fbpx

May 20, 2021

Popular Israeli Comedian Tom Aharon Blasts John Oliver’s Segment on the Conflict

(JTA) — In case you missed it, British-American comedian John Oliver unloaded on Israel in a widely viewed segment of his weekly HBO show “Last Week Tonight” on Sunday night.

Unsurprisingly it prompted heated social media responses from both sides, but it also inspired an extended answer from a popular Israeli comedian who modeled his own show after Oliver’s.

Tom Aharon hosted “Pa’am Be’shavu’a im Tom Aharon” (“Once a Week with Tom Aharon”) on Israeli TV from 2018 to 2020 and is now developing a new show. He is of Mizrahi descent and often critical of his native country, but he argues in a seven-minute video that Oliver’s critique went too far.

“I would hope to someday have just a fraction of a white man’s confidence when I’m talking about things that happen thousands of miles from where I live,” he says in the video posted Wednesday, which as of Thursday morning had garnered nearly 44,000 YouTube views in a day. “S***, I don’t even have that much certainty about things that happen in my own home.”

Aharon begins by pointing out just a few of the many celebrities who have come out strongly against Israel’s actions in the ongoing military conflict with Gaza. He also shows snippets from Oliver’s segment, including one in which Oliver raises his voice to call Israel “an a**hole.”

“Everyone has a right to criticize Israel, it’s ok — I mean, the Holocaust did just happen, but ok, if you have to, that’s how I make my living,” he says in response. “Some might even conclude that we’re the bad guys — someone’s gotta be it right? But I also believe that simplifying a complex matter doesn’t do justice to either side.”

Aharon then goes after the specifics of Oliver’s arguments, including one about the imbalance of military power between Israel and the Palestinians.

“Does being stronger bear certain responsibilities? Sure. But does it automatically mean you’re at fault? Of course not. It almost sounds like you’re mad at us for not taking more casualties,” he says.

“Claiming that imbalance is immoral is the privilege of those who don’t need to make the choice between their own safety and their care for others.”

Like Oliver, whose career took off as a correspondent on Jon Stewart’s “The Daily Show,” Aharon became a known comedian through appearances on Lior Schlein’s satirical Israeli news show “Gav HaUma” — the closest thing Israel has to a “Daily Show” equivalent. Aharon then modeled his own show after Oliver’s HBO series, which he humorously calls “the incredibly popular HBO show I never stole format from.”

“It pained me to see a personal hero of mine saying something” he found so “unfair, unjust” and “simplistic,” Aharon added.

Watch the full video here.

Popular Israeli Comedian Tom Aharon Blasts John Oliver’s Segment on the Conflict Read More »

May I Suggest? — A poem for Torah portion Nasso

Command the children of Israel to banish
from the camp all those afflicted…
-Numbers 5:2

No one understands a quarantine
better than everyone alive today

But it’s a sensitive subject to
send people away when there are

those who have stated they’d rather
all of us be in the sea.

May I suggest a hospital tent?
May I suggest we take all the walls

and not give them back?
May I suggest we remember

the dirt was here before our buildings?
May I suggest we let the doctors

take a look before we send anyone away?
May I suggest the property laws

may be binding, but before they were
written down, our first guy

opened up his tent? May I suggest
beating hearts and hunger

take precedence over technicalities?
May I suggest tearing down

is the weapon of the one who
feels they’re owed something?

May I suggest, everyone gets to go
on the forty-year walk, and when we

get to where we’re going, we do more
than care for the trees of the people

who are already there? If you take
even one of my suggestions, we’ll

really be going somewhere and I’ll
be ready to make my offering to the One.


God Wrestler: a poem for every Torah Portion by Rick LupertLos Angeles poet Rick Lupert created the Poetry Super Highway (an online publication and resource for poets), and hosted the Cobalt Cafe weekly poetry reading for almost 21 years. He’s authored 25 collections of poetry, including “God Wrestler: A Poem for Every Torah Portion“, “I’m a Jew, Are You” (Jewish themed poems) and “Feeding Holy Cats” (Poetry written while a staff member on the first Birthright Israel trip), and most recently “The Tokyo-Van Nuys Express” (Poems written in Japan – Ain’t Got No Press, August 2020) and edited the anthologies “Ekphrastia Gone Wild”, “A Poet’s Haggadah”, and “The Night Goes on All Night.” He writes the daily web comic “Cat and Banana” with fellow Los Angeles poet Brendan Constantine. He’s widely published and reads his poetry wherever they let him.

