fbpx

May 7, 2014

Syrian brown bear undergoes back surgery in Israel

Mango the brown bear was clearly in pain, as his keepers at Israel’s Ramat Gan Zoological Park observed some three weeks ago. He was eating well, but his walk had slowed and he clearly didn’t like getting up. Sure, there was clearly a problem, but just try asking a bear where it hurts.

After a few days with no improvement, the zoo called in the A-team: a team of experts from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, headed by Merav Shamir, an expert on veterinary neurology and neurosurgery.

For the purposes of examination, as is normal procedure with large scary animals, the unhappy Syrian brown bear – whose fur is actually more of a honey-blond color – was knocked out by the zoo’s in-house veterinarian, Igal Horowitz. A long series of X-rays and tests found the problem: Mango had a slipped disc between his second and third vertebrae.

Read more on Haaretz.com.

Syrian brown bear undergoes back surgery in Israel Read More »

Anti-Semitic vandal arrested on hate-crime charges

A 49-year-old man who previously claimed to be Jewish has been charged with multiple hate crimes for allegedly vandalizing a San Fernando Valley business with anti-Semitic graffiti.

According to a May 5 press release from the Los Angeles City Attorney’s Office, Amos Hason is charged with three counts of suspicion of vandalism and three counts of suspicion of committing a hate crime against a Jewish business owner. He was arrested over the weekend and could face up to three years behind bars if he’s successfully convicted.

City Attorney Mike Feuer said in a statement: “This case is a stark reminder that there is still hate in our society, and we must strike back against it every time it emerges.”

Prosecutors indicated that surveillance videos show Hason driving to the location and painting swastikas and other anti-Semitic slurs on the fence and trash bin behind a San Fernando Valley business on two separate instances last month, with the sole intention of targeting the business’s Jewish owner. According to the city attorney’s office, among the anti-Semitic graffiti was the message, “Adolf was right. Kill Jews!”

“He has criminal history and was arrested with a weapon,” Feuer said. “He allegedly has been involved in a hate crime; that’s a very dangerous combination.”

The city attorney’s office stated that Hanson was previously prosecuted twice by the Los Angeles City Attorney’s Office. He was convicted last year of possession of a zip gun, and in 2008 was found guilty of “possessing a deadly weapon with the intent to assault another.”

According to a report in the Los Angeles Times, Hason identified himself as Jewish in a previous federal lawsuit in which he claimed that his civil rights had been violated.

Anti-Semitic vandal arrested on hate-crime charges Read More »

FBI finds anti-Semitic material in home of K.C. shooting suspect

The FBI found printouts containing addresses of synagogues and kosher eateries in the home of Kansas City shooting suspect Frazier Glenn Miller.

Miller — who is also known as Frazier Glenn Cross – is accused of killing three people on April 13 outside the Overland Park JCC and the nearby Village Shalom senior facility.

During their search of Miller’s home in Aurora, Mo., located about 200 miles from Kansas City, FBI agents found anti-Semitic paraphernalia, including a copy of “Mein Kampf” and a book Miller had written titled “A White Man Speaks Out.” They also found a user’s manual for a shotgun, three boxes of ammunition and computer printouts with directions to area synagogues and kosher eateries as well as the details of a Kansas City-area talent contest.

Miller is charged with two counts of capital murder in the killings outside the JCC of William Corporon, 69, and his grandson, Reat Griffin Underwood, 14, and one count of first-degree murder in the killing of Terri LaManno, 53, who was at the senior center visiting her mother. None of the victims were Jewish.

The next court hearing in the case is scheduled for May 29.

FBI finds anti-Semitic material in home of K.C. shooting suspect Read More »

Moving and Shaking: Carl Reiner and Phil Rosenthal at the L.A. Jewish Film Festival

The Saban Theatre was filled with laughter as legendary comedian/director/producer Carl Reiner and writer/producer Phil Rosenthal (“Everybody Loves Raymond”) participated in a free-flowing conversation about life, comedy and everything in between as part of the Los Angeles Jewish Film Festival’s opening-night ceremony. The May 1 gathering in Beverly Hills marked the start of this year’s annual festival.

