fbpx
Monday, August 3, 2020

Less invasive method of replacing aortic valves

Enjoying this article?

You'll love our roundtable.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

The aortic valve is the valve that allows blood out of the heart into the aorta, but not back. As people get older it’s not uncommon for the aortic valve to accumulate calcium deposits, stiffen, and not open as widely. This condition is called aortic stenosis. As the aortic valve narrows, it impairs the blood flow through it. Patients can develop heart failure, lightheadedness, chest pain, and fainting. There are no effective medications for aortic stenosis. Until several years ago the only treatment was valve replacement through open-heart surgery.

The first aortic valve replacement was performed in 1952. The initial mechanical aortic valves were plagued by blood clot formation, requiring patients to take high doses of anticoagulants (blood thinners) forever. Since then many incremental improvements have been made to prosthetic heart valves, but there was only one way to insert them – open-heart surgery. Surgery is quite effective, but it’s risky and has a prolonged recovery. Frail patients who have other medical problems frequently cannot tolerate the surgery. Up until a few years ago patients who could not undergo surgery would eventually die of worsening aortic stenosis.

Several years ago a new procedure for aortic valve replacement was developed. A catheter is placed in a large artery in the leg and threaded to the heart. The prosthetic aortic valve, folded via a miracle of origami engineering so that it can fit inside the catheter, is pushed through the catheter until it reaches the heart. A balloon is inflated to expand the valve into place. This procedure is called transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR).

Since then, several studies have shown that for patients who cannot undergo open-heart surgery or are at extremely high risk from open-heart surgery, TAVR is an effective alternative. Initially TAVR was plagued by complications, but as cardiologists became more familiar with the procedure, and as the prosthetic valve itself incrementally improved (it’s already on its third version) the complication rate has fallen.

A study in 2013 found that about 67,500 aortic valve replacements were done through open-heart surgery every year, and that about 290,000 elderly patients with severe aortic stenosis were candidates for TAVR, with another 27,000 new patients becoming eligible for TAVR every year as their aortic valves worsen or as their health worsens, making surgery too dangerous.

In a rational marketplace, this would be cause for celebration. Hundreds of thousands of patients with a serious disease stand to benefit from a procedure that didn’t exist a decade ago. Their quality of life and possibly their longevity will be enhanced. The developers of the TAVR technology will make a lot of money. Everyone wins.

But our system is far from rational, because we all pay for each other’s stuff. Medicare is projected to become insolvent in the mid-2020s. The last thing the Medicare budget needs is a brand new very expensive procedure that hundreds of thousands of people can get. So Medicare established criteria to regulate who can undergo TAVR. For example, patients have to be examined by two cardiothoracic surgeons and have both of them decide that the patient is not a candidate for open-heart repair before Medicare will cover TAVR. It’s hard to justify these restrictions in terms of patient safety. These can only be motivated by thinly disguised rationing of a new and expensive procedure.

This month a new study in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) compared TAVR to open-heart surgery in patients whose risk for surgery is not as high as in the initial studies. The study showed again that TAVR had equally good outcomes with much faster recovery.

For readers who follow technological change, this pattern is familiar. Open-heart surgery is a mature technology. Its radical breakthroughs and large incremental improvements happened decades ago. Surgical aortic valve replacement is very unlikely to undergo further drastic improvements. TAVR, on the other hand, is new, and is still in the early phase of exponential improvement. Think of word processors in the 90s, digital photography a decade ago, self-driving cars 10 years from now.

As the valve itself and the insertion technique improves, and as cardiologists build more experience, it’s reasonable to predict that TAVR will prove itself effective with patients at lower and lower risk for open-heart surgery. That is, patients who would be reasonable candidates for surgery may in a few years opt for TAVR.

Again, in a rational system this would be heralded as another example of Schumpeterian creative destruction. Surgically implanted valves could eventually go the way of the Polaroid Camera, the typewriter, the dial telephone. Cardiothoracic surgeons would find more productive things to do than replace aortic valves. Most importantly, patients would be much better off.

But instead, patients must now jump through bureaucratic hoops that were inappropriate when they were first implemented and now proven to be clinically unsound. Medicare will of course revise its restrictions, but this will take months, while sick patients wait.

We’re using a 1964 payment system to adjudicate coverage of twenty-first century procedures. Worse, we’re centralizing decision-making when all around us we see examples that leaving decisions to as many different people as possible yields the best outcomes. I would think that the best people to sort out how a patient’s aortic valve should be replaced are the patient’s cardiologist and the patient herself. And in a rational system, the price for TAVR would quickly fall (as it has for smart phones, and cars, and almost everything else you can think of) and she would put down her MasterCard to pay for it.

But instead, Medicare will slightly relax their byzantine rules, and many patients will unnecessarily undergo surgery rather than TAVR. And because of insurance coverage, prices will stay unaffordable indefinitely. And Medicare will still go bankrupt. Meanwhile, because the current system is both so unaffordable and so inadequate, and because some of us have boundless optimism about centralized decision-making, we are considering scrapping the current system and giving everyone Medicare.