May I Suggest? — A poem for Torah portion Nasso Read More »

L.A. Middle School Quiz Asks Where “Palestinians Are Facing Evictions”

A question on a Los Angeles middle school quiz generated controversy for asking where “Palestinians are facing evictions” at the hands of the Israelis.

The full question read: “In _____, some Palestinians are facing evictions from their homes by Israelis,” referencing the potential eviction Palestinian families in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood of East Jerusalem over a property dispute. The multiple-choice options were Haifa, Tel Aviv, Nazareth and East Jerusalem.

A spokesperson for the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) told the Journal that the question was asked during a class for sixth-grade students at Portola Middle School. “The quiz was produced by a third-party program that provides digital lessons for teachers for use in the classroom. It included a question about events in the Middle East and was phrased in a way that may have been deemed culturally insensitive. We immediately contacted the provider of the program, and the question and related content have been removed. We also provided counselors for students and staff who may need additional support.”

The spokesperson added, “We understand that this is a sensitive topic. This incident was unintentional and does not reflect the commitment of Los Angeles Unified or Portola Middle School to respect and inclusivity.”

Jewish groups criticized the quiz question. “Presenting one narrow part of a much larger conflict out of context is educational malpractice and political indoctrination. It is especially shameful given how little information most middle school students would know about this issue,” StandWithUs CEO and co-founder Roz Rothstein said in a statement to the Journal. “While we thank LAUSD for indicating they will no longer use the app that generated this misinformation, we remain concerned about who is selecting LAUSD’s quiz material and whether it is part of a malicious attempt to indoctrinate middle schoolers with an anti-Israel narrative.”

StandWithUs filed a California Public Record Act request on May 20 requesting that LAUSD hand over the quiz in its entirety and all communications related to the matter. A district spokesperson told the Journal they have nothing further to add at this time.

Associate Dean and Director of Global Social Action Agenda at the Simon Wiesenthal Center Rabbi Abraham Cooper also said in a statement to the Journal that he has two suggestions for the district. “Stick to 2+2, Algebra, and other math skills that will help youngsters get a job in the future, but if school districts want to introduce ‘human rights’ into math classes, here are a few suggestions: How about ‘How many Uighurs are in Chinese Communist concentration camps’…‘how many hundreds of miles ( or kilometers) did Venezuelan refugees have to walk to reach the border of Chile?’….  ‘How many innocent Iranians have been executed by the regime of Ayatollah Khamenei’…. ‘How many rockets has Hamas launched against Israeli communities?’ (Hint — over 4k) ‘How many Israeli Arabs sit on the Jewish state’s Supreme Court?’”

American Jewish Committee (AJC) Los Angeles Regional Director Richard S. Hischhaut said in a statement to the Journal that the question “is symptomatic of a fundamental lack of context and factual perspective surrounding recent [Middle East] tensions. The question itself is simplistic but also gratuitous in naming other cities among the potential correct answers. Is this intended to be a geography lesson? It most certainly is not a history lesson in misrepresenting what is actually under consideration by Israel’s justice system.”

He added that the AJC is happy “that LAUSD officials quickly recognized the inappropriateness of this material. In furtherance of this ‘teachable moment,’ AJC will be pleased to offer additional resources to Portola Middle School and others to better inform teachers and students alike to the realities of this evolving situation.”

Anti-Defamation League (ADL) Senior Associate Regional Director Matthew Friedman said in a statement to the Journal, “We are aware of this issue as several community members have brought it to our attention. ADL has reached out to the school directly and offered our resources so that in the future they do not utilize materials with biased or culturally-insensitive content.”

The Sheikh Jarrah situation stems from a property dispute. Some argue that it’s simply a matter of enforcing property rights against squatters and tenants refusing to pay rent; others contend that the evictions are part of an effort to “Judaize” the area.

L.A. Middle School Quiz Asks Where “Palestinians Are Facing Evictions” Read More »

A Moment in Time: The Middle East — The Crossfire of a Difficult Situation

Dear friends,

Emotions are so highly charged right now.  There is a groundswell of support for Palestinians who are caught in the crossfire of such a difficult situation – a situation that really and truly must change.