The memory of Sid Caesar was the theme of the opening night, featuring a screening of “Ten From Your Show of Shows,” a 1973 collection of 10 legendary sketches from Caesar’s “Your Show of Shows.”

“I hope we have fun and a lot of laughs. That’s what we’re here for,” Reiner told the Journal, as his handlers ushered him through the lobby of the historic theater. “If we don’t laugh, we fail.” 

Reiner, L.A. Jewish Film Festival executive director Hilary Helstein and others, including Jon Voight, began the night in a flash, posing for photographers on the red carpet. 

For the Q-and-A following the screening, Rosenthal was supposed to generate conversation by asking Reiner questions, but the latter made Rosenthal’s job easy, opting instead to reminisce freestyle and read passages from his latest autobiography, “I Just Remembered!” 

The subject matter for the weeklong festival included “Icons and Heroes,” “Tradition and Identity,” “Conflicts and Issues” and “History and Legacy.” It is a program of TRIBE Media Corp., which produces the Journal.

A Q-and-A with Jewish Journal Arts Editor Naomi Pfefferman; American Jewish Committee-Los Angeles’ Rabbi Mark Diamond and the Rev. Alexei Smith of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles was scheduled to follow the closing night screening of the 2012 film “The Jewish Cardinal.”



Judea Pearl

UCLA computer science professor Judea Pearl has been elected to the elite National Academy of Sciences, in recognition by his peers of his “distinguished and continuing achievements in original research,” particularly in the field of artificial intelligence (AI).

Pearl, a contributing writer and occasional columnist for the Journal, is an international leader in AI, which probes the partnership between humans and robotic machines. Its applications extend to medical diagnosis, homeland security and natural language understanding.

The discipline, a subfield of computer science, aims to understand the fundamental building blocks of thought, creativity, imagination and language — those elements of the mind that make us intelligent.

Two years ago, Pearl was the recipient of the Turing Award, generally described as the “Nobel Prize of Computing.” The citation noted that “his influence extends beyond artificial intelligence and even computer science, to human reasoning and the philosophy of science.”

Born and raised in the Orthodox enclave of Bnei Brak near Tel Aviv, Pearl is perhaps best known in the Jewish community as the president, and co-founder with his wife, Ruth Pearl, of the Daniel Pearl Foundation. The foundation’s purpose is to perpetuate the ideals of their son, Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, who was murdered in 2002 by Muslim extremists in Pakistan.

In addition, Pearl is an activist in the academic world and on the UCLA campus in championing the cause of Israel in a sometimes hostile climate.

The National Academy of Sciences was established by Congress in 1863 and signed by President Abraham Lincoln, to act as adviser to the federal government in matters pertaining to science and technology.

—  Tom Tugend, Contributing Editor



From left: Beth Chayim Chadashim’s (BCC) Rabbi Lisa Edwards; BCC 2014 Awards Brunch honorees Elissa Barrett and her wife, playwright Zsa Zsa Gershick; and Edwards’ wife, Tracy Moore. Photo by Marcia Perel Photography.

Beth Chayim Chadashim’s (BCC) 2014 Awards Brunch, which took place at the Omni Los Angeles Hotel on April 27, was “one of the most successful galas we’ve had,” according to the congregation’s new executive director, Ruth Gefner. She began full time on April 16 after having previously worked at Temple Isaiah and Temple Emanuel of Beverly Hills.

Among the event’s honorees was Brad Sears, founding director and current executive director of the Williams Institute, a think tank at UCLA School of Law that conducts research on sexual orientation and gender identity law and public policy. He received the Rabbi Erwin and Agnes Herman Humanitarian Award. 

Award-winning writer, filmmaker and educator Zsa Zsa Gershick and her wife, Bet Tzedek Legal Services vice president and general counsel Elissa Barrett, together were given the Harriet Perl Tzedek Award. And Felicia Park-Rogers, who served as BCC’s executive director for eight years, was honored with the Presidents’ Award. 

Founded in 1972 as the world’s first lesbian and gay synagogue, today Beth Chayim Chadashim describes itself as an inclusive community of progressive lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and heterosexual Jews, their families and friends. 



