fbpx

N.Y. Town Votes to Keep ‘Swastika’ Name

The town argued that the history of the town's namesake isn't rooted in hate.
[additional-authors]
September 24, 2020
Photo from Wikimedia Commons.

An unincorporated community in upstate New York will keep its name as “Swastika” after a unanimous vote by officials on Sept. 14.

The proposal to change the name stemmed from a visitor from New York City, Michael Alcamo, saw the town sign while he was riding his bicycle in the area this past summer.

“I think it should be obvious that the town should update its name and should pick a name that is not so offensive to so many Americans and so emblematic of intolerance, hate and tyranny,” Alcamo told National Public Radio (NPR).

The four members of the town of Black Brook’s board, which has jurisdiction over the hamlet, rejected a proposal to change the name. The town’s supervisor, Jon Douglass, told CNN: “We regret that individuals, for out of the area, that lack the knowledge of the history of our community, become offended when they see the name. To the members of our community, that the board represents, it is the name that their ancestors chose.”

The town was named Swastika in 1913 after the name appeared on the hamlet’s post office at the time, according to the Associated Press (AP). Douglass told the AP that there have been numerous efforts to change the hamlet’s name and they have all failed; he pointed out that the hamlet’s World War II veterans have in the past opposed changing the name.

“There’s a long history there,” he told NPR. “For the uneducated that immediately assume it’s connected to Germans and Hitler, it’s not. Swastika means ‘to prosper.’ ”

According to CNN, the word “swastika” comes from the Sanskrit word svastika, which is defined as good fortune. The Nazis appropriated the symbol in 1920; before that, the symbol commonly had been used among Hindus and Buddhists.

In 2019, a town in Colorado just outside of Denver was renamed from Swastika Acres to Old Cherry Hills. The town had been named after the Denver Land Swastika Co. in 1908.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Bringing Israeli Doctors Back

ScienceAbroad works with two groups in medicine: physicians who leave Israel for fellowships and Israeli students who attend medical school in Europe.

The Antizionist’s Dilemma

It’s not easy being an antizionist these days. Especially if you’re determined to live in accordance with your most important moral imperative: the denigration of the world’s only Jewish state.

How the Supreme Court Adapted Parshat Shoftim

The Torah offers a better model than avenging and avoiding. It offers a safe opportunity for parties to meet and peacefully explain their perspectives, which might have been misunderstood. They can offer apologies and, where necessary, make amends for harms caused.

Can One Be a Non-Observant Orthodox Jew?

The tradition has always been bigger than any one person’s grip on it. What draws me is simple: I think these texts are a good part of why we are still here as a people. I want to know them and, in my own way, embrace them. Orthodox is where I turn.

Lies, Damned Lies and the Right Side of History

One question alone matters these days: Does this fact strengthen my tribe, or is it bad for it? If bad, it must be suppressed, denied, explained away. The higher truth is the narrative that serves the cause, the quest of the righteous and true.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.