Let me be very clear. I support a two-state solution.  I believe that Palestinians should have the opportunity for self-determination. I believe it is the only way forward.

I know that for every innocent Palestinian that just wants to live in peace, there are Hamas leaders who use them as human shields as they fire rockets into Israel.

I also know that Israel has fought for its survival since its birth, and that every offer for a peace deal has been rejected.

We are living with deep scars and emotional wounds. With the horrible violence, there are good people, Arabs and Jews, who want to live in peace. We need a ceasefire, and we need to embrace shared values.

This is a true tragedy.

We have seen the vitriol unfold here at home.  There have been anti-Jewish hate crimes in our streets and attempts at intimidation against Jewish youth in our schools.

In response to my recent post on Facebook that shared that our people are hiding in bunkers in Israel, a person wrote, “you are a disgrace to your religion and exactly the reason this violence and immorality has gone on so long.”

Sigh….

I have a thick skin.  I will continue to stand up for Israel.

Yes, I will question Israel.
Yes, I will have expectations of Israel.
Yes, I will express frustrations when Israel fails to live up to its ideals as expressed in the Israeli Declaration of Independence.

But I will continue to stand up for Israel.  Why?  Because I know in my soul that Israel strives to embody the words of the prophet Amos: That justice should roll out like a river, and righteousness like a mighty stream. (Amos 5:24).

We can’t have full justice for all inhabitants with rockets hurling toward us all the time. But I firmly believe that on the day those rockets from Hamas and her allies stop, righteousness will flow for all.

This is our moment in time to study the history, to understand the narrative, and to pursue the justice that been a source of light for 5000 years.

With love and shalom,

Rabbi Zach Shapiro

A Moment in Time: The Middle East — The Crossfire of a Difficult Situation Read More »

Unscrolled, Nasso: A Story Worth Retelling

This week, as I read through Parashat Nasso, I came to a particular sentence and paused.

“On the day that Moses finished setting up the Tabernacle, he anointed and consecrated it and all its furnishings” (Numbers 7:1).

I furrowed my brow. I had a vague memory that the Tabernacle had already been completed. I flipped back to the book of Leviticus to be certain. There it was in chapters 8 and 9.

In my family, retelling a story is grounds for opprobrium. Indeed, we observe a cruel tradition of shouting “repeat!” at one another when someone is telling a story that we’ve already told.

Curious, I texted a friend and asked her why she thought the Tabernacle’s completion is described twice in two different places.

“Actually, it’s three times,” she said. Apparently, I had forgotten about Exodus chapter 40.

My family has a special word for this. It’s called a “three-peat,” and there’s nothing more shameful.

The three tellings of the Tabernacle’s completion, however, bear little resemblance to one another.  

The three tellings of the Tabernacle’s completion bear little resemblance to one another.

In Exodus, we are told a story of assembly. The tabernacle’s various components have been constructed. One by one, Moses sets them in place. When he is done putting it all together, the cloud of the presence of God settles upon it and fills it.

In Leviticus, we are told a story of sacrifice. Moses ordains Aaron and his sons by means of a number of bloody rituals, complete with descriptions of animal entrails and organs being turned into smoke on the altar. When this is complete, the fire of God descends from the sky and consumes the sacrificial offerings.

Here, in Numbers, we are told a story of donation. The princes of the tribes of Israel bring forth, each one on a different day, identical offerings of silver, gold, flour, oil, incense, and livestock. At the end of this procession, God speaks from between the golden cherubim that rest atop the ark of the covenant.

In each of these tellings, we are given a different understanding of what completion looks like. In Exodus, completion means being built. In Leviticus, completion means being sanctified. In Numbers, completion means being acknowledged. The physical, the spiritual and the interpersonal.

We also have three different manifestations of God. In Exodus, a cloud. In Leviticus, a fire. In Numbers, a voice. God as presence. God as force. God as a relational being.

Three distinct tellings. Three distinct completions. Three distinct theologies. Considering this, perhaps it’s unfair to call this a repetition.

Some stories become deeper as we repeat them. It’s why we read the Torah year after year after year. It’s why I keep watching Frasier reruns. And it’s why there are some family stories at which we don’t dare shout “repeat!”

Like when my mother recounts how, on what was supposed to be her first date, she hid behind a dumpster out of painful shyness. Or when my father retells how he had a life-changing conversation with a stranger at a rest stop during a cross-country motorcycle trip. Or when my brother recalls how oddly perfect the water in the lake Sunapee was when we jumped in some two decades ago.