American Jewish Committee-Los Angeles’ new president, Dean Schramm; Schramm’s wife, former city controller and current congressional candidate Wendy Greuel; and their son, Thomas. Photo by Ryan Torok.

The American Jewish Committee chapter in Los Angeles (AJC-LA) named attorney and producer Dean Schramm as its president during its annual meeting on April 30.

Schramm, the husband of former city controller and current congressional candidate Wendy Greuel, voiced his support of Israel, the Jewish people and the organization. 

“We know that the best way to stand up against bigotry and hatred directed at the Jewish people is to give expression to the values Judaism teaches,” Schramm said from the podium, as Greuel and the couple’s son, Thomas, looked on from their seats at a table near the front of the room. 

He succeeds Clifford Goldstein, and his election is effective immediately. Meanwhile, Goldstein is continuing on as chairman of the organization’s regional lay leadership.

AJC regional director Rabbi Mark Diamond delivered the invocation at the ceremony, which took place at the Skirball Cultural Center. It drew more than 100 guests, including AJC supporters and elected officials.

“Dean has deep and binding friendships and bonds here in Los Angeles. He cares much about this community, and he cares a lot about AJC priorities,” Diamond told the Journal.

Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti was the event’s keynote speaker, and he used his remarks to, among other things, highlight the important role of AJC to Los Angeles. Additional participants in the program included Uri Herscher, the Skirball’s founding president and CEO, who joked that the mayor’s agenda ought to include moving City Hall to Sepulveda Boulevard, where the cultural center is located. 

The event honored Judi Kaufman, an active member of AJC’s local chapter, brain cancer survivor, poet and founder of Art of the Brain at UCLA Medical Center. AJC currently collects funds in Kaufman’s honor through an initiative known as the Judi Fund.

Among the familiar faces in the crowd were Greuel; Richard Volpert, an attorney and founding publisher of the Jewish Journal; community leader Barbara Yaroslavsky; and L.A. City Controller Ron Galperin.

AJC-LA is one of many chapters of a national organization committed to advocating for Israel, immigration reform and more. It names a new president every two years. 


Moving and Shaking highlights events, honors and simchas. Got a tip? Email ryant@jewishjournal.com.

Moving and Shaking: Carl Reiner and Phil Rosenthal at the L.A. Jewish Film Festival Read More »

Don’t think outside the box!

“Think outside the box” we hear repeatedly. Often the wit of a sharp phrase destroys years of conventional wisdom.  Recently, my brother popped the question.  Looking over the glorious proposal album, I noticed the all important ring inside the box.  All things vital are guarded inside the box!  Why become distracted looking outside?

When I was five years old, I had a box of treasures.  I started collecting early.  I had an eye for rare items.  Erasers.  Beads. Early on, I knew that it is what you put inside your box that defines you.  By separating ourselves from the outside world, we gain identity.  At ten, I found a bump in the attic of our old house.  I ripped off the wallpaper, and found old coins that proved to be over two hundred years old.  True treasures!  They replaced the lesser items in my box.

1979, I was eleven when the Iranian revolution displaced my family.  Mr. Shahin, a trusted source, came over to our house and my father asked him to safely transfer my box of treasures to our new home in America.   That was the last I saw of the box.  Immigrants leave themselves behind like a dying pet that must be placed to rest before a long journey.  Some attempt to pack their older self into a stork’s pouch.  They fail to realize that hoarders can’t survive the journey through the desert.  We desperately try to revive the memories of the smell of a perfume, the sound of a vibrant voice, the touch of a warm, heavy hand. But alas.

I was thirty eight.  I finally built up the courage to collect again.  Or it was out of a genetically encoded compulsion that had been kept dormant long enough?   There is a Persian saying that quitting an addiction leads to a new disease.  I started collecting Japanese earthenware and eventually co-produced the definitive book on the subject of Satsuma. 

Collectors know, all too well, that we are but temporary guardians of the objects of our obsession.  The value of the collection is often more than the collector’s home.  Yet, as we stare at an object that is over a hundred years old, we quickly realize that the hand that created it is beneath the ground, and ours will be too, while the object will slip through our hold to another.  We enter this world with both fists tightly gripped, yet leave with open hands, nothing in them.  In the end, the object is placed inside one box, and its collector into another, six feet under.

