fbpx

Malaysian PM At Columbia: ‘Why Is It That I Can’t Say Something Against the Jews’?

[additional-authors]
September 25, 2019
Malaysia’s Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and Foreign Minister Saifuddin Abdullah hold publication of the Foreign Policy Framework in Putrajaya, Malaysia, September 18, 2019. REUTERS/Lim Huey Teng

Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad defended his prior remarks on the Holocaust and Jews while speaking at a Sept. 25 event at Columbia University, arguing that it was an example of free speech.

During the question-and-answer session, a Students Supporting Israel (SSI) Columbia board member pointed out that Mohamad has questioned if six million Jews died during the Holocaust, and gloated about being called an anti-Semite. She then asked him to clarify his stance on the Holocaust.

“I am exercising my right to free speech,” Mohamad said. “Why is it that I can’t say something against the Jews when a lot of people say nasty things about me and about Malaysia and I didn’t protest?”

Mohamad added that he accepts that the Holocaust occurred, but claimed that there are varying statistics on the number of Jews that died. He also said he was once “sympathetic” toward the Jews during World War II and mentioned that he was alive during that period while the SSI member wasn’t.

“My grandmother was in the Holocaust,” the SSI member interjected. “So she was around.” Mahathir then replied, “Thank you. I think I’ve said enough.”


Mohamad posted his free speech defense to Twitter, prompting Claire Voltaire to respond, “You’re an anti-Semite and allowed to be one. In the same way we’re allowed to point and show disgust.”

Before Mohamad started speaking, Columbia University Senior Adviser to Foreign Affairs Vishaka Desai introduced him as “a figure of significance.” However, she pointed out Mohamad has a history of “anti-Semitic statements” and that Malaysia banned Israeli athletes from participating at the 2019 Para Swimming World Championships.

“Such attitudes are absolutely contrary to what we stand for,” Desai said. She then highlighted University President Lee Bollinger’s statement that while “the anti-Semitic statements of Prime Minister Mahathir to be abhorrently contrary to what we stand for,” it’s important “to understand and confront the world as it is, which is a central and utterly serious mission for any academic institution.”

SSI Columbia thanked Desai in a Facebook post for calling out Mohamad.

“We are very grateful that she stressed that although hosting him, Columbia does not support such anti-Semitic statements,” they wrote.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Rosner’s Domain | No Suspension of Suspicion

These countries plotted – or at least one of them plotted – to advance peace agreements with Israel simply to lull it to sleep ahead of a war at a more convenient time. Or so the “sources” say.

The Power of a Quilt

I think of how something as simple as a blanket can carry a person’s spirit, their story, their love, their hope.

The Iranian Intellectual Who Admired Israel

The scholar’s earlier affinity for the Jewish state is worth revisiting and appreciating, reminding us in this moment of uncertainty that more positive possibilities could very well emerge between two nations, a friendship as existed decades ago, renewed.

What Do We Give Our Children?

Parenthood has a way of exposing the limits of instruction. Children do not necessarily inherit what we tell them to value. They inherit what they see us value.

Between Governance and Political Rot

Political appointments systematically damage the very core of the public service. They sever the connection between office and competence, replacing professional qualifications with party loyalty.

Senators, Shandas and Stoopers

How wonderful it would be if instead of shandas and stoopers, we had courageous leaders who refused to be part of any “big tent” that included antisemites, racists, and those who would slander and undermine the state of Israel.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.