Here we go again. Israel is at war, and young American Jews are having an “identity crisis,” if one is to believe a recent report by the New York Times. Ten years ago, such stories seemed fresh. The old Israel-Diaspora relations is making room for new Israel-Diaspora relations. Today, it is an old story. Old and tired. A few prospective rabbis can no longer tolerate Israel’s actions. They wrote a letter. It convicts Israel, among other things, because “Israel’s choices come from a place of power.”
Maybe they aren’t quite familiar with the Zionist idea or with Israeli spirit. Yes — this country’s choices come from a place of power. That’s the whole idea. When Israel is attacked, it doesn’t write letters. It has means of defense. Means of power. If this makes the rabbis uncomfortable, I have no remedy for them. None other than writing letters.
The rabbis are an outlier for now. The Pew Center study from last week proved, and not for the first time, that the more observant Jews are, the more connected to Israel they are. Thus, I found the following paragraph in the NYT story amusing:
Alyssa Rubin, 26, who volunteers in Boston with IfNotNow, a network of Jewish activists who want to end Jewish American support for Israeli occupation, has found protesting for the Palestinian cause to be its own form of religious observance.
Religious observance. What is religious observance? Here is another opportunity for Jews to debate: For some, it is the synagogue, for others, lighting candles, for yet others, trying to convince the American government to reduce its support for Israel. Maybe that’s the source of the growing demand for young rabbis who can write letters.
To be somewhat more serious, the support of American Jews is important for Israel. It is important as long as it is support for policies that Israelis see as necessary. This doesn’t mean that all Israeli policies should be supported by every American Jew. It does mean that at some point the price of support could become too high for Israelis to still want it.
If gaining the support of some rabbis and activists means that Israel must disarm, or become weaker, or take risks with the Palestinians that they deem unworthy, then Israel will not do it. Neither religious observances, nor provocative letters, not even articles written by important figures, such as Senator Bernie Sanders, are going to change that.
If gaining the support of some rabbis and activists means that Israel must disarm, or become weaker, or take risks with the Palestinians that they deem unworthy, then Israel will not do it.
You may ask, but what if the articles, the letter, the observances, lead to a weakened American support for Israel? That’s a good question to which I have four answers:
- Israel did not always have the support of the United States, and cannot presume to always have it in the future. That’s one reason why it has to be powerful, and not weak.
- I am old enough to know that political trends come and go, that social trends go in one direction and then reverse. If America is to remain a superpower, the nonsensical trends that sometimes make life difficult for those wanting to support Israel aren’t going to be the dominant culture of the land. And if American does not remain a superpower, then Israel can no longer rely on it anyways.
- I have faith in the American people. Most Americans still support Israel. Most of them still understand that surviving in the Middle East is slightly different than surviving in New Jersey.
- I have faith in the core of the American Jewish community. Those who have it in their guts. Those who care in easier and more difficult times.
Shmuel Rosner is an Israeli columnist, editor, and researcher. He is the editor of the research and data-journalism website themadad.com and is the political editor of the Jewish Journal.
Should Israel Apologize for Its “Place of Power”?
Shmuel Rosner
Here we go again. Israel is at war, and young American Jews are having an “identity crisis,” if one is to believe a recent report by the New York Times. Ten years ago, such stories seemed fresh. The old Israel-Diaspora relations is making room for new Israel-Diaspora relations. Today, it is an old story. Old and tired. A few prospective rabbis can no longer tolerate Israel’s actions. They wrote a letter. It convicts Israel, among other things, because “Israel’s choices come from a place of power.”
Maybe they aren’t quite familiar with the Zionist idea or with Israeli spirit. Yes — this country’s choices come from a place of power. That’s the whole idea. When Israel is attacked, it doesn’t write letters. It has means of defense. Means of power. If this makes the rabbis uncomfortable, I have no remedy for them. None other than writing letters.
The rabbis are an outlier for now. The Pew Center study from last week proved, and not for the first time, that the more observant Jews are, the more connected to Israel they are. Thus, I found the following paragraph in the NYT story amusing:
Alyssa Rubin, 26, who volunteers in Boston with IfNotNow, a network of Jewish activists who want to end Jewish American support for Israeli occupation, has found protesting for the Palestinian cause to be its own form of religious observance.
Religious observance. What is religious observance? Here is another opportunity for Jews to debate: For some, it is the synagogue, for others, lighting candles, for yet others, trying to convince the American government to reduce its support for Israel. Maybe that’s the source of the growing demand for young rabbis who can write letters.
To be somewhat more serious, the support of American Jews is important for Israel. It is important as long as it is support for policies that Israelis see as necessary. This doesn’t mean that all Israeli policies should be supported by every American Jew. It does mean that at some point the price of support could become too high for Israelis to still want it.
If gaining the support of some rabbis and activists means that Israel must disarm, or become weaker, or take risks with the Palestinians that they deem unworthy, then Israel will not do it. Neither religious observances, nor provocative letters, not even articles written by important figures, such as Senator Bernie Sanders, are going to change that.
You may ask, but what if the articles, the letter, the observances, lead to a weakened American support for Israel? That’s a good question to which I have four answers:
Shmuel Rosner is an Israeli columnist, editor, and researcher. He is the editor of the research and data-journalism website themadad.com and is the political editor of the Jewish Journal.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
John Ondrasik, Jonah Platt Highlight AJC, ADL Press Briefing at UCLA Hillel
Shabbat Prayer for Our College Students and Ourselves
1,400 Yizkors
Being Good is Easier to Resist than Sweezy vs New Hampshire
A Bisl Torah – Souls Connected
All the Fish in the Sea – A poem for Parsha Acharei Mot
Culture
Welcome Back, Carbs!
A Perfect Pair of Confits
‘The Enemy Beside Me’: Can the Truth of Lithuania Holocaust History Be Told in Lithuania to Lithuanians and By Lithuanians?
A History of a Pivotal Era in Palestine Wins a Top Jewish Book Prize
State Legislator Demands Federal Probe into UCLA’s Failure to Protect Pupils
Assembly member Rick Chavez Zbur said UCLA’s inaction “likely violate” Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
Chancellor Block Addresses Pro-Palestinian Encampment Removal: “It Needed to Come to an End”
Block said the encampment “became a focal point for serious violence.”
Police Clear Pro-Palestinian Encampment at UCLA
More than 200 protesters were arrested during the late night raid.
The Assault: A Coordinated Attack on America’s Jews and Israel
American Jews are awakening to a new political reality concerning our changing status and position in the United States.
We Need Tactical Training to Combat Campus Antisemitism
We need on-the-ground tactical training for Jewish student activists and leaders if the Jewish community is going to push back against this madness and protect college students.
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Chico Menashe: Asif: Culinary Institute of Israel, Cooking with Chutzpah and The Open Kitchen Project
Beth Lee: OMG Yummy, Exciting Flavors and Preserved Lemons
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.