Those supporting peace at any price are celebrating the ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas. After 15 months of war, a peace agreement was reached that mirror’s Neville Chamberlain’s piece of paper. Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump both rushed to take credit for a deal deserving blame. Israel again surrendered rather than finish the job. Charlie Brown will not be kicking the football. Israel will not receive lasting peace.
Mr. Biden foolishly insists his administration deserves credit. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeatedly and properly ignored Biden and Secretary of State Anthony Blinken. Biden and Blinken continued their trend of being spectacularly wrong about war and peace matters. They are the heirs to former President Jimmy Carter’s peace through weakness doctrine.
Mr. Trump is different. He believes in former President Ronald Reagan’s doctrine of peace through strength. There were zero wars during Trump’s first term because his threats of overwhelming force were credible. He vowed to smash ISIS to pieces, and he did. America’s enemies noticed.
Trump has always been a friend of Israel. His Abraham Accords are a major success. He personally admires Israelis, who share his love of military strength and business negotiating skills. He wheels and deals. They shpiel and deal. The admiration is mutual.
Sadly, Trump’s peace deal is a sequel to the terrible Gilad Shalit deal. Israel received two dead bodies and one live soldier in exchange for 1,000 Islamist prisoners including October 7th mastermind Yah-Ya Sinwar.
Now Israel is accepting some live hostages and dead bodies while releasing more terrorists including the next Sinwar.
For family members of hostages, this deal is good. Their top priority, understandably, is bringing loved ones home. For Israelis unrelated by blood or friendship to the hostages, this deal is a future inevitable nightmare. A weakened Hamas is still alive. Unlike Trump obliterating ISIS, the Israeli Defense Forces were denied the right to smash Hamas and Hezbollah to bits.
Trump supporters insist he has earned the benefit of the doubt. His pro-Israel credentials are significant. If Hamas or Hezbollah attacked Israel again, Trump would encourage Mr. Netanyahu to go full tilt.
This is true, but meaningless. Trump’s strategy makes sense with him in power. Iran will forego meaningful action during his presidency. Iran was economically strangled during his first term.
Iran funds Hamas, Hezbollah and other global Islamist terrorist groups. The mullahs in Iran are the hydra’s heads. They play the long game. They know that in four or eight years, Democrats will retake the White House. Tehran can then restart the jihad party.
Former President Barack Obama gave Iran billions of dollars. Former Secretary of State John Kerry performed shadow diplomacy during the first Trump presidency. Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris continued coddling Iran. Democrats show zero interest in changing their feckless foreign policy approach.
Trump will contain Iran’s Islamists, but containment is not total victory. Even reimposing sanctions on Iran is not dayenu. Hamas and Hezbollah already received their foreign aid. Clawing that money back is impossible.
Hamas and Hezbollah will use the next four years to quietly rebuild, rearm, and reproduce. Their young children will reach Jihad-waging age by 2032. Eight years comes in the blink of an eye. Hamas and Hezbollah had their ambitions delayed but not ended. All the Islamists need is one more Democrat in the White House. Rather than have their nuclear facilities destroyed, Iran will be able to build nuclear bombs.
Israel’s only hope is Hamas or Hezbollah violating the ceasefire. With Trump in power, that is highly unlikely.
Israelis are now free to enjoy a temporary lull. If they thought October 7th was hell on earth, just wait until the next war that could be 100 times worse. Such is life of Western democratic nations when brilliant military leaders are restrained by political leaders. The IDF won. The Israeli government under heavy American pressure surrendered again.
Eric Golub is a retired stockbrokerage and oil professional living in Los Angeles.
Israel Surrenders
Eric Golub
Those supporting peace at any price are celebrating the ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas. After 15 months of war, a peace agreement was reached that mirror’s Neville Chamberlain’s piece of paper. Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump both rushed to take credit for a deal deserving blame. Israel again surrendered rather than finish the job. Charlie Brown will not be kicking the football. Israel will not receive lasting peace.
Mr. Biden foolishly insists his administration deserves credit. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeatedly and properly ignored Biden and Secretary of State Anthony Blinken. Biden and Blinken continued their trend of being spectacularly wrong about war and peace matters. They are the heirs to former President Jimmy Carter’s peace through weakness doctrine.
Mr. Trump is different. He believes in former President Ronald Reagan’s doctrine of peace through strength. There were zero wars during Trump’s first term because his threats of overwhelming force were credible. He vowed to smash ISIS to pieces, and he did. America’s enemies noticed.
Trump has always been a friend of Israel. His Abraham Accords are a major success. He personally admires Israelis, who share his love of military strength and business negotiating skills. He wheels and deals. They shpiel and deal. The admiration is mutual.
Sadly, Trump’s peace deal is a sequel to the terrible Gilad Shalit deal. Israel received two dead bodies and one live soldier in exchange for 1,000 Islamist prisoners including October 7th mastermind Yah-Ya Sinwar.
Now Israel is accepting some live hostages and dead bodies while releasing more terrorists including the next Sinwar.
For family members of hostages, this deal is good. Their top priority, understandably, is bringing loved ones home. For Israelis unrelated by blood or friendship to the hostages, this deal is a future inevitable nightmare. A weakened Hamas is still alive. Unlike Trump obliterating ISIS, the Israeli Defense Forces were denied the right to smash Hamas and Hezbollah to bits.
Trump supporters insist he has earned the benefit of the doubt. His pro-Israel credentials are significant. If Hamas or Hezbollah attacked Israel again, Trump would encourage Mr. Netanyahu to go full tilt.