We know that at the end of our time, it is not things that are important, but memories.  Yet, we spend most of our waking moments collecting things, not memories.  And still, as I care for stroke patients and hear the moans of the caretakers of those with dementia, I am even doubtful of the value of memories we accrue. 

A treasure is not collected.  A treasure is not remembered.  A treasure is made in the moment it receives attention and love and cannot be lived without.  Kindness improves life.  Attention improves objects.  Love improves memory.   So I write with the faith that the hand that cast me as a stone onto this world will care for the ripples I create to future generations.

Our lives revolve around what is inside a box.  The bassinet.  The treasure box.  Your brain.  My heart.  My brother’s ring box.  A box of chocolates.  Our Mishkan.  Luggage packed for an unknown trip.  Our Coffin.  The value of what is inside the box is measured only by the light that shines on it by the admirer and is seen only when given away in love.  The rock in the box becomes a promise of a lifetime of caring;  our souls are returned back to our Creator once the final box is closed.

Each of us is a living treasure box and love holds the key.

Next time, think again, think inside the box!
 

Don’t think outside the box! Read More »

Survivor: Curt Lowens

“We are surrounded by Hitler Youth throwing stones. Get home as fast as you can.” Dr. Leonore Goldschmidt, director of the Goldschmidt Schule (School) in Berlin, told the students as she rushed into one of Curt Lowens’ (then Loewenstein’s) morning classes. Amid the chaos, Curt bolted for his bicycle. He hurriedly pedaled home along the Kurfürstendamm, one of the city’s most fashionable avenues, dodging rocks thrown by hoodlums and Hitler Youth as they smashed the windows of the many Jewish-owned stores and restaurants. “It was very scary,” he recalled.

Inside the family’s apartment, Curt’s mother took him to the window, pointing to the smoke pouring from the nearby Fasanenstrasse Synagogue. No bar mitzvah, she told him.

It was Nov. 9, 1938, eight days before Curt’s 13th birthday, and the day that became known as Kristallnacht. 

Curt was born on Nov. 17, 1925, in Allenstein, East Prussia (now Olsztyn, Poland), to Alfred and Ellie Loewenstein. His brother, Henry, was born in 1923. 

The Loewensteins’ comfortable life changed in 1935. Curt, one of five Jewish boys in his public school, was beaten up, and his father, a well-established lawyer, was no longer permitted in court. The following year, the family moved to Berlin, Curt and Henry enrolled in the Goldschmidt Schule, and life continued somewhat normally, despite the Nuremberg Laws.

But on Kristallnacht, Alfred was deported to Sachsenhausen. He was released three weeks later. 

The Fasanenstrasse Synagogue’s Rabbi Manfred Swarsensky was also imprisoned in Sachsenhausen. After his return, he gathered together 35 boys — including Curt — who had been preparing for their b’nai mitzvah and, on Jan. 14, 1939, conducted a group ceremony. “I remember a flood of tears,” Curt said. 

In August 1939, Henry left for England. Meanwhile Alfred had applied to the American Consulate for visas, which arrived the following spring.

Curt and his parents boarded a train for Holland on May 8, 1940, with plans to depart Rotterdam on the SS Veendam on May 11. But on May 10, Germany attacked Holland, and the Loewensteins, along with 700 people, were picked up by the Dutch police and interned in Rotterdam’s De Doelen (concert hall).

Then, on May 14, the German Luftwaffe began firebombing Rotterdam. The De Doelen was hit, and the prisoners scattered amid fire and debris.

A few months later, the Loewensteins were evacuated to Venlo, in southeastern Holland, where Curt worked as an apprentice in an electrical shop. Sometime in 1942, Alfred was offered a desk job with the Jewish Council, and the family moved to Amsterdam.

In June 1943, Curt and his mother were snared in an unexpected roundup and sent to Westerbork. After two weeks, however, when the camp commandant saw that their identification papers read “Postponed from deportation until further notice,” they were returned to Amsterdam.

Two months later, all three family members were picked up and shipped to Westerbork. Again, after six weeks, they were released. But Curt’s mother had become very ill, and their apartment had been looted. 