These are the stories of our lives. If we are good storytellers, they are never the same from one telling to the next. Different language will be employed. One detail will be emphasized and another forgotten. If they are good stories — the kind worth repeating — we will always find something new in them.


Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.

Unscrolled, Nasso: A Story Worth Retelling Read More »

L.A. City, Faith Leaders Denounce Anti-Semitic Restaurant Attack

 

Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti denounced an antisemitic attack that occurred outside a sushi restaurant in West Hollywood on Tuesday night.

“This is a moment for our Jewish community to stand united — and, unfortunately, for all of us to stand united — to be able to speak against antisemitism,” he said during a May 19 Zoom call, which his office organized with Los Angeles City Councilman Paul Koretz.

The call on Wednesday evening drew elected officials, LAPD officers and faith and community leaders, including Salam Al-Marayati, president of the Muslim Public Affairs Council (MPAC), who strongly condemned the incident, a video of which was widely shared on social media on Wednesday.

“What I saw was nothing less than thuggery,” Al-Marayati said, describing the video, which depicts pro-Palestinians driving in a caravan, waving flags and attacking diners, including several Jewish people, outside Sushi Fumi on La Cienega Boulevard on May 18. The MPAC leader called upon the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) to conduct an investigation of the incident and other recent antisemitic crimes.

The LAPD is investigating the incident as a hate crime. As of publication time, no arrests had been made in connection with the attack.

Koretz — who visited the restaurant to speak with LAPD the night of the attack, which had occurred in his district — said the attack reminded him of what his father experienced on Kristallnacht before the Holocaust. “Certainly not something I ever expected to start to see in the City of Los Angeles,” he said.

The city councilman said he welcomed a diversity of opinions about the ongoing violence in the Middle East — seen as a catalyst of the attack — but added acts of hate were unacceptable.

Additional participants on the private call included LAPD Deputy Chief Vito Palazzolo, LAPD Assistant Chief Beatrice Girmala, Jewish Federation of Greater Los Angeles CEO Jay Sanderson and Anti-Defamation League Regional Director Jeffrey Abrams.

Sanderson described the events outside the restaurant as “blatant anti-Semitism.”

Abrams said the ADL is offering a $5,000 reward, in consultation with the LAPD, for information leading to the arrest of those involved in the incident. He also called on city leaders to use their bully pulpit to strongly condemn the recent and “unambiguous acts of violence.”

Another speaker on the call, American Jewish Committee Regional Director Richard Hirschhaut, said the unity various communities have demonstrated in denouncing the violence was an encouraging sign, particularly as the public emerges from the pandemic.

the unity various communities have demonstrated in denouncing the violence was an encouraging sign, particularly as the public emerges from the pandemic.

The restaurant attack on Tuesday night took place amid ongoing violence between Israelis and Hamas in the Gaza Strip as well as on the heels of numerous anti-Israel demonstrations occurring around Los Angeles. According to LAPD, it was one of at least two incidents targeting Jews in Los Angeles following the dramatic uptick in violence between Israel and Hamas.

Along with the restaurant attack, police are investigating a May 17 incident involving an Orthodox man being chased by two cars on La Brea Avenue in the Fairfax District. The passengers in the vehicles can be seen in a video, captured on closed-circuit television, waving Palestinian flags. Law enforcement does not believe the two incidents are related, the Los Angeles Times reported.

Additionally, LAPD officials described a window being smashed at Orange Delite and Grill, a kosher restaurant in Sherman Oaks, at the conclusion of Shavuot. But LAPD said they have no evidence to indicate the window smashing was a hate crime.

While speakers in the Zoom conversation were short on specifics about the police investigation, Garcetti appeared to suggest they were making progress in identifying and apprehending those involved.

“The vaguer we are,” the L.A. mayor said, “the more confident we are.”

L.A. City, Faith Leaders Denounce Anti-Semitic Restaurant Attack Read More »

BREAKING: Israel and Hamas Agree to Ceasefire After 11 Days of Bloodshed

(JTA) — After 11 days of fighting, Israel and Hamas agreed to a “mutual and simultaneous” ceasefire on Thursday that will begin at 2 a.m. Friday Israel time.

