coalition. They operate on patients in hospitals and are soldiers in the IDF. An Ethiopian Jew was crowned Miss Israel. Wonder Woman herself, Gal Gadot, is a woman of color!
Does that sound like anything even remotely separate and apart?
As for the West Bank, yes—those Arabs do not have the same rights as the ones in Israel because they don’t live in Israel. Arabs that live in Brooklyn don’t have rights in Israel, either. Nor does a Jew who lives in Malibu.
Newsom’s newfound sensitivity to Jewish concerns and reclaiming of the moderate mantle is commendable. Now all he needs is for the Angel of Death to “pass over” the Democratic Party.
Gavin’s New Jewish Groove
Thane Rosenbaum
With Passover days away, it should be remembered that California’s governor, Gavin Newsom, unlike Ramses, the Pharoah of ancient Egypt, actually let his people go—without putting up a fight.
Not that disgruntled Californians were enslaved, of course. But like Pharoah, Newsom wanted them to stay. Jews escaped bondage in Egypt for the Promised Land; the Exodus from states like New York, Illinois and California to Texas and Florida arose from an entirely different set of plagues: high taxes, rising crime, declining municipal services, woke insanities and reckless sanctuary city policies.
Governor Newsom and the California Highway Patrol can’t very well mount chariots and chase after former residents all the way down to a parted Gulf of America.
But there are some things he might be able to do to lure his people back and keep others from leaving. As an added bonus, he could boost his presidential marquee by separating himself from progressives who have hijacked the Democratic Party and remade it in ways that are wholly unrecognizable to centrist, common-sense Americans.
It would require that we see more of what he accomplished this past week, however: a welcome display of moral courage in defiance of his party’s descent into antisemitism as improbable selling point.
Lax criminal law enforcement and a twisted misreading of the First Amendment have given American Jews ample reasons to make haste to red states.
Since the October 7, 2023 massacre and Israel’s eventual routing of its Islamist enemies in a just war that has now, finally, set its sights on Iran, Jews have become conditioned to watch their backs in synagogues and on college campuses and city streets. Identifying as a Zionist—or even sharing a sympathetic word about Israel—can be a career-ending, friendship-shattering, and family-dissolving experience.
Here’s an area where California’s governor could generate some political goodwill—by flexing his Jewish mojo. Jews are slowly coming to the realization (far too slowly, to my mind) that the Democratic Party to which they have been eternally loyal since the FDR administration, actually wants the existence of Israel to come to an end.
Democrats have renounced their fidelity to the only democratic nation in the Middle East. Solidarity now favors the incalcitrant, rejectionist and faithfully violent Palestinian people. What a poor choice that is: Clamoring to “Free Palestine”—a mythical place that never existed—by killing the Jews of Israel who built their nation 1,500 years before a Muslim ever walked anywhere on Earth.
The Gulf nations that joined the Abraham Accords came to the obvious conclusion that Palestinians don’t want a state, never showed any interest in nation-building, and wouldn’t know what to do with a state if they had one. Honestly, how many suicide vests does a people need? The two-state solution is one-step closer to yet another terrorist state.
That’s what AOC, Omar, Tlaib and Mamdani are selling to a guileless American public.
Newsom redeemed himself for having carelessly read from the script that excites Democratic Socialists and maniacal Islamists alike. Appearing on “Pod Save America,” he spoke of Israel as becoming “sort of an apartheid state,” referencing Thomas Friedman, from the New York Times, as his source.
After speaking with leaders of California’s Jewish community and a Florida lawyer with a long history of Jewish advocacy, Newsom, in a subsequent interview on a Politico podcast, reflected more thoughtfully and recanted the apartheid charge. He then said, “I revere the state of Israel. I’m proud to support the state of Israel.”
Bernie Sanders must have had a heart attack when he read that revocation. Progressives, especially Jewish ones, live to libel Israel. But for the governor, it was a wise decision to distance himself from the antisemitic riffraff.
The governor could also benefit from an information overhaul. Who’s handling his briefing books? Because they are outdated and rife with Jew-hatred—and Jewish self-hatred.
For instance, no one outside of the New York Times cares what Tom Friedman thinks anymore. They did in 1989 when he wrote “From Beirut to Jerusalem.” Nowadays, he’s just an overpaid Israel-bashing shill. He’s been wrong on most matters related to his purported expertise: the Middle East! He supported Barack Obama’s Iran Deal and never saw the Abraham Accords coming.
Even his falafel restaurant recommendations should now be disqualified.
Here’s someone else to ignore. Mark Ruffalo roundly criticized Newsom’s backtracking on Israeli apartheid, stating, “I don’t know what billionaire got in your ear but it’s not working for you. This is not how you are going to win. It’s Apartheid and it’s a Genocide. Today!”
What a lack of humility from an empty-headed actor. Is Ruffalo, or, for that matter, Javier Bardem, John Cusack, Emma Stone, Ariana Grande and Dua Lipa, really credentialled to render opinions on Middle East history and politics, and international law? Ruffalo never attended nor graduated from college (neither have the others). He doubtlessly is poorly read, knows very little history, has not travelled to regions infested with terror, and has had no direct contact with terrorists and Islamists.
Ruffalo is in no position to advise Governor Newsom or any presidential candidate on American foreign policy or international humanitarian law.