Alfred put Ellie into the Jewish hospital, and he and Curt lived in a friend’s attic. During this time, Curt contacted a resistance group led by Piet Meerburg and, he said, after saying farewell to his parents, “Curt Loewenstein disappeared.” 

He became Ben Joosten, a small-town teacher, and was taken by resistance members to the village of Broekhuizenvorst, where he stayed with a blacksmith. 

Three weeks later, he was directed to a house in Tienray, which served as the Meerburg group’s regional headquarters and where he met leaders Hanna van der Voort and Nico Dohmen. He lived with the Maartens family, working on their farm. But needing something more to do, he became the region’s third resistance leader.

Soon after, when someone suspicious came looking for him, Curt left the Maartens to live with another family, the Moorens — a couple and their seven children — in Meerlo.

In early December 1943, Curt discovered that his father was in hiding in Venlo and his mother was in the Catholic hospital in nearby Tegelen. He bicycled to see them. His mother was very ill and died on Jan. 3, 1944. 

As resistance leaders, Hanna, Nico and Curt (using the name Ben) worked together to deliver Jewish children — and a few adults — to families who hid them. They regularly checked on the children, bringing food and clothing, and transferring them when necessary. All told, these three are credited with saving the lives of 123 Jewish children.

On the night of July 31, 1944, however, the Gestapo raided several homes and arrested 11 hidden people — nine children and two adults. “We lost wonderful people,” Nico told Curt.

The following month, while bicycling to the Moorens, Curt heard the sound of a sputtering engine. He looked up to see a plane disappearing into the distance and two open parachutes falling from the sky. He raced to a field, where he found farmers folding up silk parachutes and pointing to a haystack. Curt crawled inside. “Gentleman,” he said to the fliers, “I am with the resistance. The Germans also saw you coming here. Please trust me and crawl away with me.” They hid in a nearby forest, where the fliers — Tom Wilcox from Akron, Ohio, and Reg McNeil from Rochester, N.Y. — updated Curt on the war and taught him the words to “Pistol Packin’ Mama.” 

At nightfall, Curt led the Americans to the Moorens’ house, and they stayed in Curt’s attic room. The men remained hidden in various locations until liberation on Oct. 17, 1944.

Early that morning, Curt and 16 other people, including his father, were hiding in a cellar in Venray when they suddenly heard footsteps on the staircase. “Is Ben down there?” the local priest yelled. Three English soldiers, part of a British government military detachment, needed an interpreter. 

A few days later, learning that Curt (still called Ben) spoke English, Dutch and German, the British soldiers offered him a job as an interpreter. Curt donned a British uniform and crossed into German territory with the British army’s Eighth Corps. It was November 1944; the war was still being waged.

Curt served as a liaison between the British government military detachment and the local populations, as the unit forged deeper into Germany and as the war was winding down. 

Then, soon after an armistice was declared between the Allied forces and Germany, Curt found himself riding in a jeep with two British officers and a driver. They pulled up to Glucksburg Castle, near Flensburg, which served as headquarters for what was then, after Hitler’s suicide, the High Command of the German armed forces. There, Curt translated as the British officers spoke with Grand Adm. Karl Donitz, Hitler’s designated deputy, and Reichsminister Albert Speer. That experience, Curt said, after years of marching boots and unexpected knocks on the door, “was a total psychological turnaround and restoration of sanity.” 

Curt remained with the British Army until fall 1946, when he returned to Holland. 

In 1947, Curt, his father and his father’s new wife immigrated to the United States. He studied acting at New York’s Berghof Studio, where, in the late 1950s, he met Katherine Guilford. They married on Nov. 23, 1968. 

Curt’s first acting role, in 1951, was in a Broadway performance of “Stalag 17,” in which he played a Nazi guard. A prolific career on stage and in films and television followed. 

In 1984, Curt traveled to Jerusalem, where Yad Vashem recognized Hanna and Nico as Righteous Among the Nations. Curt himself is included on a Yad Vashem list of Jews rescuing Jews.

Curt’s memoir, “Destination: Questionmark,” was published in 2002, leading to various speaking engagements at Chapman University, Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust and other venues.