Israel’s security cabinet unanimously approved the truce, according to reports, after military officials presented what they deemed the successful outcomes of their campaign.

“Hamas is deterred and suffered serious blows,” one official said, according to The Times of Israel.

A Hamas official confirmed the news to Reuters on Thursday.

The ceasefire was mediated by Egypt and supported by the United States and other countries. On Thursday, Vice President Kamala Harris tweeted that she spoke with Jordan’s King Abdullah about “our intensive diplomatic efforts to support the path to a ceasefire in Gaza.”

President Joe Biden had added to the international pressure on Wednesday, stating on a call with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that he expected “de-escalation” within a day.

About 230 Gazans and 12 Israelis have died in the exchange of fire that began on May 9 with Hamas launching rockets into Israel.

BREAKING: Israel and Hamas Agree to Ceasefire After 11 Days of Bloodshed Read More »

A Bisl Torah: Cowering Under the Covers

In Los Angeles, as a group of people enjoyed a meal outside, a Pro-Palestinian mob targeted and attacked the diners because they are Jewish. A separate incident: An Orthodox man was chased by a vehicle donned by two Palestinian flags. These are not isolated events. In the last ten days, anti-Semitic events have increased by almost 500%. The frightening underbelly of anti-Zionistic statements is a movement that speaks towards the destruction and elimination of the Jewish people. The wiping of Israel off this earth.

The building of peaceful coalitions that bring forward conversations about a two-state solution for both Israelis and Palestinians must be an ongoing process. Make no mistake: we are not witnessing peaceful discussion as Jews are targeted and violently harmed.

Hear this rabbi, loud and clear: I won’t quiver as I proudly and publicly wear my kippah and send my children to school with Stars of David around their necks. We will unabashedly walk through the streets of Los Angeles and take pride as staunch supporters of the Jewish people and the State of Israel. Without qualifiers. With full realization that once again, the Jewish people and Israel’s very existence are being questioned and threatened.

Where is your voice? If you are a Jew, stop closing your eyes to the reality set before us. If you are a non-Jew, stand with your Jewish friends as the Jewish people reexperience this trauma of hate and oppression.

The Talmud teaches, “When the community is immersed in suffering, a person should not say, ‘I’ll go home and eat and drink….” When even one Jew is attacked for their faith, when even one Jew is singled out and harmed as a child of Israel, when even one Jew feels as if they cannot wear a kippah in the United States of America, no person has the luxury of going home, cowering under the covers. Stop hiding.

Stand with the Jewish people. Stand with Israel. Call out hate. Because if you won’t, who will?


Rabbi Nicole Guzik is a rabbi at Sinai Temple. She can be reached at her Facebook page at Rabbi Nicole Guzik. For more writings, visit Rabbi Guzik’s blog section from Sinai Temple’s website.

A Bisl Torah: Cowering Under the Covers Read More »

Who Will Speak For Us?

This is something I’ve pondered writing about for years, and have come close at times, but have avoided until today.

I’m not a fan of speaking or yelling into an echo chamber, so I generally avoid discussing politics on social media. I find that it’s incredibly rare for someone to change their mind, and the emotional energy I expend ultimately results in my feeling depleted and defeated – I’ve achieved no detectable gain – so I just avoid it and focus on the happy, such as family, funny, and sure, informed health updates.

I scroll through my feed and find people posting things I disagree with, and it makes me tense and anxious. Then I’ll keep scrolling and see things I agree with, and it will give me a brief second of calm…followed quickly by the angry argument within the comments, which 99% of the time results in no resolution, even between friends…and I feel tense and anxious again.

On a similar note, I’m never actually satisfied with the parties or politicians running, because I’m a man without a party that I can really be proud to stand behind. I’m a Modern Orthodox Jew living in the USA, with close family and friends in Israel, a flawed democratic country that I truly love; a nurse,  extremely trusting of the scientific community; and a child of British parents who have instilled in me a sense of extremely socially liberal politics. And I’m far too uninformed to have opinions on economics or ideal tax plans. So where does this leave me? Let’s examine for a moment…

I proudly wrote about the causes of the Women’s March movement, Natalia even had a personally knitted P-hat by her Godmother, but they had Anti-Israel leadership in Linda Sarsour and others. I proudly posted my support for the black community, but the BLM movement has consistently come out against Israel, saying not a word about globally recognized terrorist organization Hamas which Israel is actually fighting. I have frequently stood behind causes that actively choose not to stand behind me. This does not make their causes any less important, in fact I still care about each and every one of them, but being a part of such a thing becomes a somewhat masochistic act.

