The fight for religious charter schools is back in court — and this time with a new protagonist: Jews. Late last month, the Ben Gamla Charter School filed suit in Oklahoma after the state charter school board denied its application solely because the proposed school is religious. But while the stakes of the debate over religious charter schools — competing views of religious liberty and church-state separation — have by now become familiar, this time around a darker line of criticism has emerged: that the effort to establish a Jewish charter school in the Sooner State is not a genuine case at all, but the product of Christian nationalist actors using Jews to advance their broader aims.
In making this claim, separationist critics argue that, after an earlier Catholic charter school effort in Oklahoma stalled at the Supreme Court last year, proponents have simply propped up a Jewish plaintiff as a more sympathetic stalking horse for advancing a broader strategy to reintroduce religion — and, more often than not, Christianity — into publicly funded schools.
Unfortunately, in an environment where antisemitic conspiracy theories flourish — where Jews are blamed for everything from the Iran War to Jeffrey Epstein — this framing should come as no surprise. But distorting Jewish efforts to secure support for Jewish education into a form of manipulated self-betrayal comes with its own unique set of harms. It undermines Jewish efforts to assert their legal rights at the very moment they are most urgently needed.
Casting the Ben Gamla litigation as merely a Christian nationalist ruse is harder to sustain once one looks more closely at the facts. The founder of the proposed Ben Gamla school, Peter Deutsch, is a former Democratic congressman who has operated a network of “English-Hebrew Charter School[s]” in Florida for decades. The goal of his new Oklahoma initiative is to create a virtual charter that provides a “rigorous academic education alongside a deep cultural and ethical grounding derived from the Jewish faith, heritage and tradition.” Built in this way, the school aims to provide a Jewish education in locations where families do not currently have access to such an option.
The Ben Gamla litigation follows last year’s failed effort to secure approval of a proposed Oklahoma Catholic charter school, which stalled after a deadlocked Supreme Court left in place a state court decision rejecting it. As in previous rounds of litigation, critics have responded to the proposed Ben Gamla charter school proposal with familiar — and reasonable — arguments asserting that funding religious charter schools would violate principles of church-state separation.
Assessing the constitutionality of a religious charter school is no straightforward matter. The core legal dilemma derives from the very nature of charter schools: they are government authorized, but privately operated. As a result, courts have debated over the years whether, for the purposes of constitutional analysis, they ought to be viewed as public schools or private schools. If they are public schools, then allowing them to operate would offend core constitutional prohibitions against public institutions engaging in religious indoctrination. If they are private schools, then refusing to authorize them qualifies as religious discrimination; as the Supreme Court has made clear multiple times over the past decade, government cannot open a program to private institutions, but then exclude religious institutions on account of their being religious.
Both constitutional values – the prohibitions against state-sponsored religious indoctrination and state-sponsored religious discrimination – have long been fiercely guarded by the American Jewish community. Of course, in this case, figuring out which of these two values is the one actually implicated turns into somewhat of a constitutional Rorschach test. When it comes to classifying charter schools as public or private, there are strong arguments on both sides of the ledger.
To be sure, given the overlap of interests, it is not surprising that some of the people involved in earlier efforts share partners and allies with those behind Ben Gamla. But the fact that the two proposed schools draw on overlapping networks and deploy the same legal arguments simply reflects what should be obvious: that there exist committed Jews and Christians who both see real benefit in securing funding for their respective faith communities, making religious schools more affordable and accessible and using the existing panoply of legal arguments to advance their rights.
But the argument that the case is fake, concocted and really driven by an unholy alliance between Jews and Christian nationalists deserves no quarter. Consider, as a prime example, the claim advanced by the CEO of Americans United for Separation of Church and State: that this case amounts to “using Jews to advance a Christian Nationalist agenda that is not ultimately in Jews’ best interest.” Or, alternatively, the Freedom from Religion Foundation’s claim that Ben Gamla’s “motivation” is “ideological, not theological” — not a genuine effort to expand access to Jewish education, but an attempt “to secure public funding for religious indoctrination by any means necessary.” These claims do more than raise constitutional objections; they recast Jewish advocacy as instrumental to someone else’s agenda.
Viewing Jewish attempts to protect their own rights – especially their religious liberty rights – as part of some elaborate scheme is dangerous stuff. Jewish efforts to secure access to public funding on the same terms as other educational institutions are not only as American as apple pie; they are as Jewish as matzah balls. And Jews engaged in such advocacy are no more the puppets of shadowy Christian Nationalists than they are participants in some vast “globalist” conspiracy.
The twin, and at times dueling, First Amendment values with respect to religion — against establishing religion and in favor of religious liberty — have both been essential to Jewish flourishing in the United States since the very beginning of this country. Insinuating that Jewish efforts to protect those rights — on whatever side of the political ledger — are anything other than good-faith attempts to secure the place of American Jews threatens the very ability of Jews to access those rights. It risks casting Jewish advocacy as presumptively suspect — a manipulated and illegitimate form of advocacy with no place in a properly functioning democracy. More troubling still, it reinforces a familiar and corrosive trope: that Jews do not act as independent agents, but as instruments of broader, and often suspect, agendas and conspiracies. And as the place of Jews in America has become increasingly precarious in recent years, it is hard to imagine a more dangerous time to allow constitutional disagreement to undermine the legitimacy of constitutional advocacy.