A concerto honoring Curt’s life, “Bestemming” (“Destination”) Cello Concerto No. 1, by composer Sharon Farber, premiered on Jan. 5, 2014. It will be performed again on June 13 at the Saban Theatre. 

Curt, who is a survivor, a Dutch Resistance leader and a British army veteran, resists the appellation of hero. 

 “You don’t do things to become a hero. You do things at the spur of the moment, when the situation presents itself,” he said. 

Survivor: Curt Lowens Read More »

6 things Donald Sterling Could Have Done to Avoid This Mess

6. Spend his first waking moment, as a proud Jew, to say the Modeh Ani Lefanecha prayer and bless the day. ( In case you forgot: Modeh anee lefanecha melech chai vekayam, she-he-chezarta bee nishmatee b’chemla, raba emunatecha.)

5. Spend his second waking moments meditating to clear his head from the previous day's baggage. With a clear head, he would avoid such monumental mistakes as a “texty” with V. I know she and the Clippers would apreciate it

4.  Read a damn book. This will help him connect the “1,000 piece” puzzle of his soul, and learn the lessons he is struggling to get. Here are some examples: Course of Miracles- by Marianne Williamson; The Four Agreements- Don Miguel Ruiz; and, Falling into Grace,

3.  Hire a nice Jewish trainer, with many years of experience, to whip his butt into top shape. “>http://www.expresshometrainer.com/4-best-detoxing-smoothies/

1. Be grateful. Look around at how blessed his life is. Call his children.  Stop and smell the roses.

6 things Donald Sterling Could Have Done to Avoid This Mess Read More »

Salute to The Mother

As a proud mother, who also has worked with other mothers, I can truly say that there is nothing more rewarding than motherhood. I can put all my endorsements, trophies, paychecks, careers, and achievements together, but all of that is worth nothing, compared to the joy, happiness, and fulfilment that I get from being a mom.
We all have dreams. Many of us run a business- whether small-town or large corporation. We all wish to create something beautiful. Us mothers, we are the real backbone of the family. On top of all that we do- the cooking, cleaning, caring for our young, and taking care of everybody else in the way only mothers can- we also try to live a healthy life.
But how do we fit that healthy life into our busy schedules, and remain guilt-free? Like most mothers I know, we do get around to the workout, but we still cannot let go of our sweet tooth. Can we still enjoy a sweet pleasure without the guilt? The answer is yes. I have the best, most scrumptious dessert, that boot the guilt out, and lets the sweet in.

Raw Chocolate Truffles

Not only does it only take less than 5 minutes to prepare, it doesnt require any baking. It is also the host to antioxidants, vitamins, minerals, and friendly fats. Make an extra batch, those babies won't last!

Ingredients:

1 cup raw sunflower seeds
1 cup walnuts/almonds/pecans
1 cup pitted, chopped dates ( I prefer Medjool dates)
1/4 tsp sea salt
4 to 6 tbsp raw, unsweetened cocoa powder (depends on the strength you prefer)
1 tbsp extra virgin coconut oil (optional)

3 tbsp Goji berries (optional)
3 tbsp shredded, unsweetened coconut

Preparation:

1. In a high speed blender, or Vitamix, add the nuts and seeds. Process until the seeds are completely blended. Don't over process, only blend until very fine.
2. Add the rest, except for the Goji berries
3. Process again until everything is clumped together in a fine paste.
4. Roll the paste into small balls and set on a tray
5. If you like, you can roll each ball in the Goji berries or coconut- or both if you like


Happy Mother's Day to the most amazing humans on this earth. My wish for you is to enjoy Mother's Day every day, with this guilt-free, scrumptious pleasure

Salute to The Mother Read More »

Favorability and the Gap: Both Growing in Favor of Israel

Our Israel Favorability tracker has a long history and is a complicated feature to handle. Among other things, because of the many ways favorability can be measured, the type of questions asked, their frequency, their timing. The main graph that Prof. Camil Fuchs computes for us deals only with questions that specifically measure Israel’s favorability – that is, questions that ask about “Favorable versus unfavorable opinion towards Israel in general”, as Prof. Fuchs defined it when we last posted an updated graph (see it here).

