fbpx

French Judge Resigns in Protest of Sarah Halimi Verdict

Jack Broda, who presides over the Tribunal Commerce of Nancy in Eastern France, announced he was resigning in protest of the verdict, saying that “at first I couldn’t believe” the court’s verdict.
[additional-authors]
April 29, 2021
The protest in Los Angeles. Photo by Harvey Farr

A French judge resigned from his position on April 23 in protest of the verdict involving Sarah Halimi’s suspected killer.

Halimi was killed in April 2017 after being beaten and thrown out of her window. Her suspected killer, Kobili Traore, allegedly shouted, “Allahu Akbar!” while attacking her and “I have killed the sheitan! [demon]” after throwing her out the window. On April 14, the French Supreme Court upheld a lower court’s verdict that Traore was unfit to stand trial because he was high on marijuana at the time of Halimi’s killing.

Jack Broda, who presides over the Tribunal Commerce of Nancy in Eastern France, announced he was resigning in protest of the verdict, saying that “at first I couldn’t believe” the court’s verdict. “My resignation was accepted and regretted.”

Jewish groups praised Broda’s act of protest. Anti-Defamation League CEO Jonathan Greenblatt tweeted that Broda’s resignation was “an inspiring show of solidarity.” “We must continue this fight and demand #JusticeForSarahHalimi.”

 

The Simon Wiesenthal Center similarly tweeted, “G-d bless this French judge who has the courage to walk away from a corrupted justice system that disrespects and puts French Jews in mortal danger #JusticeForSarahHalimi.”

End Jew Hatred also tweeted, “Will any others follow? Will anyone else demand justice?”

 

The verdict on Halimi’s suspected killer sparked worldwide protests, including at the Los Angeles French Consulate on April 25. Among those who spoke at the protest included Associate Dean and Director of Global Social Action Agenda at the Simon Wiesenthal Center Rabbi Abraham Cooper, StandWithUs CEO and Co-Founder Roz Rothstein and Journal Editor-In-Chief David Suissa.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Are We Dying of a Broken Heart?

Whatever the future holds, we must remember, especially during Hanukkah, that miracles are part and parcel of our history—and will continue to be. We cannot let our sadness overwhelm us.

Of Doughnuts and Dreidels

This week Rachel and I are thrilled to share our column with our friend Rinat to tell us about a unique Hanukkah tradition involving women. 

Not Your Bubbe’s Latkes

Whether you switch up your latke ingredients, toppings or both, you can have lots of oily goodness without getting bored.

A 1944 Hanukkah Message to America

Eighty-one years ago, while America was at war and millions of Jews were being slaughtered, the rabbi of the Washington Hebrew Congregation delivered a Hanukkah message that resonates to this day.

Rosner’s Domain | The Psychology of Accepting Reality

Israelis expected the war would end when Hamas is eradicated. They now have to face a different reality. After two years of blood, sweat and many tears, the enemy is still out there, lurking in the dark, waiting to fight another day.

A Prophet among the Rhinos

In this selection of essays, op-eds and speeches, the first piece written six months after his son’s murder, Pearl gives us words that are, yes, sometimes heartbreaking, but also funny, profound, scrappy, informative and strikingly prescient.

As We Wrestle

My hope is that we, too, embrace the kind of wrestling that leads to blessing.

Time of Hope

It is truly in darkness, the night which starts the Jewish day, that we come to face our fears and uncertainties, to find the glow of light that reignites faith, hope and possibility.

Choosing Good Over Evil

The conclusion of 2025 is an excellent occasion to step back and reflect on our failings.

Jews Aiming for White House

Rahm Emanuel is one of four Jewish political leaders seriously considering a run for the Democratic presidential nomination, at a time when antizionism is growing and antisemitism is coagulating.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.