Michael Helfand is the Brenden Mann Foundation Chair in Law & Religion at Pepperdine Caruso School of Law; Visiting Professor at Yale Law School; Senior Fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute; and Senior Legal Advisor to the Teach Coalition.
The Fight for a Jewish Charter School Isn’t a Christian Nationalist Plot
Michael A. Helfand
The fight for religious charter schools is back in court — and this time with a new protagonist: Jews. Late last month, the Ben Gamla Charter School filed suit in Oklahoma after the state charter school board denied its application solely because the proposed school is religious. But while the stakes of the debate over religious charter schools — competing views of religious liberty and church-state separation — have by now become familiar, this time around a darker line of criticism has emerged: that the effort to establish a Jewish charter school in the Sooner State is not a genuine case at all, but the product of Christian nationalist actors using Jews to advance their broader aims.
In making this claim, separationist critics argue that, after an earlier Catholic charter school effort in Oklahoma stalled at the Supreme Court last year, proponents have simply propped up a Jewish plaintiff as a more sympathetic stalking horse for advancing a broader strategy to reintroduce religion — and, more often than not, Christianity — into publicly funded schools.
Unfortunately, in an environment where antisemitic conspiracy theories flourish — where Jews are blamed for everything from the Iran War to Jeffrey Epstein — this framing should come as no surprise. But distorting Jewish efforts to secure support for Jewish education into a form of manipulated self-betrayal comes with its own unique set of harms. It undermines Jewish efforts to assert their legal rights at the very moment they are most urgently needed.
Casting the Ben Gamla litigation as merely a Christian nationalist ruse is harder to sustain once one looks more closely at the facts. The founder of the proposed Ben Gamla school, Peter Deutsch, is a former Democratic congressman who has operated a network of “English-Hebrew Charter School[s]” in Florida for decades. The goal of his new Oklahoma initiative is to create a virtual charter that provides a “rigorous academic education alongside a deep cultural and ethical grounding derived from the Jewish faith, heritage and tradition.” Built in this way, the school aims to provide a Jewish education in locations where families do not currently have access to such an option.
The Ben Gamla litigation follows last year’s failed effort to secure approval of a proposed Oklahoma Catholic charter school, which stalled after a deadlocked Supreme Court left in place a state court decision rejecting it. As in previous rounds of litigation, critics have responded to the proposed Ben Gamla charter school proposal with familiar — and reasonable — arguments asserting that funding religious charter schools would violate principles of church-state separation.
Assessing the constitutionality of a religious charter school is no straightforward matter. The core legal dilemma derives from the very nature of charter schools: they are government authorized, but privately operated. As a result, courts have debated over the years whether, for the purposes of constitutional analysis, they ought to be viewed as public schools or private schools. If they are public schools, then allowing them to operate would offend core constitutional prohibitions against public institutions engaging in religious indoctrination. If they are private schools, then refusing to authorize them qualifies as religious discrimination; as the Supreme Court has made clear multiple times over the past decade, government cannot open a program to private institutions, but then exclude religious institutions on account of their being religious.
Both constitutional values – the prohibitions against state-sponsored religious indoctrination and state-sponsored religious discrimination – have long been fiercely guarded by the American Jewish community. Of course, in this case, figuring out which of these two values is the one actually implicated turns into somewhat of a constitutional Rorschach test. When it comes to classifying charter schools as public or private, there are strong arguments on both sides of the ledger.
To be sure, given the overlap of interests, it is not surprising that some of the people involved in earlier efforts share partners and allies with those behind Ben Gamla. But the fact that the two proposed schools draw on overlapping networks and deploy the same legal arguments simply reflects what should be obvious: that there exist committed Jews and Christians who both see real benefit in securing funding for their respective faith communities, making religious schools more affordable and accessible and using the existing panoply of legal arguments to advance their rights.
But the argument that the case is fake, concocted and really driven by an unholy alliance between Jews and Christian nationalists deserves no quarter. Consider, as a prime example, the claim advanced by the CEO of Americans United for Separation of Church and State: that this case amounts to “using Jews to advance a Christian Nationalist agenda that is not ultimately in Jews’ best interest.” Or, alternatively, the Freedom from Religion Foundation’s claim that Ben Gamla’s “motivation” is “ideological, not theological” — not a genuine effort to expand access to Jewish education, but an attempt “to secure public funding for religious indoctrination by any means necessary.” These claims do more than raise constitutional objections; they recast Jewish advocacy as instrumental to someone else’s agenda.
Viewing Jewish attempts to protect their own rights – especially their religious liberty rights – as part of some elaborate scheme is dangerous stuff. Jewish efforts to secure access to public funding on the same terms as other educational institutions are not only as American as apple pie; they are as Jewish as matzah balls. And Jews engaged in such advocacy are no more the puppets of shadowy Christian Nationalists than they are participants in some vast “globalist” conspiracy.