Moreover, in an article published about a year ago (in Haaretz), Fuchs and I explained why the “favorability” question is superior to other measurements of Israel’s situation. Other – as in questions that don’t solely ask about Israel but rather ask about Israel in comparison to something else. In almost all cases, and there are many such cases, the “something else” is the Palestinians. The public is not asked to tell the pollsters to what extent it supports, likes, believes in, or feels affinity toward Israel. It is asked what side it supports in the conflict – Israel or the Palestinians.

Surely, this is a tricky question. It can make things seem good even when the actual state of support is one of erosion, if the erosion in the support for Israel’s mirror-image, the Palestinians, is even worse. Nevertheless, building on a new PEW survey from last week, we decided to take a break from favorability per-se and take a look at Israel’s situation compared to “the Palestinians”.

This is something worth doing for a couple of reasons.

1. Because of the collapse of the last round of peace negotiations, and the relatively high visibility of the topic in recent months.

2. Because the collapse is the end of talks and the beginning (well, this began long ago) of a blame game in which both sides aim to score points against one another – the kind of points that one might be able to follow by looking at Israel-vs-Palestine polls.

3. Because the polls before this last one showed us that Israel’s current state of favorability is solid (here it is again), and we wanted to see if this is also the picture seen in other types of polls.

4. Because, well, this is what we have that is fresh, so we might as well use it.

5. It was Israel’s Independence Day yesterday, and we wanted to see if there’s reason for celebration (of course there is, no matter what the numbers say).

As we use it, though, we don’t just look at the new numbers and the couple of sentences provided by PEW. We also skipped, at least this time, the examination of partisanship, as the picture is well known and well documented: “Support for Israel in its dispute with the Palestinians has been consistent over the nearly four-decade history of this measure. There continue to be partisan differences in views: 68% of Republicans sympathize more with Israel compared with 46% of Democrats (just 15% of Democrats and 7% of Republicans sympathize more with the Palestinians)”.

This time we focused on the larger picture, and on the Israel-Palestine gap – that is, not just how Israel fairs in comparison to the Palestinians, but also what the gap between the American public’s appreciation of Israel and its appreciation of the Palestinians looks like. And we didn’t just do it with the last PEW survey, we did it with PEW surveys dated back to the late 1980s. And we didn’t just do it with PEW surveys, but added to them the very similar surveys by Gallup. The PEW question is: “In the dispute between Israel and the Palestinians, which side do you sympathize with more, Israel or the Palestinians?”, the Gallup question is: “In the Middle East, are you sympathizes more with Israel or with the Palestinians?”. Both institutions ask these questions quite frequently.

(If you want to see the detailed tables and graphs, and some technical notes, click here and see the Favorability tracker. In this post we will use just one graph, and provide some analysis)

Pew and Gallup show the numbers for both Israel and the Palestinians in their respective surveys. What we did is simply put the numbers all together and provide a graph of the “gap” – that is, Israel’s favorability, always higher, minus the Palestinians’ favorability. We did it separately for both polls, and here is the result:

I find it quite revealing. Not only are Israel’s numbers gradually climbing, but so is the gap. Amid all the talk – and there is such circular conversation around Washington from time to time – about the looming decline of Israel’s favorability, the numbers tell another story. If once the gap between Israel and the Palestinians was twenty or thirty percent different – and this, by the way, seemed enough at the time – it is now above forty percent. To be exact: 42% in the latest Pew, 44% in the latest Gallup (again, if you want all the detailed numbers, click here). In 2012, it was 40% and 44%. The widening of the gap is slow, but is hard to deny. Opinion makers who find Israel at fault for the collapse of the Kerry initiative, Obama supporters who believe that more pressure on Netanyahu is the key, BDS activists who disrupt university events, creating an impression of a “movement”, all seem much less significant when one looks at the numbers. 

Of course, worrying about the future is always an option. When things look grim, we worry, and when the numbers are so high we worry that they will eventually decline. Yet as Israel celebrates its 66th year, after more than forty five years of occupation and more than a hundred years of fighting with the Palestinians over land, the American public – to the extent that it has a view – vastly prefers Israel to its neighbors.

Favorability and the Gap: Both Growing in Favor of Israel Read More »