This is true, but meaningless. Trump’s strategy makes sense with him in power. Iran will forego meaningful action during his presidency. Iran was economically strangled during his first term.
Iran funds Hamas, Hezbollah and other global Islamist terrorist groups. The mullahs in Iran are the hydra’s heads. They play the long game. They know that in four or eight years, Democrats will retake the White House. Tehran can then restart the jihad party.
Former President Barack Obama gave Iran billions of dollars. Former Secretary of State John Kerry performed shadow diplomacy during the first Trump presidency. Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris continued coddling Iran. Democrats show zero interest in changing their feckless foreign policy approach.
Trump will contain Iran’s Islamists, but containment is not total victory. Even reimposing sanctions on Iran is not dayenu. Hamas and Hezbollah already received their foreign aid. Clawing that money back is impossible.
Hamas and Hezbollah will use the next four years to quietly rebuild, rearm, and reproduce. Their young children will reach Jihad-waging age by 2032. Eight years comes in the blink of an eye. Hamas and Hezbollah had their ambitions delayed but not ended. All the Islamists need is one more Democrat in the White House. Rather than have their nuclear facilities destroyed, Iran will be able to build nuclear bombs.
Israel’s only hope is Hamas or Hezbollah violating the ceasefire. With Trump in power, that is highly unlikely.
Israelis are now free to enjoy a temporary lull. If they thought October 7th was hell on earth, just wait until the next war that could be 100 times worse. Such is life of Western democratic nations when brilliant military leaders are restrained by political leaders. The IDF won. The Israeli government under heavy American pressure surrendered again.
Eric Golub is a retired stockbrokerage and oil professional living in Los Angeles.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Rabbis of LA | The Rembaums’ Happy Life Together
Some LA Business Owners and Residents Taking Safety Into Their Own Hands
‘The Israeli in Me Came Out’: At 81, Howard Rosenman Fought His Attackers
Jewish Activist Says She Won’t Be Silenced After Being Attacked at the University of Michigan
A Popular Skewer Recipe
Table for Five: Chayei Sarah
Settling on the Outskirts – A poem for Parsha Chayei Sara
The life of Sara ends with death.
A Moment in Time: Beyond Politics
A Bisl Torah ~ Love at First Hearing
Is attraction based solely on the physical? Or is chemistry based on something deeper?
Why Moses’ Name Is Changed to Menasseh in Judges
Why Israel’s Messy Election Should Worry Washington
The tight relationship between Trump and Netanyahu masks the real debate over Israel churning in the Republican Party, and Israel’s standing among Democrats has never been lower.
Jewish Community Weighs Implications of Democrats’ Midterm Election Victories
Some emphasized the importance of combating antisemitism and protecting Jewish safety, while others called for political engagement and cooperation across party lines.
Print Issue: Election Fever | November 6, 2026
What comes next?
Rosner’s Domain: Weeks of Known Unknowns
So here we are, stuck with just a few bad options to consider. And that’s just the political superposition of undetermined future – alongside it there’s also the possible – probable? – war with Iran.
The Switched Passport: A Lesson in Seeing the Other
That is my hope: that by finding things we can do together, by recognizing each other’s humanity, we might come to see each other more fully.
After the Last Out, Collect a Different Kind of Card
At a time when Jewish education is competing for attention in a world dominated by screens, sports, short-form videos and endless streams of content, these easily collectable cards offer a different kind of engagement.
6 Jewish Takeaways from the Midterm Elections
There is little chance that the combination of a weakened Trump and an emboldened Democratic Congress produces similar levels of support for aggressive action against Iran and its proxies, and other policies that a wide spectrum of Israelis see as crucial to their security.
Israel Drives Them Crazy
In the diaspora and in Israel, we cannot turn back the clock and undo the harm that was done to us. But we can shape our own future. Israel is strong and resolute. So must we be.
A Democratic-Run Congress Will Target Israel as Well as Trump
Democrats who were long considered “moderates” or even pro-Israel have been signaling over the course of the last year that they can no longer be relied upon to back a Jewish state under assault by Iran and its terrorist proxies.
Why Jewish Unity Is So Difficult
When each dispute seems existential, an error is a catastrophe and disagreement seems like betrayal.
Torah Portion: Chayei Sarah
The Torah offers a comforting view of a life beyond this life. We aren’t told what it will be exactly — yes, it’s abstract and vague — but we are told it’s waiting for us as it was for Abraham.
The NAZA Election — Israel and the Jews were Collateral Damage on Tuesday
History teaches that you can always trust the fanatics to overplay their hand, allowing muscular moderates to reassert power.
Present at the Scene: The 2026 Mid Term Elections and the Jewish Vote
How do voters reconcile longstanding party loyalties with changing views of Israel, communal security and American political leadership?
Hatred Opened the Door. A Missed Victory Held It Open.
For me, the disaster isn’t that Democrats won or Republicans lost. It’s that politicians who demonize Israel, deny Jewish self-determination and explain away antisemitism are finding an increasingly receptive electorate in the world’s most important democracy.
The Jewish Dilemma
The central issue is not whether Jewish voters should support Democrats or Republicans. It is whether either party can demonstrate that Jewish security, Jewish identity and Jewish self-determination are compatible with its broader political agenda.
Democrats Win Control of Congress as Election Produces Historic Firsts
Abdul El-Sayed (D-Michigan) becomes first Muslim elected to U.S. Senate, longtime Republican strongholds turn Democratic, and at least five Democratic Socialists of America-backed candidates win U.S. House seats.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.