Every few years, Israel is at a state of conflict or war. This is far too complex to get into in a post, and yet simplistic enough to predict when your perpetual peace partner (Hamas) has created a mission statement to wipe you off the earth and drive you to the sea. It’s almost surprising that they are not in a state of war and conflict at all times, but I suppose your enemy does need time to regroup and reinforce before trying to destroy you once again.

I spend my days hearing from dear friends and relatives in Israel who run the gamut from militant to peaceniks, and all of them are hearing the air raid sirens, and running to bomb shelters with their children on a daily basis, their safety successfully terrorized. And then I watch people with no actual understanding of the region beyond memes, retweeting how evil Israel is, with nary a whisper of how evil Hamas is. I see synagogues and kosher restaurants vandalized here in the US, and people attacked year after year for being Jewish, being the victims of blatant Anti-Semitism, but I hear almost nothing from the same communities who stand up for the downtrodden.

I’m Jewish, which means I’m part of the 2-3% of the US population, but did you know that per the FBI, we Jews receive over 60% of the religious-based hate crimes in the country? Wow, I feel so popular!

This week here in my own Jewish community, an attack from cars brandishing Palestinian flags “looking for Jews” here in West LA turned into a violent hate crime. A kosher restaurant in the valley was also vandalized. Police and people in my community have been put on high alert in the likely event of more attacks. And I remind you, this happens every few years, especially when there is a new “wave” of conflict in Israel.

A few years ago my brother’s synagogue in Irvine was vandalized with “Fuck Jews” written in big letters, and these events are simply not uncommon. There are hundreds and hundreds each year, that range from violent physical attacks, to destroying graves. But who will stand up for us Jews?

If you’ve taken the time to read, write or even just share a meme in the past few years caring about others, whether it’s women being treated with inequality, or black people feeling terrified when pulled over for a broken tail light, or an LGBTQ individual for their personal safety, or an Asian person for being attacked for starting the pandemic, then those are all noble, important and crucial things to stand up for. All of those groups (and more) have frequently been given the shit-covered end of the stick in life, and deserve to have their voices elevated, and their safety and equality addressed. But you know what? It would be wonderful to be included in that mix. To see these same celebrities and influencers who know next to nothing about complicated geopolitics, but who take a stand anyway, actually take a stand for us too. You may claim that being Anti-Israel/Anti-Zionist is not the same as being Anti-Semitic, and while in a vacuum that may be true, in actuality try telling that to the many of us who have synagogues/businesses/homes which have been vandalized with Israel/Zionist/Jew as interchangeable vernacular over the years. Try going back in time and telling a 20 year old Boaz walking down UCLA’s Bruin Walk, that every time I walked by wearing my kippah and had people yell “Zionists are murderers” at me, that they were not targeting their hatred toward me because I was wearing that kippah, and it was simply a random occurrence.

I am used to a world where people only care about themselves. It sucks, but it’s one I’ve grown highly familiar with. I’m thrilled by this new world where people actually care (or virtue signal care) about others. But what I cannot tolerate, and what makes me feel lonelier than ever, is a world where the same people who show that care toward others, completely ignore me. They remind me of just how alone we actually are.


Boaz Hepner grew up in LA in Pico/Robertson and now lives here with his wife and daughter. Thus, the neighborhood is very important to him. He helped clean up the area by adding the dozens of trash cans that can still be seen from Roxbury to La Cienega. When he is not working as a Registered Nurse in Santa Monica, he can be found with his family enjoying his passions: his multitude of friends, movies, poker and traveling.

Who Will Speak For Us? Read More »

Throwing Israel Under The Bus Will Not Save American Jews

“Mom, if this is our last conversation, I don’t want it to end this way,” said my 18-year-old daughter before walking out of the house to spend Shavuot with her friends.

“I am scared of rockets,” my five-year-old cried as she kept popping out of bed after “just” one rocket siren we had in the relative safety of Jerusalem.

“We are late,” my husband and son texted me yesterday, “the car right in front of us got firebombed and burnt down completely. The road is blocked, but we are OK.”

