Rosner’s Domain | What Do You Want from Me?
Is it our job to tell the story, or to help win the war? Does our job require that we be impartial, or does it require that we be partisan?
Shmuel Rosner is an Israeli columnist, editor, and researcher. He is the editor of the research and data-journalism website themadad.com, and is the political editor of the Jewish Journal.
Is it our job to tell the story, or to help win the war? Does our job require that we be impartial, or does it require that we be partisan?
What will the Gaza Strip look like the day after? That depends, first and foremost, on the outcome of the war. It also depends on Israel’s wishes, and on international pressures, and on internal Palestinian trends.
Upheavals of the kind that Israel is going through are often followed by significant social, political and ideological changes.
Waiting is a difficult challenge. War – of course – is an even more difficult challenge. And still, waiting for war is not to be taken lightly.
American backing is essential as long as it doesn’t mean that Israel is going to compromise on its main objectives.
The most difficult day in Israel’s history is behind us, and very difficult days — hopefully not equally difficult, or more difficult — are still ahead of us.
A war for a degree of separation of religion and state is not a religious war.
It’s a discourse of people who live in parallel universes: those who regard what happened as an enraging sabotage of a Yom Kippur prayer, and those who regard it as a provocation masquerading as a Yom Kippur prayer.
Fifty years have passed, but in Israel it is still impossible to disentangle the tremble and awe of Yom Kippur from the trauma of the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
On Tuesday, Israel’s High Court convened to hear the case for and against striking down the so-called “reasonableness law,” that would curb the top court’s power to exercise judicial review over government decisions.