Learn more:

” target=”_blank”>Warning: Medicare May Be Bad for Your Heart (Wall Street Journal opinion)
” target=”_blank”>Will TAVR Become the Predominant Method for Treating Severe Aortic Stenosis? (NEJM editorial)
” target=”_blank”>The Healthcare Meltdown (a four-part series I wrote in 2009 about the causes of the problems of the US healthcare system)

Enjoyed this article?

You'll love our roundtable.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Latest Articles

Amazon’s ‘Hunters’ Renewed for Season 2

“Hunters,” Amazon’s thriller about a band of Nazi hunters in 1977 New York, has been picked up for a second season.

LAMOTH to Present ‘The Holocaust & Italy’ Film Series and Panel Discussions

The Shoah-related movies and live Zoom discussions are part of this month's “Teicholz Holocaust Remembrance Film Series: The Holocaust & Italy.”

Niall Horan, the 1975 and More British Pop Stars Condemn Anti-Semitism After Rapper Wiley’s Tweets

"All forms of racism have the same roots — ignorance, lack of education and scapegoating.”

Special Envoy Elan Carr Discusses How to Fight Rising Anti-Semitism in AJC Webinar

He said the best way to fight it is to teach others about the Jewish community's positive contributions to humanity.

Jewish Agency Chair Says Seth Rogen Apologized for Israel Comments, Rogen Denies Apologizing

Rogen also claims that he never gave Herzog permission to publicize the conversation.

Home Shalom Monday Message #19

Home Shalom promotes healthy relationships and facilitates the creation of judgement free, safe spaces in the Jewish community. Home Shalom is a program of...

Israeli Army Says It Thwarted Attack on Syrian Border by Infiltrators Who Planted Explosives

A spokesperson for the army said the Syrian regime was responsible.

‘Unorthodox’ Creator Anna Winger on Celebrating Eight Emmy Nominations

The series became a critical and popular success after its March premiere on Netflix. Now, it has been honored with eight Emmy Award nominations.

Pandemic Times Episode 75: What is the Secret to Jewish Resiliency?

New David Suissa Podcast Every Monday and Friday. Reflections on the worsening times and how the Jewish approach to resiliency can guide us. How do we...

The Allure of the Onion: Perfectly Piquant ‘Pizza’

Every roast, every chicken, every stew, every soup starts with onion. It’s engraved in stone for a Sephardic cook. 

Culture

Amazon’s ‘Hunters’ Renewed for Season 2

“Hunters,” Amazon’s thriller about a band of Nazi hunters in 1977 New York, has been picked up for a second season.

LAMOTH to Present ‘The Holocaust & Italy’ Film Series and Panel Discussions

The Shoah-related movies and live Zoom discussions are part of this month's “Teicholz Holocaust Remembrance Film Series: The Holocaust & Italy.”

Jewish Agency Chair Says Seth Rogen Apologized for Israel Comments, Rogen Denies Apologizing

Rogen also claims that he never gave Herzog permission to publicize the conversation.

‘Unorthodox’ Creator Anna Winger on Celebrating Eight Emmy Nominations

The series became a critical and popular success after its March premiere on Netflix. Now, it has been honored with eight Emmy Award nominations.

The Allure of the Onion: Perfectly Piquant ‘Pizza’

Every roast, every chicken, every stew, every soup starts with onion. It’s engraved in stone for a Sephardic cook. 

Latest Articles
Latest

Amazon’s ‘Hunters’ Renewed for Season 2

“Hunters,” Amazon’s thriller about a band of Nazi hunters in 1977 New York, has been picked up for a second season.

LAMOTH to Present ‘The Holocaust & Italy’ Film Series and Panel Discussions

The Shoah-related movies and live Zoom discussions are part of this month's “Teicholz Holocaust Remembrance Film Series: The Holocaust & Italy.”

Niall Horan, the 1975 and More British Pop Stars Condemn Anti-Semitism After Rapper Wiley’s Tweets

"All forms of racism have the same roots — ignorance, lack of education and scapegoating.”

Special Envoy Elan Carr Discusses How to Fight Rising Anti-Semitism in AJC Webinar

He said the best way to fight it is to teach others about the Jewish community's positive contributions to humanity.

Jewish Agency Chair Says Seth Rogen Apologized for Israel Comments, Rogen Denies Apologizing

Rogen also claims that he never gave Herzog permission to publicize the conversation.

Hollywood

Roy Moore’s Lawsuit Against Sacha Baron Cohen Over Being Pranked Can Proceed, Judge Rules

By the time the episode aired, it was widely known that Cohen was punking public figures.

‘Expecting Amy’ Highlights a New Comedy Dynamic of Jewish Mothers Making, Not Being, the Jokes

Jewish moms like Amy Schumer, who were once the material, have become the premier comics of this age.

Podcasts

Pandemic Times Episode 75: What is the Secret to Jewish Resiliency?

New David Suissa Podcast Every Monday and Friday. Reflections on the worsening times and how the Jewish approach to resiliency can guide us. How do we...

Pandemic Times Episode 74: A Test of Jewish Resiliency

New David Suissa Podcast Every Monday and Friday. Rabbi Nicole Guzik shares her thoughts on "opting in" to communal life during these pandemic times. How do...

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

x