“We were so lucky to have left late! There were burning tires and boulders on the road that were thrown at cars just minutes before we passed. And our friends got hit,” my daughter told me. “But now I don’t know how to get to my ultrasound appointment in Nahariya. I am scared.”

We are just one Israeli family, and our experiences of the previous 10 days have been relatively mild compared to those of friends and relatives in southern and central Israel, like my 75-year-old in-laws, who have all of 45 seconds to run down two flights of stairs to the bomb shelter (an elderly woman in a neighboring community found her death slipping in the rush). Like my nieces and nephews dealing with PTSD with as many as 100 rocket alarms a day. Like our friends in Lod, holed up in their apartments, watching helplessly as their Arab neighbors, the people with whom they have lived with in peace for decades, burn their cars, shoot and throw stones at their windows, break into their homes, destroy synagogues and schools and beat up Jews who venture out onto the street.

30 years of living in Israel have helped me work up the resilience to live through scenarios like these. But nothing has prepared me for the shock and dismay of feeling betrayed by many of my American brothers and sisters, the people with whom I grew up before moving to Israel.

Nothing prepared me for comments unequivocally accusing Israel of genocide and apartheid in numerous Jewish Facebook groups or the letter signed by almost 100 liberal rabbinical students telling Israel it deserves the violence while completely failing to mention Israeli suffering, or the demand by Jewish employees at Google that the company publicly call out Israel for “militarized colonial violence” and terminate contracts with Israeli bodies, including IDF.

At first I felt angry and violated. If American Jews were in harm’s way, God forbid, Israelis would show in a heartbeat to help them out. Israelis wouldn’t ask questions of how this happened or take the time to analyze American Jewry’s involvement in various social issues. Israel and her people support every Diaspora Jewish community always, no questions asked. Because this is what brothers do.

But apparently this is not how it works in the American Jewish community. Understandably, American Jewry has a plurality of outlooks on the Middle East conflict. And, also understandably, many American Jews desire to be fair and impartial. This however does not justify embracing the Palestinian narrative hook, line and sinker or willfully ignoring facts, which point to Hamas as the culprit of both Jewish and Palestinian suffering.

It takes a special kind of blindness to dismiss the fact that Hamas is a terrorist organization calling for the genocide of all Jews, not just Israelis. It takes closing one’s eyes not to notice that Hamas is performing a double war crime by firing over 3,500 rockets from within its own civilian population onto Israel’s civilian population. It is prejudiced to dismiss Israel’s right to defend her citizens and not acknowledge her efforts to take outmost care to preserve Palestinian lives, forewarning civilians of upcoming strikes. And where is the genocide exactly when thousands of Israeli strikes on military installations have resulted in a very unfortunate death toll of 50 Palestinian civilians, while 500 Hamas rockets falling short have killed as many as 20 of their own people inside the Gaza strip?

It takes a special kind of blindness to dismiss the fact that Hamas is a terrorist organization calling for the genocide of all Jews, not just Israelis. It takes closing one’s eyes not to notice that Hamas is performing a double war crime by firing over 3,500 rockets from within its own civilian population onto Israel’s civilian population.

Or maybe it’s a defense mechanism. With race relations and oppression narratives becoming the focal point of American social discourse, many American Jews are anxious to be on the “right” side of political trends. They think that by distancing themselves from their Israeli brothers and vocally embracing the Palestinian racial narrative, they will affirm their allegiance to social justice. With Jewishness now classified as “hyper whiteness,” denouncing fellow Jews has become the ticket into the antiracist club.

This is a mirage. Antisemites on the right and the left do not distinguish between Jews. Denouncing Israel for genocide and apartheid will only strengthen the anti-Jewish sentiment in America. The attackers at the Los Angeles sushi restaurant the other day chanted “Free Palestine” and “Death to Jews” all at once. They didn’t ask the patrons about their political opinions. They punched Jews indiscriminately.

My shock and anger have given way to sadness and fear. The sadness for so many of my brothers and sisters, who are cutting themselves off from our mutual relationship, and fear for the hate they are bringing onto themselves in the process.

“A house divided against itself cannot stand,” said Abraham Lincoln. I hope more American Jews remember this before they throw their Israeli brethren under the bus.


Leah Aharoni is the founder of Machon Arev Leadership Institute in Jerusalem.

Throwing Israel Under The Bus Will Not Save American Jews Read More »