The twin, and at times dueling, First Amendment values with respect to religion — against establishing religion and in favor of religious liberty — have both been essential to Jewish flourishing in the United States since the very beginning of this country. Insinuating that Jewish efforts to protect those rights — on whatever side of the political ledger — are anything other than good-faith attempts to secure the place of American Jews threatens the very ability of Jews to access those rights. It risks casting Jewish advocacy as presumptively suspect — a manipulated and illegitimate form of advocacy with no place in a properly functioning democracy. More troubling still, it reinforces a familiar and corrosive trope: that Jews do not act as independent agents, but as instruments of broader, and often suspect, agendas and conspiracies. And as the place of Jews in America has become increasingly precarious in recent years, it is hard to imagine a more dangerous time to allow constitutional disagreement to undermine the legitimacy of constitutional advocacy.
Michael Helfand is the Brenden Mann Foundation Chair in Law & Religion at Pepperdine Caruso School of Law; Visiting Professor at Yale Law School; Senior Fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute; and Senior Legal Advisor to the Teach Coalition.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Mazal Tov and the Luckiest Woman in the World
Israel ParaSport Center Benefit, Simon Wiesenthal Center Gala, Goldrich Center
A Moment in Time: The Beauty of an Interruption
A Bisl Torah ~ I Didn’t Know
Establishing Shalom on Shabbat while Lighting the Home
UC Regents Meeting Features Palestine Presentation, But No Jewish Student Voices
Longtime Ramah Family Gives $5 million to Endow Scholarships at Camp Ramah in California
The Donna and Spencer Gilbert Foundation’s gift, inspired by Sheryl Sandberg’s scholarship in memory of Dave Goldberg, will support campers every summer.
Another Way – A poem for Parsha Vayetzei
There’s always another version of something –
Print Issue: The Gratitude Issue | November 20, 2026
Inside: Your own Jewish Journal Thanksgiving Haggadah
Noahides Sign Historic Declaration in Jerusalem at Global Congress
Noahides, or “b’nei Noah” as they are called in Hebrew, are those who accept the first covenant God made with humanity, through the Noah family.
Lessons in Gratitude
The deepest expression of gratitude isn’t simply saying thank you for what we’ve received. It’s allowing what we’ve received to shape who we are, who we become, and how we treat others throughout our lives.
‘Notes of Deception’: The Klezmer Was a Spy
Like a good spy novel, “Notes of Deception” will have you racing ahead, wanting to find out more. But it is also the heart-wrenching story of dignity under the worst conditions.
‘Tell Me Everything’: The Family Secrets and Personal Struggles Behind Israel’s Oscar Submission
Set in Holon, Israel, in 1987, against the backdrop of the AIDS epidemic, the film follows 12-year-old Boaz (Yair Mazor), the youngest child in a family with two older sisters.
‘Topol: On Top of the World’ – The Story Behind Israel’s Most Celebrated Actor
For Gur Arye, making the documentary was a race against time. Some of the people interviewed, including Topol’s wife, were over 90, but still able to recall events in remarkable detail.
Building the Jewish Homeland’s Future With So Much More Than Little Blue Boxes
Speaking personally, spending three days in an environment filled with optimism, youth and family truly hit the spot.
At 88 Years Old, Bob Waldorf Is One Happy Camper
In an age when so much of children’s lives revolves around screens, the camp gives them an opportunity to unplug, explore and discover new strengths.
Held Hostage to Gratitude
The idea is to say thank you for everything you are experiencing because it is all from God.
A Thanksgiving to Remember
The first holiday my family celebrated in Los Angeles was Thanksgiving. Although it was many decades ago, I can picture that day like it was yesterday and my heart bursts with gratitude for how meaningful and special that day was.
Table for Five: Vayetzei
Jacob’s Holy Pillow
The Thanksgiving Parade and a Jewish Pennsylvanian
The Gimbel family had benefitted greatly from America, and for that they were grateful. A Jewish family, thankful for the freedom to pursue the American Dream, gifted the country, among its many contributions, its quintessential Thanksgiving public celebration.
Gratitude and Mindfulness
To live Jewishly is to discover that life is not somewhere else. It is here, in this moment.
From a Global People to a People of Israel
Today, 46% of world Jewry lives in Israel. In 2070, according to the forecast, 62% will live there. The U.S. share of world Jewry will drop from 39% to 26%, which numerically means 1.2 million fewer people.
We All Need the Zionist Trifecta of Patriotism, Gratitude and Decency
Patriotic gratitude generates the grace and graciousness we should bestow on our neighbors, even if they dare disagree with us politically.
To Turn Together: Israel, Intractability and Distant Horizons
How do you proceed when there are no workable solutions, only a host of unworkable ideas?
Giving Thanks
Below are some of the things for which I am grateful.
The Magic Words
At every turn Judaism is a religion that is held up by gratitude. Our identity is linked with this most remarkable value, to be grateful.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.