A federal judge rejected an effort from Ben & Jerry’s lawsuit against their parent company Unilever’s decision to resume selling ice cream in the West Bank.
The Times of Israel and Reuters reported that Ben & Jerry’s filed the lawsuit on July 5 after Unilever vetoed the ice cream giant’s July 2021 decision to stop selling ice cream to Israeli settlements in the West Bank, arguing that Unilever was contractually prevented from interfering in Ben & Jerry’s social justice activism. After the two sides failed to reach a settlement, Judge Andrew L. Carter Jr. sided with Unilever, ruling that Ben & Jerry’s arguments failed to demonstrate that Ben & Jerry’s would suffer “irreparable harm” from it.
Ben & Jerry’s had argued that customers could be under the false impression that the company supports the Israeli settlements if Unilever’s veto wasn’t overturned; Carter dismissed this line of reasoning as being “speculative.”
Jewish groups celebrated the verdict. The Simon Wiesenthal Center tweeted that Ben & Jerry’s “should stick to making great ice cream and not using its profits as an ATM for anti-peace and extremists who hate #Israel. If they don’t, our community and many other Americans will buy elsewhere.”
>@benandjerrys in Vermont should stick to making great ice cream and not using its profits as an ATM for anti-peace and extremists who hate #Israel. If they don’t, our community and many other Americans will buy elsewhere. https://t.co/kuVbHlx4t9
— SimonWiesenthalCntr (@simonwiesenthal) August 22, 2022
StandWithUs CEO and Co-Founder Roz Rothstein tweeted, “BYE BYE Ben & Jerry’s— YOU LOST THIS BID to halt sales in #Israel. And I have personally found other ice cream brands that have replaced you in my life.”
BYE BYE Ben & Jerry's— YOU LOST THIS BID to halt sales in #Israel. And I have personally found other ice cream brands that have replaced you in my life. @benandjerrys https://t.co/hoaFfp7F00
— Roz Rothstein (@RozRothstein) August 22, 2022
Stop Antisemitism tweeted that the verdict was a “big loss” for Ben & Jerry’s and that the ice cream giant should bring forward a “sour grapes” ice cream flavor.
Big loss for the antisemitic BDS movement and @benandjerrys – a US Judge just rejected Ben & Jerry's attempt to stop its parent Unilever from allowing its ice cream to be sold in various parts of Israel!
Maybe B&J should launch a new flavor – Sour Grapeshttps://t.co/RLQj4kTHmA
— StopAntisemitism (@StopAntisemites) August 22, 2022
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.