These red-carpet virtue-signaling spotlights, and Bardem’s narcissistic commentary while presenting an Oscar, are especially galling. Palestinians—even most of the civilians—are accomplices to terrorism. They are also the source of their own suffering. Meanwhile these celebrities blithely ignore the 50,000 who have been murdered by the Islamists of Iran.
It’s time to properly acknowledge that for many of these A-listers, the “A” stands for antisemites. They repeatedly single out Israel—where artists, women and homosexuals live freely and thrive—but have nothing to say about the terrorism of Hamas or the suffering of tens of millions in nations run by Islamists.
There’s something seriously awry in having a predisposition to think the worst of Jews and always have a ready justification for any harm that comes to them, or Israel—the repository of all contemporary Jewish hatred.
One final thought for Gavin Newsom should he falter or be enticed to restate the false apartheid charge. For apartheid to be present, a state must forcibly separate and discriminate against a disfavored group within the population on racial grounds. Jews and Arabs, however, are not racial groups, and there is no “racial separation”—or any division at all—between them.
In Israel, Jews and Arabs (20 percent of the population) ride the same public transports, eat in the same restaurants and enjoy identical civil and political rights. Arabs serve on the Supreme Court, in the Knesset and governing coalition. They operate on patients in hospitals and are soldiers in the IDF. An Ethiopian Jew was crowned Miss Israel. Wonder Woman herself, Gal Gadot, is a woman of color!
Does that sound like anything even remotely separate and apart?
As for the West Bank, yes—those Arabs do not have the same rights as the ones in Israel because they don’t live in Israel. Arabs that live in Brooklyn don’t have rights in Israel, either. Nor does a Jew who lives in Malibu.
Newsom’s newfound sensitivity to Jewish concerns and reclaiming of the moderate mantle is commendable. Now all he needs is for the Angel of Death to “pass over” the Democratic Party.
Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is the legal analyst for CBS News Radio. His most recent book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.”
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
The Match That Oct. 7 Struck
Will Sept. 30 Go Down in History Like Oct. 7?
This Just Makes It Worse
Oct. 7 Makes Me Grateful for the Secular Calendar
October 7th and the Secret of Simchat Torah
Rabbis of LA | Rabbi’s Heroic Friend Remembers Oct. 7
EarlyJ Invests More Than $510,000 to Expand Jewish Parenting Centers Across California
Their goal is to ensure Jewish preschools become community hubs for families, starting in the earliest stages of parenthood.
Our Eyes Blink — A poem for Parsha Vezot Hab’rachah
My son turned eighteen yesterday…
AFHU Bel Air Affaire, Los Angeles Jewish Film Fest Screening
Notable people and events in the Jewish LA community.
A Moment in Time: Give a Child a Summer to Remember
A Bisl Torah ~ Fragility Beckons Daily Courage
Sukkot emphasizes that which we intrinsically know. We go outside and show the world that no matter the environment, we will express our Judaism with pride and joy.
October Seventh and the Reversal Caused by Sukkot
The Antisemitism You Won’t Hear About in the News
Liat Cohen-Reeis, director of the Antisemitism Task Force at StandWithUs San Diego, has tried to bring local news media’s attention to antisemitic incidents, but has encountered disinterest.
Print Issue: Crisis of Truth | October 2, 2026
An uproar over an article showing discrimination against Jewish and Israeli writers dramatizes how ideology and politics prevail over truth.
A Free Makeover: A Bath, a Haircut and a Second Chance
At the shelters, the grooming does more than make the dogs look and smell better.
Rochelle Furstenberg, Iconic Writer, Editor, Passes Away in Jerusalem
Furstenberg has been an iconic writer and editor in Israeli and American publications for decades, including for the L.A. Jewish Journal, and her death, even at the age of 90, on the eve of Rosh Hashana, deeply moved Jerusalemites who knew her.
What Kind of Judaism Do We Want After Oct. 7?
Arthur Green, “Can Judaism Be Saved: Its Future After Gaza” (Teaneck, NJ: Ben Yehuda Press, 2025) pp. 139.
Your Organization Doesn’t Need a Chatbot. It Needs Its Hours Back.
The point of all this isn’t to replace the people who keep our institutions running. It’s to give them back the hours they spend being human copy machines, so they can spend those hours on the work only people can do.
The Architecture of L’Dor Vador: How Physical Structures Shape Jewish Values and Intergenerational Life
This is more than a proposal to construct apartments. It is an invitation to reconsider what a Jewish institution can be.
Stuffed with Spice and Simcha
The custom of eating stuffed vegetables on Simchat Torah is to symbolize the scrolls of the Torah filled with the wisdom of the holy text.
Table for Five: Simchat Torah
Exclusive After-Party
Crisis of Truth
An uproar over an article showing discrimination against Jewish and Israeli writers dramatizes how ideology and politics prevail over truth.
Rosner’s Domain | Election Day Will Just Be a Beginning
Israelis are an impatient bunch, but their political processes can drag on and on – and on.
Saudi Arabia Is Encircled. The Way Out May Run through Jerusalem
Saudi Arabia’s growing vulnerability presents Israel – and the United States – with an opportunity to deepen the partnership between two of the region’s most important forces against extremism.
Two Elections, One People
On October 27, Israelis will elect the 26th Knesset. A week later, on November 3, Americans will vote in pivotal midterm elections.
The Return to Biblicalness
Shattering as it’s been, there’s something to be said for this abrupt return to biblicalness. By this awkward word I don’t mean belief in religion, necessarily, but appreciation for values that have fallen into disfavor in our supposedly enlightened age.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.